10 ms·
Basic income may be needed to combat robot-induced unemployment
- rhino369 11y agoUntil wealthy people get sick of #feelingthebern and take over government with robotic force. I'm not sure you want to make the majority of people useless beggars.
- Mikeb85 11y agoThey're already developing autonomous weapons. Once countries no longer need poor people to make up the military and police force, there'll be no incentive to help poor people. They can live in cloistered communities, and with all the means of production as well as war machines, there'll be parallel worlds - one ultra rich, one ultra poor.
- stegosaurus 11y agoNo, it's needed because forcing people to perform increasingly pointless tasks for wealthier humans in order to be granted the right to live is obscene. Unemployment is _good_. Being poor is bad. They are only correlated because we decided that made sense in the past. It doesn't any more.
- gwright 11y agoI find it difficult to understand exactly what type of a social contract you are suggesting as 'making sense'. You seem to be suggesting that people shouldn't have to be 'forced' to be employed (i.e. trade their personal skills for $$) but instead should receive an income from the government for simply existing. They could then do whatever they wanted in their free time. This clearly doesn't work for everyone unless you are working under the assumption that the 'government' can just print money and everything will just work out. So you seem to be suggesting that there should be two groups of people. Those who simply live on income given to them no strings attached by the government and another group of people who are doing something bad by being employed and are forced to give up some of their income/wealth to the government to be given to the group of people who opt out of that system. This seems to be what you are advocating but I must be missing something. BTW, I'm actually interested in a basic income mechanism as a more efficient way of delivering a social safety net to those who need some assistance but in my mind that presupposes that only a fraction of the people need assistance. I can't see how that works if the basic income is an attempt to provide a minimal viable income for everyone!
- afterburner 11y ago"and another group of people who are doing something bad by being employed" Did you overlook the group of people that has huge capital resources from accruing it from generation to generation and can simply sit on this wealth as the robots it purchases bring in even more wealth? Or do you consider that "being employed"? And do you think that if someone cannot find employment because there are not enough jobs in the world that they should therefore have a shitty life in their one and only finite existence?
- mycroft-holmes 11y agoRedistribute the group of people's wealth and then what?
- afterburner 11y agoWhy, what are you imagining?
- gwright 11y ago> And do you think that if someone cannot find employment because there are not enough jobs in the world that they should therefore have a shitty life in their one and only finite existence? I think it is pretty clear from what I wrote: "delivering a social safety net to those who need some assistance" that I don't think that.
- stegosaurus 11y agoI think the point being missed here is that those with high incomes or wealth essentially have their lifestyles subsidised by those who are forced to take the basic jobs in order to live. Their labour is cheaper than it would be if they were truly free. Essentially, they have little negotiating power. I'm advocating for flipping that position and seeing where it leads us. I don't think that people would suddenly stop working entirely. I think there would be a redistribution from rich to poor. I think that's reasonable. If you feel that the world would fall apart and people would stop doing anything useful if they weren't coerced, then I would ask the question - why do the wealthy work? They already have a basic income. What proportion of people who could retire permanently at say, age 40, actually do? I think the picture being painted of a bunch of feckless, consuming meatballs, is wildly off base.
- scarmig 11y agoContext: I'm a big proponent of the basic income. That said, it seems too much to say "Unemployment is good." It's hard to disentangle the effects of poverty versus unemployment, but there are pretty strong hints that having a (good) job is good for health--prolonged unemployment from solidly middle class jobs leads to depression, and people die at higher rates after retiring. People need a purpose and outlet for their creativity, and a sense of order and direction for their lives: sitting at home all day playing video games would be disastrous, and encouraging automation (which a basic income will do) will make it even harder to get entry level positions. We've got to enable some kind of meaningful labor (market-compensated or not) that people still can engage in after the basic income is implemented.
- rqebmm 11y agoIt might be more accurate to say "being required to be employed is bad" since 'unemployment' is a loaded word. But then again, that's OP's point.
- intopieces 11y ago>We've got to enable some kind of meaningful labor (market-compensated or not) that people still can engage in after the basic income is implemented. Are there no charities, no community organizations, no sports teams? Why trade the forced labor of market compensation for forced labor of government compensation? Meaningful labor already exists outside of market compensation. Anything the government would implement would just be beaurocracy soaking up funds that should be going towards the basic income.
