11 ms·
Why America abandoned nuclear power, and what we can learn from South Korea
- fpoling 11y agoAs with many article about proponents of power from nuclear fission it totally misses the cost rise due to future accidents. If past is any indication, those will inevitably happen increasing the operation cost for all plants. We literally export the cost of dealing with the mess into the future to get cheaper prices now.
- AnimalMuppet 11y ago> We literally export the cost of dealing with the mess into the future to get cheaper prices now. That's true of a lot more than nuclear fission...
- BurningFrog 11y ago> If past is any indication, those will inevitably happen increasing the operation cost for all plants. What we can learn from the past is that advanced technologies become much safer over time. I don't have the numbers here, but air travel is maybe 1000 times safer than when it started. So I'd be very confident assuming the accident rate in the future to be vastly less than during the first few decades of nuclear energy.
- fpoling 11y agoThe problem is that total potential harm from a nuclear accident is very big. It is limited, but if the limit is all fission materials from the reactor dispersed into the air or used to produce a real nuke by terrorists, then the cost can be loss of millions human lives. Compare that with aviation where the worst that can happen is a loss of airplane and few buildings. Given this potential threat anything that will be discovered to increase its probability will increase operation cost of reactors in the future. This is just not the case with planes. There minimizing the risk beyond a certain threshold is sufficient especially since it is known that an error in estimation of that threshold is bounded.
- BurningFrog 11y ago> the cost can be loss of millions human lives Can it really? That would be an order of magnitude worse than the Hiroshima bomb.
- greg5green 11y agoOil, natural gas and coal also transport these costs into the future. Why does this stop nuclear and not them?
- fpoling 11y agoOh, this must stop oil and gas even faster than nuclear as the total potential harm is catastrophic climate change that one cannot rule out. It is just the article talks about operation costs of nuclear completely ignoring future costs increases.
- erkkie 11y agoI'll just put this out here https://www.quora.com/How-does-nuclear-energy-compare-to-other-sources-of-energy-in-deaths-per-kWh https://www.quora.com/How-does-nuclear-energy-compare-to-oth... (per kwh nuclear kills less than coal)
- pluckytree 11y ago"Plus, there are thorny issues like how to dispose of radioactive waste and how to decommission old plants." The fact is, we're creating tremendous amounts of potentially dangerous waste and we have no long-term plan, much less the technology to pull it off. We don't know what the political situation will be in a country 500 years from now. If we put 1/100th of the money that we put into dangerous technologies and subsidizing fossil fuels and put them into renewables, we wouldn't even be having this discussion. Germany is on track to be 100% renewable by 2020. Including solar. And they are not exactly known for their excess of sun.
- peferron 11y ago"Germany is on track to be 100% renewable by 2020" Do you have a source for this? It seems completely unbelievable.
- melling 11y agoNo he doesn't because what he said is complete bullshit. http://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/nuclear-power-germany-renewable-energy http://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/nuclear-powe...
- toomuchtodo 11y agohttp://cleantechnica.com/2015/05/05/new-study-95-renewable-power-mix-cheaper-than-nuclear-and-gas/ http://cleantechnica.com/2015/05/05/new-study-95-renewable-p... "New Study: 95% Renewable Power-Mix Cheaper Than Nuclear And Gas" Applies to both France and Germany.
- melling 11y agoSounds like we still talking 35 years from now: "With wind and PV growing to 80 % of total power production in 2050, the study gives a lot of attention to how – and at what cost – the different regions can fill the gap when neither the wind nor the sun can meet the demand."
- 11y ago
- m0llusk 11y agoThis article is really light on the problem of complexity. Even relatively simple reactors have huge amounts of pipes and wires and such many of which need to be able to handle unusual temperatures and acidity levels. This is one of the reasons that Thorium looks great on paper but is doomed in reality. The sheer complexity of even relatively simple implementations is overpowering and causes the costs and organizational challenges to make sustainable alternatives look cheap.
