13 ms·
Blame Zoning, Not Tech, for San Francisco's Housing Crisis
- fiatmoney 11y agoCash inflows from overseas are also a major contributor. The exemption of real estate from money laundering regulations makes it a sink for a lot of shady revenues.
- bkjelden 11y agoAre there any pieces of data quantifying how much of an effect this is having in San Francisco?
- api 11y agoIs the information public? Equity investments are visible in SEC filings, but can this even be quantified from public data?
- linkregister 11y agoThere's a very small amount of data available. It suggests that international purchasers are around 6% of the total cash buyers of real estate. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11270279 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11270279
- fiatmoney 11y agoIt is somewhat frequent for the buyer to be local, and the money to come from overseas. Son buys a house with his dad's dubious-origin money. And given the lack of required information & intentional ignorance ("so, Mr. Boriskypov, would you describe yourself as an oligarch?") I'm not sure how that dataset could reliably identify "international" purchasers.
- linkregister 11y agoThe dataset was from a real estate company's reports from individual realtors. I'm confident the realtors know the origin of money. I think a more appropriate criticism would be to focus on the narrow class of purchases (cash only) or small sample size (n=300, though the company represents 10% of the real estate market in the SF Bay Area). Unfortunately, it's the only published information I could find.
- Tempest1981 11y agoThis article throws around numbers like 15% for the Bay Area (not US), in 2014. Not sure about SF. http://www.sfgate.com/business/networth/article/How-and-why-buyers-from-China-are-snatching-up-5924991.php http://www.sfgate.com/business/networth/article/How-and-why-...
- jseliger 11y ago1. I'm not sure this is true. 2. Even if it is, housing is actually an amazing American export: http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/05/19/exporting_housing_services_a_huge_economic_opportunity.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/05/19/exporting_hou..., though it's rarely recognized as such outside of the literature.
- hardcandy 11y agoKeep in mind neither tech nor entertainment was ever California's main industry. It is and always has been real estate. Money from real estate flows down stream into MANY pockets.
- Finnucane 11y agoSure, but if you have high prices and high demand, that's driven by money. Where's the money coming from? And, what happens when the money runs out?
- simoncion 11y agoA year or two ago, ~8% of SF's population worked "in tech". It seems like median tech salaries are in the very low six-figure range. 120k/year gross will (assuming no car or loan expenses) pay for -at most- $3500/month rent with typical utilities, Internet, and food expenditures. Even then, that leaves you with $2,500/year to save for emergencies or retirement. Where's the money coming from? It's likely not coming from the majority of tech workers. What happens when it runs out? I... really don't know. Whatever happens, it will take quite some time for landlords to adjust their rates to match the new reality. In the interim, I would expect even more "grassroots" hate generated for tech workers.
- Finnucane 11y agoIt doesn't have to come from the majority--the fact that there's a lot of it is what causes the distortions. I live in Cambridge, and there's a lot of money going through the biotech sector--that money is surely as unevenly distributed as the tech money in SF, but it's a lot of money going through a small space. Sure, you can build more housing where you can squeeze it in, but as long as the money hose is going full blast, there's no way to keep up with it. The other problem that kind of gets lost here is that we have a few places where there is a lot of money, there are jobs, housing shortages, etc., and a lot of places in the country where the opposite is true. And that's not really good. I don't think it's really sustainable to think that a few coastal cities are going to be able to accommodate everyone who would like to live and/or work in them. We could actually relieve some of the pressure on these cities by making _other cities_ more desirable destinations.
- ghaff 11y agoBingo. This sort of dynamic has played out forever, but whatever the flaws in housing policy in today's shiny locales, not everyone can live there however perfect housing and construction policies were (and, of course, not everyone will agree on what constitutes perfection). The good news is that this is somewhat self-correcting. To the degree that a locale becomes unsupportably expensive, people and jobs start shifting to other areas. Adding a million housing units to San Francisco and the South Bay isn't going to happen anytime soon whoever is setting policy.
- nether 11y agoI still hate the playas
- mmanfrin 11y agoPeople don't want the truth, they wan't someone to blame. Rich 20-something white males from out of town are a very convenient and easy target. Brogrammers ruining this city.
- kafkaesq 11y agoOh, the "bros" (and less sardonically, the tech crowd in general -- independent of age, ethnicity and gender) themselves aren't to blame. They are but passive agents. However, the influx of their paychecks is quite obviously a factor. Attempts to deny this fact are just that... denial.