- pasquinelli 11y agothere're two distinct senses for the word "work" that're pertinent. let's call it toil when we're given work to do, and play when we find our own work to do. in my experience, i see we're conditioned from childhood to think that toil is the normal way in which we're to make ourselves useful, or rather that it's the normal way in which we're made useful. we're also conditioned to think that play is kids stuff, that it isn't serious. so play becomes stunted, not maturing past kids stuff, and toil becomes serious and responsible, when actually it's infantile. so, you get laid off and find yourself, first of all under stress because your financial situation is uncertain, but secondly wasting away as a person and frittering you newly abundant free time playing video games. i don't think that points to your deep need to toil, to be given work to do. it's evidence of a poorly developed ability to play, that is to find work to put yourself to. as for me, i've had a few stints of unemployment and it's improved everything in my life, except my bank account. and when i got work again, everything became worse, again, except my bank account. now, like i said, this is just my own experience, but though i hear often enough that people have a real need to toil, i've never seen it in my actual experience. on the other hand i can see a real human need to play, which most people are deprived of. and, of course, a need for money, which is the only tangible thing people get from their toil.
- madspindel 11y agoUnemployment isn't good. I get your point, and agree. But basic income is not about unemployment = good but more about giving you the time to transform to do what you really want to do in life. Doing nothing in your life sucks hard. Everyone gets depressed and suicidal in the long term.
- Turing_Machine 11y agoThere are lots of things you could do that aren't menial jobs. Arts, crafts, travel...heck, fishing or bowling -- the list of things that are more rewarding than flipping burgers could go on for quite a long time.
- intopieces 11y agoInteresting that you automatically equate "unemployment" with "doing nothing in your life." It is possible for people to find meaning outside of labor.
- madspindel 11y agoI think we are playing with words here. I read your other comment about sports team, charity etc. Of course that is "doing something". And one could argue that _working_ for the Red Cross is some sort of labor?
- intopieces 11y agoThe discussion, so far as I can tell, has rested on the notion that people "need something to do" and that -- I guess? -- the government should be responsible for making sure that Basic Income money isn't going to "waste" on people who are just "unemployed." I'm arguing that no such discussion is necessary. People are perfectly able to entertain themselves, work or no, and find meaning in their lives. Those that aren't won't be helped by the government, that bluntest of tools used for the most delicate of incisions. My point is: Basic Income should be free from stipulation. Play video games, care for a sick mother in law, grow plants on your balcony and sing to them in Hindi -- none of the government's concern. While we're at it, eliminate the minimum wage and let the small businesses hire workers at whatever they can afford to pay. Let someone work at the local bakery if that makes them happy. Let's see what the people come up with when they don't have to worry about how they're going to eat.
- seivan 11y agoI am all for basic income, that being said... Unemployment is bad overall. Too much free-time and not enough money (basic income won't cover "fun") will have consequences regarding crime. Look at Sweden. Even with free healthcare, education and living costs covered the suburbs are filled with crime and radicalisation.
- lukasm 11y agoWhat to do with alcoholics and drug addicts that need jobs to avoid addictions? What to do with people that some sort of purpose in life? Wouldn't negative tax be better?
- baddox 11y agoWhy do you think that people's jobs are increasingly pointless? It seems to me that the opposite is true, since types of jobs disappear when they become much more efficiently performed by machines. To me, having someone plow a field by hand or operate a telephone switchboard is very pointless.
- stegosaurus 11y agoRight - that's the point. The jobs which actually need to be done in order for us to feed and clothes ourselves are increasingly done by machines. In some cases overseas labour is cheaper than automation, but we're still progressing there. As a result, because we're clinging to the idea that a person shouldn't eat unless they perform labour, we have to invent more and more categories of employment which become less and less essential - basically, people work in luxury sectors. I don't think we've quite reached the point at which the world can spin without unskilled labour, but I do think we can now afford to compensate it appropriately, and I think that giving the lower classes negotiation power via the basic income is the best way to achieve that.
