7 ms·
The best way to put this for the other side is: "How about we start with FBI mandated remote control gun disablers given that it's guns that killed these peopl
by bsder 11y ago
The best way to put this for the other side is:
"How about we start with FBI mandated remote control gun disablers given that it's guns that killed these people? Oh, you're concerned that someone will figure out how to bypass it, and it won't just be the FBI disabling your gun?
Congratulations. You now understand my position."
- knd775 11y agoGiven the original motivation for the Second Amendment, I think that the even just the FBI being able to remotely disable guns would be pretty concerning to some.
- bsder 11y agoUm, exactly?
- api 11y agoI think a case should be made for a right to strong encryption based on the second amendment. If anything, encryption is far more relevant today to personal defense than gun ownership and does far more to protect your individual rights against both government excess and private attacks. A gun won't stop a government from watching your every move by converting every device in your house into a surveillance device and then using "parallel construction" to persecute you if some political apparatchik doesn't like your views or opinions. A gun also won't stop a criminal from emptying your bank account or stealing your identity, attacks that can today steal far more from you than a home invasion. A gun won't stop a stalker from hacking your home devices to secretly record your kids playing, or hacking your e-mail account to spy on you, etc. Encryption on the other hand can stop all these things. Cyber-attacks today are potentially even more damaging than non-violent physical invasion (burglary, etc.). Not only that, but we are very close (if not already there) to a world where you can kill someone by hacking a device. Self-driving cars, Internet connected buildings, etc., could all be used to conduct a homicide remotely. If, for example, the signing key to a car's firmware were to be leaked, then hackers could remotely flash a person's car to murder them on the highway and make it look like a hardware failure or a freak accident. A government could even do this and have almost no chance of detection. The opportunity for corruption both public and private is fairly large given how clandestinely these kinds of attacks could be conducted. Crypto is the new "well armed militia" and the new right to personal self-defense.
- LordKano 11y agoThe "well regulated militia" is still the same. Crypto is just another weapon in the arsenal.
- MCRed 11y agoI'm not sure which "other side" you're targeting with your argument, but as a gun rights advocate its' completely consistent to be a privacy rights advocate-- and basically a human rights advocate. That it doesn't hurt another, do what thou wilt. Thus gay married farmers should be able to defend their marijuana crops with fully auto AK47s. Marijuana, guns and gay sex don't do bad things to society. Only people can misuse them.
- Karunamon 11y agoFrom my perspective, most of the crowing I see about how Apple is terrible for not immediately capitulating is coming from the American right wing, a political bloc traditionally associated with gun rights.
- doktrin 11y ago> I'm not sure which "other side" you're targeting with your argument, but as a gun rights advocate its' completely consistent to be a privacy rights advocate-- and basically a human rights advocate. I can't speak for the parent, but I'd imagine s/he has observed a correlation in that the political "right" seems to be more in favor of an encryption backdoor than the "left". The "right" is also unequivocally more enthusiastic in its defense of 2a rights. To support this notion - at least insofar as being an indicator of public sentiment - I would point to the Republican primary field which has almost unanimously spoken out in opposition of Apple's decision. Their two Democrat counterparts have thus far been more reserved about the matter.
- ikeboy 11y agoThat's putting a backdoor into phones, which is not what's requested in this situation. It's more like "the manufacturer of this safe has the ability to reprogram the safe to make it crackable, we should hand them the safe and demand that they reprogram it so we can access it".
- mikegerwitz 11y agoThe request is to provide alternative software that bypasses normal security features of the system; that qualifies as a backdoor: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backdoor_%28computing%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backdoor_%28computing%29
- ikeboy 11y agoBut they aren't asking Apple to install it on all phones. The example above is only appropriate if they were asked to put it on everyone's phones.
- dkuntz2 11y agoThat doesn't matter! Apple's entire argument, which I completely agree with, is that if they make this firmware, then it exists. It doesn't matter that they were only instructed to put it on one phone, once it's out there, there's almost no way they can make sure that firmware doesn't get picked up by other people, and placed on other phones, without users consent, without court orders. There's no such thing as one-off and then it disappears in the world of software. Once it exists in the world it's only a matter of time before everyone has it.
- ikeboy 11y ago>It doesn't matter that they were only instructed to put it on one phone, once it's out there, there's almost no way they can make sure that firmware doesn't get picked up by other people, and placed on other phones, without users consent, without court orders. I already wrote a rebuttal of this argument in a different subthread. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11134257 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11134257 If you have something to add to that, respond there.
- mikeash 11y agoWhat if the FBI asked a gun manufacturer to build a disabler for one gun the FBI already possesses? That's more analogous here.
