17 ms·
Unexpected evidence of a new particle at LHC
- mojoe 11y agoSo just to be clear, this particle is not predicted by the standard model? I'm no physicist, but that seems like a huge deal.
- valevk 11y ago> The fact that two separate detectors spotted it at almost exactly the same energies gives some hope, but anomalous signals such as this often show up in experiments only to later vanish back into the noisy background. Yes, it would be, if it's not background noise.
- soheil 11y agoYes, that would not be something that the SM predicts. It needs more verification, two teams out of thousands coming up with similar results on just one occasion hardly means anything, so we'll have to wait and see.
- misthop 11y agoWhile the sentiment that is needs more verification is accurate, there are not thousands of teams in this context. ATLAS and CMS are the 2 general purpose detectors at the Large Hadron Collider - they are the only teams/detectors in the world that can detect this signal, significant or not.
- gibybo 11y agoThe standard model currently has 17 particles[1]. This number has grown over time, most recently when the Higgs boson was added a few years ago. The standard model makes no claim as to how many particles there can be, what their masses should be, what spin they should have, and so on. Those are unsolved questions outside of the scope of the standard model. Instead, it uses the particles we know about to make predictions about how they behave. A new particle doesn't necessarily violate the standard model in the same way that discovering a new element wouldn't necessarily violate the periodic table. It could just expand the types of predictions that it is capable of making. It is also possible that a new particle could have properties that do violate constraints predicted by the standard model, but I don't know it well enough to know whether this particular particle does so. [1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/00/Standard_Model_of_Elementary_Particles.svg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/00/Standard...
- soheil 11y ago> If it turns out to be true, the chart linked below showing the 17 known elementary particles would be expanded to show an 18th. no, actually the standard model would fundamentally break down. The math does not allow for such a heavy particle. No charts could save it.
- gibybo 11y agoHow would it fundamentally break down? Admittedly I don't know enough to know how a particle with these particular properties would affect it, I was just trying to make the point that a new particle doesn't necessarily break the standard model. I'll try to edit my post for more accuracy.
- claudius 11y ago(It's been a while since I took this class, the following might well be wrong or grossly inaccurate) The particles of the standard model are assumed to correspond to the irreducible representations (irrep) of the groups associated to the symmetries of the strong, weak and electromagnetic interactions. These groups are SU(3) (strong) and SU(2)×U(1) electroweak. The currently known particles correspond to the first few irreps of these groups, with the dimensionality of the irrep nicely matching the number of “similar” particles, see e.g. [1]. This means that, if the above assumptions hold, finding a single new particle requires there to be yet another irrep[2] which would imply that there are even more new particles corresponding to the other dimensions of this irrep. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Model_%28mathematical_formulation%29#Field_content_in_detail https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Model_%28mathematical... [2] If this is even possible, I’m not quite sure, but SUSY does something similar I guess.
- cshimmin 11y agoThat's not really the case. The standard model would need to be extended, sure (as the 750 GeV particle isn't predicted by the current SM). But there's no fundamental reason this can't be done; in fact in the weeks following this announcement by ATLAS/CMS, there were literally hundreds of theory models posted to the arXiv, claiming to extend the SM to account for the (potential) new resonance.
- ssivark 11y agoYes, the Standard Model would be completely oblivious to this particle. If this turns out to be a new particle, this would be the first concrete detection of physics beyond the Standard Model. EDIT: Fair point below by @InclinedPlain. Neutrino oscilations were the first signal, but that does not motivate a radical extension like this evidence might. Needless to say, most particle physicists are excited -- but we need to hold our horses -- this does not have a sufficient p-value to warrant the status of a confirmed detection -- such statistical fluctuations come and go once in a while. Also, recent "inside" news seems to indicate that there might not be any new updates till later in the summer (rather than what the last paragraph indicates).
- InclinedPlane 11y agoNot exactly true. The detection of neutrino oscillations was concrete evidence of physics beyond the Standard Model. Though the consensus has been that only slight modifications of the Standard Model are needed to allow for such oscillations (and neutrino masses).
- daveguy 11y agoOh good! A particle physicist. I was looking for the current p-value in the article, but couldn't find it. Do you know what it is currently compared to what is required (something like 1E-6 or 1E-9)??
- dukwon 11y agoCMS observes the peak with a global significance of 1.2σ http://cds.cern.ch/record/2114808 http://cds.cern.ch/record/2114808 ATLAS observes the peak with a global significance of 2σ http://cds.cern.ch/record/2114853 http://cds.cern.ch/record/2114853 5σ is the gold standard for a discovery
- pc86 11y agoIs it true that 2σ holds some significance? I imagine if it was common to get erroneous 2σ or 3σ readings this wouldn't have made the news in the way that it did. Just trying to determine if this is closer to "this is probably something but we will need to confirm" or "something weird happened but it's probably nothing"
- junto 11y agoCan anyone tell me if there are any practical applications for this, or it is 'just' a further understanding of the world around us (albeit an important one)?
- FeepingCreature 11y agoIt is about thirty to fifty years too early to expect any practical applications from this.
