16 ms·
Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan
- aabajian 11y agoCan someone enlighten me about the history of the taxi industry? I have a medical background and I know that HIPAA came to be because insurance companies were taking advantage of patients with known conditions. There were other reasons, of course, but horror stories of patient's protected health information being sold to the media and insurance companies prompted the legislation. I have a hard time understanding how regulating personal transit is a governmental matter. A taxi driver may overcharge me a significant amount, and then there are instances of physical confrontation, but these are both rare and a risk that is inherent in accepting a ride with another person. It seems to me that the benefit to society (less pollution, traffic, easier commute, automotive scrap waste, etc) outweighs these risks.
- ghaff 11y agoThe theory is that taxicabs are a public service (especially in a city like New York). My understanding of the history is that, around the time of the great depression, there was significant oversupply of taxis with fare wars and various unsavory tactics, including violence, for hustling business. From there, regulation grew over time helped along by the incumbents who benefited from it of course.
- icebraining 11y agoThe violence came from the incumbents themselves, in the strike of 1934: "Rioting Cabmen Smash Autos, Crack Heads, As They March On Hall" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xIE3vc-RvOc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xIE3vc-RvOc http://cdsun.library.cornell.edu/cgi-bin/cornell?a=d&d=CDS19340323.2.12 http://cdsun.library.cornell.edu/cgi-bin/cornell?a=d&d=CDS19... "the strikers, marching to the City Hall to-day to protest to the Mayor, stormed through the Lower Broadway, destroyed 30 cabs and assaulted 25 chauffeurs, leaving the men for the most part stripped of clothing lying in a bloody and dazed state in the streets. They then staged a final riot within sight of Laguardia's chambers, dragging men and women passengers from the taxis and beating the drivers unconscious." http://trove.nla.gov.au/ndp/del/article/2342997 http://trove.nla.gov.au/ndp/del/article/2342997
- vertex-four 11y agoRoad management is a Government matter - specifically, managing congestion, where vehicles are allowed to stop and when, etc. Add on top of that the not-uncommon story in many countries of a taxi driver charging an extortionate fare without notice. Add on top of that ensuring that taxi drivers actually do their jobs and get people where they're going, rather than refusing to take people to locations within the city that are "too far away". Add on top of that regulating taxis so that people with disabilities can actually get out and about, seeing as public transport is dire in the US. All of these things are things that people had huge problems with convincing taxi companies to actually solve - after all, it's more profitable not to - and eventually local Governments agreed that taxis are as important to a city's transport infrastructure as anything else and should be held to a certain standard. You can only realistically argue against that if you believe that everyone who was using taxis had an alternative, which isn't the case. Uber solves many of these issues, I must admit - but what about five years down the line, once they have the near-monopoly they're seeking? Can we be absolutely certain it will continue to do what's best for the cities it services, even when it affects Uber's bottom line?
- amelius 11y ago> ... the near-monopoly they're seeking ... They will probably not get anywhere near a monopoly. Their businessmodel is flawed: anyone can start a similar service. In fact, many similar services already exist in Europe.
- vkou 11y agoAnecdotally, none of my co-workers use Lyft in Seattle because "There's always an Uber 2 minutes away." The network lock-in is quite real - if you can't get a critical mass of cars on the road, you can't get customers, and you can't get a critical mass of cars on the road without having customers paying fares. What can really hurt Uber is unionization of their drivers - since nothing stops them from collectively switching to a competing service.
- amelius 11y ago
- RodericDay 11y agoSome more stuff I guess. All car owners have to deal with insurance, in case they get into an accident. Public transport needs a different kind of insurance. Regulation here ensures compliance. Licensed cab drivers are also trained in terms of being able to provide First Aid and whatnot. Uber does away with this. (https://www.reddit.com/r/toronto/comments/3de8xr/ama_someone_who_works_in_the_toronto_taxi/ https://www.reddit.com/r/toronto/comments/3de8xr/ama_someone...) Cab fleets, by virtue of being composed of multiple cabs, are able to comply with regulations regarding having a certain % of cabs and drivers prepared to handle disabled passengers. Uber, seeing as they exist in a weird limbo where they both represent all the cabs and none at the same time, has fought such restrictions (http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/05/21/uber-disability-laws-don-t-apply-to-us.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/05/21/uber-disabi...).
