20 ms·
Tech workers are increasingly looking to leave Silicon Valley
- inmyunix 11y agosurprised Denver/Boulder isn't on this list. I've gone from lusting over migrating my career to the Bay Area, to becoming almost completely averse to the idea over the last two years.
- willholloway 11y agoHow are/how many dev jobs are in Boulder?
- inmyunix 11y agoa LOT. the area is burgeoning. http://www.builtincolorado.com/ http://www.builtincolorado.com/
- mooreds 11y agoLots of stuff happening in the metro area. Boulder is more startupy and small to medium size companies, but just southwest of Boulder is Interlocken, which has some biggish tech companies (Oracle and Level3 being the largest). Downtown Denver has all manners of software companies, from startups to big telcos. And then in south Denver (about 1-1.5 hours of commuting from Boulder) are a bunch of larger corporations (it's called the Denver Tech Center).
- econner 11y agoShhhhhh. Don't let the secret get out.
- kzhahou 11y agohttp://www.trulia.com/property/3223512589-714-Douglass-St-San-Francisco-CA-94114 http://www.trulia.com/property/3223512589-714-Douglass-St-Sa... http://www.trulia.com/property/3224704811-407-Loreto-St-Mountain-View-CA-94041 http://www.trulia.com/property/3224704811-407-Loreto-St-Moun... http://www.trulia.com/property/3164651301-1625-NE-Marine-Dr-Portland-OR-97211 http://www.trulia.com/property/3164651301-1625-NE-Marine-Dr-... http://www.trulia.com/property/3152279353-109-Syrah-Cir-Austin-TX-78738 http://www.trulia.com/property/3152279353-109-Syrah-Cir-Aust... Of course, life isn't about how big/nice your house is. But at some point you realize you've just been working on a CRUD app the last few years (and not changing the world with a self-driving AI satellite hyperloop), you can't cross your apartment without stubbing your toe, and you have enough money for whatever you want but no time or room for anything, and maybe (just maybe) there's delicious food outside silicon valley, too.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- muzz 11y agoMarkets reveal preferences
- toomuchtodo 11y agoThey also stay irrational longer than you'd expect.
- muzz 11y agoSo how many decades now?
- ossreality 11y agoThis has nothing to do with preference and everything to do with jobs. Otherwise the headline wouldn't be what it is.
- kzhahou 11y agoI think you're saying that people must prefer crappy housing with SV's tech scene, versus the alternative nice houses with a smaller scene? If so, that much is self evident. It is what it is.
- minimuffins 11y ago[robot voice] markets reveal preferences markets reveal preferences markets reveal preferences markets reveal preferences markets reveal preferences BZZZZT markets reveal preferences PHFFFFFZT markets reveal preferences markets reveal preferences markets markets markets market mark mark mark mar mar mar marmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
- abbasmehdi 11y agoThese are list prices, we are finding list and sale prices are quite different in the Bay Area. Folks list low on their realtor's advice to ignite bidding wars. And bid buyers do. On the plus side now we are hearing from our realtor and others that prices are stabilizing (i.e. not going up as fast, but definitely not coming down). Still hugely unaffordable for most.
- zellyn 11y agoFor anyone interested… We just moved back to Atlanta in September after five years in the Bay Area, to be closer to family, and to be able to afford a house, ever. I was well paid at Google, and loved working at YouTube. I also severely miss our many friends, as well as beautiful San Francisco: I used to walk up Bernal Hill one or two days a week with my toddler. Pictures of oceans and hills and everything else make me sad… That said, we could never afford a house in San Francisco. And to get affordable, we'd have had to have gone way out, and the commute would have been terrible. I was lucky enough to find out that Square has an Atlanta office, full of very smart people, so I was able to keep doing Silicon-Valley-style programming, which is a big win.
- smrtinsert 11y agoPlease define Silicon Valley style programming?
- Fluid_Mechanics 11y agoProgramming with an inflated salary.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- muzz 11y agoYou mean market-based salaries
- hendzen 11y agoHow about programming with a market-based salary in an inflated market?
- bdcravens 11y agoDoes this really exist? If a company could meet the need cheaper, wouldn't they? Instead, you're either referring to using the wrong tool, and hence a high salary, or you're being relative to a given location. If that's the case, then pretty much everyone's salary is inflated, since there's certainly someone in the world who will do the job for $20k USD.
- dismal2 11y agoDon't worry, it will happen naturally when the current tide recedes. I think a lot of older people underestimate how flexible young people, especially ones who graduated into the financial crisis, are.
- muzz 11y agoDon't worry, the best and brightest from all around the world-- especially India and China-- will come to replace them.
- anpk 11y agoActually there have been articles on how the tech boom in India is directly correlated to the 2008 financial crisis and tightening of H1B visas. The reverse brain drain might not be long term but if that trend continues I dont think the western world has to worry much about jobs being lost.
- mabbo 11y agoInterestingly, the opposite is true: young people are actually less willing to relocate for work than previous generations. http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/11/opinion/sunday/the-go-nowhere-generation.html http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/11/opinion/sunday/the-go-nowh...
- Xcelerate 11y agoThat's really interesting; I wonder why that's the case. My girlfriend and I are split on this particular issue. I have no problem moving around to wherever the best job offers are (even if they're in a different country), whereas she wants to stay in the town she grew up in — or at least within a few hours drive of it. The difference may come down to how we grew up; my father traveled quite a bit when we were younger, so I lived in France from ages 3-6. I thought those few years added to my life experience and gave me a unique cultural perspective. My girlfriend never moved growing up though, and she believes that moving hurts the friendships that young children develop. To be honest, I'm not sure who's right. I was always kind of introverted, so I didn't have particularly strong attachments, but she is very outgoing and extroverted and still keeps in touch with friends from elementary school.
- ig1 11y agoI'm at a London based startup (MarketInvoice) that's open to sponsoring work visas and we've seen an increasing number of candidates from SF, not only for tech roles but across the board. London isn't exactly known for cheap housing so there's likely other factors at play.
- xlayn 11y agoI can mention one reason why it could happen and would: Price Taking your IT out of SF and SV means you could spend the money you save on offices and increase developers salary. On the other side for developers it could mean better earnings with less being spent on paying rent and other services which could lead to more savings for you. At industry level this would translate to a competitive advantage as you can build a service cheaper.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoTaking your IT out of SF/SV means you can pay them less.
- thesimon 11y ago>spend the money you save on offices and increase developers salary. Yeah, the salary of the developers is usually increased when moving into a lower cost of living area, because of all the money the company saves thanks to the low office rent.
- maxxxxx 11y agoSalary increases will certainly not happen. Most likely the opposite.
- ryanSrich 11y ago
- jonathankoren 11y agoIt's just so fucking expensive to live here, and coupled with the constant drumbeat of money money money, and seeing the vast differences in wealth, it's just so so depressing.
