13 ms·
Why China’s Economy Will Be Hard to Fix
- ZoeZoeBee 11y agoAnswer Demographics, China's Working Age Population peaked 4 years ago. Since then the working age population of China has been losing over a million people a year. Long Story Short, it is too late for China, they just don't know it yet.
- zanny 11y agoI'm guaranteeing you supply of labor is not the dominant factor in China's economic climate. The rigged economics of their core competencies has a much larger impact than the availability of cheap workers - labor markets can adjust seamlessly and effectively to less available labor by having the most valuable work done and less valuable work gets delayed. To some degree you have a cutoff valuation where less valuable work is not worth doing - in the west we call it minimum wage. I highly doubt China's economy is anywhere near that threshold yet.
- ucaetano 11y agoI think parent wasn't saying that supply of labor is the problem now, but that it will be in the future. If thinks are looking bad now, imagine when dependency ratio increases significantly. It's not just about absolute supply of labor, but also about how much of that labor is being used towards supporting old and young people.
- ZoeZoeBee 11y agoThanks, I'm often amazed how many people like zanny are incapable of seeing the likely future for societies who's economic and social models are dependent upon constant expansion. At this point in time it is simply too late for most of the EU and Asian nations, it is not a question of if but how the population will react when things begin to unravel. The Demographics of said nation's give us a very good idea of when.
- imtringued 11y agoThey already are heavily investing in robots to counteract this.
- ucaetano 11y agoYou're still misunderstanding this point. It ins't about labor availability, but dependency ratio (people working vs. people not working).
- zanny 11y agoThis ratio is increasing regardless of mean population age. Automation is making even 20 year old prime-of-their-life human labor gradually obsolete.
- ucaetano 11y agoI wasn't clear. Dependency ratio doesn't depend on unemployment, but on people who CAN work vs. people who CAN'T work (elderly, young, sick, disabled, etc.).
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoThis problem isn't about using robots to refine steel or manufacture iPhones, or have workers magically move up the value stack, it's a question of who will take care of the legions of elderly Chinese. Throw in the fact that China lacks a serious social safety net and the spice of nobody wanting to be an elderly care worker, and you have a full on crises on your hands.
- Moshe_Silnorin 11y agoIt will be interesting to see how more-powerful labour replacements effect these predictions. With the death of Moore's law, perhaps this point is moot, but if we get perfect replacements for intellectual and physical labour, a large population of savers may be ideally placed to benefit from the transition, as perfect mass-produced labour substitutes will likely presage enormous economic growth.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoThat large population of savers is largely doing so because houses are extremely expensive and the gender gap is so wide that most (of the few) Chinese women can disregard (the very many) men without property and do so without consequence. So even if this large population of savers were to start spending their money, what are they expected to do with their lives, jack off until they die? I wonder if this point will hit home to Bay Area engineers who live and work mostly among men and can't afford a house without serious pay or a startup buyout.
- Moshe_Silnorin 11y ago>So even if this large population of savers were to start spending their money, what are they expected to do with their lives, jack off until they die? VR girlfriends? A comfortable retirement as the economy expands. There have been far worse fates in history.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoI doubt a VR girlfriend would be of much help for the (already) millions of elderly Chinese with dimentia and in need of constant care. http://www.economist.com/news/china/21693241-china-ill-prepared-consequence-ageing-lots-people-dementia-state-minds http://www.economist.com/news/china/21693241-china-ill-prepa...
- adventured 11y agoChina has between 400 and 500 million fake farmers that are a readily available supply of working age labor. Supply of labor is the absolute least of China's problems. In fact, they have far too much labor compared to global consumer demand, which is why the bottom 50% of China is so poor. If China operated its farming as efficiently as South Korea, much less the US, they'd need no more than 30 million farmers. They have hundreds of millions of people producing very little output, and they're kept that way - and without any ability to own their own farms - on purpose because the state has no idea what to do with them if they're not subsistence farmers.
