19 ms·
The Madness of Airline Élite Status
- pricechild 11y ago> I then asked my wife for permission to spend five hundred and sixty dollars for a flight that I already had a free ticket for. Why would this make sense? Surely there wouldn't be a benefit worth more than $560?
- corbet 11y agoA single business-class upgrade on a long-haul flight way exceeds that.
- curun1r 11y agoIt costs that, but I've yet to be convinced that it's worth that. A cattle-class ticket and a Valium gets me to my destination in just as much comfort as that business class ticket would.
- tamana 11y agoValium will get you through most of life with as much comfort as any other way, but still...
- mirimir 11y agoUntil you run out of Valium ;)
- tptacek 11y agoSerious (and weird) question: does valium help with flying that much? What is it like flying on valium?
- niels_olson 11y agoMainly, if you don't take valium much, on the rare occasions you use it, you pass out within minutes. And it feels like you go from stone sober to completely lit in those few minutes, which is quite pleasant. For one to a few hours you will sleep like the dead. With luck you'll sleep through the flight, or through the night, or whatever. The next time, it won't work so well. The next time, it won't work so well. The next time, it won't work so well. And down the path you go. Up the dose, etc, etc. Don't use valium unless you have a real and only very occasional use for it. And try to keep that in mind: it's a use case. Not a need. You never need valium. You need food, and shelter from weather. But you don't need valium.
- girvo 11y agoDepends, different people respond differently to benzodiazepines. For myself, a 5mg valium relaxes me but does not induce sleep. Similar to having a glass or two of wine, really. For others, they'll basically be knocked out. I'm not convinced it's necessary for flying myself, but if you have any sort of flight anxiety it can be a game-changer.
- peteretep 11y agoI fly long-haul more than most people, albeit mostly in business. I started taking valium for flying 7 years ago for a fear of flying when I was flying mostly economy. I started with 2mg, which was completely ineffective for anything, and then went to 15mg. At the higher I didn't notice any effect, until the plane started bouncing, and then I realized I didn't care, which was perfect. I didn't notice any drowsiness at that level, which may have been due to adrenaline. Over the course of 6 years, my regular dosage approached 50mg as I kept upping it whenever I started to get nervous flying. If taking it while I got on a plane, I didn't feel drowsy. It became not always effective. About a year ago I made a conscious effort to wean myself off it over the course of 12 weeks, by flying a return business long-haul flight every week, and taking a little less each time, practicing the principles in Dr Claire Weekes "Freedom from Nervous Suffering" (essentially breathing exercises, although it's a little more nuanced), which is in fact a book for agoraphobics which someone had suggested to me. I got down to zero, but found under 10mg then turbulence still had fairly heavy emotional and physical effects on me. Now I take 0-10mg when I fly. I don't notice any effects, other than I am less sensitive to turbluence. However, I exclusively fly business class rather than economy, which I suspect helps a massive amount. During this time I also tried Propanalol at some high doses. I found it ineffective for fear of flying, but very very effective for giving presentations. However it started to make me short of breath, so I ditched it. In terms of intoxicating yourself for flying, I have found Ambien to be highly effective. However, it seems many many people have bad side-effects from it - sleep-walking, etc - so unless you're totally certain you can handle it well, I don't know that I would recommend it. These days I'll settle for 10mg of valium and some alcohol.
- Nelson69 11y agoI was on vacation when a trip to Beijing was planned for me. The secretary, for reasons I don't expect I'll ever know or understand, insisted on flying Eastern China Airlines. Complete with an extra stop in Shanghai... It might be different now (this was like 6 years ago) but it was very much "the people's airline" then. It wasn't just very tight seating with limited recline capacity, but there were some strong odors as well. Not sure a valium would have got it done. It's the only time I attempted to buy an upgrade mid-flight. The American flights to and from L.A. on the American side were delightful. Maybe the idea was to help with the culture shock in the same way "getting jumped in" helps you adapt to gang-life.
- robotresearcher 11y agoIt's nice to have the choice of using those hours for work. 10 hours of uninterrupted time in a comfy seat with snacks at hand and laptop in a good position can be great. In a middle-middle-seat in the back not so much.
- edutechnion 11y agoIf elite status results in a free upgrade on 20% of your flight segments, and you fly 50 segments per year: 10 upgrades to business class > $560
- superuser2 11y agoOne upgrade to business class is already going to be a few hundred dollars. 10 exceeds it by a wide margin.