- ryandrake 11y agoGlad you pointed out the vast differences in wealth as a negative of the Bay Area. Even if you're not an envious person by nature, it's really depressing and grates on you when you see it day in and day out. A 15 minute drive can take you from "bullets whizzing over your head crime and poverty" to filthy, shameful mega-wealth. Parking my Toyota between a Tesla and a Maserati when I go downtown with the family. People at work talking about paying [my salary * 0.5] for their kid's private school. Sheesh... I come from a small town where the best off made maybe 3X the worst off. The Bay Area is total culture shock.
- danans 11y ago> People at work talking about paying [my salary * 0.5] for their kid's private school. Sheesh... Before you judge too much, consider that some (not all) of those folks might be paying that because they live in an area that has failing public schools, and they may be living in that area because they can't afford housing in an area with better public schools. Many middle to upper-middle class people find themselves faced with that choice. In California overall, aside from anomalies like San Francisco itself, wealthier cities correlate with better public schools, and the correlation is > linear.
- ryandrake 11y agoNot judging at all--just pointing out how weird it feels to live and work side-by-side with people on all parts of such a massively wide income spectrum.
- Tempest1981 11y agoAnd where public schools are good, it feeds back on itself, esp in Cupertino and Palo Alto. Good schools draw in tech millionaires, who supplement their kids' public education with private tutors and summer school booster classes. Scores go up, house prices follow. Seems like there is an infinite supply of newly minted tech millionaires to consume all available housing. And to be fair, who wouldn't want what's best for their kids? It's a culture of being the best.
- jorgecurio 11y agoand here I am thinking, surely Silicon Valley will be nothing like Vancouver, we are all leaving Vancouver for better paying jobs and housing we can afford.
- inmyunix 11y agowhere the heck have you been? the entire west coast of north america is in the same boat (because it's awesome). the Chinese are buying as much property as possible as fast as they can, young people are moving there as fast as they can, and we aren't making any more land.
- titanomachy 11y agoI love Vancouver, and I hope our government is able to mitigate the housing crisis before it totally tears the city apart. Families and non-professional workers are being driven further into the suburbs by housing prices, sterilizing the core of the city and fomenting a bitter class divide. We need to make radical moves -- heavy penalties for vacant properties, aggressive densification, serious investment in mass transit... We're letting a small reactionary minority filibuster these projects and dictate the city's future. From what I've heard, it's much the same in SF.
- sterl 11y agoSeattle and SF are way beyond Vancouver's unaffordability ratio. Vancouver is cheap.
- aianus 11y agoSoftware Engineers in Vancouver make ~US$45,000 a year... It's much, much less affordable there than Seattle or SF, trust me.
- neptunespear 11y ago> Software Engineers in Vancouver make ~US$45,000 a year... Which is $60K CAD. If you get roommates, rent can be $600-1000 (again, CAD)/month. Health insurance is $72/month, single-payer, and increasingly being 100% covered by tech companies. You don't have to worry about a car if you live downtown, and transit is good enough that living downtown isn't your only option if you don't want a hellish commute. (e.g. Hastings-Sunrise, Metrotown, New West)
- brightball 11y agoShameless plug: http://www.visitgreenvillesc.com/ http://www.visitgreenvillesc.com/ Greenville and Charleston, SC are working pretty hard to become tech hubs. Charleston is booming to a degree that housing is starting to go the way of SF (which is nuts in this area) but Greenville and it's surrounding cities have virtually no risk of that degree of price inflation. There's just too much land and space. I live in Easley, which is about 10 minutes from downtown Greenville and you can get a decent 1100 square foot, 2 BR/2BTH apartment with washer/drier for about $500 / month. Houses tend to run between 80-110 / sqft. Also, food is awesome: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=73GcUAb2HO0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=73GcUAb2HO0
- lukeqsee 11y agoI grew up in Greenville and am moving back in a month. I would love to connect. You didn't have anything in your profile, so feel free to drop me a line to the email in my profile, if you want.
- harryh 11y agoOh hi Greenville people! I don't have a ton to add really but since the city almost never comes up on Hacker News I just wanted to chime in. Was born there and lived there until I went to college. Mom still lives there so I visit once or twice a year. Great lil' town.
- brightball 11y agoDone and fixed the profile too.
- chriscls 11y agoI lived in Greenville for two years. For the southeast it's a pretty great spot especially if you want to own a house and have a family and comfortable life. The tech scene is good, comparatively and there are some really talented people around. The one drawback for me is the strongly ingrained conservative nature of the area.
- 11y ago
- jackcosgrove 11y agoI left the Bay Area, not Silicon Valley, 6 years ago and since then I've been able to realize a 40% salary increase (this has more to do with experience and seniority than locale - just making the point that good salaries are possible outside SV) and I've purchased a house and a rental property. The latter would have been unthinkable in the Bay Area. Plus the gender ratio is much better for men almost anywhere else. I don't even think SF and SV are good places to start out anymore. You can learn skills anywhere with the internet, and you miss out on early investments due to the opportunity cost of rent. If you want to live in the Bay Area, it's better to hunker down someplace cheaper for a decade or more, save up a down payment, and then lateral into a midlevel or senior role at a tech company, whose salaries are high enough to service a mortgage but not high enough to save a down payment and pay rent at the same time.
- cyanbane 11y agoCome to Alpharetta, Ga (or Atlanta in general). It's great. Home prices are not terrible, taxes are not bad, great schools & people are friendly. Only real problem is traffic - staggered commutes and working from home can mitigate that.
- cyanbane 11y agoSurprised at how many upvotes this has. If you honestly are looking for a coding position around here (Alpharetta), feel free to DM me (shoot me a tweet asking for refollow). I don't mind sending your info to my local contacts. I love building the local IT community. Great community, awesome local gov't support and large companies moving in daily. Honestly, it gets no better.
- jameslk 11y agoI've been wondering, as someone who has been observing the Bay Area on the outside, is it really the cost of living that's so high or just the cost of housing? I've been looking at some of the stats here: http://www.bestplaces.net/cost_of_living/city/california/palo_alto http://www.bestplaces.net/cost_of_living/city/california/pal... http://www.bestplaces.net/cost_of_living/city/california/san_francisco http://www.bestplaces.net/cost_of_living/city/california/san... It seems that aside from housing, everything else is just moderately higher. Compare that to NYC, which is also on the list: http://www.bestplaces.net/cost_of_living/city/new_york/new_york http://www.bestplaces.net/cost_of_living/city/new_york/new_y... If it's just housing that's insanely expensive, I could see why some have been trying to arbitrage the situation by living in alternate housing arrangements (think RVs), such as some notorious cases with Google employees.
- grimmdude 11y agoMy opinion is it's the cost of housing that people mainly talk about here, but often call it "cost of living". Don't get me wrong; housing is definitely part of cost of living, but if you own or are have been renting in a rent controlled situation then you don't have much to complain about really.