- tudorw 11y agoVery exciting then, fifty years and we could be unlocking some serious building blocks :) It's a blink of an eye when you look at the speed of scientific progress over 2000 years !
- adrianN 11y agoThe coolest thing we can do with the last unexpected particle, the muon, is this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muon-catalyzed_fusion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muon-catalyzed_fusion It's not in the "Mr. Fusion" stage, of course, but pretty neat nonetheless.
- jacquesm 11y agoAssuming it is actually true and not some kind of sensor anomaly.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoSorry to be so petty but it seems very anti-intellectual to downvote such a carefully posed question. It's on topic, the answer would be interesting, and it's stimulated good responses.
- Grishnakh 11y agoIt's typical HN moderation: downvote anything that disagrees with (or even appears to disagree with) the popular orthodoxy.
- 11y ago
- crdb 11y agoThe Trisolarians are coming!
- Cyph0n 11y agoSophon lockdown begins?
- crdb 11y agoFinishing Dark Forest made me really wish I could speak and read fluent mandarin, so that I wouldn't have to wait another 4 months for the final volume! They pushed the publication date back again...
- Cyph0n 11y agoOh that's sad to hear. It's one of the best sci-fi series I've ever read no doubt.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoI had some serious problems with the Three Body Problem, which annoyed me enough to put a pause on reading the next novel. I loved all the interpersonal stuff - I haven't liked a character as much as I like Big Shi in a long time - but the tech and science of it seemed implausible to me. It's hard to go into details without being spoilerific, but: the problem is hard to solve, but you can still make very useful short-term predictions; the technology they have access to is being insanely under-utilized given their goals; and I don't believe the actions of the scientists given how they use that technology - I would expect the reaction to be the exact opposite of what ends up happening. I left a review on GoodReads: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/1553897979 https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/1553897979
- crdb 11y agoI liked this essay on plot holes (and more generally good writing) despite the all caps and rather long winded style: http://birthmoviesdeath.com/2012/10/30/film-crit-hulk-smash-hulk-vs.-plot-holes-and-movie-logic http://birthmoviesdeath.com/2012/10/30/film-crit-hulk-smash-... Personally, I found the strength of TBP and DF to be the depth that Liu achieves with his plots at the highest level, and it's important to take a step back and not judge him as pure hard SF (as it seems to have been sold to you, based on your review) but as a writer of literature using SF as his medium (as might have Heinlein, PKD, or Asimov who is his clear and direct inspiration). The science "plot holes", the suspension of disbelief were I think fair play as a base to deploy his explanation of the Fermi paradox (which is to an extent the point of the whole series). Like psychohistory in Asimov's Foundation or Batman's seeming invincibility in Nolan and Ledger's masterpiece, it helps plot development and the greater ideas about human nature, politics, information operations and so on that are put forward by the book. The analyses of human nature, particularly of bureaucracies and destruction via inaction (to quote Admiral Rickover, "the person who disclaims responsibility is correct: by taking this way out he is truly not responsible; he is irresponsible"). What makes a good book/movie/narrative work of art? To me it is increasingly about the plot and, to quote FCH, about how long the work can make you think about it after you're done reading it. It's clearly working since it's been weeks since I've read the books and I still couldn't resist making the quip despite the increasing amount of karma it is costing me for being off-topic. Compared to another famous recent Hugo winner, Rainbows End, I thought Liu's work was much more enjoyable, because it was technically unpolished but had a great, interesting, innovative plot (and I'm sure half of the polish went missing in translation), whilst the latter was technically impeccable if now a little dated, but had little in the way of plot; the plot was almost a frame in which Vinge was developing his ideas about wearable tech and information operations' logical conclusion. It's like Esterhase mysteriously putting on a bad Hungarian accent in Smiley's People when he was the epitome of the try-too-hard British arriviste in TTSP - you can forgive them the glitch since the core of the writing is so exceptional and both Esterhases were fabulous characters with great depth. Liu's ability to toy with the reader and take unconventional paths is rather rare in today's crop of writers. I would draw a parallel there with many of Charlie Stross' books; the polish is not always there, but he keeps reinventing himself and (at least for me) each foray into a new genre or avenue of thought is a success (and a source of great movies and books to explore). As a side note, I thought it was one of the few successful depictions of a truly alien culture (what you call near-Strong-AI?) in SF today (and no, I didn't think Vinge's FOTD's Hugo winning hive-dogs were truly alien: put human heads instead, set it in medieval "Ireland-Spain", and you get Game of Thrones, down to an epic fire battle before the walls of King's Landing). As a second side note, isn't it fun to draw parallels between TBP and the real world? How do you, today, as the PLA, deal with the fact the NSA can hear and read everything except your thoughts when planning defense strategy? Suddenly the sophons don't seem so alien... I don't like tin foil hats, so I didn't try too hard to put myself in the Chinese position, but it was definitely an interesting line of thought.
- pjc50 11y agoLast time there was an "unexpected reading", we spent 3 months being excited about faster-than-light particles until someone found the error. Let's not get too excited just yet.
- abricot 11y agoI'll take three months of excitement, damn the consequences.