- icebraining 11y agoIs First Aid training common? Sounds specific to Toronto, as I've never heard of that requirement elsewhere.
- majewsky 11y agoA friend of mine recently got a German "Personenbeförderungsschein" (person transport permit) to work part-time at a chauffeur service (which, from what he told, is mostly identical to a taxi service). There was no First Aid training involved as far as he told me, only a knowledge test of about 100 Points of Interest around the city, including routes to there and in some cases opening hours.
- DanBC 11y agoOver charging is not rare. A busy cabbie doesn't dramatically over charge a few people. They'll overcharge everyone by a small amount. Remember that one of the common user groups of taxis are "people who are drunk". These are vulnerable people who are less able to make sensible decisions, so the regulation needs to be a bit tighter. That vulnerability means you don't want people with a history of sexual violence to be cab drivers. There are other risks to passengers. You want to make sure all drivers have adequate insurance. We know that people are not capable of assessing that risk. You want to make sure that cabs are safe vehicles. For some cabs you want to make sure that they're capable of carrying disabled passengers (eg, people with guide dogs, or people with wheelchairs) so you specify that bigger companies include adapted cars. The regulation exists for the same reason the HIPAA regulation exists: because there used to be so much abuse in cab companies. Whether the current regulation makes much sense is another question - I don't think you'd end up with the current US style regulation if you tried to design a system from scratch.
- nommm-nommm 11y agoTo put it another way "I don't know why we need HIPAA because it's pretty rare for insurance to divulge health information." Of course you don't see insurance companies doing stuff like that anymore because of HIPAA.
- nstj 11y agoHuge fines > According to the Highway Act, Uber has been fined NT$100,000 (approximately US$3,070) to NT$150,000 (approximately US$4,605). Uber drivers have been fined NT$50,000 (approximately US$1,535).
- ilamont 11y agoThere are a few local factors that change the dynamics of app-based ride services in Taiwan. They include a solid public transportation infrastructure in Taipei, widespread scooter use (I estimate at least 20% of the population owns or has access to scooters), and relatively low-cost taxi rates. On the last point, a 45-minute cab ride from eastern Taipei to the international airport cost NT$1200, or about $36, and if you call a private limo service by phone it's NT$1000 for a big van, probably less for a car. By comparison, rates from Boston' airport are about $60 for a 30 minute ride and $40 for an Uber. FWIW, I found Uber cars to be somewhat rare in Taipei and nonexistent in Chiayi, a smaller city in the south that I visited earlier this month. That could be the crackdown mentioned in the article, but I suspect the demand isn't sufficient owing to the factors mentioned earlier.
- xiaoma 11y agoAccess to scooters is more like 85%. It's probably lowest in Taipei but still the vast majority of people if you rule out children and the very old.
- talloaktrees 11y agoTaiwan's rule of law is mostly about connections, money and shady backroom deals (sure, most countries are like this, but it's a matter of degree). I'm sure this has come about because of taxi companies being unhappy rather than any proper legal reasoning.
- audreyt 11y agoThe process leading to this was documented here: https://blog.pol.is/vtaiwan-uberx/ https://blog.pol.is/vtaiwan-uberx/ Registration was cited as one of the six consensus items by the e-deliberation process, and so far the only one that Uber has not yet assented to.
- temp 11y agoJust to clarify, they're banned from offering Uber service until they register as a Taxi service. >There are also cases in which legal loopholes have allowed the company to continue its operations. For example, Uber plans to purchase commercial licenses for its drivers in Germany, where ride-sharing services are banned from operating without taxi licenses. It's similar in the country I'm currently in - Uber works as a Taxi service and Uber drivers have Taxi licenses. Altho I would not call this a "loophole" as this is the route Uber should have taken from the get go in those places where they don't allow those without Taxi licenses to operate Taxi services.
- ThomPete 11y agoThe irony is that Uber is somehow showing that you don't need taxi licenses to run a responsible taxi service from the point of view of the drivers. It's totally doable to run an effective and safe service without requiring taxi licenses. The problem is their morals when it comes to how they treat their drivers.
- newman314 11y agoAND your data...