- baddox 11y ago> because we're clinging to the idea that a person shouldn't eat unless they perform labour I don't understand this way of phrasing the argument. Do people really "cling" to this idea? It sounds equivalent to saying "we're still clinging to the idea that a person shouldn't be in good physical shape unless they exercise and eat well." I don't think many people cling to these ideas in an ethical sense, as if it would be immoral to be healthy without exercising or wealthy without working [0]. The ideas are just reflections of the actual state of the world, even though it might suck. I'd certainly rather be healthy without exercising and wealthy without working, but I don't expect or demand a forceful restructuring of society to satisfy my wishes. [0] Actually, now that I think of it, many people even in this thread do condemn people who become wealthy without working. It's perhaps somewhat ironic.
- stegosaurus 11y agoThe distinction is that trading labour for money/capital is a creation of society. It's not a natural rule. There are gatekeepers. I can't simply decide to go out and kill some wild animals or whatever and eat, and I can't decide to chop trees down and build a house. Getting a job is not a simple matter of just deciding to do it. By contrast, eating well is, aside from in cases of poverty, completely a matter of free choice.
- ZenoArrow 11y agoUnemployment is neither bad nor good. What's bad is forced employment. Work can be a source of satisfaction and social cohesion, I don't see the benefit in getting rid of it completely, but the important difference is that work shouldn't determine your ability to survive. We are capable of letting everyone have a decent quality of life without being a wage slave (and without destroying the planet), any work beyond that should be based on what we're interested in doing.
- lsc 11y ago>Unemployment is _good_. Being poor is bad. They are only correlated because we decided that made sense in the past. It doesn't any more. The way I see it, the idea behind basic income in a largely capitalist society would be to make being poor a lot less bad. It'd still be bad, probably, as a lot of us like having nice stuff; we like living in desirable areas, and those things won't be available to people on basic income, assuming we continue to use markets to distribute those scarce goods. Those of us who come from middle class families who maintain good family relationships often have a similar option; crashing with mom and dad for a while. It's not really something you want to do for any length of time, but it's nice to know that if things really go south, you aren't homeless, and you don't have to do anything truly repugnant. But just like crashing with mom and dad, it's not really a desirable long-term option for most of us. Sure, sure, it's going to be better than the jobs that are the worst on the unpleasantness/compensation scale, and I predict would dramatically drive up wages in the least pleasant fields, (and I predict would lower the rates of the less remunerative forms of crime for money) but if you are a software developer or something, especially if you come from a middle-class family that you maintain ties to, a realistically-sized basic income isn't really going to change your motivation. Point being, unemployment (as usually defined in statistics, meaning people who want work but can't get it) will remain a bad thing, and assuming a realistically sized basic income, most people who currently work are going to want to continue working. And... this is important. We need people to continue working. The basic income choice is really, "do we want people to do really unpleasant jobs for not very much money?" and then "are we all willing to pay rather a lot to make it so that people don't have to do really unpleasant jobs for not very much money?" The argument in favor is the idea that if a job really is that unpleasant, it ought to be compensated for that unpleasantness, and effort ought to be put into automating that job away. Making workers less desperate would make those things happen. Making workers less desperate would also decrease the workforce participation rate. More people wouldn't work, and more people would work part time. The argument against is that this is going to be pretty expensive, both in terms of what we have to pay to get the difficult-to-automate unpleasant jobs done, and in terms of just the taxes that would be required to fund the scheme.
- pluckytree 11y agoPeople seem to forget history and the fact that statements like this have pretty much always been wrong. There’s always something that supposed to replace something else and throw people out of work. Plus, robots are cute.
- vkou 11y agoWhen the industrial revolution put artisans out of work, there were factory jobs to replace what was lost. They were by far and large, absolutely terrible. Quality of life across Europe plummeted.
- ChrisNorstrom 11y agoand yet here you are typing on a computer, driving a car, and surrounded by hundreds of inventions made by factories. Terrible isn't it?
- vkou 11y agoIt took almost a hundred years, and a lot of bloodshed for quality of life to return to where it was prior to the industrial revolution. I'm not particularly keen on seeing that happen in my life.
