11 ms·
Well sure, mathematicians are so nutty about notation, it's amazing any mathematics gets done at all. Not at all convinced it's a feature. More like an unfortu
by skybrian 11y ago
Well sure, mathematicians are so nutty about notation, it's amazing any mathematics gets done at all.
Not at all convinced it's a feature. More like an unfortunate side-effect of tradition.
- michael_fine 11y agoI'm sure mathematicians would say the same thing about programmers and their verbosity.
- duaneb 11y agoYou think english would be much better? It's trading one symbol for another. It's complex reasoning no matter what.
- TheCowboy 11y agoI don't think the choice is between pure English and what we have now. It's easy to just stick with the traditional notation(s) of every subject, but there could be some cases where an attempt to refactor some notations might be of benefit. I usually like to criticize the combined use of i and j. Their use in pseudocode for analyzing loops also just aids confusion. I've helped some people by telling them to go through examples and change one of the variables into something more readable, and then it clicks for them.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y ago"Writing everything out in prose" is the way it used to be back in the long-ago days. Modern notation is far superior.
- kmm 11y agoThat really surprises me. I've never found mathematical notation to be anything than very useful and terse. Can you make it any more clear what bothers you? It has always been very clear for me, and I'm not sure what could be improved. I'd think any attempt to make it less ambiguous or more expressive would eventually devolve in something very similar to what we have now, because of our compulsion to simplify repeated tasks (eg Einstein notation, bra-ket etc..)
- mrob 11y ago>Can you make it any more clear what bothers you? A few things that spring to mind: dx/dy notation, and especially manipulating it like it's a real fraction. Implicit multiplication, which forces use of single character variable names, which forces use of weird fonts and greek letters. Writing sin^2(x) for (sin(x))^2 Writing sin^-1(x) for arcsin(x) (especially bad because it conflicts with sin^2(x)) The base for log(x) is ambiguous. Writing |x| for abs(x) (abs() is obviously a function, it shouldn't have special notation) Calling abs "modulus" And the names "imaginary number" and "complex number" seem almost deliberately designed to intimidate outsiders. IMO they should be called "oscillating numbers" and "rotating numbers".
- Maken 11y ago>Writing |x| for abs(x) (abs() is obviously a function, it shouldn't have special notation) >Calling abs "modulus" Both of those are because the absolute value of a number is the norm of the one-dimensional space.
- mrob 11y agoI've been successfully using abs() for a very long time, and I have no idea what "the norm of the one-dimensional space" is. If the notation requires understanding something of so little practical relevance to make sense then it's bad notation.
- schoen 11y agoIt's a generalization, and it makes sense as one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norm_%28mathematics%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norm_%28mathematics%29 It allows you to think about |x| when x is a vector (or even other kinds of objects!) rather than just a real number. This kind of generalization can be a really powerful thing about mathematics, making existing insights more broadly applicable.
- mrob 11y ago
- Animats 11y ago"In mathematics there is no unified documentation, just a collective understanding, scattered references, and spoken folk lore. You’re lucky if a textbook has a table of notation in the appendix. You are expected to derive the finer details and catch the errors yourself." This has always bugged me. Andrew Ng's notation for machine learning sometimes uses superscripts as indices, and sometimes as exponents. In the same formula. Years ago, when I was working on a physics engine for animation, I was struggling through a 2-volume treatise on nonlinear differential equations. One formula in Volume 2 had a symbol I didn't understand, and couldn't find in the text. I eventually found it defined in the first volume, about 500 pages back. Steven Wolfram was annoyed by that, and he created Mathematica partly to define an unambiguous notation for much of mathematics. This is a fixable problem. By now we should have programs which read mathematical papers and textbooks, and check that all symbols are defined and unambiguous. There would be style sheets for different branches of mathematics. When reading a paper processed through such a system, you would be able to see the expanded, unambiguous form of a formula, and the definitions of all the standard operators and symbols. This might not be possible for truly cutting-edge mathematics where the conventions haven't settled yet, but that's a small fraction of what's published.
- bsilvereagle 11y ago> Andrew Ng's notation for machine learning sometimes uses superscripts as indices, and sometimes as exponents. In the same formula. I've never read Ng's work, but typically upper and lower indices is a sign of a summation. It's known as "Einstein Summation Notation". At first glance it seems obtuse, but when you start doing covariant/contravariant derivatives on tensors, the notation makes things much easier.