- ThomPete 11y agoFor what?
- trollingineer 11y agoGo easy on the sass there, Thomas...
- brbsix 11y agoThere's been some legitimate concern over what Uber does with the customer data it collects. Spying on and blackmailing journalists and whatnot. Who knows what else. They don't exactly have a "do no evil" motto. http://www.whosdrivingyou.org/blog/ubers-deleted-rides-of-glory-blog-post http://www.whosdrivingyou.org/blog/ubers-deleted-rides-of-gl...
- newsignup 11y ago> The Business Insider reports, some countries and regions have completely banned the service, finding it illegal under national or state laws. These places include Japan, Thailand, Nevada in the United States and Karnataka in India. Not in Karnataka, India - I and everyone uses it everyday.
- witty_username 11y agoYep, even their website has a page for Bangalore. https://www.uber.com/cities/bangalore/ https://www.uber.com/cities/bangalore/
- pfarnsworth 11y agoAlso it's legal in Nevada as of last year. This article is really poor reporting.
- audreyt 11y agoUber and Airbnb participated in the vTaiwan e-deliberation process, with quite different results — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qbdvvStfWT0&list=PLdwQWxpS513DB98lg8kgEVG66dierWOio&index=3 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qbdvvStfWT0&list=PLdwQWxpS51... explains the crowd-policymaking process in 14 minutes.
- chatmasta 11y agoWhen I was in Taipei, the cab system was 100 times better than uber and had none of the problems of the cab system in the US. If uber's main value proposition is superiority to taxis, then it makes no sense for it to try to take over in a city where the taxis are perfectly fine. Honestly, the same is true in NYC. I rarely call an uber because it's just easier to get one of the hundreds of yellow cabs than it is to stand on the street like an idiot looking for the Toyota Prius with the right license plate. Since uber arrived, all the issues I had with cabs seem to have disappeared. The fares are lower, drivers accept credit cards, and don't talk on their cellphone to their buddy in India. Uber put the pressure on cabs and it worked. I see no need to use uber.
- audunw 11y agoI can confirm the positive experience with cabs in Taipei. Taxi there is cheap anyway, and the taxi drivers I've experienced have been very friendly and professional. A lot of them don't speak english though. I don't know if there are special english-speaking taxis you can call up like I've seen in other countries. Personally I've never needed it.
- UK-AL 11y agoUber applies competition. If you get rid of competition, it will go back to the way it was over time. It's not something you can do once, and that's it.
- pfarnsworth 11y agoFalse. They have said their goal is to be competitive against public transportation and to keep dropping prices. Not engage in a monopoly and become fat cats like the taxi industry.
- notyourwork 11y agoEvery business would want to appear genuine, what business would say openly that they outright plan on being a monopoly?
- 11y ago
- jheriko 11y agoisn't uber already on shaky legal footing nearly everywhere anyway?
- matthewrudy 11y agoI work at GoGoVan in Hong Kong. We operate in 5 countries in Asia offering van hire and delivery services. But in Taiwan we've had regulatory issues, so we only operate a scooter delivery service. Its a similar issue to Uber. We'd need to have a license and a minimum size fleet of vehicles to do it. https://www.gogovan.tw https://www.gogovan.tw
- imrehg 11y agoIs there any English speaking site/app for non-Taiwanese living in Taiwan? I really think for every locality there should be English as an option.
- matthewrudy 11y agoThat's a good question. We're currently talking about this. But, even if our app and website works perfectly in english, there's little chance the driver will speak english. In Hong Kong we have a "speaks english" service you can pay for.
- imrehg 11y agoI cannot completely tell from the app pictures on the site, but it would worth thinking about it how much English people need for delivery? E.g. Uber is in English here, and was using it pretty fine without much Chinese. It's less of an issue for me, have an "everyday" level of proficiency, but in general. Also, do you have different apps for the different markets? If it's the same app everywhere, then it would make sense that the people can bring the "service" with them e.g. going from Taiwan to HK on a business trip, or Singapore for a few months work stint (or any other direction), and they can still use it the same way. It drives me crazy to no end when there's an international company, and language is completely tied to the location. Your case make a bit more sense than others, and it's a ton of work, I know. Just some thoughts.