- ryanlol 11y ago20%? What airline you're with, for "elite" statuses it's generally less than 20% of the flights that do not get upgraded. Obviously depends on availability on the specific flights though.
- ropiku 11y agoOn a long haul international flight ? I doubt it. It's hard to find even mile redemption availability.
- lnanek2 11y agoDepends on what you fly. I always used to fly first flight out of Newark preferentially compared to anything else out of Newark/LGA/JFK simply because I always got upgraded without fail. First flight out of Newark leaves before the mass transit gets running. So you can game the system to make sure there are seats to be upgraded to.
- potatolicious 11y agoIt depends on how you value the perks - many of them (access to the GS lounges, for example) can't actually be purchased so there's no "real" value for them besides how much they are worth to you. If you're flying 50 times a year for business, lounge access may be worth substantially more to you than if you only flew a few times a year. Not to mention if you're going to be flying 50 times a year, that $560 means ~$10 per flight to make your experience substantially less awful.
- EvanKelly 11y agoI've occasionally gotten to a lounge access tier, but I've never used it. What's the benefit? I typically don't want to get to the airport earlier than I have to, and once you're at that level, security and boarding are a breeze. I don't fly internationally much, so most of my flights are direct. Is it mostly for layovers?
- monknomo 11y agoIt's nice for layovers and delays. It's also nice if you've just gotten off the plane and it's a long enough flight that you want to freshen up in a nicer, less crowded bathroom and then have a complimentary soda and cheese plate. That's how I've used it when I've had it.
- eitally 11y agoIt's terrific for layovers, and a lot of times you can find a shower if you want one. Having decently comfortable chairs, a more private and cleaner restroom, free snacks (sometimes real food, like in the Amex Centurion Lounges), good wifi and power outlets everywhere, and in some cases even business services (printer, phone rooms, etc).
- crdb 11y agoThe biggest benefit for me internationally (flying long haul once or twice a month from SIN) is absolutely being able to take a shower between two long-haul flights and, if the lounge is not airside, shave (e.g. The Haven by JetQuay at SIN). Peace and quiet is a second benefit. If you're waiting a couple of hours whilst sleep deprived (often the case for business travel or when booking budget flights that leave at 1:30am), those loud, constant announcements are very annoying. Bonus points if the airport has terrible seating and the lounge has comfortable sofas. If you need to work for a bit, it's a great place to do so, especially in airports that don't have free WiFi (increasingly rare these days). The food is rarely good in Asia (at least at those lounges I have access to). Reheated noodles and some meat if you're lucky and flying at the right time. It's convenient, at most, saving you the trouble. It really varies by city. HNL and NRT have terrible lounges for PP card holders - basically a room where you can sit for a while, sometimes with a free beer (but there is a great sushi-ya just opposite the NRT lounge). GVA has my favorite ones - nice view on mountains, usually empty (except if Aeroflot is flying soon...) and a decent breakfast with muesli and fresh bread and pastries. SIN lounges often have free massage chairs. Which are available for free in T3 as well, but it saves having to take the monorail there. On timing, if you are flying long haul you can face serious delays (like a huge queue at check-in and security) and need to pad it by a couple hours. Most of the time, you don't face these delays and have a spare hour to kill, and in most airports the lounge is a better place to do so. Sort of applies to short haul too; I once missed LHR-GVA check-in on BA by a single minute and they were very annoying about it despite the empty airport (had to book another flight).
- untog 11y agoWell that's kind of the core of the article, no? In dollar amount alone, yes, there are benefits worth more than $560. But are they worth the money? I have resigned myself to never taking a first class reward flight because I can get at least two economy trips with the same amount of miles. I just can't justify that to myself, despite the (more than 2x) dollar amounts attached.
- coldcode 11y agoYou aren't 2 meters tall.
- untog 11y agoI'm not far off. Whenever possible I pay the $50 or whatever for an exit row seat on top of my economy reward.
- eitally 11y agoBut god help you if you accidentally choose either a bulkhead seat or an exit seat that doesn't recline. SeatGuru is your friend. (am also nearly 2m tall.)
- pc86 11y agoAbout 6'6" for the Americans here (myself included).
