6 ms·
Vatican Economist: Recession caused by low birth rate
- dkimball 17y agoNote that the Vatican's not the only one saying this. Others have pointed out that a larger proportion of elderly to young population results in smaller amounts of wealth creation, larger amounts of wealth consumption (healthcare and the like); and that old managers who are slow to retire give their companies an unnecessarily hesitant, cautious character. In fact, doesn't Paul Graham have an essay about this?
- old-gregg 17y agoTrue. What upsets me is that publicly accepted solution to this seems to be "lets breed more babies" as opposed to "lets change our way of thinking as we get older". WTF? I refuse to accept the idea that I'm predestined to get slower, dumber and more conservative as I get older. I also believe that instead of overbreeding we should find ways to feed the existing 6 billion or/and shrink to a more sustainable number.
- pyre 17y agoI believe there is already a introductory video to this: Logan's Run.
- dkimball 17y agoYour medical expenses will grow as you get older, even if your thought processes don't ossify. Sidenote: I don't think "conservative" is an appropriate term here; in fact, I don't like the word in almost any context. Desiring to enrich oneself and/or being careful with one's money do not correlate usefully with, for example, opposing abortion; libertarians and the CDU-type ideology opposed to libertarianism (Roosevelt, Chesterton, Dorothy Day, etc.) are both refutations of that. As far as population goes, we are not close to the carrying capacity of the planet. The only starvation in the modern world is in extremely undeveloped countries governed by the likes of Robert Mugabe; I don't know what a fully-developed Earth's carrying capacity at American or at European levels of consumption would be, but I'm unwilling to guess, since I'd probably low-ball the number severely. Malthus was right in one sense, and there are real examples of Malthusian crises in the late 18th century (that's probably where the French Revolution came from, in particular); but these days, land in the Malthusian sense is expanding faster than population is -- _much_ faster. And remember, too, the (very Y-Combinator-y) point that each new person brings a new mouth to feed, but also a new pair of hands...
- thenduks 17y agoAs far as population goes, we are not close to the carrying capacity of the planet. There is space available!? Well what other option could there be other than to fill it with people? I mean, clearly, the human race can't shout 'we win!' until we are unable to physically fit another person on the streets, right?
- dkimball 17y agoWhat I mean is not "physical room for people," it's "exploited versus un-exploited resources." It's not as if we're running out of room for farming -- and even if we were, it's not as if we're managing the oceans in anything that vaguely resembles a serious, competent fashion. Earth is much larger than we tend to think, and much more empty (remember how if the population of the Netherlands lived at New York density, everyone in the country would fit in the "dongle" of southern Limburg that borders on Belgium). In other words, we can afford to worry about more urgent things -- torture, for example. (Not just American; how about the Uzbek dictator who boils prisoners alive, or of course the Chinese?) Additionally, there may be a difference in my values relative to yours: I believe that people are intrinsically valuable, and that therefore it is better to have more people in the world than fewer people in the world, all other things being equal.
- thenduks 17y agoBut why should all the resources be exploited? Why not, you know, just use what we need? And why should the people in the Netherlands live at the same density that people in NYC do anymore than vice versa? I don't see what 'value' people have over anything else, say, fish, deer or even trees, mountains, etc -- I say we leave some room for the other things that occupy the earth and not just claim it all for ourselves because we can.
- dkimball 17y agoThen here we part company: as a Roman Catholic, I believe that human beings come first -- although we are to be stewards of the earth rather than masters of it.
- gwern 17y ago> I refuse to accept the idea that I'm predestined to get slower, dumber and more conservative as I get older. Do you also accept that magic fairies stop your brain from being physiologically affected at all by the process of aging?
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoThis jumped out at me: > the cause is ordinary people who do not "believe in the future" and have few or no children The notion that the reason people are having fewer children because they don't believe in the future is pure ideology. They may have accidentally landed at the right conclusion (I'm not persuaded of this, particularly given the opportunities related to immigration), but their reasoning is highly suspect.
- blue1 17y agoGotti Tedeschi is italian. While it's true that a low birth rate is typical of rich countries, it is also true that in Italy the hope for the future is currently at historical lows (sociologists are also writing profusely about this). Not that there is necessarily a causal link, of course.
- iujhygfbh 17y agoItaly is in a typical 2-generation pattern. The first generation of women to get the chance at education, real careers etc = birth rate plummets. A generation (or two) later, there are women in politics and at the top of companies, introduce generous maternity leave, childcare etc. as in Scandinavia = birth rate rises again.
- DeusExMachina 17y agoI am italian and actually living in Italy and I can tell you this: Italy is in a very bad historical period, with corruption and organized crime spread in the government. I am one of the italians thinking that this country has no future and this is why I'm leaving. Like me many italians (good and smart ones that are not part of the actual clientelistic system and are not able to get a good job) are leaving my country. I also have a lot of friends that are deluded and do not plan to have children, also because they can't get a decent salary to build a family. I cannot tell if there is a casual link, though. Actually Italy is engulfed in a media regime, where the prime minister own three major TV channels and controls the three public ones. 80% of the people only get news form TV, and TV is not telling the bad news. So there may be a link and I think that hope for the future plays a big part, but I also think it's more than that. I think that many things in the actual system contribute on the low birth rate. About vatican I can tell you that they primarily look at italian society and are very biased by their religion.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- rbanffy 17y agoA low birth rate is not surprising in the Vatican, but they will have some trouble increasing it.
