5 ms·
America’s airlines are introducing a class below economy
- s_m_t 11y agoHow exactly is this a bad thing? When I buy a plane ticket I only buy it for the privilege of being flown from one area of the country to the other, I don't care about anything else and I don't want to pay for anything more.
- baby 11y agoI don't think it's a bad thing. But the experience of flying has now became more than awful. Between the 2 hours TSA lines that make people miss their flights, the "you have to walk bare foot to pass the security" while we shout at you, the lack of space when you're sitting at your seat, ...
- CardenB 11y agoHave you flown recently? I don't think flying is as bad as you describe, at all.
- dmak 11y agoIf you have you flown domestically in other countries (such as Japan), you'll be surprised how easy and fast it is. It was like the 90s in the U.S.
- rayiner 11y agoI don't remember it really being any better in the 90's. The only difference was you walked through a metal detector instead of a millimeter wave machine.
- mikeash 11y agoAnd you could bring a drink and keep your shoes on and nobody was swabbing and bomb testing your toothpaste. The cumulative effect made the lines move about four times faster. Edit: I think there's also a lot of inefficiency. So often I see a huge line, half the equipment sitting idle, and half the TSA agents standing around talking to each other. I don't remember that sort of thing in the before times. Maybe because the security people were employed by private companies motivated to get their money's worth.
- azakai 11y agoTrue. If you get TSA Pre, though, then you get something very much like the 90's experience.
- baby 11y agoBut then you are giving money to the TSA.
- epoxyhockey 11y agoPlus fingerprints and the benefit of being entered into another government database. There is also no guarantee that the precheck line will be open at the airport for the time you visit.
- pklausler 11y ago+1 for TSA Pre-Check. Also, Global Entry. Well worth the trouble to apply for.
- marak830 11y agoIs it that bad over there now? I have never flown domesic in the us, i mean i had heard it was bad, but i had assumed tey were just the worst of the worst horror stories.
- rayiner 11y agoI just took a flight DCA - ORD the other day. Stood in line maybe 5-6 minutes. I regularly get sub-10 minute trips through security at BWI. I think people confuse airport congestion with security holdups. Carry-on x-rays have been mandated for a very long time (long before 9/11). And people always had to walk one-at-a-time through the metal detectors. What's happened over the last 25 years or so is a massive increase in air travel in the U.S., without a corresponding increase in airport capacity.
- baby 11y agoI went to ORD 7 times this last year, plus went there to pick up people 6 other times. I think maybe once I didn't have to wait for more than 30min. Also waited 3 hours for someone to cross the border last time I was there (obviously non-american, after she had spent 13 hours in a plane). This is just backwards. > Carry-on x-rays have been mandated for a very long time You didn't have to wait so much. You didn't have to go barefoot. You didn't have to go through the "get naked" machine.
- Grue3 11y agoI flew domestically in Japan, Sapporo - Tokyo. It was pretty bad, I almost missed the plane standing in the super-long line to registration. To be fair, I think it's considered to be one of the most congested domestic routes in the world. But especially in Japan I'd take train over plane any time.
- matwood 11y agoI agree with you. I have not had an issue flying in years.
- baby 11y agoYeah I fly quite often, I hate it. I guess it also depends where you are flying? I've flied in Asia and Europe without a problem this past year, but as soon as you're in the US you get TSA.
- viraptor 11y agoI think it depends on the length of the flight. I'm happy to go with Ryanair in Europe (not sure you can go with a worse airline), because it's max 2-3h. But there's no way I'd do that for a longer flight for a number of reasons. For a 23h trip, I'll definitely get the better option I can reasonably afford.
- officialchicken 11y agoTransavia - the Dutch competitor of Ryan Air and owned by KLM is one to avoid as well.
- aikah 11y ago> When I buy a plane ticket I only buy it for the privilege of being flown from one area of the country to the other Sure you want to pay for a confortable flight that will not make you feel totally exhausted or in bad shape once you land. Would you travel from US to UK while standing up because it would be 50% cheaper? with no toilets ? and a 100% fee for luggage ? because after all, you "only buy it for the privilege of being flown from one area of the country to the other". I remember a time when consumers believed their interest was the best possible value for their money. Now we have a generation who justifies the worse business practices "because corporations must maximise profit for their shareholders" ? How is it in the interest of the consumer ?
- H0n3sty 11y agoWhen I read the title I thought about Spirit airlines - funny that they mentioned this being done in response to Spirit.
- dmak 11y agoInteresting how the airline industry has become a race to the bottom.
- masterleep 11y agoInteresting how people value low prices and companies are reacting to their wishes.
- two2two 11y agoAvg. air fares have only dropped 13.8% since 1995. Nearly 20 years of innovation later.
- masterleep 11y agoSounds like a fantastic achievement compared to college education, health care, or government.
- rayiner 11y agoIn 1995, jet fuel was $0.50 per gallon. Between 2010-14 it was almost $3 per gallon. It's about $1 now.
- bendykstra 11y agoThe bottom being an exceptionally safe and rapid form of transportation. As someone who is willing to endure mild discomfort in return for $20-$100, I welcome this new option.