- fit2rule 11y agoI 'grew up' in the Valley, 80's and 90's, lucky enough to wise up and leave it by way of a move to Europe. Never looked back. My personal, subjective reality is that the reason to leave the valley is this: culture. Which is to say, by way of corollary, a reason to Be in the Valley is this: the lack of culture. Let me explain what I mean by culture: If you have to drive and park, its not culture. After 15 years of success in the Valley as a relatively content systems software developer, what it boiled down to was this: can I take a bus where I need to go? No? Well, go where the buses are. Go where the train, is. Too many long days spent in dread of the ride home, the inevitable gear-grinding maelstrom of disaster that starts on the onramp and doesn't end until you get to your generic hide-away. Cars: a reason to move.
- beachstartup 11y agowhy don't you just say you don't like cars, instead of redefining what human culture means? that would be a lot easier.
- HelloMcFly 11y agoWhile I find the comment you replied to poorly stated, I think I can buy the point if modified slightly. No matter how great any city's culture is, cities that require one to spend a significant amount of time commuting inherently limit the culture that can be experienced in any given day. I don't see how an hour car ride vs. an hour bus/train/bike ride operates any differently in this regard though inasmuch as the time spent is non-optional for traversing the city.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- acchow 11y agoYou were describing life in the valley, not the city. People in the city walk and bike and ride muni and uber.
- 11y ago
- heezo 11y agoI pay $6/sq ft for my office in Braddock, right outside of Pittsburgh, PA. ...that's $6/sq ft for a year. So two months paying for my two bedroom apartment, in Mountain View, can get me more than a year of rent for my office.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- theandrewbailey 11y agoPittsburgh is rather cheap, and it has CMU. It might be because I live here that see it in tech news every so often. There's a lot more places up for rent lately, because the fracking bubble popped.
- cwilson 11y agoMade the transition from SV to Brooklyn. Wages are basically the same, housing is much more affordable (our apartment would be at least 2k more per month in San Francisco), and there are people here who do things that are not tech! Don't get me wrong, there are plenty of startups and great companies with offices in Brooklyn and Manhattan, but it's SO refreshing to be around people who don't just want to pitch their startup or talking about growth hacking. I'm very happy with the change. I do miss the beauty of the pacific northwest, but otherwise it's been great.
- danso 11y agoSorry but I LOLed. I would've never believed you had I not made the same move, but in reverse. I lived in a good 2BR apartment in the best part of Manhattan downtown -- we even had a fireplace (but no fire escape...such is the situation with old Manhattan construction)...Now I live in Palo Alto. In a converted garage. And while it is technically a 1 bedroom, it is much, much more than what I paid for in New York. Quality of life is much worse in Palo Alto too.
- ghaff 11y agoWhen people talk about moving from downtown Manhattan to someplace else that has a much higher cost of housing, you know something is screwy!
- brooklyndavs 11y agoWow, your housing in Brooklyn is MORE affordable vs SV? What neighborhood are you in? Brooklyn has some of the highest housing costs in the country and is on par with Manhattan at times depending on the neighborhood.
- sxcurry 11y agoAs Yogi Berra said, "Nobody goes there anymore. It's too crowded."
- waimbes 11y agoD’Arcy said this type of migration—from big to smaller cities—is common around the world. The same patterns can be found in the UK and Germany, for example, with people moving from London to Cambridge and Berlin to Munich. This is a strange comment, given that 5 of the 8 cities listed as top destinations outside of San Francisco are larger cities/metro areas.
- branchless 11y agoSo you lost out due to people exploiting our flawed system which pushes all productivity gains to land speculators. Then you went and got a rental. Christ. People just love rentier activity. What is better than money for nothing!
- jcoffland 11y agoClearly you've never been a landlord.
- branchless 11y agoMany landlords have made a lot of cash for themselves using leverage by sitting on property which is forcing up land prices. I think that's undisputed. I know landlords always harp on about how hard their (chosen) path is but land prices have rocketed in SF due to this mentality. His post intimates it was a core reason for leaving. Then off he goes and joins those who let the plebs work for them once they can get a down-payment together.
- eclipxe 11y agoDon't hate the player...
- branchless 11y agoNo, we are responsible for our actions. If we have a horrible system of exploitation it is incumbent upon people to avoid this. The USA has a real problem with ethics that stems from the simple problem "it's just business". "Yeah I kicked him in the face and robbed his family, but it's just business" seems to be an acceptable sentence there. It covers a multitude of ethical sins. And let's not cop out of this with "but who decides what is ethical" - you do. This guy didn't like being exploited by high rent in SF. It also seems impossible for people in the USA / UK to imagine a world where, although they are satisfied and have plenty, they would actually forgo having even more money for ethical reasons. Thinking "yes, I could holiday in luxury and exploit my fellow man" seems fine to them. No, hate the player.
- tschellenbach 11y agoThat's true, we're hiring in Boulder and Amsterdam, angel.co/stream
- branchless 11y agoAnd then what? All other houses are doubled. Does he cash out his "money for nothing" and live elsewhere or realise that the gap between his 2 bed and a 3 bed is now also twice as large. Property speculation is utterly engraved into Western society now and it's killing it. EDIT: it's interesting how people upvote this as they can see it's a truism, but downvote my post attacking land speculators. NEWSFLASH: buying land and sitting on it to exploit scarcity creates no wealth. Therefore if you buy lower and sell higher that money comes from wealth created elsewhere, making you a leech. If you buy somewhere to live in, fine, but more than one place to speculate: you are leeching off of the labour of others. EDIT: don't have time to reply now as i've got a prod issue to debug. Read up on Henry George or don't. If you think making money from doing nothing then using the same money to consume goods is fine, well to hell with you.
- jMyles 11y agoI'm largely a believer in private property (and mostly libertarian even), but I really don't think that this dividing up the earth into tiny little squares and pushing everyone out of them in order to make money is defensible.
- branchless 11y agoYou're damn right it's not. We are effectively asking young people to join a game of monopoly that's been going for 2 hours. Would you play under those conditions? Well actually you have no choice thanks to the banks and their landlord foot-soldiers. As many economists have noted, land is not applicable to the general laws of economics because it is finite in supply. We need land value tax to squash speculators who add nothing to the world, right now.
- fapjacks 11y agoThis is one of the most astute and coherent metaphors I have ever read about the subject.
- 11y ago
- princetontiger 11y agoBoston fell off the map. Whatever happened? It seems like New York, Bay Area, and Austin, TX have become the three large Internet/App tech hubs.
- inmyunix 11y agoincredible local talent pools, the people never left after school.
- MicroBerto 11y agoThe latest complaints in Austin is the lack of access to large VC money. Personally I see that as a good thing. Go be profitable and bootstrap a bit before looking for money.
- princetontiger 11y agoVC money is stupid. Mark Cuban took VC money at the very last minute. The latest incarnation of VC-backed tech companies leave very little for the founding members.
- ghaff 11y agoLots of tech in Boston, including bio and pharma. There's just a lot less of the startup Internet/App stuff going on. But pretty much all the big West Coast firms have Boston/Cambridge offices in addition to all the local companies. Boston/Cambridge real estate has really be escalating as well, both for residential and commercial.