- dennisnedry 11y agoThe pursuit of discovering something new and interesting that could potentially change your entire understanding of the universe, is what makes science so utterly satisfying. It's like being re-born. Everything you once knew was completely wrong and you have to re-learn everything.
- lagadu 11y ago> Everything you once knew was completely wrong and you have to re-learn everything. It's really cool in practice but the way you phrased it makes it sound dreadful :)
- Kenji 11y agoThat made me laugh. I like your attitude.
- defraptor 11y agoI don't know about this one, but I don't think many scientists believed in faster-than-light particles, at the time it felt to me like only the media did.
- Ensorceled 11y agoMy recollection was even the scientists who discovered it were basically saying "this is an odd result, can anybody reproduce or figure out where we went wrong before we get excited"?
- abricot 11y ago"[...] before the experiment shut down for its winter recess." Can anyone shine a light on why the particle accellerator needs recess?
- claudius 11y agoRegular maintenance work (maybe just sweeping dust off everything or fixing minor leaks etc.) might require complete shutdowns, as the magnetic fields and temperatures around the accelerator might be dangerous. Further, scientists often move to their job for just a few months/years and hence have most of their family far away. Christmas/New Year is a traditional time to go home and spend some time with them, especially since most other institutions (schools, unis etc.) also shut down around then. Combining the two might lead to a somewhat extended “winter recess”.
- dghf 11y ago> Regular maintenance work (maybe just sweeping dust off everything or fixing minor leaks etc.) might require complete shutdowns, as the magnetic fields and temperatures around the accelerator might be dangerous. Confirmed by http://phys.org/news/2016-01-winter-therapy.html http://phys.org/news/2016-01-winter-therapy.html. Also makes sense to have your annual shutdown when electricity prices are likely to be high: I'd guess that heating has a higher impact on these than air conditioning in Switzerland.
- peteretep 11y agoSkiing countries in Europe make sure there's a good period of holidays factored in for skiing holidays
- 77pt77 11y agoGeneva needs power for the winter. (not joking) http://home.cern/about/engineering/powering-cern http://home.cern/about/engineering/powering-cern "At peak consumption, usually from May to mid-December, CERN uses about 200 megawatts of power, which is about a third of the amount of energy used to feed the nearby city of Geneva in Switzerland."
- UweSchmidt 11y agoAbout time! I can see how scientists were excited when the LHC confirmed existing theories, but the thing was kinda expensive, so it would be nice to get some new physics out if it instead of just a "yup we were right".
- CIPHERSTONE 11y agoELI5: Presumably this was a result of the LHC's power upgrade to 13 TeV. If so, should they now be able to repeatedly get these results again and again?
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoYes, the energy needed was reachable because of the upgrade. And yes, they should be able to repeatedly get there.
- dukwon 11y ago> Presumably this was a result of the LHC's power upgrade to 13 TeV Eh... despite what the other guy is saying, you can't really say this for sure. These bumps appear in a region that was accessible during Run 1 at 7 and 8 TeV. See figure 3: http://arxiv.org/abs/1504.05511 http://arxiv.org/abs/1504.05511 If it is something real, and not just a statistical fluctuation (that's a big if), then it would have to be e.g. some decay product of a much heavier particle to account for why it wasn't seen during Run 1. > If so, should they now be able to repeatedly get these results again and again? Again, depends if it's a real effect or a fluctuation.
- CPLX 11y ago"An unexpected data signal that could change everything has particle physicists salivating." I know I'm like an old man screaming into the wilderness, but I can't be the only one that's profoundly sad that even nature.com has to resort to this sort of horrible clickbait formulation for a headline. Notwithstanding my aesthetic dislike of it, the thing about these headlines that makes me really upset is the fact that they aren't actually telling the truth. Not to be pedantic, but they have not observed any particle physicists with an unusual amount of saliva, presumably. There is no anecdotal or visual evidence of people drooling, nothing. It seems to me this is like the most horrible way to start off an article in a publication that is about the scientific method for gods sakes, where precision and accuracy is sort of the whole point. Would it really be so hard to have a headline like "Shocking and unexpected evidence of a new particle" or something similar that actually says or at least approximates what the news is?
- widdershins 11y ago>Not to be pedantic, but they have not observed any particle physicists with an unusual amount of saliva, presumably. There is no anecdotal or visual evidence of people drooling, nothing. So journalists shouldn't even use figures of speech? That will make for much more dull language. I really think you're picking nits here. It's obvious the article means that scientists are excited by this new data, not that they are literally salivating.
- AI_Overlord 11y agoI think it was pretty obvious nobody was "salivating",etc. but that rather it is a way of saying how excited they are about studying this new phenomenom. They are just metaphors, I see nothing wrong with that. They are used all the time and are an important part of any language.
- Loughla 11y agoI mean, you have to admit that this 'use of metaphor' for exaggeration is being used at a startling rate. And you have to admit that clickbait being used by respected magazines and journals is a bit frightening.
- tobias2014 11y agoThis is one case of ambulance chasing: http://arxiv.org/abs/1603.01204 http://arxiv.org/abs/1603.01204 EDIT: I just noticed that this is also linked in the article.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]