- mmanfrin 11y agoYeah, the middle class is such a damper on this city. How dare the middle class want to live in the Bay Area. Also, let's completely ignore that medical wages are higher on average than tech in the city, and that the major redevelopment of China Basin s/Mission Bay/ was spurned by the med sector of the economy; tech worker's middle-class wages are to blame.
- kafkaesq 11y agoA $120k median salary definitely isn't "middle class." And there's been nothing like an influx of medical workers that would any way be comparable to the tech influx since the start of the century. EDIT: Also, medical workers, though larger as a force head-count wise, appear to have decidedly lower median salaries ($67k) than to tech workers. Based on some quick searches, my guesstimate above appears to have been a bit off, but not by much -- and only when we include the non-engineering component of "tech" workers (i.e. marketing and regular admin types). In any case there definitely appears to be a significant gap between the two industries, in terms of median salary.
- browseatwork 11y agoI doubt there's been a sudden influx of med related workers. I suspect the Bay Area's universities, pharmaceutical, and biotech companies have created a slow influx over time. Like tech, a long slow one. Because a large chunk of "tech" is medical related. It's worth excluding the lab techs, genetic counselors, admins, etc., from the medical field if you're going to exclude the non-engineers from the tech field. It makes for a more apples to apples comparison.
- kafkaesq 11y agoWhat a simplistic article. Any examination of the housing woes in SF will reveal multiple factors, playing out over decades. And yes, "new money" is definitely one of them.
- jdavis703 11y agoWhich the article says, "The new wealthy are ruining everything because the old wealthy decided not to let them live anywhere near them."
- kafkaesq 11y agoNo it doesn't. It points to only two factors, and clearly implies that zoning (the decisions of "the old wealthy") was the more important of the two. As if decades of voting patterns in this (once) famously and beautifully economically diverse city might not have also had something to do with it.
- simoncion 11y ago> Any examination of the housing woes in SF will reveal multiple factors, playing out over decades. Is "new money" more or less significant than zoning restrictions? [0] If it's less significant, is it so much less significant as to be nearly insignificant when compared to the effect of zoning restrictions? (Spoiler alert: I expect that it is.) [0] Restrictions which include the ability of SF residents to effectively veto new development that they don't want to happen, for whatever reason.
- kafkaesq 11y agoYou can debate that all you want. But an article which attempts to explain the SF housing situation by listing just two factors (ignoring several other very obvious factors of equal or greater weight) -- just doesn't seem to explain very much.
- beatpanda 11y agoIt is mind-numbing the extent to which everyone playing a role in this housing crisis wants to wriggle out of their share of the blame more than they want to actually solve the problem. I was one of the people constantly seeking a single source of blame for this until I read a book about systems thinking. Completely changed my life. The problem is I now see how the competing interests of all the players make this an almost completely intractable problem. A huge influx of highly-paid workers is partially to blame for the housing crisis. So are activists who prevent any new construction. So are politicians who make policies making new construction prohibitively expensive. Etc etc etc. Everyone plays a role, but nobody wants to give anything up, so the people who lose, as always, are the people who are already marginalized. We need less writing like this and more writing that gives people a bird's-eye view of the entire problem.
- jdavis703 11y agoWhat was this book?
- beatpanda 11y agoThinking in Systems: A Primer
- saosebastiao 11y agoAn excellent book, and unfortunately one that most people are not going to bother reading. It has permanently changed how I think about problems and their solutions.
- methodover 11y ago> Everyone plays a role, but nobody wants to give anything up, I'm just curious, but what could new tech workers give up, exactly? Entrenched local interests could ease up on building restrictions. That's what they'd give up. Politicians who make anti-construction policies could stop doing that. That's what they'd give up. I don't understand what migrants like myself (a programmer who moved here a few years ago to work at a startup) are supposed to give up.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Eridrus 11y agoI just wish the tech industry had taken root somewhere less NIMBYish that actually wanted growth and I'm hoping that SF gets what it wants and the tech industry just leaves.
- ghaff 11y agoThe Bay area has grown enormously. There were fruit orchards in Silicon Valley not (relatively speaking) all that long ago. No, I don't see the tech industry leaving. A lot of people like the Bay area for reasons that have nothing to do with tech jobs. It's also the case however that it's simply not possible (or desirable) for everyone in tech to work and live in a geographically constrained peninsula and people/companies need to deal with that reality.
- Tempest1981 11y agoMaybe Vegas?