- matthewrudy 11y agoIt'd be fair to say that our customer base is mostly Chinese speaking in Taiwan. But that doesn't mean we shouldn't be more friendly. We have one app with a whole host of different options baked into it for each country. * different graphics * different mapping SDKs * different languages * different vehicle types and service options I should give a technical talk in Taipei one day on it. I used to live in Taipei, but moved full-time back to HK in September.
- sherbondy 11y agoAs a side note, do any native Mandarin speakers have a good understanding of why app is usually spelled and pronounced as if it were an acronym (A.P.P.) instead of an abbreviation? Have been wondering about this for months, and the Quora thread on it is a little unsatisfactory: https://www.quora.com/Why-do-some-Chinese-people-in-China-pronounce-app-as-a-p-p https://www.quora.com/Why-do-some-Chinese-people-in-China-pr...
- neilni 11y agoI'm a native mandarin speaker from Taiwan and now living in NY. I think it just comes down to the fact that english is not everyone's first language there. For your example, people end up pronounce A.P.P because not everyone knows that app comes from `application` and therefore you might run into conversations with people speaking with different pronunciations. Some people pronounce 'app' the normal way, and some people pronounce 'app' similar to (ape). After awhile, people would explain what they're trying to say by spelling out, and eventually you'd learn to just say A.P.P instead of attempting to incorrectly pronounce the word. Same thing goes with Facebook, which is referred as F.B, and Instagram, which is usually referred as I.G
- xiaoma 11y agoInstagram is "eye jü". Nobody in Taiwan really says G.
- jake_morrison 11y agoIt's because Mandarin has standard syllables. While the sound for "p" is in the language, it's normally bound into a syllable. So saying "app" with the "p" sound at the end is awkward, but "pi" is natural.
- imron 11y agoNot a native speaker, but I speak Mandarin. I'd say it's because to a Mandarin speaker A.P.P is easier to pronounce than 'app' (Mandarin doesn't have any syllables that end with a p sound, but it does have syllables that start with p). There's also a history of 3 letter acronyms imported from English, such as DVD, VCD, MP3 which are all pronounced letter by letter and even though APP is not an acronym, to a native speaker it fits a similar pattern.
- vfusion 11y agoIs it because of taxes as to why countries don't like Uber/Lyft? Because in my opinion they are way better drivers, perhaps because they are driving their own cars.
- studentrob 11y agoI live in the south of Taiwan and uber just became available here over the weekend. Taxi service is already good if you speak Chinese. You can call a taxi automated system, give them a street corner, and they will give you a time estimate. It is usually 3 minutes and they show up on time. The benefit uber provides is to foreigners. If you do not speak Chinese, then you previously needed to flag down a cab.
- randyrand 11y agoAlso, there is no negative for a Taiwanese to have more options.
- studentrob 11y agoMaybe. Like I said the service is already good.
- aurizon 11y agoIn Toronto, Canada, taxis run 24/7 with 2 shifts of drivers. Insurance costs about $10,000 annually, more or less. On a per hour basis that = $1.14 per hour. Uber should obtain insurance on their driver fleet on that basis
- vertex-four 11y agoThat would likely involve Uber admitting that their drivers are not, in fact, self-employed.
- aurizon 11y agoWell, Taxi drivers are self employed
- Gratsby 11y agoTaiwan number one!
- Hydraulix989 11y agoThat's a shame. When I rode in cabs in Taiwan, I'd get ripped off because I was a foreigner. Uber had consistently better cars and was cheaper too
- xiaoma 11y agoHighly doubtful. In seven years and over a thousand cab rides in Taiwan that never happened to me. One one occasion my wallet fell out and the driver even called me to give it back. Ripping off the foreigner is more of a mainland China thing.
- Hydraulix989 11y agoActually, I had no problems at all in Shanghai with the cabs (aside from their ostensibly "crazy" driving). Anyway, since I'm not going to provide proof, you don't have to believe me.
- Hydraulix989 11y agoActually, ever since I posted this comment, I've received several emails from other HN users telling me of their Taiwanese cab driver rip off stories. Get rekt, Taiwanese sympathizer.
- runholm 11y agoFor once an article translated by Bing without grammar errors all over the place.