- Negative1 11y agoThis article is strange to me. The conclusion it tries to get you to draw is that the Bay Area is expensive to live at so techies are now starting to leave. The data they draw this conclusion from is search data for jobs. The number 1 place on that list; New York City. So people are leaving SF Bay Area to go to NYC, because it is cheaper?
- yolesaber 11y agoNYC, in my experience, is cheaper, yes. We just hired someone who left Apple to come out east because they were being priced out. Obviously NYC can be ridiculously expensive and the real estate market is annoying to navigate (broker's fees, wtf) but there is more housing stock available here, with decent-to-great public transportation that makes living in the outer boroughs pretty convenient. Brooklyn, Queens, and Jersey City (NYC metro area) are all much cheaper than SF. Even parts of Manhattan above 59th st are quite affordable.
- inmyunix 11y agoI'm guessing NYC is at the top simply because it hosts the greatest number of opportunities. it's the rest of the list that's telling. the article also points out that the age 30-40 cohort represents the greatest portion of searches, which could indicate a natural course of settling down with family etc. [which further proves to me that suburbs are not dead. it's merely been the vocal majority (millennials) blabbering on about big city living and how they'll never do this or that, only to hit the family creation stage in life and realize they were naive to think in such extreme absolutes]
- jiaweihli 11y agoI don't think this is a millenial problem, this is true of the young adult population in every generation. One trend I've noticed is that those who grow up in suburbs tend to prefer cities in their 20s, and those who grew up in cities tend to prefer urbanized suburbs.
- davidw 11y agoThere are a ton of people here in Bend who have had their fill of the bay area, and want a place where they can afford a decent house, have good schools, and so on. Feel free to ping me if you're interested in the area.
- mooreds 11y agoAnd feel free to ping me if you'd like to hear me sing the praises of Boulder, CO.
- joeax 11y agoDoesn't Boulder have similar high expense issues? I considered that area for all the tech opportunities, but found myself realizing I'd need to live 30+ miles away in Longmont for a house with a decent sized yard. I also have been considering south of Denver but it has similar expense issues.
- mooreds 11y agoIt's expensive for Colorado but I don't think it compares to SF or SV. Houses with decent size yards are 450-600k in Boulder, depending on location and square footage (7000 SF lots). Low property taxes (CO has a counterpart to prop 13, TABOR, where every tax increase needs to be voted on by the public), a flat 4% state income tax, and great schools (in Boulder) add to the attraction, IMHO. I haven't looked at the rental market for housing in depth, but I think you can get a 4br 2br ranch w basement for about 2000-2500/month. Lived most of my adult life in Boulder so can't really speak to the real estate situation in south Denver.
- davidw 11y agoI think your prices are optimistic: http://www.zillow.com/homes/for_rent/Boulder-CO/house,mobile_type/30543_rid/3-_beds/1.5-_baths/any_days/40.245205,-104.867592,39.790863,-105.760232_rect/10_zm/ http://www.zillow.com/homes/for_rent/Boulder-CO/house,mobile...
- igorgue 11y agoThe tech industry needs to be more global, why is it, that we build global communities on the internet, take pride of them, yet, we cannot make it work if we're more than 100 cm away from each other.
- gdilla 11y agoPeople keep asking this, along with why people love the bay area with it's high cost of living. It has to be obvious that a great swath of people are willing to pay high rent/housing costs to have access to: lots of sunshine, bright people everywhere, top notch arts, culture, food scenes, good universities. And that should be enough of an answer. Silicon Valley isn't more international because they don't have to be.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoYet there are so many other places with almost all of that. And not the high cost of living.
- gdilla 11y agowell, i forgot the most important part: be in a cluster of a jobs, opportunity and entrepreneurship. Where else is going to match all that? Taken together, NorCal leads the world in spades,
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoI've worked for Silicon Valley startups all my life. From Iowa. Remotely.
- gdilla 11y agoSure. But you live in Iowa. You may like it, but many people don't. It's great that it works for you. As a visible minority, I wouldn't be too comfortable myself in any of the flyover states. The lack of diversity and general ignorance (But where are you FROM?) is not worth $200/month rent to me.
- erickhill 11y agoI moved my family (wife, 2 kids) from SF/Bay Area to Seattle in 2011 after living down there for a decade (and loved most of it). Worked in downtown SF, lived in the East Bay. For a while there, we could drive our Prius over the bridge in the HOV lane - and bypass tolls - and I could get to work from my house in 18 minutes. We owned a home in El Cerrito near Albany with some initial d/p help from family. It was a very nice neighborhood, walkable, and close to BART (which we also used regularly). The house was small, but we made it work. But the school situation was horrific. Either go to so-so schools which lacked financial support at the time, or pay upwards of 20K for private school kindergarten. Nope! In Seattle, with as much public angst as there is for the schools here, they are light years ahead of the public options we had before us down there. Everything up here just feels easier. Stress reduced, larger house for kids to grow up in, neighborhood where everyone knows everyone else no matter where you go - I've never experienced this type of community my whole life. And the tech sector has plenty of opps here, too. We love it. To be fair, my wife has to commute to SF at least twice a month for her job, so she still gets her SF fix. I, on the other hand, have gone pure North West. I've got my Subaru to prove it. ;)
- bduerst 11y agoConstruction of the Salesforce tower has started. According to the skyscraper theory, there is an economic bubble set to burst in SF before 2018. Maybe this is one of the signals?
- jghoman 11y agoAfter eight years in Silicon Valley, we returned home to Seattle last year. Bought a huge house on an acre with awesome schools. Now that I'm a parent, it just wasn't worth the cognitive dissonance of doing very well financially, but not being able to buy my family a good home. There are definitely things I miss, but overall, it was absolutely the right move to make. The job market, while 1/10th what is was back in the valley, is still great. Now that Microsoft is embracing open source, the vast pool of talent that was previously locked away in msft's proprietary tech will be free to leave and spin off many new start ups over the next few years. SF in your 20s, South Bay in your early 30s and Seattle when you have a family.
- rconti 11y agoI moved the opposite direction. Granted, I'm only in my mid-30s, but I have no plans to move back to the Northwest. I love it when I visit, but I realize what you see of an area when you visit is very different from when you live there. I always visit when weather is nice, I don't mind the traffic as much when I'm on vacation.. Granted, the traffic on the Peninsula has gotten really bad in the past few years, it's ALMOST as bad as Seattle!
- kin 11y agoAs a happy engineer in LA, I'm pretty sad to see we're not in the top 8. I just wanted it say that the tech industry here is pretty great and you should all check it out. Actually, talent is pretty hard to come by down here and plenty of companies are hiring.
- donretag 11y agoI moved to LA last year and I love it. Great salary, while having a much lower rent compared to SF/NY.
- leetNightshade 11y agoNot the best comparison points when you're comparing the most expensive places to live in the United States. L.A. is still kind of expensive compared to everywhere else besides those mentioned. My gf and I are considering sharing an apartment with another couple just to be able to make a dent in our student debt and savings. I can't imagine owning a house or a condo. I also don't foresee being able to afford having kids for some time. Hell, I'm holding off on getting a dog because of high rent.