- baddox 11y agoThis seems like a difficult moral argument to develop precisely. At what point in history do you prevent the current suffering, even if it would have resulted in a huge subsequent increase in quality of life?
- Turing_Machine 11y ago"It took almost a hundred years, and a lot of bloodshed for quality of life to return to where it was prior to the industrial revolution. " Sorry, that is simply not true. According to one study, real wages almost doubled in England between 1780 and 1850. An attempted rebuttal claimed that they "only" went up 30%. Like many people, you seem to have an overly-rosy idea of what life is actually like as a subsistence-level, stoop-labor, agricultural peasant. Workers flocked to the new factories because those jobs were an improvement over what they had before (the exact same process is going on in China as we speak). Were those jobs pretty nasty and horrible by modern standards? Of course they were. But not by the standards of the time.
- zazen 11y agoThe idea of basic income is popular on this site and has many ardent supporters here. Whichever side of the debate you're on, please bear in mind this topic needs an extra effort of patience and civility to have a productive conversation. Politicized topics like this break down into angry confrontations very easily.
- quadrangle 11y agoYes, but if you look over the comments, you'll see that the critics of BI are all either confused, ignorant, or have invalid world-views. ;) (wish I had an emoji for only-kinda-tongue-in-cheek, i.e. saying something kinda unfair with self-awareness to be half-joking, but actually kinda asserting it anyway)
- 11thEarlOfMar 11y agoI am genuinely concerned for the millions of Americans who drive for a living. Autonomous vehicle technology is a clear and present risk to that class of work. Like the rust belt of the 80s and 90s as manufacturing moved out of the US, there will be a major shift in where people work and what kind of work they do. Many, if not most, of those affected will go through hell getting their lives sorted out again. There are other affects of autonomous vehicles to consider. Labor is a major cost of shipping or taxiing. Accidents and the resulting repair, liability and insurance costs are expected to come down with autonomous vehicles. So the cost of just about everything we buy will come down, and we'll spend that difference elsewhere. Those 'elsewheres' will then see more employment. What we can expect, at a macroeconomic level, is not massive national unemployment, but a transition period as the work opportunities change. At a micro economic level, it will be very painful for millions as they go through the transition. I don't know if a basic income can make this transition smoother for the country, but it is worth studying.
- nopinsight 11y agoThere are a lot of jobs that humans can inherently perform better than robots for the next few decades at least: taking care of the elderly, hospice care, community development, physical therapy, etc. Humans are wired to trust and engage with our own species over any machines that could be developed any time soon. Populations in most countries likely to own robotic technology are aging fast and there will be even more demand for such jobs. In fact, a lot of demand already exists, only that the costs are too high for middle-class elders or patients to afford the services regularly. (See: expansion of nursing care in lower-cost countries like Thailand, but most people would prefer to stay in their own country if they have the choice.) Moreover, aptitudes the tasks required often match with those present in lower-wage workers in the service sectors. We need to retrain them for these higher-valued jobs. As a big plus, the jobs above often feel more meaningful than scanning items at cashier, delivering packages, or waiting table. There is evidence that being unemployed is not good for people's psyche and well-being in the long run. Demand for meaningful, high-valued services still exists and we ought to retrain workers for these jobs instead. Pay for these jobs should be higher and hours reasonable--more redistribution could be utilized to accomplish these. I believe earning one's living through work leads to a more meaningful existence. Demand for human work still exists for several decades to come. We need better social infrastructure to retrain workers at risk from technological unemployment and fully support them (including with good pay) during retraining. Technology has the potential to let us be human, free us from menial jobs, and focus on what we do best--if we develop the socioeconomic system to complement it and help with the transition.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nefitty 11y agoA basic income tied to GDP per capita would be interesting. If automation begins pervading every industry, the inherent improvement processes involved would lead to maximally efficient production. A basic income should be tied to the productive power of these systems, as leaving the BI pegged at a certain point could make income inequality much worse than it is now. Capital-holders would begin benefitting tremendously from automation as it improves. Another thing to ponder is, if certain technological innovations come to pass (ie, an affordable personal-AI system), should the government consider providing those technologies to all of its citizens? The disparity between someone with a personal-AI and someone without would increase exponentially, very quickly. This is simply considering the economic value an AI could provide, in terms of helping with business ideas, self-improvement, secreterial work, etc. Anyways, massive unemployment is going to occur soon. If governments can't come to terms with providing a universal basic income, I would suggest they begin planning emergency food supply distribution systems immediately. The first thing that people will begin missing is food, and if a government can provide sustenance to needy populations, it would buy itself some time before civil unrest spread throughout the country. http://livescience.com/52724-can-strategic-games-prevent-food-riots-from-returning.html http://livescience.com/52724-can-strategic-games-prevent-foo...