- api 11y agoMy impression for a while has been that nuclear power is one of those techs that looks good on paper but fails in practice due to what Elon Musk calls a high "PITA factor." (Pain in the A$$) I interpret PITA factor as referring to the existence of a long tail of thorny, hard, nasty, complicated problems that do not show up on a straightforward "paper" model of the tech. Some don't show up because they're complex edge case issues, and others (like "black swan event" risk) are just flat out hard to quantify. I also think wishful thinking plays into it, since if a tech looks sexy and cool on paper there's a desire to believe in it and it leads us to overlook less obvious or less straightforward to analyze issues. Elon uses high PITA factor when talking about why SpaceX isn't pursuing hydrogen as a rocket fuel. It similarly looks awesome on paper but results in higher TCO and higher complexity in practice. It's cheaper (according to SpaceX) to use kerosene or methane and build a bigger rocket. For nukes vs. renewables it's likely overall cheaper to just over-build renewables and storage than to handle the long tail of pain from current-type nuclear. Spend a few billion dealing with nuclear waste, or spend a few billion on more generation and storage capacity. The former is sticky and complicated, while the latter is just straightforward commodity scaling of stuff everyone already knows how to build and handle. It's stupid and simple and scalable and if it's not enough just do more of it. In other words: just build a bigger rocket. What I say applies to conventional and near-term fission. Fusion and other exotics might be a different ballgame. Fusion would likely be complex and high capital cost but it doesn't have the waste and "black swan failure" issues that pee in the pool for fission.
- pdonis 11y agoI think the perceived "black swan event risk" of nuclear is the result of over-hyping a few incidents rather than doing a rational across the board risk assessment. When a rational across the board risk assessment is done, nuclear does less harm per unit of power generated than any other energy technology. But the harm from other technologies is distributed in space and time (for example, coal dust in the air and radioactivity in coal ash), so it doesn't get the big media play.
- Terr_ 11y agoI still think the waste is the elephant in the room. Exactly how is the (indefinite) cost of safely managing it factored into all those kilowatt-hour costs? Does it include tax-dollars going to projects like Hanford or Yucca Mountain? Even if we're now experienced-enough to develop good socio-regulatory systems for day-to-day generation safety and standards, is the same really true for the waste? Our collective record is still a sad tale of fraying "temporary" solutions, leaks, NIMBY reactions, and playing an institutional game of radioactive-hot-potato.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- coin 11y agoThe waste issue has already been solved. You turn it into glass then store it somewhere geologically stable, such as Yucca Mountain. See http://www.phyast.pitt.edu/~blc/book/chapter11.html http://www.phyast.pitt.edu/~blc/book/chapter11.html
- jaskerr 11y agoUmmm, no. Irrational tho' it may seem, local, regional and national resistance has made Yucca Mountain untenable. So we're back to dry cask and concrete, which is not a long term solution.
- pdonis 11y ago> The waste issue has already been solved. Yes, but the solution isn't to store it. The solution is to reprocess it. That's what all the other major nuclear-using countries do. The only reason the US doesn't is politics.
- jeffwilcox 11y agoThe glassification plant at Hanford is just starting to come online, but Yucca doesn't want it. We have a political problem now, not a technical one... and yeah that's going to be a tough one. I wonder how long until someone figures out ways to let a 3rd world country be the deep bore storage place and allow export?
- philliphaydon 11y agoIs Thoriam a real alternative?
- LeifCarrotson 11y agoThorium, and not yet.
- tim333 11y agoAs far as I can tell the basic problem with Thorium reactors is they would be more complicated and expensive than conventional reactors. Given that, Thorium probably isn't going to happen at scale for a long time even though it's technically doable.
- philliphaydon 11y agoBoth China and India are investing in it with China claiming it will have it working within 10 years... It seems like the Molten Salt Refactor is much safer than a Liquid reactor will ever be. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molten_salt_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molten_salt_reactor
- tim333 11y agoI just noticed UPower (YC S14) is also working on it https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8195554 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8195554 Dunno how that will go.