- apercu 11y agoI had to do early morning flights to a city about an hour away pretty frequently for all days meetings, flight back same day. With security this meant getting up at 4 to catch a 7:30 flight, to get to the meetings by 9:30, all day in a conference room, leave at 5 to get to the airport for a 7:30pm flight to get home by 9:30 or 10:00pm. Flying business class changed the whole dynamic. I was fed a real breakfast in the morning instead of getting the shakes from a relatively empty stomach and too much coffee. I got a hot towel to wipe my face with and feel human when I showed up at the meeting. On the way back a light dinner and a glass of wine with a little elbow room. The extra 30% for business class was well worth it. If I was staying overnight, perhaps not.
- devereaux 11y agoHere is an alternative algorithm: fly with whichever airline is the cheapest, having a frequent flyer account on each airline. Accumulate miles separately. It won't get you a elite status, just a status slightly better than the normal flyer -- and free tickets too. It will prevent you from reaching the extremes of this mile madness, like spending money just to maintain your status. Bonus: when airlines merge, you get a really nice status. It may not be that interesting now with so little airlines in competition, but around year 2000 that was something regular
- lucaspiller 11y agoAlso if the airline does have a frequent flyer program, you should always register as they will bump up frequent flyers (even when brand new) before other people. This worked out for me twice so far, one airline bumped me to business on my first ever flight with them.
- Justin_K 11y agoWhen you have a 1k or global services status, almost all your seats are automatically upgraded to business or first class. It makes spending your life in an airplane seat tolerable. For that reason, it's best to focus. If you haven't spent months of your life in a plane and away from home, it's hard to grasp how valuable an upgrade is.
- scurvy 11y agoFat chance on that if you mostly fly out of hubs. Most 1K's will still be stuck in 20 and 21. Line 1 is 3 times longer than any other line at SFO, EWR, LAX, ORD, etc.
- ropiku 11y agoYou would only need one per alliance. You still need to fly quite a lot to get even first level status if you are flying economy and spreading around in multiple airlines. That won't get you much, not even lounge access which is a big benefit. Also on some airlines miles expire.
- imartin2k 11y ago
- frandroid 11y ago> Absent posted guidelines, road-warrior message boards are filled with speculation about why certain travellers receive Global Services. Is it a measure of dollars spent? Segments flown? Behavior? The fact that he actually tried to redeem his points for a free flight probably made him a target for infection with GS-MAD :)
- gist 11y ago> I then asked my wife for permission to spend five hundred and sixty dollars for a flight that I already had a free ticket for Back in the day this gentleman would have been called "pussy whipped". (Yes I did just say that knowing there might be consequences...).
- sp332 11y ago$560 seems like a large enough amount of money to talk over.
- gist 11y agoWell then that depends on the relationship that you have as well as who you are married to, doesn't it? I didn't need my wife's permission to buy real estate or an expensive car for example. And she has no problem with that. Nor does she ask me permission to spend her money either. And do you really think that $560 is "a large amount of money" and needs to be talked over?
- ska 11y ago"Well then that depends on the relationship that you have as well as who you are married to, doesn't it? " Absolutely true. But it doesn't make other peoples choices in this wrong or inferior. I don't need to ask either, but I find the idea that someone would be considered "pussy whipped" if they have a different arrangement to be, well, moronic.
- sp332 11y agoYeah, at least mention it and give the other person a chance to raise objections even if it doesn't happen often. Someone told me about a $100 rule, and that seems like a good cutoff to me. And you're right, it would be different if we had "her money" and "his money".
- gist 11y ago> at least mention it and give the other person a chance to raise objections You are not considering the downside of all of this. (Since I get paid for negotiation let me give you my thoughts.) By "giving the other person a chance" you are giving them power over you. Which they could use to extract something from you in exchange for your agreement. Now this may or may not matter depending on the person you are with, but I will point it out so you know that in some cases there could be a downside by "running something by the other party". And yes, there is negotiation in relationships as there is in business.
- gyardley 11y agoThe only thing better than business-class upgrades on your work-related travel is not having work-related travel.
- jmspring 11y agoI don't mind a bit of work travel, but I am also picky about the routes I take. Anything in Europe, it is SFO to "somewhere in Europe, not Heathrow" and then from there. I've usually had status (Gold) but my wife and I also travel enough privately where taking advantage of a travel credit card that gives you status (and extra miles blahblah) helps. I've not done a milage run, nor will I do multiple hops just to get a few hundred (or a thousand) extra miles. The only exception to that is if the alliance I prefer (Star Alliance) doesn't have as direct as say One World, I'll still take the Star Alliance route for the miles. About the only airline I travel with more than UA/other star alliance partners is Alaska because I head up to the Pacific Northwest frequently.