- lossolo 11y agoIt's future, in 100 years from now, all food, all energy and most of other services/products will be made without any human interaction. While everything will be produced without wasting any resources (full automation, recycling etc), there is no reason why food and energy should not be free. To work will be a choice not requirement.
- krapp 11y agoWhat you're describing is impossible. There's no such thing as free energy, or a system with perfect efficiency which doesn't waste resources.
- lossolo 11y agoDo you know how fusion reactors work ? You give it energy to heat it up and you get MORE (edit: transform) energy than you gave from this reaction.
- krapp 11y ago>You give it energy to heat it up and you get MORE energy than you gave from this reaction No, you don't[0][1]. [0]https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/59673/why-doesnt-fusion-contradict-the-1st-law-of-thermodynamics https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/59673/why-doesnt... [1]https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/3xxpw9/why_doesnt_nuclear_fusion_violate_the_second_law/ https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/3xxpw9/why_does... Fusion might be a vastly more efficient version of what we already have, but it's still neither perfect nor infinite. Sooner or later, you run out of fuel, or the reactor breaks down, or you have to build more reactors or something.
- lossolo 11y agoSo you interpreted what i wrote about "infinite" literally..? Ok... We are talking about fusion... So you suggest then i think Sun will never die and has infinite energy too, yes? Maybe i will explain you what i mean and everyone else mean when they say what i said. It means that we can RELEASE MORE (transform) ENERGY, because energy is never destroyed, it's transformed. In other words the total mass of the tritium and deuterium nuclei before the reaction is greater than the mass of the helium and neutron after fusion has taken place – even though it is the same number of protons and neutrons.
- maxerickson 11y agoIs a basic income meant to cover healthcare needs? If yes, what incremental steps could be taken in the US to start reducing healthcare costs down to a level where we can even think about providing a stipend on top of the free healthcare?
- quadrangle 11y agoPreventative care and the most cost-effective healthcare treatments should be universally available separately from BI. There's no good way for market systems to manage health care well. As a society, we simply cannot afford to give everyone whatever-it-takes care for end-of-life though. We need to prioritize the health care that has the most impact for the cost, the stuff that keeps a normal healthy person healthy and productive, not the stuff that extends a terminally ill person's life by an extra 6 months. To reduce our costs, we have to focus on managing end-of-life to be a positive experience rather than trying to extend it as far as possible at whatever cost.
- raverbashing 11y agoThe thing that is most effective in reducing healthcare costs is prevention. Easiest way today of increasing "overall health" in the US: better diet and more exercise I believe this will also be automated and there will be a 'Computer doctor' that can give you guidance and maybe a basic Rx for the majority of problems that take people off work (a lot of which are resolved by staying at home for a couple of days) Then you would have more complex problems dealt by a doctor
- maxerickson 11y agoPrevention reduces spending. Lack of it doesn't provide a satisfying explanation as to why an xray bill is much higher at a given hospital and things like that. Or is the lack of preventative care somehow showing up in the price of only some xrays?
- raverbashing 11y ago> Lack of it doesn't provide a satisfying explanation as to why an xray bill is much higher at a given hospital and things like that. Of course not, but prevention will lower your "consumption of services" Providers gauging the price of x-rays are a separate problem
- lucb1e 11y ago"May be"? I thought that was the whole point: automation produces wealth but people are put out of jobs to make it happen, so it makes sense that they're compensated by something like a government.