- philliphaydon 11y agoI just noticed in the wiki link: In January 2016, the United States Department of Energy announced a $80m award fund to develop Generation IV reactor designs.[19] One of the two beneficiaries, Southern Company will use the funding to develop a Molten Chloride Fast Reactor (MCFR), a type of MSR developed earlier by British scientists.[16]
- philliphaydon 11y ago
- bluthru 11y agoThis video provided some downsides to nuclear that I was not previously aware of: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B3nhhOitYmk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B3nhhOitYmk You can make a lot of PV's in the 14 years it takes to make a fission plant. I'm all for Thorium research, but fission as it is now has a lot of downsides.
- apsec112 11y agoEveryone is so terrified of nuclear waste, because it lasts "hundreds of years", which seems like a really long time. Why is almost no one terrified of chemical waste, which lasts literally forever, or at least until after the Sun burns out? Global production last year: Arsenic (arsenic trioxide): 44,000 metric tons Mercury: 1,900 metric tons Selenium: ~3,000 metric tons Beryllium: 400 metric tons Lead: 4,000,000 metric tons Cadmium: 23,000 metric tons All of this stuff will last literally forever, and is more-or-less impossible to destroy. This doesn't include all the fun chemicals (eg. cyanide) which are possible to destroy, but get dumped into the environment before disposal and so are floating around anyway.
- x5n1 11y agoThis is silly. That stuff is simply being refined, it was always there on the planet somewhere. The question is where that stuff goes and how we control its movement. The same is the case for nuclear waste, but if we can spend trillions of dollars on war we can send that stuff to outer space, not very far from that technology being feasible. Space elevators and whatnot. Sooner or later we will have nuclear fusion which will solve the problem of waste altogether. List of ways of getting rid of nuclear waste: http://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/nuclear-fuel-cycle/nuclear-wastes/appendices/radioactive-waste-management-appendix-2-storage-an.aspx http://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/nuclear-fue...
- indlebe 11y agoOr even compared to the 8 million tons of plastic dumped into the ocean each year, which will never truly degrade. I understand plutonium has a half life of 25,000 years without anything aiding it.
- mikeash 11y agoI always make this point too. It's very weird. My guess is that when you name a timeframe for the danger, like "a million years," people start thinking about waiting it out. And waiting a million years for toxic waste to be safe sounds really tough! With more mundane sorts of toxic waste, it's not even an option, so people are forced to think about it differently.
- windlep 11y agoIf we ignore waste for a minute, this article highlights a key issue for why nuclear in the USA will never be as cheap as France or South Korea. Those countries can impose a single builder, single supplier requirement and enforce it the whole way through. That'd never happen here, everyone would have to get involved. Blame cronyism and the US lobbyist political system, but every nuclear company would freak out if they weren't the chosen provider, and then they'd sue.... and then it'd be as expensive as it is now.
- _delirium 11y agoAnother difference is the legal regime. The U.S. makes much more extensive use of the courts as a tool for balancing interests, and an indirect way of regulating industries, which makes projects much slower, riskier, and more expensive. In a country like France, you can't normally sue to stop a nuclear plant being built. Once the government decides to build it, they have sovereign immunity from suits in their own courts. So if you don't want it, you can agitate for the government to stop it, but you can't sue the project to stop it (or at least, there are many fewer ways to do so). The U.S. by contrast has waived its own sovereign immunity in a lot of cases, setting up a more decentralized decision-making process where the legislature passes general laws, agencies like the DOE and EPA are delegated rule-making authority, and courts then adjudicate disputes. The multiple levels of government (federal agencies, state agencies, federal courts, state courts) add another complication.
- jklowden 11y agoLittle known fact: the legal regime in the US shields the utility from liability in case of accident. Recall the utility wasn't sued after Three Mile Island. If utilities were made liable for harm for nuclear disasters, how long do you suppose it would be before every last one was decommissioned? I suspect all the cost savings TFA hopefully imagines vanish in comparison to the cost of liability. I also note TFA makes no attempt to express the South Korean costs in USD terms. It wouldn't surprise me, given the state of South Korea's economic development in 1971, if what the graph depicts is not a miraculous decline in costs, but a predictable trend toward the global norm.