- striking 11y agoIs that still true compared to the (as above) higher salary in LA compared to the other places?
- leetNightshade 11y agoWith cost of living going up, minimum wage going up, you think business would think to bump their base wages up to account for cost of living. But not everyone does, and some that do don't do it by much. One example is my gf: set production assistant wages have not gone up with cost of living in the area, at least for the companies she works for. Set production assistants are freelance, non-reliable work with sometimes terrible hours. You think they'd make okay money. But even in L.A. where the industry is at it's biggest, they're usually shortchanged. Another example: A friend of mine accepted a position as a mid-level gameplay programmer at a place that is choosing to pay them hourly so they can make them work overtime without having to pay $100k or more, because of CA law. Yet another business strong-arming someone who wasn't in a good position to negotiate due to circumstances. Hopefully that friend can work their way into a senior level position soon, but even then not every place pays senior level as well as they should. Industry can be very stingy, focusing on the short-term business instead of long term employees.
- rdl 11y agoI've been wanting to leave the Bay Area for at least 3 years -- Seattle, Austin, or Berlin. I don't love California, but really dislike virtually everything about San Francisco. Of course, I've been working in San Francisco for 21 months now, but that's because of a specific company -- otherwise I'd be gone, at least to the South Bay. SFBA is not a good place to hire engineers, unless you're heavily funded AND a clear winner and need to hire a bunch of diverse types. For anything else, I could find other places which are far superior. It's a great place to hire professional services to support startups, and the best place in the world, hands down, to raise money. YC being here makes it great early on, too. I think investors become less location-sensitive as you get to later stages, if you're winning. The biggest problem is if you're selling b2b to tech companies at all, you can literally bump into your customers here. With my next startup, I plan to do Seattle (probably) or Austin for a US office, with a small SFBA presence, and then Berlin, and run EU and US companies as separate entities with separate officers, so people can choose if they want to be customers of a US or EU company. Maybe add other location in the future. (I'd obviously be doing something in the infosec space, which is becoming increasingly jurisdiction sensitive.) I absolutely encourage people to work in SFBA for a while to build a network, but after that, GTFO unless you really want to be here.
- rudolf0 11y agoOut of curiosity, why would you prefer other US cities over a Californian city? (That is, why don't you love California. Also excluding European alternatives.)
- rdl 11y agoCA laws (guns, primarily; taxes, secondarily, and a bunch of other stuff. Guns are a personal thing for me, but the rest has business impact.). I'd also like to actually be involved in my community somewhere, but everything about SF (and CA) is repellent to doing that. (In Bellevue/Issaquah/etc., I'd happily be a volunteer EMT or even reserve PD officer; might get involved in local non-partisan politics. There is no way I'd ever want to do anything like that in SF.) There are also no non-SFBA cities in CA that I'd actually want to do an infosec startup in. The set of places I'd personally consider (in no real order) is: Seattle, Portland, SFBA, Austin, DC-Metro, Boston, Boulder/Denver, SLC, Raleigh/Durham. I dislike NYC and Chicago but those are also viable (also dislike Atlanta; might be ok). I actually like Las Vegas, Nashville, and Louisville, but they would be challenging. I think Houston, Dallas, Miami, Phoenix, LA, San Diego, Philadelphia, Pittsburgh could work, but not sure. Some other big university places (Ann Arbor being the canonical example) could be fine if you're from there.)
- jonesb6 11y agoDuh?
- ashwinaj 11y agoI guess it depends on what you want. I think it's fair to say that most work places outside of SV have less innovation (with some exceptions of course). I'm saying this as someone who moved from Texas to SV. For me personally, there are tons of activities to do and not enough time in SV, which wasn't the case in Texas. It's a fast paced life and it took a while to get used to. Yes there are negatives: cost of living, taxes, commute etc. but I'm okay with this trade off. IMO, I don't need 4 acres of land in the middle of suburbia or nowhere with nothing to do.
- anacleto 11y agoThis is happening. Finally.
- bobstobener 11y agoI always thought it was incredibly ironic that an industry that's responsible for creating the virtual world would require all those working to create it to live in the same physical neighborhood.
- biztos 11y agoI moved to Europe a few years ago, though entirely for personal reasons and not because of the cost of living in the SF Bay Area. I'm sure I'd be making more money if I'd stayed, but I'm also pretty sure I wouldn't have the same quality of life. I know others who did the same thing, and are doing fine over here ("here" being mostly Berlin but also further afield). I think the trick is to know what you're moving for, as opposed to what you're moving away from. In most cases you will make less money, at least over time, and miss out on career opportunities. But there are other opportunities people in SF are missing out on. And as others have said, the income difference can easily be balanced out by a cost-of-living difference.
- rjurney 11y agoIf you don't do R&D, if you don't aspire to founding a successful startup, if you don't need to work with the smartest people on the latest tech... the Bay Area does not make sense. But if you check yes to any of those, you get what you pay for.
- emirozer 11y agoi am sorry but this is a very elitist comment, please consider all the successful startups that are born outside of Bay Area/US and really smart people who work on them...
- rjurney 11y agoI'm not disparaging those people. However, the fact is that the best and brightest give up a lot to move to the bay area and build the things that change the world.
- joeax 11y agoI've been working from home of the past four years. About once or twice a month I get an email from a recruiter from the Bay Area. I in turn reply that I'd be interested if I didn't have to relocate and can continue working from home, to which they usually reply no. At what point in this tech worker shortage/drastic expensive economy do I convince one of these companies that I'd be a better value working remotely, even willing to work for less salary? The tooling is so good now it almost seems like I'm in an office anyway. And the irony is many of these companies already have distributed teams that use these tools. What am I missing?
- selmat 11y agoI am from Europe and all European companies/offices have same attitude. Even you have global customer/projects and nobody (from customer side) cares if your are sitting here or 500 kilometers over there. They still expect the same service. From my point of view there are issues like "knowledge sharing", team spirit, group problem solving, reporting, etc. All of these "important" reasons are raised to be on-site, even you have project specific position where you are the only one who has required knowledge (nobody for sharing), you are the only one working on project (like migrations).
- tedmiston 11y agoIt seems like we have some fully remote startups (Buffer) and SMBs (Basecamp) that embrace this culture. But I think the problem is that you're being contacted by recruiters in the bay at big tech cos. The small cos. might not have a recruiter, and the big cos. grew big without a remote-first culture.
- joeax 11y agoThose companies are definitely on the bleeding edge of remote work culture, but there seem to be many others who would hire someone remote if it were the right fit (my company for example). I've been contacted by outside recruiters and corporate recruiters big and small, but when in comes to bay area they always seem to be hellbent on you being on site. Then again, maybe it's because I'm not really looking, and I'm being contacted by those who are just grasping at straws at that point.