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoHonestly, the end of the article gets into what's actually necessary to change to fix the housing situation. There's a ton of locally-optimal but globally-detrimental decisions to not build places - so what's necessary is a regional zoning czar for the Bay Area that can tell people to shut the hell up and allow people to build. Nobody really has the power to do this, and the voters are demanding NIMBY policies, so I'm not holding my breath. The next best strategy is coming up with an acceptable measure of how many people a certain plot of land "should" house and taxing/subsidizing landowners based on how much housing they actually provide on the land. That's technically not an ad-valorem tax, so would dodge Prop 13, while still pricing out people who really should make room for better use of the land.
- foota 11y agoThat's an amazingly good idea imo.
- bhickey 11y agoIt's generally called a 'land value tax'. Most of the value of land derives from the amenities provided around it. By taxing the land you encourage development and discourage speculation: excess land value will be extracted through taxation.
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoLand-value is a better measure of how much housing "should" be built in an area. Ideally, it'd be a land-value tax with a housing capacity subsidy, making the entire thing revenue-neutral. Unfortunately, Prop 13 makes a LVT infeasible to implement. Maybe a national LVT program would work, but that's replacing a smaller problem with a more difficult one.
- tryitnow 11y agoInstead of a subsidy you could just allow the write-off of the structure's depreciation. Structures, unlike land, lose value over time since they have to be maintained and suffer wear and tear. The bigger the structure, the bigger the tax write-off. LVTs make perfect sense and won't ever be implemented because we just started off on the wrong path. We're stuck with Prop 13.
- tptacek 11y agoNo matter where you'd like to pin the blame for the SF housing crisis, be it zoning, NIMBYism, new money, gentrification, or anything else, there is one thing I think we can be pretty confident about: The only solution to the problem is for the city to build its way out of it. There is no rent control regime that will, in the medium term, prevent money from ultimately swamping local concerns. Real estate is a good, not a moral principle, and most people who own real estate have a number. I would be interested in anyone with a counterexample of a US metro area that withstood sustained market interest, without extensive new building, without skyrocket housing prices and the demographic shifts that come with them.
- pj_mukh 11y agoTalking to a few activists about this solution and most of them say that "building your way" out of it only makes sense if you are also building affordable housing. I don't see a builder voluntarily building low-cost housing in the Mission district, just more luxury condos. A municipal ordinance that removes restrictions while imposing a requirement to build affordable housing along with more luxury condos might be the right solution.
- rosser 11y agoYou'd think so, but we actually already have such a thing, and it's not doing anything to mitigate the issue it was designed to address. A city ordnance was passed in the late 70s, IIRC, which says that for every SRO (Single-Room Occupancy, basically, long-term flop house) in the Tenderloin that a developer wants to tear down and replace with a high-rise hotel or whatever, that developer must also put up another building with an equivalent number of SRO units to the one being torn down, somewhere else within the 7x7. So, you have to build two buildings for the price of ... well, at least two. Now, given the current rental market in SF, I can't imagine we're actually very far from (or even already over) the inflection point where that becomes economically viable, but it's demonstrably not affecting the new construction rate in any way I've noticed...
- tptacek 11y agoAffordable housing requirements make sense to me, I don't think they're silly, and I'm glad to see them. But they make only a marginal difference. The default trajectory for SF is towards pricing out the working class. Rich people can afford to live in SF even with its nosebleed prices, and they will hold a systemic and intractable advantage against the working class over the long term, because, again, real estate is a good, not a moral principle. When things get more expensive, rich people get more of those things. I'm sure there are cases where this isn't true, but as a general rule, any opposition to new housing in SF concedes ground to wealthy owners at the expense of working-class renters. If there's a place/time this scenario has played out differently elsewhere in the US, someone, please let me know.
- vorg 11y agoZoning is a demand-side control residents use to raise rents and housing prices. Tech is a supply-side control residents use. In other cities and countries, Tech is a proxy for Immigration -- it could be any industry drawing people in. There's other cities in the US, as well as virtually all of them in Canada, Australia, and New Zealand, where the twin controls of demand-side zoning and supply-side immigration are used to raise housing costs, both sale prices and rents. In New Zealand, because the largest city, Auckland, and the smaller ones surrounding it make up over half the country's population, this is seen very clearly because the city government and national government are virtually the same thing. Government representatives speak in a wink wink nudge nudge manner, talking about fast-tracking new housing stock in Auckland and controlling immigration, but making sure house owners know they're not serious so they don't lose votes. So we should blame both demand-side Zoning and supply-side Tech (i.e. Immigration) for housing crises.
- HaloZero 11y agoI'm curious, how does a place like Hong Kong handle this? It's another large city that's locked on 3 sides by water (they do have other islands but I imagine the population is not signifiant on those). I know rent in the city even in the fancy condos is expensive but they still have their working class workers. Where do they live?