- Zikes 11y agoI will happily fly in the equivalent of a capsule hotel if the prices are reasonable.
- greggman 11y agoA capsule hotel to me would nearly be as good as first class for long flights. Much much better than actual business class because I'd get to sleep.
- viraptor 11y agoSame. I just can't sleep sitting up. It doesn't matter how much free space there is, I'd take horizontal, stacked place over business class seat/pod.
- pklausler 11y agoWhat sucks about this is that many corporate travel policies require you to take the lowest available fare for a trip. So now that's going to often be an even more horrible cattle-car steerage nightmare than it is today. I'm not overly tall and not seriously claustrophobic but I already view airline travel outside "first class" with dread -- these new sub-economy fares are going to be torture.
- mbell 11y agoDon't work for them, it's pretty simple. I don't know what field you work in, but give that this is HN I assume you're a developer, if so you'll probably not see a better job market, don't put up with shit.
- Pyxl101 11y agoIt's not pretty simple if travel is an insignificant part of your job that you only undertake once every year or few years. (You shouldn't casually suggest that someone quit their job over something that might be and probably is trivial just because they don't like it. It's disingenuous. Note, I didn't downvote you, though I thought about it.) But there are better solutions than that, anyway. Corporate travel policies might only reimburse the cheapest fair, but you can often book a better fair and reimburse the cheapest rate while paying the discrepancy yourself if you wish (which is how you might fly first class).
- mbell 11y ago> It's not pretty simple if travel is an insignificant part of your job that you only undertake once every year or few years. If you're concerned over uncomfortable travel 'once every year or few years' then you have better things to be worried about. I can't imagine a better example of a 'first world problem'.
- greggarious 11y agoConsidering one of those employers is the federal government (and anyone receiving money from them) that could be harder than you expect. Almost all of my travel in grad school was funded through taxpayer money. You ever fly to Okinawa in economy? It's not fun.
- kawera 11y agoNext, no seating at all, just standing, like in a metro train at 6pm!
- GFischer 11y agoUnfortunately, RyanAir's proposal was shut down: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/news/New-call-for-standing-seats-on-planes/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/news/New-call-for-standing... I am definitely willing to experience more discomfort in exchange for a lower fare, and from other comments, so are many others here.
- dzhiurgis 11y agoAsides from safety, wouldn't standing be actually more comfortable? Sleeping pods make much more sense - you are safe in case of sudden breaking and somewhat comfortable. The fairest way would be introducing progressive seat sizes and charge accordingly. Small people pay less for seats that are actually more comfortable (more fitting their height) and tall people have option not injuring themselves without paying 3x more.
- plorkyeran 11y agoFor flights of up to a few hours I'd pay more to be able to spend the entire flight standing without getting shooed into a seat. Wouldn't work too well for anything crossing an ocean, though.
- greggman 11y agoCheap airlines (and maybe cheap seats?) actually have an unintended side effect for me. Recently I flew from Singapore to Hong Kong. The first 4 options in price according to Google flights were $69, $105, $540, ~$1500. I found that spread kind of shocking. The 2 bottom prices were for budget airlines (Tiger and Jetstar) both rated at 1 of 5 and 1.5 of 5 respectively. The $548 option was Singapore Air, consistently rated very good. $548 is 7x $69!! That's a HUGE difference. Anyway, I ended up taking Singapore Air because it flew at a time that fit my schedule. On the flight I had an issue with the entertainment system. It was resolved but had it not been resolved I'd have been extremely angry because I knew I'd paid some portion of $469 for entertainment. I don't know how and if that will ever play out or if there will be any real repercussions but just knowing I paid 7x more means I expect extreme perfection, something I would not have expected if the price difference was only ~5% or something.
- hboon 11y agoFor Singapore Airline vs the budget airlines in the region, there is a key difference that makes it worth paying for business travel — more predictable arrival time.
- wtvanhest 11y agoThe time and day you fly are the biggest factors in price. It was 100% intended.
- wtvanhest 11y agoThe time and day you fly are the biggest factors in price. It was 100% intended.
- wtvanhest 11y agoThe time and day you fly are the biggest factors in price. It was 100% intended.
- rayiner 11y ago> Travellers have signalled that they are willing to suffer all sorts of discomforts and inconveniences for the sake of a lower fare. America’s big airlines are simply giving them what they wished for. I feel the same way about people who complain about crappy airlines as I do about people who complain about crappy video games. If you don't want to be treated like cattle don't buy the cheapest ticket you can find on Hotwire (and stop buying from EA). It's not like there aren't dozens of other options to choose from.
- pklausler 11y agoAnd what do you do about the corporate travel policy that requires you to book the cheapest available fare?
- stegosaurus 11y agoDon't work for that employer?
- madeofpalk 11y agoThe same thing as when you disagree with any other policy or action your company might set.
- pmiller2 11y agoWhich is? Submit, quit, or be fired/disciplined?
- Strom 11y agoNegotiate an acceptable situation. Change the company if needed.