- wambotron 11y agoI never went to SV or the Bay Area for work, instead opting for NYC since I lived nearby anyway (nearby being within 3 hours). It's a similar issue, though. Housing is way too much. Taxes are horrendous. You make a good salary, but the cost to live there is rough, especially if you have a family. I still work for a NYC-based company, I just work remotely from Richmond, VA. I like it better this way. I may not always work for a NYC co, but I will stay here. I bought a house last year that would be well into the millions in NYC's commutable suburbs. My kids go to just as good of a school as they did in NJ. There is no traffic to speak of. If you have a dream of being in one of those cities, one of those scenes, then by all means, go for it. It's just not for me (and from what I can see, a lot of other folks on here).
- Swizec 11y agoSo here's a question: why do you absolutely need to own a house? I'm 28, still haven't figured out why people are so obsessed with the idea of owning. What practical benefits does it give you? All I can see are many many downsides. edit: I can see it making more sense if you can pay the whole sum in full on the day of purchase.
- niccaluim 11y agoThe money you spend on your mortgage (minus interest) is still yours, in the form of equity. If/when you sell, you get that money back, modulo market fluctuations. Or your kids get it via inheritance. When you rent, you might as well be lighting that money on fire. There are a few other terms in the equation (property taxes in particular) but that's it in a nutshell.
- Swizec 11y agoI've heard that argument a lot. Then I calculate how much a mortgage costs for an apartment in a place I'd like to live in. And the mortgage payments are literally more than for rent. Take SF for example. I'd need $1mil to buy an apartment. At 30 years, that gives me a mortgage payment of $4700. Rent for a similar apartment is $3400. And I don't have to pay for upkeep. So if my rent stays the same, I will have saved almost $40,000 in the next 30 years. I can do a lot with an extra $1300 per month. Not to mention I can maintain my desired lifestyle of moving every 2 years or so.
- nnnnnn 11y agoAfter leaving the YC startup I co-founded, then doing consulting in SF for about 6 months after, I decided to leave the valley at the end of 2015. Where did I move to? Medellin, Colombia. While I'm not sure I'll stay here forever and may move back to SF at some point, I'm definitely enjoying living down here for the moment. I'm doing remote software consulting, so I am geographically agnostic. I definitely miss friends, the hustle, and being surrounded by smart people in SF. However, there are a lot of things I do not miss about SF. For example: Prices: SF <> Medellin Rent: $2000 (mediocre) <> $300 (nice, best part of town) Nice restaurant dinner: $30-40 <> $10-15 Uber (20 mins): $25 <> $3
- michaelvkpdx 11y agoIf your mindset is $$$ first it doesn't matter where you live. We have a ton of valley expats here in Portland. The ones who are really artists and creatives at heart and work to subsidize their outside lives tend to thrive here. The ones who just want to live more cheaply end up miserable because this is not California North. Wanna move to Portland? By all means come on up! But leave your dot-com privilege and your "live to impress VC's" mentality back home. Come to Oregon and be an Oregonian. Also- if you're attached to your car, Portland is not for you. The commutes from the 'burbs are as nasty as the Bay Area, and the inner city is made for biking and walking. Your car is good for the weekends- getting to the Coast and the Mountains- but not for your work week. Change your perspective on commuting. This ain't CAr-ifornia Note- I said "weekends", meaning Saturday and Sunday when you are not working. If that is a foreign concept to you, Oregon is not for you.
- swang 11y agoHoly cow are you a character from Portlandia? I mean I was fine with most of what you said until you literally wrote, CAr-ifornia. What? People actually use that word and expect to be taken seriously? I mean maybe there are people who talk too much about VCs, but your post didn't make you sound any better than those people. Talk about exclusionary.
- nedwin 11y ago"The ones who just want to live more cheaply end up miserable because this is not California North." Why do you think that is? I'm interested in it due to the lifestyle but also the idea of being able to afford to bootstrap my next company in the next year or so. My gf had a friend who moved up but couldn't stand the lack of sun (former San Diegoan) - this has made her reticent to make the move from our rent-controlled shoebox...
- alexc05 11y agoWow. That makes me really want to move to Portland! Sounds glorious.
- billhendricksjr 11y agoAustin is a great city. I went to school there, lived there for 10 years, and went through Techstars there 10 years later. But the cynic in me wants to point out that Indeed.com is based in Austin has a vested interest in bringing more talent to town.
- sevensor 11y agoLived in Austin (Hyde Park), loved it, but it felt like I was constantly bidding up the price of things that used to be appealing because they were so fun, simple, and cheap. Barbecue, housing, Mother's, breakfast tacos... When I left in 2010, the only part of the city that still felt real and vital to me was Lamar north of Central Market. The part with the stip malls.
- blakecallens 11y agoI left California (L.A.) for Raleigh three and half years ago and my quality of life skyrocketed. The pay is the same, the worst N.C. commute is half of the best California commute, and my mortgage is the same cost as my 650 sq ft apartment was.
- RomanPushkin 11y agocan you explain what exactly have skyrocketed? I'm considering moving to NC
- kabdib 11y ago12 years ago we moved from Silly Valley (where I worked for 20 years at places you've definitely heard of, and some start-ups) to the Seattle area. Great move, would do it again. With the exception of a little weather and geography (the motorcycling is definitely poorer up here), I don't miss SV at all. I definitely don't miss California. Never going back there.
- nlh 11y agoOk, counterpoint: I moved to SF from NYC about 3 years ago and, yes, it's now definitely more expensive than NYC. But I've built a friend network here that's absolutely unsurpassed in my short 37 years on this earth. I feel more at home in SF than I ever did in NYC - I see friendly faces all around the city, I run into people when out for a walk, I've got a group of people I cycle with regularly. So - for that reason - even if you offered me 2x what I earn and a home/apartment 3x the size - I wouldn't even give leaving a minute's thought. How does that play into the thinking for other folks? Do the folks who are thinking of just picking up and leaving not have friends they care about? There's got to be more to where you live than whether or not you own a home (and how big it is)....
- taurath 11y agoI lived in the bay for 10 years - 2004-2014. Half of my friends from there are now up in Seattle where I am. Wait until you stop seeing all those friendly familiar faces around the city because their landlord decided to sell the place. I don't think I have any friends left in the bay that are in an industry other than tech.
- iblaine 11y agoI left SV for Santa Barbara and could not be more happy. My compensation package took a hit but living expenses decreased proportionally. More importantly, I got my life back. My commute went from 90 mins to 15 mins and my family is happier.
- sixQuarks 11y agoMoved to Portland recently. If you move here, don't tell people you're from the Bay Area. They don't like your kind around here. The quality of life is 500% better here in Portland than the Bay Area. Even if housing prices were the same, I would still prefer living in Portland.
- steveax 11y agoNaw, us stumptowners don't mind y'all moving up here. Just don't be spreading lies about how great life in Portland is. Sucks up here, rains all the time, can't find a good cup of joe or pint of beer to save your life. Did I mention the rain?
- sixQuarks 11y agooh, actually you're right. I forgot about all that. It does suck here, you all don't want to come here, too wet. Beer sucks so bad, no good food anywhere. Nothing to see here, carry on.
