5 ms·
They are sentient. It is slavery.
by carapace 11y ago
They are sentient. It is slavery.
- LeifCarrotson 11y agoOn the one hand, I wish I lived in an era of human history when technology had improved to the point where we could explore or communicate with distant planets and meet other sentient life forms. On the other hand, our treatment of lifeforms of varying difference to ourselves already on our planet is deeply troubling. The thought of that culture spreading across the galaxy like a disease is horrifying. I have a pet dog. I think I treat her well. Will my descendants look back on this and compare me to my not-so-distant ancestors who were racist or sexist?
- diogenescynic 11y agoDemetri Martin: It seems like there's a fine line between having a pet and having a hostage from a different species. You go to somebody's house, they're like, "Close the door. He'll get out. CLOSE THE DOOR! HE'LL GET OUT!" Okay. What kind of relationship do you have with this dog, exactly?
- danrisso3 11y agoIt seems like there's a fine line between having a toddler and having a hostage from the same species. You go to somebody's house, they're like, "Close the door. He'll get out. CLOSE THE DOOR! HE'LL GET OUT!" Okay. What kind of relationship do you have with this kid, exactly?
- StephenConnell 11y agoHa. Same problem? Communication issues?
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI have the same fears about sentient machine intelligence. Will it be a kind god?
- dpflan 11y agoHere is an article about a Beluga whale that began to mimic human speech: http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/story-one-whale-who-tried-bridge-linguistic-divide-between-animals-humans-180951437/?no-ist http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/story-one-whale... Also, In the "Animal Minds" episode, Radiolab recounts a story of divers saving a net-entangled whale, and the whale in turn "thanks" each diver. It's a good show, and the examples included are thought-provoking. If you found this story intriguing, I recommend giving this Radiolab episode a listen. If not, the stories leads to what is intelligence and connection possibilities across species, and the topic of Spindle Neurons is presented which are explored as a connection between high and low order parts of the brain. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spindle_neuron https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spindle_neuron) _ The Goods: 1. The episode: http://www.radiolab.org/story/91701-animal-minds/ http://www.radiolab.org/story/91701-animal-minds/ 2. A related follow-up about whales: http://www.radiolab.org/story/149761-whale-saying-thank-you/ http://www.radiolab.org/story/149761-whale-saying-thank-you/
- alanwatts 11y agoWhat are your thoughts on Jon C. Lilly's work?
- krapp 11y ago>The thought of that culture spreading across the galaxy like a disease is horrifying. Why the assumption that humans are uniquely pestilential in our behavior? For all we know, 'the galaxy' might consider our capacity for tolerance to be the disease.
- kazinator 11y agoDogs are not exactly in captivity; they are domestic. Many of them show that they are not in captivity by roaming freely but then returning home. They do so even if they are not verbally threatened with negative consequences if they fail to come home; and they wouldn't understand that anyway. :) Domestic animals kept as pets that are treated well have good lives that they arguably enjoy. Wild animals have it very tough, by contrast.
- logfromblammo 11y agoHachiko. Greyfriars Bobby. Argos. Silverton's Bobbie. Some dogs are famous (worldwide!) for acts of extraordinary loyalty toward their humans.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoWithout conversation how can you tell it's loyalty. An animal trained from birth to stay by their master in order not to be chastised and in order to be fed; is it loyalty or conditioning. You can condition a human to "stand in line" but whilst their actions may appear loyal we can often find that assumption to be false. Loyalty of animals seems to be something for which we have no good evidence?
- logfromblammo 11y agoWe have a handful of animal behavior studies. These have suggested that your dog actually cares about you, and your cat does not. They also suggest that dogs and wolves do have significant differences in their behavior, attributable to selective breeding. These studies used the same techniques that researchers use with pre-communicative human babies. They measure gaze direction and duration, among other things. Even with conversation, how could you tell? Humans are able to prevaricate and dissemble, after all. How can you tell if someone is loyal to your crime family? Maybe he's just conditioned to not wear concrete overshoes and get a cut of the rackets? How can you tell if someone is loyal to your country? Maybe they are just conditioned to not get fired and blacklisted or imprisoned, and to receive government benefits?