- ZoeZoeBee 11y agoI'm sorry could you please explain to me why you believe I'm talking about the supply of labor?
- adventured 11y agoThere's no other reason to have referenced their working age population than to talk about what their actual supply of productive labor is. Losing a mere one million people per year in working age population is entirely irrelevant when you have 400-500 million people sitting on the sidelines available to replace them. China could improve the efficiency of their farming by 0.25% each year and replace those lost one million working age persons. It's a complete non-issue, they have drastically too many working age persons and nothing for them to do.
- ZoeZoeBee 11y agoSeriously? From The Article you linked to: China risks growing old before it gets rich As China’s population becomes richer and more urban, it's also getting older... Extend the graphic out a few years and its an inverted pyramid. I'm sorry you're unaware that working age population means much more to a country than simply the supply of labor...
- adventured 11y ago
- mixedmath 11y agoThis page contains many pleasantly-made visualizations, which I always like. The editorial content is a little slim to my tastes. For instance, I have a slightly hard time looking at a graph indicating a mere 7% GDP growth and concluding that an economy is in need of fixing. In a related fashion, I'm a bit surprised that there is not a dedicated graphic to some sort of private debt. Perhaps this information is simply not known well enough. But it's my [admittedly quite limited] understanding that one of the problems the Chinese economy will soon have to face is rising reliance on individual debt for wealth generation.
- sandworm101 11y ago7% would be fine elsewhere, but China needs more. The deal with the general population is that, in exchange for stalled political progression, the people shall be allowed economic progress. Should the later break down, the population may/will become difficult to rule. Anything even hinting at revolution may see the Chinese economy do far more than stall. So china's 10% goal isn't so much an economic but a political necessity.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Mikeb85 11y agoNo one believes that China's in a recession, not even the most sceptical of western observers.
- adventured 11y agoThe problem is, essentially nobody credible on China believes they're actually growing at 7%. Their imports and exports have declined dramatically as of late. Their manufacturing sector is contracting, with millions of people set to be fired across several major industries such as steel and coal. Their services sector is barely expanding. Capital outflows are of epic scale. Their stock market has crashed by ~50% and is lower than it was five years ago. 7% is basically impossible given that data, and those are government figures. Where is that vast growth supposedly coming from while most of the economy is contracting? Going by China's history on economic data (a statement which is not excusing any other nation on bad data accuracy), the real data is likely even worse. No chance they're growing anywhere near 7%. Given their behavior and the government figures alone, I'd bet on their economy being closer to recession than not.
- bsbechtel 11y agoOne theory here is that it is easy to predict basic needs for a population, and thus let the government control the production of those - food, shelter, medicine, etc. For an extremely simplified example, you have 1 billion people in China, so you need to build 1 billion housing units. That is going to keep a lot of people very busy for 20+ years. Once the general population's needs move beyond basic necessities, it becomes much harder for a central authority to predict what will be needed by it's citizens. Services, entertainment, and consumer goods are all highly dependent on many more variables than shelter and food are.
- sandworm101 11y ago>> Services, entertainment, and consumer goods are all highly dependent on many more variables than shelter and food are. I'd agree with that for the most developed economies. The US government is in no place to predict consumer wants 5/10/15 years out. But china is far behind. They can look to the more liberal/advanced economies for guidance. They seem to be doing this in their allowance of some international culture (hollywood) and communication (internet). And I think the population is following the pattern. They haven't demanded anything radically different than more advanced economies have.
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago> The US government is in no place to predict consumer wants 5/10/15 years out. It doesn't have to. It just need to provide the framework for US businesses to be successful and allow the entrepreur class to handle future demand. China, Russia, etc have so much state owned industry that the government itself needs to predict this stuff, which is the problem.