- optimusclimb 11y agoSo your desires to use and own devices designed to maim and kill people is what keeps you from wanting to have a technology company in one of the intellectual hubs of the country?
- sliverstorm 11y agoYou might even say it's people like you he/she is tired of!
- dang 11y agoPlease don't respond in kind; instead, flag the comment by clicking on its timestamp to go to its page, then clicking 'flag' at the top.
- sliverstorm 11y agoSorry; I use 'flag' so rarely I forget it's there. I remembered when I saw the parent comment has been flagged.
- dang 11y agoPersonal attacks are not allowed on Hacker News. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11198270 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11198270 and marked it off-topic.
- iamleppert 11y agoI came to the bay area five years ago from Ohio where I was working a soul-sucking job. I have two roommates and a SO, and my rent is $800 (my cost) for a two bedroom loft in Potrero hill. I get the opportunity to work at an amazing startup and have been able to build a specialization in mapping technologies. On the weekends, I can hike or take a day trip or go to Sausalito, Angel Island, or just hang out and get high at Delores Park. Sometimes it feels like life isn't real we are so privileged around here, despite all the negativity. I've made lifelong friends and connections here who "get me" more any other place I've lived. The gay community here is also especially strong...and weird! ;-P It makes me sad that people are struggling, but I think the key is to value your experiences and spend the best part of your life less consumed with strict acquisition of wealth, and more with the depth and richness of experience. Of course that's a trade off. Here's my advice on the bay area: Don't rent an apartment in SOMA. Don't be consumed with trying to buy a house. Learn to accept living with roommates even though you make 6-figures and your friends back home are buying huge houses on far less. Forget about trying to save a lot of money. Be creative in your living situation if you want to save money. Enjoy your life and all that SF has to offer. I've lived all over the world and there's no place like it. I guess for most people they are consumed with having kids and feel pressure to own a home and save for retirement. I've been able to save money and keep my living expenses down by having roommates, but I know owning a home here is probably out of my reach and that's OK. If you're unhappy here and really want to live a different lifestyle, and SF isn't able to provide you what you need to be happy, I would say you should move so you can give someone else the chance to be happy and thrive here.
- massysett 11y ago> Learn to accept living with roommates even though you make 6-figures and your friends back home are buying huge houses on far less. I'm glad you like the Bay Area and this is a great post. If this is what it takes to love the Bay Area it's no wonder people would want to leave. But you are right. The extraordinary expense of living there will chase a lot of privileged people away because they don't want to pay the price. (Unfortunately some of the less privileged cannot be so flexible.)
- acchow 11y ago
- kazinator 11y agoI want to design a system that will be fabricated in China, and sold to customers in Europe. I expect my engineers will work from home a lot of the time. Where should I locate the firm? I know! How about the most expensive fucking are in the USA, so I have to pay the highest possible salaries, which everyone will blow on basic living costs.
- s3nnyy 11y agoIf you look for a coding job in Europe, Zurich is a great place to live and is the only place where net-salaries are on par with the Bay Area. Salaries are in the range of 7000 - 12000 CHF / month after taxes and apartments can be way cheaper than in San Francisco. I am a technical recruiter with a software engineering background and I live in Zurich. You find my email address in my HN-handle.
- scentoni 11y agoZurich is one of the most expensive cities in the world to live[1], though I have fond memories of when I did my postdoc there. I lived downtown a block from the Hell's Angels, 4 blocks from where the junkies and hookers hung out, and it was still cleaner than most parts of San Francisco. [1] https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=cost+of+living+index+zurich+vs+san+francisco https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=cost+of+living+index+z...
- s3nnyy 11y agoThat is right but Zurich is tiny and almost everyone lives "in the suburbs" where the rents are half as much and which only means a 10-15 min commute[1] to town (using the superb public transport). [1]"Living in the suburbs" anywhere else in the world but Switzerland means a >1h commute...
- jxm262 11y agoOf all the comments I see stating how happy they were to _leave_ San Francisco. I'm wondering if there's anyone in the opposite - happy _moving to_ San Francisco. I live in Mid-Ohio (Columbus), and have been contemplating a move for some time. I know there's lots of tech companies outside of the Bay Area, but it seems like there's sooo much concentration there that I want to experience it at least for a short while. I was planning to try it out for a year or so, but now I'm not so sure. FWIW, I make about 100k and but plan a significant increase when I transition into my own consulting full-time.
- arebop 11y agoI was very happy to move to SF from the midwest, because: much better job (albeit with lower pay and much higher living costs), more walkable city, can-do/optimistic/accepting culture, better weather, more options in the job market. But things were much cheaper then and something's gotta give. If not for rent control, I might have moved away already.
- jxm262 11y agoWow , I wasn't aware of rent control in SF, but a quick google search shows there's a big debate. Any suggestions on where to best look for apartments? From my brief visit (1 week trip) I really liked pretty much all over the downtown area, although it looks crazy expensive. I'll be living with my gf, so the rent would be split between the 2 of us which makes it easier.
- arebop 11y agoThe cool part of town where the new billionaires live is The Mission. Note that it is a transitional area with a more crimey side (east) and a more gentrified side (west). This is also the area where anti-tech-worker sentiment, violence, etc. is most common. The Castro is a nice, vibrant gayborhood in the south. The Tenderloin/Civic Center/Western SOMA are pretty gritty, but other than that the entire northeast quadrant is nice and walkable. The western half of the city has a more suburban flavor and worse weather, but it's cheaper. In general, I'd recommend you take a short-term rental to explore the city rather than trying to lockdown a long-term rental from afar. Especially because the open houses are often open for an hour or two and result in waiting lists (dozens of would-be tenants) in length. Also, just be aware of rent control. I think the market prices aren't any different between older (rent-controlled) and newer buildings, but after a couple of years of 20% pa price increases for the non-rent-controlled place, the rent controlled unit will be much relatively cheaper.
- ryandrake 11y agoA question I have for you folks who left SF for a smaller town: Aren't you worried about what you'll do if/when you lose your job or have to leave? In the Bay Area, you walk across the street resume in hand to one of the 5 tech companies in that office park and you're all set (in the best times), or you tough it out through a 3-6 month job search (in not so great times). In small town America, you may be working for the only tech company in 200 miles. What happens when the recession comes? I moved from small-town tech to SF tech for the employment security.
- timr 11y agoTalk to someone who lived through the first dot-com crash. A lot of good folks were moving from the bay area, because they couldn't find jobs. Living here is no guarantee of anything, except (possibly) of a higher cost of living. Tech is such a weirdly age-distorted industry that there seems to be no historical memory. They forget that as recently as 2009, a lot of highly qualified people around here were struggling to get work.
- enjo 11y agoThere are lots of places with thriving technology scenes. It's not exclusive to the Bay area. A high skill programmer is going to have no problem findings jobs in places like Portland, Austin, Seattle, Denver, Boston, or New York. With the rise in remote work moving beyond even those places isn't going to be problematic for most.