- rbcgerard 11y agoWhich in turn created a template that can easily be adapted and called upon to unlock anyone else' "gun"
- ChuckMcM 11y agoThis is a confusing point. At the moment, there is no software or tooling to do what the FBI wants so the subpoena asks them to "develop new capabilities" in order to meet it. However, once they have done that for this one phone, they will no longer be able to say truthfully "We can't do that." and any time a phone needs to be unlocked the FBI will get a judge to issue a subpoena and if Apple doesn't comply, with the proof out there they could comply, then they are in contempt. It is that follow on that is the back door. So now Apple is in the position where they have to unlock phones on demand, and not doing so will subject them to fines and imprisonment (you cannot easily appeal an order to do something in a case which it is clear you have the capability to do). What is worse, if they are forced to comply and develop this capability, and then design the next generation of phone so that they once again don't have a capability to break into it, that case then is even harder. The FBI can sue Apple for intentionally obstructing justice. Don't be fooled, this isn't a case about one phone and one set of people who have shot a bunch innocent people. This is very much a calculated strategy on the Justice Department's behalf to get back doors into phones and create legal precedents for which they can compel those back doors. That will force the group that doesn't want back doors to get Congress to create a law that specfically forbids them. And the Justice Dept knows that would be very hard for folks to achieve.
- mikeash 11y agoIf Apple can build the software and tooling in question (and as far as I've seen nobody disputes that they can, the question is simply whether they will), then they are already unable to truthfully say "we can't do that."
- snowwrestler 11y agoWhy don't we have remote take-over capability built into airplanes? People have certainly crashed them intentionally. Why don't we have remote kill switches in cars? Think of the high-speed chases that could be prevented. Why don't we have surveillance cameras in private homes? Think of all the crimes that could be solved. Even if these are all off by default, and the law requires a court order to turn them on, Americans would not accept them. Encryption is no different, except that most Americans don't understand it well enough to see the parallels. But these are just arguments against backdoors. The even more fundamental argument is about the All Writs Act. Can the FBI require companies to develop new capabilities just with a court order? Shouldn't that require legislation? Why did we bother to pass CALEA, if the government could have just said "All Writs Act" and gotten what they wanted that way?
- danjoc 11y agoIt is easier to understand if the same task is rephrased. "Apple ordered by Chinese government to disable lock on phone seized from undercover CIA agent." The act is the same. Being a multinational company, the result is no different for Apple. A government is legally requiring Apple to make decryption possible, but suddenly the people crying for Apple to unlock this phone will take an extremely different stance.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoEverybody I've seen here saying that Apple should assist the FBI in unlocking the device takes the same stance in both cases. If Apple doesn't like it, they should either secure the device in such a way that it isn't easier for themselves to compromise than it is for a third party or stop doing business in that country if they believe the requests are unreasonable.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoUnlike telephone operators affected by CALEA, Apple is free to develop a phone with security that is as hard for them to circumvent as it is for the FBI. When they do, the All Writs Act won't apply to them.
- presidentender 11y agoWhat's this "other" side?
- LordKano 11y agoIt's funny to me because I feel the same way about this as I do about mandatory "smart guns". Basically, not only do I not trust the government but I don't trust that the information won't fall into even worse hands than theirs.
- kordless 11y agoYour assumption about someone understanding your position based on rational arguments is flawed. The reason it's flawed is because of the same reason we're currently arguing whether or not Apple has the right to challenge whether the FBI can compel them/us to write software for the government so they can "protect us better" from both real and fictitious threats. This type of reasoning leads to cognitive dissonance (believing two logically conflicting things at the same time) in the general population, which is caused by people applying double bind[1] arguments to conversations. Those double bind arguments end up creating additional cognitive dissonance in others and the vicious cycle is repeated, all the while being accelerated by our ever increasing connectedness. There's a going theory that these types of meme-based arguments are actually thought viruses[2]. One way to stop these types of arguments is to take a quiet moment and identify arguments or language structure that lean on speculative unknowns and which encourage equally speculative rhetoric which is dissonant in nature. In other words, let's all start to learn how to identify dissonant speech and reject it as a truth when we hear it. Let's tell others we think the conversation may be dissonant in nature to help stop the cycle. One thing to consider while approaching solving these complex problems is setting the goal of removing rules of conduct as technology becomes more complicated. All this talk of creating new rules (and seeking new rulings to establish them) is creating an extremely complicated house of cards for all of us to thoughtfully manage. This is because we're basing our arguments on a fundamentally false premise, which is it's the government's job is to completely remove all suffering from society. That's actually not their job, nor is it achievable, so perhaps it's time to question why they think it is and figure out a solution that isn't in disagreement with itself. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_bind https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_bind [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viruses_of_the_Mind https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viruses_of_the_Mind
- bsder 11y ago> Your assumption about someone understanding your position based on rational arguments is flawed. I'm not attempting a rational argument. I am attempting to phrase the argument in terms that a set of authoritarian advocating individuals can relate to. To most of them, their guns are more important than preventing terrorists from killing people. By driving home the fact that this precedent will eventually apply to their guns, you get their attention. Otherwise, they just fluff it off as a "whining from a bunch of liberal, elite pansies".