- steffan 11y agoWhy not Heathrow? I just flew there last month and it didn't seem particularly bad. Was I lucky?
- jonathanpoulter 11y agoI'm in Heathrow now, I can confirm... it's fine.
- mollmerx 11y agoYour experience will depend very much on which Terminal you're at (there is a big difference in age and layouts of individual terminals) and, in particular, whether you're forced to switch terminals when transiting. A good airport for transiting into Europe, and in my view usually more pleasant than London, Frankfurt or Paris, is Amsterdam Schiphol.
- 11y ago
- gadders 11y agoMy old boss discovered that there is a class higher than first with British Airways when he found himself on a flight with the research analyst from Goldman Sachs that covered the airline sector.
- ryanlol 11y agoAre we talking service level or seats? Off the top of my head nobody but Etihad has real 4-class seat configurations (Not counting economy+). Edit: I'm curious as to what was downvote-worthy about this comment?
- Geekette 11y agoI imagine you're referring to high-roller passengers, who spend so much on a given airline they get extra perks like complimentary chauffered limo service and high-end hotel stays around all trips. For actual travel though, they still have the same seating arrangements on the plane as other first class passengers.
- gadders 11y agoSorry - it was not a formal extra class, but clearly his name had been flagged on the BA systems so he got extra special service compared to everyone else in first class.
- cjrp 11y agoPfft, limo service (more like an S-Class, not an actual limo) is available to anyone on Virgin Atlantic flying Upper Class.
- bmelton 11y agoTechnically speaking, it needn't be a longer-than-usual-wheelbase to be considered a limousine. (Though if strictly defining a limo, it should have a partition between you and the chauffer.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limousine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limousine FWIW, stretch limos are really only appropriate for larger parties of more than 2, for conducting business. Not that anybody today should care, and I can't remember where I learned this, but effectively, a limo used to just mean "car". Business people and big execs would use limos so that they could continue working while in transit, and not have to deal with the distraction of having to talk to cabbies and whatnot. Stretch limos were employed to conduct business on the go with larger parties, again, so that business would not be interrupted despite the need for travel. It wasn't until hollywood and prom-goers decided that limousine effectively equated to stretch limousine and started using them 'inappropriately' that the connotation became what it is today.
- GirlProgrammer 11y agoIt's nice being a United Global Service member--that "secret" level among 1K. It really helps when there's irops.
- draw_down 11y agoI have traveled some for work over my career, but I never paid any attention to any of these programs or miles or anything like that. I probably missed out on a free flight at some point, but the thought of keeping track of those things seems tedious and dreadful. The whole culture of travel is like that really, parsing the tiny differences between anonymous airports and roughly-identical airlines. People become obsessed with checking in online exactly 24 hours in advance, etc. Expending effort for the tiniest, tiniest morsels of difference and succor in an overall terrible experience. It's understandable of course, but I just accept that it's all bad and try to forget about it as soon as it's over.
- peferron 11y agoYou really don't have to spend hours min-maxing your miles like described in the article. Just spend two minutes creating an account online, and ten seconds inputting your member number when buying tickets or checking in. Then two years later check your balance and you might have a free ticket worth $500+. That's a huge return given the amount of time invested. It's like credit cards. There are entire websites dedicated to min-maxing the hell out of credit card points, sign-up bonuses, etc. But you don't have to do that. You can just spend an hour getting a good credit card (assuming you can :/) and then reap massive benefits compared to the amount of time invested.
- voltagex_ 11y agoUntil your points expire or the T&Cs change - thanks Qantas.
- megablast 11y agoI didn't do anything but sign up for club access on a website, link my number to my credit card, and tell them at work my number. Everything else is done automatically. I have 4 free return flights saved up now, ready to go.