- dkimball 17y agoI'm not sure if this was meant to be humor or not, so if it wasn't, I apologize; but if it was, you win an internets. (Is that an acceptable expression around here?)
- decode 17y ago> (Is that an acceptable expression around here?) You're new around here, so I'll explain your downvotes. It's not that a particular phrase is or is not unacceptable here, it's that your comment as a whole did not add to the discussion. Use the up arrow instead of writing a reply if you think a comment was a good contribution.
- dkimball 17y agoI see. Thanks for letting me know.
- blue1 17y agoIt is worth nothing that this "Institute for the Works of Religion", aka IOR, is basically the bank of Vatican. It is shrouded by absolute secrecy, much more than the swiss banks for instance. In the past it has been involved in rather shady stories.
- Flemlord 17y agoThe article ends with this sentence: > Now, Gotti Tedeschi confirmed, "the only way to rebuild economic-financial balance [in America] is austerity." From wikipedia: In economics, austerity is when a national government reduces its spending to pay back creditors. Austerity is usually required when a government's fiscal deficit spending is felt to be unsustainable. Development projects, welfare programs and other social spending are common areas of spending for cuts. In many countries, austerity measures have been associated with short-term standard of living declines until economic conditions improved once fiscal balance was achieved (such as in Canada under Jean Chrétien, and Spain under Felipe González). Private banks, or institutions like the International Monetary Fund (IMF), may require that a country pursues an 'austerity policy' if it wants to re-finance loans that are about to come due. The government may be asked to stop issuing subsidies or to otherwise reduce public spending. When the IMF requires such a policy, the terms are known as 'IMF conditionalities'. Austerity programs are frequently controversial, as they have an impact on the poorest segments of the population and often lead to a wider separation between the rich and poor. In many situations, austerity programs are imposed on countries that were previously under dictatorial regimes, leading to criticism that populations are forced to repay the debts of their oppressors.
- diego_moita 17y agoThe Vatican must be very happy with this "new kind of science" the blogosphere created; the one that allows for tons of opinion with scant evidence. Well, truth be told, not even them endorsed Inteligent Design, yet.
- w00pla 17y agoThe Catholic Church is scarily in tune with the latest scientific thought (I say this as a protestant). I would not be surprised if they have an army of economists.
- diego_moita 17y agoRight, and I am not calling the Catholic Church scientifically ignorant. You can point to lots of problems they had with science in the past (Copernicus, Galileo, Vesalius, etc). However they're the religion that best learnt (even if by force) that science must be respected. They even produced some very fine scientists (e.g.: Gregor Mendel). My point is rather that without evidence and facts it gets much easier to manipulate debates with ideologies. I see the debates on forums and blogs as being mostly heavy on opinions and weak on facts. And I see religion as a form of ideology. Disclaimer: I am well aware that I am giving an opinion with little factual evidence; the exact problem am pointing in others. So please feel free to call all of this self-contradictory garbage. ;-)
- w00pla 17y ago> However they're the religion that best learnt (even if by force) that science must be respected. The notion that there is (or must be) a conflict between religion and science is fallacious. It is an idea currently extremely popular with 20 y/o know-it-all angry atheists – but it is far from the truth. Another popular related idea is that “you can’t be religious and be a scientist” and that religious people are of lower intelligence (the latter is usually proved with a pseudo-scientific “statistical” argument). > My point is rather that without evidence and facts it gets much easier to manipulate debates with ideologies. My biggest problem is that popular secular humanists try to pass of their ideology as “science” – and doing it on the public dime too (while working at educational institutions). Neither the church nor certain secular humanists have a monopoly on the truth or scientific fact. > I see the debates on forums and blogs as being mostly heavy on opinions and weak on facts. And I see religion as a form of ideology. Most internet debates are nothing but a circle jerk. I increasingly see pop-atheism as an ideology too. Nothing ruins social sites (such as reddit.com, digg.com) as quickly as the influx of angry close-minded atheists. That is one of the things that make ycnews nice – there aren’t that many ideologues, and even those that are there, are well mannered and moderate.
- jwhitlark 17y agoUncertainty about the future causes me to spend less, not more.
- gjm11 17y agoSo, this person apparently thinks that the way to keep the economy healthy is for the population to keep growing without limit. I fail to see why an unsustainable population bubble should be any better than an unsustainable housing / tech-stocks / tulip / South Sea bubble. (Perhaps he believes that a population bubble would not be unsustainable because in the not-very-distant future God will step in and call a halt? Such predictions have been commonplace for a long time and their track record is not very good.)