15 ms·
Uber losing $1B a year to compete in China
- cryptoz 11y ago> "We have a fierce competitor that's unprofitable in every city they exist in, but they're buying up market share. I wish the world wasn't that way." - Kalanick Haha, really? Isn't that how Uber started out, and the quote could well be verbatim from a taxi driver in 2011?
- robert_foss 11y agoThe irony struck me too.
- chrisseaton 11y agoWhere on earth is the irony? He wishes he didn't have this competitor. He doesn't say he thinks what they're doing is illegal or unethical. He doesn't say they should be stopped by anyone. He just wishes they weren't around. You're thinking he's said things which he hasn't.
- Avshalom 11y agohe's not wishing about "they", he's wishing about "the world"
- elbigbad 11y agoGiven the context, "I wish the world wasn't that way" means "I wish we didn't live in a world where people could unprofitably pour money into a market to grab market share to kill off competitors." It's ironic because it's exactly what they have done in other markets, but they're not complaining about where they were successfully the aggressor, but instead where they are the victim of the tactic.
- chrisseaton 11y ago> "I wish the world wasn't that way" means "I wish we didn't live in a world where people could unprofitably pour money into a market to grab market share to kill off competitors." I don't see how you've come to that conclusion without asking him to clarify what he means. Everyone's down voting me like I'm an evil person. I'm just defending him because I think it's lazy to attack someone's point of view with the withering criticism of 'ironic', when the actual words on the page don't really support it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- elbigbad 11y agoI don't need to ask him to clarify because I can infer what he means from the context. I can't downvote things, but I don't think you're getting downvoted for your opinion or for anyone thinking you're evil, but my guess would be that it's perhaps for your unusually generous reading of the comment. It's pretty clearly ironic that Uber would complain about this.
- airza 11y agoI think everyone's downvoting you because any other explanation of the quote makes very little sense.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- thebrettd 11y agoI thought he was lamenting the fact that Uber has to compete with an unprofitable organization buying their market share. In an article about how his very own company is losing 1B a year to exist in that market. If that isn't irony, I don't know what is.
- untog 11y agoYeah, the hypocrisy contained in that statement is stunning. I wonder how the CEO of Lyft felt when they read it.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoMaximum Schedenfraude.
- blhack 11y agoHow is that hypocrisy? >We beat some people in some markets, but now we're being beaten in this market, I wish we weren't.
- mbesto 11y ago"I wish we weren't" != "I wish the world wasn't that way"
- Avshalom 11y ago"I wish the world wasn't that way" looks like its being applied to "unprofitable in every city they exist in, but they're buying up market share" not "We have a fierce competitor" as opposed to if he had said [I wish we didn't] or [I wish they didn't] making it about the "the world" pushes it into an ethical or moral opine.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- malsun 11y agoIt's not just some markets and some people. They're a VC backed multinational that moves into markets and offers big discounts over local businesses. They are getting a taste of their own medicine with an improved flavour.
- exw 11y ago<<Haha, really? Isn't that how Uber started out, and the quote could well be verbatim from a taxi driver in 2011?>> Yes, This this is completely disingenuous... They did not only start out like this in the US, but this is the ONLY way they were able to buy their way into China. When Uber started in China, their competitors had most of the chinese local drivers, and it was Uber who started the subsidy war to gain market share.
- capkutay 11y agoIt makes more sense when comparing two "mobile ride hailing" services. Uber actually started out as a black car service, significantly more expensive than taxis while providing a far superior experience.
- kolbe 11y agoExactly. If you have a phone handy, you should give a call to a waaahmbulace for that entitled twat.
- untilHellbanned 11y agoTheir brand redesign was the beginning of the end. This will accelerate the process. Their team has no clue what it is doing. You can downvote, but this will be a fact sooner than you might think.
- ardit33 11y agoAny data points on this? I mean real knowledge, not just "I don't like redesign so they must be failing".
- untilHellbanned 11y agoYes. Countless people including those on HN, relating stories of people they know not finding the app on their phones and then using a different service.
- acchow 11y agoanecdata
- VeilEm 11y agoOn HN every day brings some new event that completely changes everything forever and deserves all our attention and capacity for outrage. Don't you ever find this exhausting?