- nickbauman 11y agoMoxie Marlinspike's advice comes to mind: "... whenever I get on an airplane and walk past first class, I inevitably go through a familiar mental process. First, I’m envious ... then, I register who is sitting in those seats. It’s usually almost all predominantly unhealthy looking ... men, who it is clear from a glance have spent literally hundreds of hours of their lives over the past year in these airplanes ... the bulk of the first class passengers resemble each other, just as there’s a reason prison guards tend to act the same. I know that by making choices designed to land me in the first class cabin, it would be difficult to avoid also inheriting the dreariness associated with its current occupants." http://www.thoughtcrime.org/blog/career-advice/ http://www.thoughtcrime.org/blog/career-advice/
- a2tech 11y agoI like Moxie, but I think he's a little off base here. I exclusively fly first class and I'm not a doughy businessman. I don't even fly for work-just pleasure. I see the flight as the beginning/ending of my journey and I see no reason to cram my legs into a seat in front of me. I want to have a pleasant flight-not flight designed to cripple me. Also, free alcohol and snacks.
- beamatronic 11y agoIn my experience, flying first class is not a 10% premium or a 50% premium over coach, it is a ~2x-3x or more premium. I wouldn't call the alcohol and snacks "free". If you look at it that way, then flying coach gives you a free meal at say, the French Laundry.
- Someone1234 11y agoUnfortunately the word "free" has lost all coherent meaning in modern usage. Amazon Prime has "free" shipping, costs $100/year. Your cellphone plan has "free" text messaging, costs $79/month. Your postage has "free" tracking, costs $11. Why, in particular in American, has the word "included" seemingly been vanished from the popular vocabulary to be replaced with "free?" Now what word do we use when something is ACTUALLY free?
- simonebrunozzi 11y agoI liked the article. This madness is real. I used to fly 110 times/year for work, internationally. I had gold status with several airlines at once. I did this for about 8 years (although the last two years I went down to about 80 flights/year). I live in SF and, of course, I have to fly United if I don't want to make one connection every time I fly somewhere in the US. And I am a Premier 1k member. I can confirm that the perks are almost useless; that this absurd race loses any meaning when everybody else is racing with you. How can Premier 1k be good, if I'm not among the top 1% (the only case in which automatic upgrades and such would actually be useful)? All in all, I hate United. And I'm not the only one [0]. By the way, why does Google NOT provide this link when I search for "Untied"? [1] [0]: http://www.untied.com/main.shtml http://www.untied.com/main.shtml [1]: https://www.google.com/search?q=untied&oq=untied&aqs=chrome..69i57j0l5.1192j0j7&sourceid=chrome&es_sm=91&ie=UTF-8#q=untied.com https://www.google.com/search?q=untied&oq=untied&aqs=chrome....
- dsp1234 11y agoBy the way, why does Google NOT provide this link when I search for "Untied"? Because Google has (reasonably) understood that it was likely a incorrectly spelled request for united.com, which is clearly evident from just looking at Google Trends[0]. Note that they do offer a "did you really mean" link which will force the search for untied.com and then it's the number 1 hit. [0] - https://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=untied.com%2C%20united.com https://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=untied.com%2C%20unit...
- DavidAdams 11y agoI'll disagree that the perks are almost useless. But they can be a bit subtle. In comparison to people's typical experience flying, as a United 1K: When I call the 800 number, a real human being picks up right away and helps me. If I'd like to catch an earlier or later flight, if it's within 24 hours, I can usually make the change with no charge. I use this perk dozens of times a year, and it even enables me to book cheaper flights because I'll usually be able to make adjustments on the day of travel. If I end up on the standby list, I'm put at the top (because it goes in order of highest status before first come first served). If I use miles to book a flight, I can cancel or change the flight at any time. This lets me speculatively book a vacation flight to Maui months ahead of time when availability is good, even if I'm not sure I'll be free then. My entire family gets free bags and free extra legroom seats when they travel with me. I get to sit in fancy lounges when traveling overseas. And the first class upgrades are a nice bonus.
- joshfraser 11y agoIt's pretty smart how these loyalty programs are designed. Much of the behavior hinges on flights being expensed, while it's the individual employee who reaps the benefits. It causes people to constantly overspend on flights because they aren't the ones paying.
- mintplant 11y agoSame business model behind high hotel wifi prices.
- ghaff 11y agoNot really even if both are largely based on the fact that the person doing the purchasing is often not the one paying for the purchase. The business model behind high WiFi prices and $9 bottles of water is more that they're opportunities to sell high-margin add-ons to price insensitive customers. Thus business-oriented hotels charge for these things while they're free at the Holiday Inn down the road. (With respect to WiFi, this does seem to be changing as WiFi is increasingly viewed as more or less essential by those traveling for pleasure as well as business. The trend I see increasingly is free WiFi being used as a perk to encourage behaviors that the hotel chain wants to encourage--such as booking directly online.)