- blubb-fish 11y ago> a system in which all citizens or residents of a country receive an unconditional sum of money, in addition to any income they bring in elsewhere. It will come - simply b/c a majority will depend on it and politicians depend on majorities. But it will also be so low that people will merely be able to afford a reasonable modern living standard. At the same time there will be incentives to take new kind of jobs to pad the basic income. Those jobs will be servant jobs - bringing people food, driving them around ... serving them ... b/c no robot can give you the feeling of being in a position of power. So the fate for the uneducated or people educated but in economically irrelevant areas will be basic income plus being a servant.
- surfmike 11y agoThere is so much work out there to be done, it's laughable that we are talking about paying people for doing nothing. Think about all the elderly retiring people that will need to be cared for. All the working moms who struggle to find people to care for their kids during the day. All the litter and graffiti all over our cities and roads. Countries like Japan are freaking out about their aging demographics and how they will support them. The solution is definitely not to decrease the amount of people working. Instead of basic income, why not use the money instead to give a generous wage subsidy to people at the bottom? So that even a street sweeper, caretaker, nanny, or preschool teacher is well financially rewarded? FWIW, the Scandinavian model, which has some of the highest equality and well-being in the world, requires people to work and has some of the highest labor force participation rates in the world.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "There is so much work out there to be done, it's laughable that we are talking about paying people for doing nothing." If automation continues to expand as expected, the majority of tasks humans do could be replaced by machines/AI. At this point, the total volume of work may be high, but the total volume of work only humans can best fulfil may be much lower than it is today. The question becomes, when we can apply automation to most jobs, what will human society look like?
- surfmike 11y agoLet's worry about that when it happens. My point is that it's premature to talk about introducing a UBI when there's so many needs out there. Also, caring for children/elderly is not something that is necessarily desirable to automate...
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "Let's worry about that when it happens. My point is that it's premature to talk about introducing a UBI when there's so many needs out there." The point of talking about an UBI now is to iron out any issues with it before it's needed. Furthermore, whilst the need for it isn't as strong as it might be later, there are certain benefits it could bring to simplifying and improving welfare even in today's society. If you're suggesting there's a risk people will not work, that all depends on the implementation (again, another reason why it's being discussed now). What I believe is likely to happen to the current job market if we had UBI is that people would be freer to switch careers, and as a consequence of this undesirable jobs are likely to have higher wages, and desirable jobs are likely to have lower wages. For example, cleaning jobs would pay more, and marketing jobs would pay less. In other words, the incentives for working would change based on the flexibility of the workforce. > "Also, caring for children/elderly is not something that is necessarily desirable to automate..." Most of that isn't paid work at it stands now, plus it's worth remembering that the automation of the future is likely to be more adaptive to individual needs (i.e. when it's driven by sufficiently sophisticated AI). Lastly, the aim isn't to remove humans entirely from the world of work, the idea is to change the need for humans to work, the option to work will still be present.
- Animats 11y agoKey quote: "Our current economic system requires people to either have wealth or to work to make a living, with the assumption that the economy creates jobs for all those who need them. If this assumption breaks down - and progress in automation is likely to break it down, I believe - then we need to rethink the very basic structure of our economic system." That's a good statement of the problem. It's useful to get that clear before talking about solutions. Solutions are hypothetical; problems are real. How far along are we in that direction already? About 14% of the US workforce makes all the stuff - that's manufacturing, construction, mining, and agriculture. That figure was about 50% in 1950 and around 90% in the 19th century. The conventional wisdom was that more education helps. That is no longer the case. About 37% of employed US college graduates are in jobs which require only a high school diploma.[1] Overproduction of college graduates has reduced the value of a college education substantially. It's not often mentioned, but there's one class of jobs that's almost totally gone - large numbers of people doing the same thing under close supervision. In 1900, Carnegie Steel had 5000 men with shovels at one plant. Today, you might see one or two people with shovels working, but beyond that, power equipment is brought in. There's a fraction of the population which needs jobs that structured. Many homeless are in that category. (Jobs where drunkenness is tolerated have almost totally disappeared.) That's a problem at the low end. 13.5% of the population has an IQ between 70 and 85. What are they going to do?[2] Nothing above is really in question. So that's a way to look at the problem as of right now. Looking ahead, there's this well-known study on jobs likely to be automated soon.[3] Understanding the changing nature of work is the first step to dealing with it. [1] http://centerforcollegeaffordability.org/uploads/Underemployed%20Report%202.pdf http://centerforcollegeaffordability.org/uploads/Underemploy... [2] http://www.dol.gov/oasam/programs/history/herman/reports/futurework/conference/trends/trendsVII.htm http://www.dol.gov/oasam/programs/history/herman/reports/fut... (Note that this paper is from 1999.) [3] http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/news/article-2642880/Table-700-jobs-reveals-professions-likely-replaced-robots.html http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/news/article-2642880/Tabl...