- acchow 11y agoHN enjoys drama and Silicon Valley is our stage.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- drchiu 11y agoI'm afraid this is a fight Uber won't win. I just can't see the Chinese internet giants letting an American company dominate this space. Call me jaded, but the world isn't so black and white, and I'm sure in the end Uber will concede to defeat after realizing their biggest competitor aren't playing by the same rules.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Call me jaded, but the world isn't so black and white, and I'm sure in the end Uber will concede to defeat after realizing their biggest competitor aren't playing by the same rules. Call me a jaded person, but Uber shall have learned a lesson. When they break the law, its distrupty, when someone else does it, its "unfair".
- icebraining 11y agoI don't see them calling it unfair. Obviously they don't like it, but that's not the same.
- jfoster 11y agoThat would seem to be the default outcome, based on experiences of other American companies in China. It still makes sense for Uber to fight for their place in China, though. The opportunity is too big to just concede defeat. Uber are also probably a bit more street smart than the other American internet companies that have previously failed to establish their place in China.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoAmerican tech companies didn't fail to dominate China because of naïveté, they failed because the Chinese Communist Party refuses to let any global tech company establish a sizable foothold when they can create their own Chinese version, especially when the Chinese version helps cement the Great Firewall and control the populace. This is not a contemporary trend, this is the consistent history of China. Baidu over Google; Alibaba over Amazon; Renren over Facebook and Twitter (both blocked in China). Only exception is Apple, but they mostly sell products instead of info (and is fashionable among the Chinese elite). But then, there's always Xiaomi...
- brentm 11y agoDoes anyone know the largest net loss a company has ever had for the year prior to an IPO? Uber must be 2 years max from going public and their losses seem to be accelerating[0]. [0] https://www.theinformation.com/ubers-losses-grow-but-so-do-its-profit-projections?shared=4d2098 https://www.theinformation.com/ubers-losses-grow-but-so-do-i...
- barkingcat 11y agoWhy does Uber need to be in China again? Why can't they be happy growing their service and providing better services (like better driver auditing and education) for the North American market? If they spent $1 Billion improving their service it's better than trying to outspend a natively innovating company in China backed by local people running under different rules.
- tim333 11y agoThe company that's losing $1bn/year, Uber China, appears to be a separate company just focused on China (valued at $8bn against Uber proper's $60 odd bn and Didi Kuaidi's $16.5bn) and so pretty much has to be in China. If that wasn't the case I could see the argument for just not bothering there.
- heydenberk 11y agoPresumably, the ROI on penetrating the world's largest market is significantly higher than the ROI on a marginal increase to their dominant market share in North America.
- mahyarm 11y agoVC backed companies have a built in promise of attempting global scope when they can. And it's for the same reason why you want visa everywhere. Even if everyone uses unionpay, the travellers want their visa cards to work.
- tim333 11y agoIt's quite a handy thing with Uber having just been in Saigon, Taipei, Manila and similar it was a pleasant surprise to find Uber just worked, avoiding having to research local taxi scams, trying to figure you've got change in local currency when you've just landed and so on.
- aetherson 11y agoI don't really know why you're being downvoted. Uber has to be in China because they raised $RIDICULOUS on a valuation of $MORERIDICULOUS. That valuation is premised on the idea that they will somehow be part of the fundamental physical infrastructure of the world, in a more-than-just-taxicab kind of way. Disclosure: I think that this is an absurd premise. But it's their ambition. So they have to eventually show solid steps on being more than just a taxi company for rich dense North American cities, because they claimed they were worth $MORERIDICULOUS. They have to pursue some more ambitious schemes. One of those is getting a dominant position in the market of the 1/7th of the world that is most rapidly growing in wealth.
- blizkreeg 11y agoI don't understand. Why not just focus on the rest of the world? It is, after all a big effin world. China has always been a different market. What's with this need to monopolize every corner of the world and lose a shiz ton of $ in the process?
- wrong_variable 11y agoIts not about the world - but who has the money. Ghanan kids prolly wont have the money to even afford Uber.
- blizkreeg 11y agoyou'd be surprised at the pace of growth of the economy in many African countries.
- grawlinson 11y agoChina is one of the biggest untapped markets in the world for just about any non-China company. No wonder they want a crack.