- santaclaus 11y ago> It's another large city that's locked on 3 sides by water Or Manhattan, for that matter.
- enjo 11y agoIn Manhattan's case the workers increasingly live off the island (as opposed to the northern slums).
- linkregister 11y agoThe amount of tech workers buying up housing is also up for debate. Though this article focuses on cash transactions (perhaps mortgaged ones don't contain occupational data?), it paints a picture of other white collar professions performing the majority of cash purchases of housing in the Bay Area. The data was taken from a company that controls 10% of the real estate market in the Bay Area. http://realestateconsulting.com/tech-buyers-only-a-small-portion-of-san-francisco-bay-area-cash-transactions/ http://realestateconsulting.com/tech-buyers-only-a-small-por...
- kafkaesq 11y agoSome of them -- most likely the majority -- rent also, you know.
- linkregister 11y agoRight, so how could they be responsible for pushing up housing prices if most are renting?
- kafkaesq 11y agoGosh, I don't know. Maybe housing prices and market rents are like... related somehow?
- linkregister 11y agoCould you flesh out your point instead of simply repeating it?
- FranOntanaya 11y agoThe sale price of a house is always going to be capped by how much you could make instead by renting it. If the average rental makes $45K a year nobody would sell that house for $250K.
- kafkaesq 11y ago
- grillvogel 11y agothis is a myth perpetuated by "urbanists" and developer shills. none of the new construction is "affordable". you can't build your way out of this problem. desirable areas will always be expensive. infrastructure and improved transit are the solutions to these problems, not more housing.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cylinder 11y agoI don't get it. Why does everyone need to live in San Francisco? The real story here is poor commuting infrastructure. Not enough of it and the existing is slow or unreliable.
- the_ancient 11y agoThe Author is 1/2 Right >The answer is to build. Build more fucking housing, just like Nolan says. But the answer is also to zone: To take away land-use decisions from neighborhoods that is where the statement should end, Take away land-use decisions from neighborhoods, and put them in the hands of property owners, if a developer wants to build something on land they legally acquired, then they should be free to do so even if the neighbors do not like it
- maerF0x0 11y agoAnd also facilitate a market for easements allowing the neighbors to cough up the dough if they care enough.
- pbreit 11y agoThat's completely idiotic. Communities are completely within their right to dictate terms of their community. If prospective owners don't like the rules, they shouldn't purchase.
- the_ancient 11y agoIf the rules are put in place pre-sale, with the agreement of the owners wishing to sell sure.. My problem is that communities change the rules with out the consent of the property owners. I do not believe in Democracy, I do not believe that 50.1% of a community has the ethical right to impose rules on the other 49.9% of a community
- guelo 11y agoWhether to blame the supply or demand side seems almost like a philosophical question.
- pzone 11y agoOK, but some philosophical questions have reasonably clear answers. Here's the philosophical difference. There's a realistic solution to zoning laws: fight hard to remove them. There's no "solution" that involves slowing down or constraining the growth of technology. That would not be a solution, that would be be a disaster. Therefore, appropriate moral blame rests on zoning, not tech.
- eloff 11y agoAs someone from outside the US with no horse in the race, I'm seriously annoyed that entrenched landowners work hard to prevent new construction and that in turn keeps housing unaffordable for a generation of young people that are already worse off than their parents. Thanks guys...
- forrestthewoods 11y agoThis week I saw exactly one building under construction between SFO and Menlo Park. That's utterly insane. I should have seen a couple dozen just from the highway.
- twblalock 11y agoYou should have got off the freeway. There is new construction everywhere in Redwood City, for example. Most of the 101 corridor has been built up for decades. The construction is not happening right next to the freeway.
- DrScump 11y agoYet just 3 years ago, you could drive the length of Central Expressway and see more vacant commercial space than occupied space.
- MrMullen 11y agoBuilding up SF or SV is not the solution, High Speed Rail is the solution. Get on a HSR train, travel 20 - 40 miles out of the city in under 30 minutes. People would still have access to SF, SV and the jobs but would be scattered upwards of 40 - 60 miles from SF, SV. It also fixes NIMBY; you can either have HSR or be surrounded by large apartment blocks.