- manachar 11y agoAt this point we still cannot actually negotiate with our pets to establish a mutually satisfactory relationship. Domesticated animals are animals that co-evolved with modern humans (lately with a lot of human selection). Some of our practices towards our pets are barbaric now. For instance, purposefully breeding worse and worse genes to get a flatter face despite the misery this causes the dogs. But in other ways, dogs and cats still can't make choices about things that would allow us to treat them as equals. For instance, we forcibly sterilize cats and dogs so they don't breed and contribute to the overpopulation problem. We restrict their movement so they do not endanger others or themselves. Outdoor cats are an environmental catastrophe in most areas. It's tough to know what the right treatment of a pet is. I do believe we've gotten better. It used to be common for vets to not give pain meds to dogs recovering from surgery. I guess it's easier to ignore the pain when they can't talk to you. It also used to be common to shoot a dog who has broken a leg. I recently had a dog who had osteosarcoma. We paid to have his leg amputated and for chemo. Our conversations with the vet were nearly identical to how I'd approach getting cancer. Some people thought we were nuts paying for such care. Cats are still treated as disposable by many people. One step above a goldfish. Meanwhile, some people are starting to actually take koi fish in to vets for treatment. If you treat your pets as individual lives worthy of dignity and let that inform your thinking, I imagine you're already better than most of human history's brutally utilitarian approach.
- matwood 11y ago> I have a pet dog. I think I treat her well. Will my descendants look back on this and compare me to my not-so-distant ancestors who were racist or sexist? I know mine will not. My dogs are living the good life.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jqm 11y agoAt what point does sentience end? Whales? Rats? Birds? Fish? Insects? Plants? Bacteria? Because something has a higher order nervous system does that mean we have to assign it equal rights? How high an order of system would be required to have equal rights? Why does it really matter how something else feels other than members of our own species? For the record I generally agree with not keeping killer whales in captivity. I'm just asking the question so we know the position has been well considered. Perhaps "slavery" is a bit too strong? (And that's without even getting into "you say that like it's a bad thing....").
- staticautomatic 11y agoI think it was the political philosopher Robert Nozick who posed a related question: If it's acceptable for humans to eat "lower" life forms, then would it be acceptable for a much more intelligent or sentient alien race to eat humans?
- Joof 11y agoThat's a question where its extroidinarily hard to draw the line. Assuming it is immoral to consume another life form, then there goes 100% of our food source (plants are life and show some intelligence in aggregate). If nothing can consume anything else then life can't exist. I'd argue that their ethical standards are wholly separate from our own. For humans, self-preservation as a race is very important.
- kefka 11y agoNot only that, but plants respond to stimuli, remember, chemically 'moan' when sick, scream when they are being harmed or killed (grass cutting), and talk amongst each other (again, chemical triggers). If you don't eat living things, that leaves milk and honey. I'm not saying "become X-ist". I'm saying that in order for us to live, others must die. Plants, animals and others aren't inherently worth more or less than we humans. But it's our responsibility to remember their sacrifices so we could continue.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y agoProve this. Hell, don't worry about proving it. Just define "sentient" in a objective, empirically measurable way.
- fnovd 11y agoDefine the word "word" without using any words. Haha! You can't! Therefore, words don't exist.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y agoThis is fallacious, not a real answer. I didn't disallow you to use words to define it.
- cookiecaper 11y agoMost animals are "sentient" to some degree or another, so I'm not sure what you mean by that. A perception of animal "sentience" doesn't automatically mean it's wrong for humans to employ, enjoy, and/or harvest them.
- junto 11y agoBut they are paid in fish! </ irony>