- nfriedly 11y agoI worked remote before moving to the bay area, and went back to working remote when I moved back home (Ohio). It might not be for everyone, but I enjoy it.
- hwstar 11y agoIf I weren't in San Diego and in SV or SF instead, I'd move to another city like Los Angeles, or where I am now. Most other US states allow noncompetes. I won't sign a noncompete so unless they'll let me work without one, I won't be working outside of California. Additionally, California labor laws are more employee friendly when compared to other states. I know this limits my choices as businesses are leaving California due to the employee-friendly labor laws and the high cost of housing, but I'm semi-retired anyway so it doesn't matter to me. I can be choosy when it comes to taking a job.
- analog31 11y agoWhat's it like to raise kids in SV? How are the public schools?
- RomanPushkin 11y agoit's hard. Prices are really high, and land lords are not friendly. We've been discriminated two times, we found affordable apartments, but were said that little one will make noise for downstairs tenants. Complained to department of housing 2 months ago, no reply.
- simonebrunozzi 11y agoTL;DR: Indeed.com, a job search site, published stats that show how tech workers in the Bay Area, and especially those from age 31 to 40, are increasingly looking for job opportunities outside, mostly in New York, Austin, Seattle. This might be attributed to the search for a balance between happiness and opportunity. Also, this type of migration is common in other parts of the world, and tech companies are willing to follow these trends, such as Facebook opening offices in Austin and Seattle, or Google in Portland. Shameless plug: I started posting summaries of HN stories here: https://github.com/simonebrunozzi/MNMN https://github.com/simonebrunozzi/MNMN
- jmspring 11y agoBay Area native here. Born basically at 17 and 85, aside from some months living in Europe, I've lived in the Bay Area my whole life. With my current role, I work at home full time unless traveling -- I do go up to SF now and then to hang out with other team mates who do go into the office. I like the flexibility, the lack of time spent in a car, etc. That said, we will likely relocated for a period of time later this year/early next north of Seattle for a bit of a change (ties there). That may dictate the overall plans we have. Honestly, while having strong ties here (and owning a house) I'm not wedded to this area. Cost for the quality of life (I live in Santa Cruz) is ridiculous -- crime, drugs, etc. -- surfing and biking are great though. I suspect the balance we will end up finding is part time in CA, part time in WA, and part time in Europe -- we both currently have location independent jobs.
- pj_mukh 11y agoI'm not convinced this is a zero sum game. There will be a lot of small Silicon Valleys popping up. And as companies in these little valleys grow and/or die (germinating other companies), they will grow to be the size of SV and maybe support the capital costs of some of the moonshots that take place in SV. SV will always be there to welcome new entrants into the tech industry and foster old ones :). Source: Proud Waterloo-ite surrounded by Ex-Blackberries. Possibly moving to the Valley soon. P.S: Every region that wants to grow will face the real-estate crunch SV is. Look to your municipal laws/stucture to see how your region will weather this storm.
- mathattack 11y agoMy 2 cents as someone who left the Bay Area in 2003 and came back in 2014... If you want to be at the core of a game changing software company that's got a decent shot of being a rocket ship, you're most likely to do it in the Bay Area. It isn't about getting rich, or cost of living or any of that. If you want a good stable technology job with a large house in a good school district, you can get it anywhere. If you want to maximize the likelihood of earning cash, hold your nose and go to Wall Street. If you want to work at Google or Facebook, you can live very well outside the Bay Area. But... The best chance at grabbing onto the next Google or Facebook, it's best to go where these companies are sprouting from.
- kzhahou 11y agoWhat companies in other areas should people be looking at?
- DonHopkins 11y agoBad thing about Silicon Valley: All the burners. [1] Nice thing about Silicon Valley: The quiet, peaceful time of year during which all the burners are on the playa. [2] [1] http://megagogo.co/ http://megagogo.co/ [2] https://www.jwz.org/blog/2014/08/i-wish-you-could-stay-on-the-playa-forever-too https://www.jwz.org/blog/2014/08/i-wish-you-could-stay-on-th...
- mwfunk 11y agoRegarding the specific case of working in SV while living in SV vs. commuting from SF: I've lived in SV for about 9 years now. I know a lot of people who live up in SF and commute to SV. I don't know how accurate this is, but my observation is that SF housing prices are >= SV. The people that live in SF and commute to SV universally do it because they would prefer to live in SF for one reason or another, rather than for financial reasons. When comparing what $x of housing will get you in SF vs. SV, the SF equivalent for the same price will have very different characteristics. The SV housing will likely be much newer and less unique than the SF housing, but it will also likely be in better condition than the SF housing. Another huge aspect is the length of that commute. It's 60-90 minutes each way, every day. Some people are much more OK with that than others- I personally couldn't do it. The big SV companies have generally nice buses with bathrooms and wifi, where you might be able to get work done and might even be comfortable, but even so that means 3 hours/day on a bus. A nice bus, but still- 3 hours/day on a bus is 3 hours/day on a bus. Now, some people will say that's great, because they use SF public transport and take the company bus to work and now they don't have to spend money on a car. In theory that sounds great, but what if you want a car? You're living in northern California, which I think is one of the most beautiful, varied, and interesting places in the world. Not owning a car means not being able to take off on a whim and go drive down Big Sur, or out to the desert, or Tahoe, or wherever. In theory a non-car-owner could rent a car when they want one and enjoy that lifestyle, but in practice most people end up sticking to destinations they can get to via public transit. That might not be a tradeoff everyone wants to make. Ah, one might say, but you can have it both ways! You can own a car and live in SF, and still enjoy the commuter buses. Well, get ready to spend several hundred dollars a month on a place to store your car that you only use for weekend jaunts, road trips, and whatever needs pop up. Now the housing that was $x in SV that included car storage will cost you $(x + y) in SF, where $y is the cost of a parking space. All of which is a long-winded way of saying that SF and SV cost about the same but it's very hard to do an apples-to-apples comparison of what $x will get you in either place. The choice comes down to how an individual assigns weights to the pros and cons of each locale.
- rdlecler1 11y agoIt's interesting that almost all the comments are related to housing costs. If Silicon Valley dies as the premier tech hub it will be because there wasn't enough done to develop housing for a growing population. That would be such a shame.
- Tempest1981 11y agoWhat should be done, and by whom? New housing is going up all the time, but with the economy booming, demand is insatiable.
- rdlecler1 11y agoThere is too much obstructionism to develop new housing. The pace of development is actually quite slow.
- greggarious 11y agoI work for a nonprofit in DC. I have a higher standard of living, lower stress, shorter commute, and generally am happier than friends in the Bay Area making 120K, when I make about half that. It says something about my time in the valley that DC feels cheap.
- aagha 11y agoIt's so surprising to me that so many of the posts here are about owning a house. Why is that so important? Sure, real-estate is a good investment, but it's a volatile one (especially given the current market in most major US cities). I would not sacrifice my quality of life (diversity, food, education, etc.) to live somewhere else because it was cheaper.