- iofj 11y agoBut in the 1950s this was solved by doing something new : get everyone and their dog a car. This got us to the 1980s or even the 1990s and is still employing large amounts of people, though not as large as before. After that we're getting everybody "services". Phones, bank accounts, insurance, apps, newsletters, ... that did make life better. That got us jobs until 2000/2001 or so. We just need to find a new "car"/"phone". Something to get for everyone and their dog, that they'd want, ideally with recurring charges, that can't be delivered without employing God knows how many people (ideally something that would improve the more people you employ). Because, whilst I don't subscribe to the positive side of Ayn Rand's philosophy, I do subscribe to the negative side. Having the government redivide wealth from the productive to everyone is something that may soften the short-term impact of unemployment, but in the medium/long term it's a disaster. I even agree that redividing wealth combined with human greed manifesting through corruption will make it impossible to turn back from redividing policies once they reach a certain percentage of the economy, by blocking any and all innovation (because it would require changing the redivision policies, which is too dangerous politically. Much easier to just block, say, autonomous cars. Meanwhile drivers die, or worse, kill others, are away from their families for weeks/months, and don't do anything useful. They're not improving anyone's life by having that job over not having that job. It would pretty much be better for everyone, including them, to just have them sitting at home watching TV. And why ? Because figuring out redividing policies would lead to political infighting, or even real fighting (just watch some European demonstrations by farmers, or students)). I agree that the economy is there so people can live, and live well, not the other way around. But having the private sector do that is almost infinitely preferable over having government redivide wealth. We essentially need to find something new we can and want to do with the economy, that would improve our lives, and require large amounts of people helping to make that happen.
- justifier 11y agoit's funny, i have been promoting this opinion in the opposite direction for the last ten years once we begin distributing gains to everyone there will be an exponential robotics boon in order to fill all of the positions people walk away from
- CM30 11y agoTo some degree, I suspect a certain number of human jobs will remain long after automation simply for the sentimental value. Like organic or free range food, where people are willing to pay a premium for goods that aren't made via some industrial type process. So you'd have 'human made' as a label on the side of slightly more expensive products tailored to slightly more well off people who see it as more ethical. Like a non food version of a farmer's market. It won't save most of the jobs, but they'll definitely be enough people out there who don't want 'machine made' products by companies only using robots. On another note, I suspect many of these articles also miss one other thing; there's no reason that every company would use robots or AI. Sure, large companies would. But in the same market would likely be hundreds or thousands of smaller ones with at least some humans in the workforce. I mean, look at it this way. Go down the high street and look at the shops and restaurants. Sure, big chains exist, whether they be coffee ones like Starbucks and Costa or supermarkets like Walmart or Tesco or the likes, but so do tons of small companies run by people aiming at a local market, or a certain niche, or anything else. They're not all going to buy expensive machinery to run the shop, and they're not all going to go out of business. Heck, it could even be the opposite; quite a few businesses in the real world have actually gotten MORE popular once a Starbucks has moved in next door. People will still buy things from small businesses (especially if they're distrustful of large multinational companies), and those small (and even medium sized) businesses will still hire human staff. That seems to be overlooked in these discussions. After all, if even something as big as Coca Cola or Disney or McDonalds or whatever has lots of competition, what makes you think your future companies won't?
- CM30 11y agoOn another note, does all this mean that in the future, intelligent robots will actually be in the same situation as humans? I mean, if simple ones can take care of simple jobs in stuff like manufacturing, driving vehicles, admin work, etc, one with real AI would basically be unemployable. If they don't want to pay humans for work, then they won't want to give a robot a paycheck either. That's going to be an interesting issue too.