- madeofpalk 11y agoIf I'm not getting paid enough, or I want to change my work hours to account for new circumstances, or I don't want to be forced into a sub-economy cattle class flight, I'll just talk to my manager about it. If they don't agree and the issue is big enough for me, I'll find a new job.
- zelcon5 11y agoAnd in year 2020... http://36.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_ln5ipwsRxJ1qd94ffo1_1280.png http://36.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_ln5ipwsRxJ1qd94ffo1_1280.p...
- orbitingpluto 11y agoA whole new branch of law emerges: leg clot liability
- throwaway_exer 11y agoFor those interested in the future of American air travel ... Regional airlines, which carry half of pax, have been "last class" for decades, but they're about to disappear. The new pilot training rules requiring 1500 hours of experience have destroyed their ability to operate. The first to declare bankruptcy is Republic, but the rest will soon join it. The majors have used the regionals for union-busting purposes, but those days are over.
- qmr 11y agoNo, regionals are not disappearing. There are still tons of kids in the pipeline who will do anything to fly jets. Several regionals are owned by majors anyway.
- lquist 11y agoThis is great! This will open airline travel to a segment of the population that has historically not had access. This is the story of airline travel. It has taken decades, but what was only available to the richest of the rich is now available to socioeconomically disadvantaged groups of society.
- macinjosh 11y agoI've always wondered why the main 'innovation' in the airline industry (when it comes to lowering fares) is to treat customers more and more like herd animals. There has to be better ways to make flying affordable while maintaining both safety and comfort. Last time I flew the reclining feature in person's seat in front of me was broken and it was 5 - 7 inches in front of my face for the duration of the flight. I couldn't even read my book. I got a free soda for my trouble. In my view flying has become something exclusively for the wealthy who can afford the half-way decent seats made for real humans who have dignity. For me, flying is now only something I do where the importance of my presence supersedes the cost of a decent seat. Otherwise, a video call will do.
- qmr 11y agoThere is not much to wonder about. It is because it is what the market responds to. Everyone bitches. No one pays more for more service.
- baby 11y agoOnce I had the opportunity to get a business ticket expensed, I looked at the price: 5 times the price of a coach seat.
- macinjosh 11y agoAnd if companies only offered what the market asked for there would never have been personal computers or smartphones. It takes someone who has vision for what could be to change the world through innovation. Not a bunch of marketing monkeys surveying customers to death.
- mikeash 11y agoHow else would you propose to cut costs? Maintenance, crew, and fuel are already near the technological limits. Profits are basically zero. The only remaining ways to cut prices are to cram more people into the same space, or make people pay for extra services. And the customers demand lower prices no matter what. They crave it. The airlines are just giving people what they want.
- perseusprime11 11y agoCaste system.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoIt will be called the 'United' class.
- fixxer 11y agoThis is why I drive now.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoIf you look at the history of air travel [1] it's clear that airplanes are the new busses. Air-travel was essentially once reserved for the wealthy, and mostly white travelers but as more people moved up into the middle class there was increased demand for air-travel which drove competition to accommodate them. When southwest was born it completely changed the game and the race to the bottom started. On one hand this has been great, as it has enabled everyone in the US to be able to fly and increased safety significantly. On the other hand, the "elegance" of air travel, which I think most people still desire, is basically gone in the US. Asian carriers such as Emirates, Singapore etc... all maintain the elegant aspect, but at significantly higher costs because they are servicing the higher end still. You'll notice that they have no US domestic equivalent. Expect that eventually there will be no pretense of elegance and it will look exactly like ground transportation. Interestingly enough, Amtrak has taken advantage of this and on the east coast at least is largely considered a better experience between the DC <> Boston corridor. [1] http://www.fastcodesign.com/3022215/terminal-velocity/what-it-was-really-like-to-fly-during-the-golden-age-of-travel http://www.fastcodesign.com/3022215/terminal-velocity/what-i...
- pklausler 11y agoI don't get the connection to increased safety. Can you elaborate, please?
- mikeash 11y agoPeople used to take other means of transportation more often for long trips, which was a lot less safe. Cheaper plane tickets means fewer people dying on the roads.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoPart of it is in the linked article. Bottom line: As flying increased in frequency, injuries went up linearly and people freaked out. The demands for better design, efficiency and well, safety, drove the industry to adopt standards very quickly which led to better records. There are some graphs out there that show it well [1]. [1]http://www.planecrashinfo.com/cause.htm http://www.planecrashinfo.com/cause.htm
- evan_ 11y agoI expected worse, to be honest. It sounds like the worst thing about it is not being able to choose a seat- but otherwise the same basic in-flight experience as "regular" economy.
- gonzo 11y agoWorse is Better?
- brianmcconnell 11y agoWhat really gets me are the people who complain about being able to fly across an entire continent within five hours in near perfect safety for a few hundred dollars. I remember being trapped next to a loud woman on one flight where she proceeded to complain about every minor insult (slow drink service, so so food, etc). When we got to the Sierra Nevada, I pointed out the Donner Pass to her, and suggested she look it up. "It'll give you some perspective on your trip".