- OscarCunningham 11y agoIn a general relativity lecture I once saw an expression where indices were being used to mean three different things. As a power, to denote the components of a vector and as an index over some other indexing set. Of course it was perfectly readable because there are implicit conventions about what kind of letters you can use for each of these things, and because the formula would only make sense if you read it a certain way.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoI think one thing that you have to remember is, ISO standards aside, mathematical notation isn't a fixed thing but a living tradition that evolves over time.
- klibertp 11y agoWhich is totally true for programming languages, yet they somehow manage to have standards, all the undefined behaviour of C be damned. How come it's not the case for mathematics? Maths notation has very many problems, most of which stem from the fact that its syntax isn't formally specified. I have no idea why would mathematicians want to continue using this informally specified, ambiguous notation when there are alternatives.
- serge2k 11y agobecause we know how to read and don't care what a bunch of outsiders think.
- klibertp 11y agoYeah, that's exactly my suspicion! I'm just happy it's not true for Computer Science and programming. Whatever you want to say about a social side of programming, there's no denying it that outsiders and beginners are warmly welcomed in the community. We create and provide for free tutorials and guides for beginners, we design languages to be as easy for people to understand as possible (we don't exactly know what makes languages easy to understand, but we at least try!), we create tools for visualisation and summarizing code, and so on. Similar activities seem to be unpopular with mathematicians. I can't help but feel mathematicians are just a bunch of elitist pricks, who know they are on their way out and who try to build artificial barriers for entry into their field to make themselves needed for a bit longer. It's actually natural, most people will fight to retain their status (and jobs). It reminds me of "refucktoring", writing convoluted, unreadable code just to make sure nobody, else than you, can work with it. Such programmers are shunned in our community, yet they are heroes in mathematics. Oh well, as an "outsider" it's not my problem.
- 11y ago
- OscarCunningham 11y agoI feel a need to stand up for mathematics notation. The main complaint seems to be that it is too minimalist, using the minimal number of symbols (or less) to be unambiguous. But mathematics notation needs to be extremely succinct because the notation is not just for reading. When you're working something out you often need to write pages and pages of formulae and diagrams by hand. So using a notation more verbose than absolutely necessary would be unnecessarily painful. Programming is different because you can use a text editor with copy, paste, autocomplete etc. But I imagine that if I wasn't allowed to use any of those then my variable names would shrink down to one letter when I was programming too. Also, I think that making formulas smaller makes it easier for the eye to see the whole formula together. This makes it easier to quickly understand the meaning of the formula, at least once you've got used to the notation for that particular area of mathematics.
- warfangle 11y agoGoing through Calc III for the first time. I can't imagine how many more trees I would destroy if I had to write out double integrals longhand. Not to mention, it would make it a lot harder to reason about everything going on... When I first started in my adult adventure in math (never doing well with it academically, I started on pre-calc with Khan Academy about a year and a half ago; I'm now working through multivariable calculus on MIT OCW), I used scratch mode in emacs because hey, I'm right there on the computer. I gave up and started using graph paper as my scratch pretty quickly :) I can't imagine trying to actually _do_ math with something "descriptive" like LaTeX. Math, from what I've come to realize, is less about describing how to compute something and more about describing something in such a way that it can be manipulated in order to reveal something new. And that's why the obtuse iconography is popular in math, and why the obtuse iconography of APL never became truly mainstream in programming.
- skybrian 11y agoYes, that's the tradition part. I certainly don't object to using whatever notation you like when you're at a whiteboard or scribbling on paper. But math papers are carefully formatted and published using LaTEX, not by taking pictures of whiteboards. This isn't because it's easiest. It's supposedly to benefit the reader, and yet fails in practice. It seems like coming up with a format that at least allows definitions and usages to be hyperlinked might be pretty nice, instead of a format whose primary benefit is looking pretty when you print it on paper.
- bitwize 11y agoMath notation is for pencil and paper what Unix commands are for typed input: terse, dense, intended to be easy for insiders to write and read at the expense of outsider accessibility. It does the job it's supposed to do. You wouldn't plow through a mathematical paper like a Twilight novel. You're supposed to slow down, consider each symbol in relation to all the others, and from that build a picture in your head of the mathematical object being described.
- skybrian 11y agoWell yes, I agree, nobody expects to be able to skim. But I don't think Unix commands are a particularly great example for your side. They are nice for interactive work but terrible for maintenance. Nobody wants to read a thousand-line shell script.
- kaitai 11y agoSounds like a really good analogy, in fact :)