- industriousthou 11y agoSo, I've worked in the nuclear industry (just a scaffold builder), so take this with a grain of salt, but there are a few things I think get left out of the conversation. One is how absolutely catastrophic coal fired plants are. People often talk about hypothetical scenarios with nuclear, but tens of thousands of people are dying every year as a direct result of coal power and that doesn't even take into account the long term effects of climate change. We need to be aggressively pursuing _any_ and _all_ alternatives to coal, in my opinion. This might sound a little crazy, but I almost feel the situation is urgent enough to justify the president declaring a national emergency and using the national guard to unilaterally shut down these facilities. I realize that's completely unrealistic, but I hope it conveys my sense of urgency. Another thing I'd like to touch on is the handling of nuclear waste. It's absolutely problematic, but I'm curious about the marginal cost/risk of additional waste now that we already have to deal with it. We already have to devise a solution to the problem, so it seems like that offsets the cost of dealing with the additional waste of more reactors. Even if we didn't use nuclear power, we would be generating waste from research reactors, nuclear medicine, etc, that we would have to deal with. If you have to figure out how to safely store a ton of material for ten thousand years, does it really cost twice as much to store twice as much material?
- chrisco255 11y agoCan't we just bury the radioactive waste in the desert?
- gratimax 11y agoI don't know of how many completely uninhabited deserts there are in the United States that aren't protected as national or state parks. In addition, how do you transport nuclear waste to the desert, especially from long distances? Nobody wants a truck carrying nuclear waste around. The biggest issue is that I don't think anyone at the federal, state, or congressional representative level would volunteer or accept putting nuclear waste close to their constituencies.
- MRPockets 11y ago
- marze 11y agoThe implicit assumption seems to be that we need nuclear because solar and wind alone (with presumably cheaper batteries in the future) won't be able to supply the needed power. It is hard to prove something like that, that future technology can't do something, but the author doesn't even try.
- jsmeaton 11y ago> There's a compelling argument that the world ought to be building many more nuclear power plants. The writer starts the article with the assumption stated explicitly. He punts on that question to discuss cost. Whether or not Nuclear is a requirement can be (and has been) discussed elsewhere. I think that's fine, because it was still an interesting article.
- Falkon1313 11y agoThe fear of waste has always struck me as illogical for a couple of reasons: First, uranium is not some mythic dark magic demon that we conjure from a hellish fairy land in another dimension. It's a naturally-occurring rock that we intentionally dig up because it's useful. Another comment mentions lead, mercury, etc. as being even more terrifying, but again, these are natural elements that we mine for various uses. They're not new. They've always been here. Most of the fear is just superstition. Secondly, fear seems to be predicated on the idea that we need to dump all the stuff, we need to find a single place to concentrate it all when we dump it, and we need to leave it there for thousands of years. Of course no one wants that next door. But why try to find a place to dump all this lead/mercury/uranium while we're still digging up and refining more? Why not find ways to use it? We used to take just the kerosene and dump most of the rest of the oil because we just didn't know what to do with it. Turns out gasoline, diesel, and jet fuel did have uses after all. We also didn't know what to do with heavy oils, oil sands, etc., but we've found ways to process them into something useful. If we do need to dump some (perhaps because we don't yet have the technology to filter out impurities), why not just put it back where we got it, or scatter it around the way that it is found naturally, or better still just tuck it away for a few decades until it becomes useful? Because it won't be a problem for a million years or 10,000 years or hundreds of years. It will soon be a valuable resource. With nuclear waste it's especially odd. That is by definition mass that naturally produces energy, and we're most worried about how to get rid of the stuff that will produce energy for a long time...while we are simultaneously worried about how we're going to produce enough energy to meet the demands of the future. Yet people are suggesting that we launch it all into space! How different would our world be if we had launched all the gasoline and diesel into space before we knew what to do with it?
- xufi 11y agoConsidering this crazy NK guy just issued a threat. We should be on your heels