- tryitnow 11y agoI used to support the view articulated in this article, but I'm more skeptical now. If higher density were the solution I would expect to see highly dense cities have cheaper real estate than less dense cities. Instead, it's just the opposite. That's because of the other side of the economic equation: demand. And therein lies the devil. I hypothesize that increasing the supply of housing in a city actually increases demand in such a way that the supply increase has little downward effect on housing costs. It makes sense why this is the case. If more people live in a city, then there's more people who are likely to move there. If you know a bunch of classmates who are all moving to San Francisco after graduation that's going to make you more likely to move to San Francisco too. So yes, supply exerts downward pressure on housing costs, but I would bet that heigthened density then causes a near commensurate increase in demand such that the supply increase has little effect.
- brighteyes 11y agoThe problem is that the increased density is happening anyway. It isn't that if we build more housing, more people will come, which will bring more people in an exponential cycle. The reality is that tech workers are coming anyway, and paying whatever is required of them to live in SF. They aren't being stopped by high rents, because high as they are, they can afford them. However, they are raising prices for people that can't afford it. That pushes other people out. The result is that whether we build or not, tech workers will live in the city. Building more won't bring more of them. The only question is whether other people can live there too.
- Tempest1981 11y agoSimilarly, I used to think that terrible traffic would discourage growth. Not really... people's tolerance is surprisingly high.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- natrius 11y agoThis is just wrong. Every reputable economist I've come across disagrees with what you're saying. As with climate change, if we ignore experts, we will needlessly careen toward disaster. Conservative economists like Edward Glaeser have long opposed restrictive zoning[1]. President Obama’s Chief Economist sees that “income inequality across cities remains entrenched and may even be exacerbated” as a result of restrictive zoning[2]. According to Nobel laureate and New York Times columnist Paul Krugman, “this is an issue on which you don’t have to be a conservative to believe that we have too much regulation.”[3] [1] http://www.city-journal.org/2008/18_3_houston.html http://www.city-journal.org/2008/18_3_houston.html [2] https://m.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/page/files/20151120_barriers_shared_growth_land_use_regulation_and_economic_rents.pdf https://m.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/page/files/2015... [3] http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/30/opinion/inequality-and-the-city.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/30/opinion/inequality-and-the...
- tryitnow 11y agoI live on the "urban frontier" in Oakland (east side of Lake Merritt) and it's pretty nice, I don't feel endangered at all. South of me there's just huge swaths of residential and commercial land that can be developed - and I think will be developed. The main problem is that there are not enough professional/middle class people living there now. But once some move in, more will follow (as has happened in other parts of Oakland). My point is that the Bay Area has quite a bit of capacity for further development once you step out of SF.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- natrius 11y agoLow density zoning—especially suburban, single family zoning—is tantamount to segregation. We must end it. It forces people who want to save money by purchasing less land to live somewhere else. That is, it forces lower-income people to live in different neighborhoods than higher-income people. And given America's racial disparities in income, these laws segregate by race, too. https://medium.com/@niranbabalola/we-must-repeal-our-segregation-laws-32348d090520 https://medium.com/@niranbabalola/we-must-repeal-our-segrega...
- djillionsmix 11y agoI'm not sure why San Francisco being an enormously popular place that lots of people want to live in is a reason why we need to raze San Francisco and build something else there instead, vs. and not a reason why we shouldn't go to one of the many other shite places that everyone hates, raze that, and build more San Francsico. Other than myopic entitlement, I mean.
- tostitos1979 11y agoI have a basic question about prop 13. I though the point of not increasing property assessments is so that if rich people start bidding house prices around you, your property taxes don't start to increase. But as I dug into this, this doesn't make sense. The community has certain expenses. These get divided based on the value of the homes. If all homes double in price but the community expenses stay the same, it is irrelevant to have different assessment amounts on homes. I've heard the term "mil rate" and am not sure what that is, but is perhaps relevant. Any experts willing to clarify?
- jowiar 11y ago"Mil rate" the number of thousandths of the property value assessed in tax each year. i.e. 20 mils = 2% of the annual property value is taxed. The actual property tax owed is rate x assessments. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Property_tax https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Property_tax
- tostitos1979 11y agoCool. That makes sense. Is there a reason they use 1000? Just convenience/convention? Also .. my question about prop 13 stands. Curious why increasing home values would cause an issue if municipal spending stays constant?
- wtbob 11y ago> Is there a reason they use 1000? Just convenience/convention? Because the mill(e) is the smallest unit of currency in the United States.
- someguydave 11y agoSan Francisco is going to be begging for the tech industry to return after it has all left because the city failed to accommodate employees with housing.
- imh 11y agoTo really put this to the test, could we compare with cities in the bay area with different zoning laws? I know there are tons of places around here where housing prices have gone up like mad. Are the ones with more lax zoning exceptions?