- tamana 11y agoLife, uh, find a way (to respond to incentives)
- robin_reala 11y agoAs part of the UK civil service I’m not allowed to keep airmiles accrued during business flights: they have to be declared and donated back to the government.
- jessriedel 11y agoHonestly, it's crazy this isn't true for all governments and businesses. Frequent flier programs are just transparent kickbacks. I'm not too worried about the redistribution (since ultimately people will count it as a perk when they are comparing jobs, so it's priced in), but there has got to be significant deadweight losses from inefficient compensation, and from the person booking the travel being insulated from various incentives.
- mathattack 11y agoFor better or worse, this just locks you in to crappy airlines. I spent 7.5 years in a full-time travel job. The perks (other than occasional upgrades on redeyes) did very little for me. I wound up using miles just for last minute flights. I did used to get a big laugh out of people (usually junior consultants) who confused airline status with real social status.
- acchow 11y ago> I did used to get a big laugh out of people (usually junior consultants) who confused airline status with real social status. I see this a lot among consultants - they love to talk about airports, airport lounges, "horrifying" delays, rude customs agents, free upgrades, and seat pitches. Bizarre.
- ghaff 11y agoI'm not sure it's so much about social status as shared "war stories" and experiences.
- mathattack 11y agoI've viewed some ghastly behavior, even worse than this -> http://www.bigtimeconsulting.org/wp-content/uploads/cartoons/2011-05-26_155644.jpg http://www.bigtimeconsulting.org/wp-content/uploads/cartoons...
- apercu 11y agoI've never been a business globe trotter, but I travelled every 2 weeks in 2014 between Ottawa, Toronto and Washington DC. That equalled about 10,000 "air" miles or about $50. Whoopety doo. In the mid-90's I was travelling about once a month between the midwest and the coasts. That was enough for a couple round trips in "air" miles. These days it's barely worth it to be part of the programs (I am, but the "perks" are way less than they used to be).
- fulafel 11y agoZero comments about ethics of contributing to climate change due to flying so much? Feels like people are missing the elephant in the room.
- omginternets 11y agoWhat elephant? Airplanes are insanely efficient, relative to cars...
- colin_mccabe 11y agoAirplanes are not "insanely efficient" when it comes to greenhouse gasses. A plane emits roughly the same amount of greenhouse gasses per mile per person as a car. Maybe 50% if we assume an efficient plane and an inefficient car. And the number of miles travelled by plane is typically much more. Even one round trip flight from SF to europe is 10,000 miles, which is comparable to a year's worth of driving for one person.
- diabeetusman 11y agoWhat's a more efficient way of getting from San Francisco to LHR? Via ship, the long way?
- acchow 11y ago> What's a more efficient way Staying in California.
- omginternets 11y ago> roughly the same amount of greenhouse gasses per mile per person as a car I see. How much non-human cargo are these cars carrying? More to the point: how else do you propose one go from SF to Europe? Reading between the lines, you're either suggesting people stay home or that they take a boat, both of which are absolute crazy talk. EDIT: moreover, wikipedia's numbers suggest jetliners get roughly 70 to 110 passenger-miles/gallon (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_efficiency_in_transportation#Aircraft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_efficiency_in_transport...). I have yet to come across a car that gets that kind of mileage period, let alone per passenger. Besides, gas turbine engines are pretty much the model of efficiency when it comes to hydrocarbon-consuming engines. I don't know where you people are getting your numbers but my BS detector is off the charts.
- yzh 11y agoYou guys may want to try this (haven't released anything yet, but looks promising): http://www.pointimize.com/ http://www.pointimize.com/
- wpietri 11y agoIt's almost as if humans are primates, and so are inclined to pursue markers of social status all out of proportion to actual utility in a civilized setting.
- pkamb 11y agoI've never understood why airline miles follow each individual person rather than the company that's paying for the weekly business class seats. Seems like the Senior Manager who just joined the firm should be bumped up to first class in front of the Junior Consultant that's been flying out weekly for a year.