- nickff 11y agoYou vastly overestimate the abilities of any central planner. Coordination through market prices is the only way to provide the goods you describe. If houses were a simple cube of bricks built in the same location every time, what you descibe might be feasible (though it would still be a challenge to design the bricks, select materials, and an assembly technique). Market pricing allows for relative valuation of different options, such as making waterfront homes in Manhattan more expensive than homes in Boise tend to be, or deciding how many strawberries should be grown off season in greenhouses, and how many factories should be dedicated to producing insulin (as well as which techniques should be used, as modern insulin techniques were created by a startup you may have heard of). You make the production of basic necessities sound simple, while ignoring the great amount of evidence to the contrary, i.e. Kruschev's famous tour of the grocery store.
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoHistorically, growth from agrarian to factory based economies is massive and fast once the political and capital elements are put into place. We saw this with the USSR, North Korea, China, etc. The problem is that the move past factory economies is tricky. The pre-reqs to be successful here are just much more complex. Service based economies are special and they can't be successful in a political vaccuum like factory work can. You need a lot of western ideals to make this actually work: free speech, open markets, powerful banking, strong monetary policies, anti-isolationism, free trade, employee protections, anti-corruption, capital protection, pro immigration policies, multi-party government, non-corrupt judiciary, etc. This is why Russia stuggles now. It ignored almost all of the above and has been held up solely by its state-owned petrochemical industry and petrochemical derived reserves. I think there's a reckoning coming for the autocratic BRIC states soon. Either they'll liberalize and migrate to a US/EU model or become economic sob stories. Russia is looking at 1% contraction this year and its oil slump has moved into a real estate slump. China has a chance to fight this I suppose, but I doubt it has the political will to move away from autocracy and political oppression. The next decade will be interesting for BRIC economies. The low hanging economic fruit in many of these countries has already been snatched up. What happens now is the big question.
- seren 11y ago> You need a lot of western ideals to make this actually work: free speech, open markets, powerful banking, strong monetary policies, anti-isolationism, free trade, employee protections, anti-corruption, capital protection, strong pro immigration policies, multi-party government, non-corrupt judiciary, etc. That is an interesting point, I wonder how all the points you have listed are intertwined. Do you need free speech because it is a prerequisite to have a low level of corruption ? Or could you in some systems have the low corruption without the free speech ? (I don't really believe that but it seems that is what is the PRC is trying to achieve) What would be the more and less important factor if you had to "implement" one first ? And so on.
- EliRivers 11y agoAs a single data-point, Singapore managed low corruption without free speech (and indeed, economic development without much attendant political freedom).
- sharetea 11y agoLatest News: China to lay off five to six million state workers http://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-economy-layoffs-exclusive-idUSKCN0W33DS http://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-economy-layoffs-excl...
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoThe report comes from anonymous Chinese government officials and cannot be accepted at face value as fact. However it is unlikely that China can rebalance from massive overproduction without massive layoffs. The quoted government official, Yin Weimin put the number closer to 1-2 million.
- RobertoG 11y ago" it is unlikely that China can rebalance from massive overproduction without massive layoffs." Why is that? it is a genuine question. Do they have an inflation problem?
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoProblems greater than inflation. Overproduction incentivizes dumping, which results in backlash from trading partners. It is also used to finance regional and local governments, which incentivizes overproduction and waste of resources. Sure, the thousands of construction workers making ghost cities get paid, but someone has to pay them. Not to mention the rampant corruption that occurs like magic when you mix money and power with a dash of unaccountability. http://www.economist.com/news/business/21693573-chinas-excess-industrial-capacity-harms-its-economy-and-riles-its-trading-partners-march http://www.economist.com/news/business/21693573-chinas-exces...
- sharetea 11y agoSo the western world should just take the Chinese government media at face value? since the foreign media now needs a 'permit' to publish online in China. This is a government that cheats, lies, and steals. Oh, and kidnaps foreign citizens and forces them to tell lies on state TV http://www.forbes.com/sites/jnylander/2016/01/07/swedens-former-pm-is-china-starting-to-kidnap-individuals-in-hong-kong/#32ebe05aea44 http://www.forbes.com/sites/jnylander/2016/01/07/swedens-for...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- m0llusk 11y ago"hard to fix" : "business opportunity"