- _delirium 11y agoThey're designed as incentives for individuals, because at most companies individuals have a significant degree of leeway in booking flights. You might have to book through the corporate travel agent, but typically you can still choose that you want flight X instead of Y. So United (or whoever) giving the specific individual status/perks is designed to encourage them to keep choosing United tickets, even when sometimes a competitor might have a better or cheaper route. It'd be possible to design a loyalty program aimed at entire companies, and there's a little bit of movement in that direction, especially targeting small and medium-sized businesses (e.g. United PerksPlus). The goal of those would be to encourage the whole company to standardize on one airline. Big companies tend not to want to do that, because their travel needs are too varied for it to make sense to require all their employees to use one airline. So the main target of the programs is the corporate traveler who is being reimbursed for travel: they have a choice in their travel arrangements (within reason), and since they're spending someone else's money, they're also relatively price-insensitive, which makes them especially lucrative. Hotel loyalty programs work similarly.
- vidoc 11y agoMight have been posted before, but there's a rather interesting documentary on this madness: https://vimeo.com/7167640 https://vimeo.com/7167640
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y agoI don't like making comments like this, but this is a prime candidate for something along the lines of "white people problems" with no additional remarks.
- mtmail 11y agoDo you mean first-world problems? I don't see what race has to do with frequent flier programs.
- benhebert 11y agoI flew two extra trips to Asia last year to get American Airlines Executive Platinum status. After a year and getting all the nice lounge access and international long-haul upgrades, I think it's worth it! Take my girlfriend and family around the world using a combination of miles / money and everything things I'm rich, when really I'm just a wannabe travel hacker.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- saryant 11y agoThere is no overlap between Global Entry privileges and airline status benefits. Obscene surcharges on awards are really only an issue for a handful of airlines like BA. I've redeemed over two million miles and the highest surcharge I've ever paid on an award was $350 for Singapore first class from Singapore to Tokyo to Los Angeles. I was fine with that.
- chrismaeda 11y agoFun article, and one which shows the dark side of gamification. If you provide points, levels, and leaderboards, people will sacrifice their lives to leveling up for stupid little perks like jumping the line, slightly larger seats, and liquor and snacks that you probably shouldn't have anyway. I was one of these people years ago. I was doing a lot of international business class flights on behalf of a public software company, and had 1k and global services status. Then I burned out and quit, and spent the next several years barely making premier silver. It's no big deal once you get over your sense of entitlement. And United has put all the perks up for sale anyway, so you can now buy whatever perk that you can't live without. A couple of months ago, I finally made million miler status, which is a kind of "emeritus" status: you (and a designated companion) get star alliance gold status for life. This is actually kind of awesome since now I don't have to worry about getting miles every year to make premier. I still accumulate points so that I can get free tickets, but being retired from the elite status rat race is very relaxing.
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoIn the early days of train travel (1840s), they quickly realised that the first class passengers arrived no faster than the cheaper passengers, somthey did the only sensible thing. They took the roof and Windows off the third class carriages and made you share them with cattle. This way people paid extra to avoid the weather and cow shit There is a hard upper limit to how good flying in a tin can at 35,000 feet can be made (1) If airlines could strap economy class passengers to the wings they would (1) actually an ad exec made an excellent point in a ted talk - instead of spending 4bn on reducing the time the high speed train went from London to Paris, spend 2bn on half naked super models handing out free champagne and no one will care how long the journey is. This is of course what airline stewardesses were supposed to be before all those pesky lawsuits.
- horsecaptin 11y agoIf you care about your 'status' with a business, then you don't have much of a status.
- joeevans1000 11y agoFor IT professionals, completely ignoring all points systems (hotel, flight, car rental, and credit card) will remove enough clutter from your mind to earn more than the points provide.
- spinlock 11y agoI can't stand that you can buy your way out of security with this status. Real security doesn't work like that.
- slapshot 11y agoGS doesn't bypass security. It bypasses the line of people waiting to start the security process. At every major United hub airport I've seen, the GS passengers get dropped at the front of the TSA precheck line but still go through the regular exercise of x-rays and magnetometers.
- spinlock 11y agoThe agents working those machines and implementing the security protocol see that. And, they treat you differently.
- mpweiher 11y agoThe only winning move is not to play.
- brbsix 11y agoCasey Neistat of Youtube fame has a video illustrating the perks and perils of flying Executive Platinum with American Airlines. The perks seem pretty damn nice if you're already going to be flying that much anyways. https://youtu.be/3AeYIUyZXKE https://youtu.be/3AeYIUyZXKE