- cylinder 11y agoChina isn't a homogenous uniform market, those large market advantages arent present like in the US
- intopieces 11y agoThe photograph in the article is of an office for Uber in Hong Kong. Is there any reliable data available about how the company is doing there? Uber is ideal for places with inefficient public transportation; Hong Kong has easily one of the most efficient public transportation systems in the world. Subway, tram, light-bus and easy walkability make Uber seem redundant.
- tommoor 11y agoThere are still A LOT of taxis in Hong Kong though...
- intopieces 11y agoDoesn't that make the case for Uber even worse? Where Uber shines is being cheap and more available than the closed system of Taxis. With Taxis everywhere (and them being so cheap, I paid about HK$40 to get from the airport to Happy Valley) it seems like Uber wouldn't have a place in the market.
- tommoor 11y agoI would think you were right, but HK is similar to New York in that respect and Uber appears to be doing well there...
- melted 11y agoSo does Tokyo, yet there are still tons of cabs.
- frozenport 11y agoInefficient transport systems tend to affect the poor. For example, spending an hour commuting to work. Where this is a serious problem, for example India, some jobs even come with a chauffeur. Daily commutes are not Uber's market.
- josu 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxicabs_of_Hong_Kong https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxicabs_of_Hong_Kong
- jdlyga 11y agoUber is amazing in China. We used it all over Beijing
- nrser 11y agodon't race to the bottom as a foreign firm against locals in China. you won't win. they will go much lower and harder and longer than you will. they will turn the heat off in the -12C winter and have people coding in their parkas to save cash. i hung out with some of the Uber e-staff and founders when they were in China. i think the most memorable quote was "there's what works for every other country in the world and then there's China". i think they stood a chance if they had positioned themselves as an upscale service. foreign brands convey status. they could have had something there that the locals didn't. but that's not what they're doing everywhere else in the world, and i understand them not being willing to split their strategy for the market. so i guess they went with firepower. and i would guess they knew it had a low chance of success. entry into China is hard. that trail is lined with bodies, every drop of blood sucked dry. it's difficult understand until you see it for yourself. there are people arranging fake uber rides online to split the subsidies. but they had some idea. it's a big market and Uber has a lot of cash, but $1B is still a big bet with such bad odds.
- randycupertino 11y ago"Never get involved in a land war (or car service price war) in Asia."
- tosseraccount 11y agoDouglas Macarthur said this ... (or part of it) and then wound up fighting the Korean War ... which we won. So ... never say never, I guess.
- BrandTurner 11y agoThere seems to be a lot of people parroting that the CCP freezes out foreign firms by onerous Chinese regulations favoring local firms. That may be the case for a number of different situations. However, Didi Kauidi, China's ride-sharing service, may just be a better offering than Uber. Last year, it arranged 1.4 billions rides, more than Uber has done worldwide in its entire history. Also, Didi doesn't just focus on private-car services. It lets users pick a taxi, private car, shared car, shuttle van, or bus to pick them up. It also is tailored to the local market. During Chinese New Year, lots of flights and trains were sold out. Didi helped users find inter-city rides at train fare prices. It also has a few quirks that separate it from Uber. You can book a test drive of new cars (Audi and Mercedes included). And, Didi is also offering a Tinder-like matchmaking service for passengers. As a kid, I was getting it on in the back seat of my parent's Dodge. What a time to be alive.
- bby 11y agowait what? you got it on while you were riding in their car and they were driving it under didi?
- tonster 11y ago>And, Didi is also offering a Tinder-like matchmaking service for passengers. As a kid, I was getting it on in the back seat of my parent's Dodge. Wait, what?
- BrandTurner 11y agoDidi will soon allow drivers and passengers to select each other based on their shared interests. It already has a deal with LinkedIn, to let people join up their accounts on the two networks. The intention of such initiatives is that white-collar workers, who often endure daily commutes of an hour or two, will have more fruitful journeys during which business, friendship and maybe even romance will develop. - Per the Economist
- jsprogrammer 11y agoSo...you matched with your parents as your driver and found a sexual interest to carpool and play with? In a Dodge? (In China?)
- GigabyteCoin 11y agoAny firsthand accounts of Didi Kuaidi pricing from chinese HNers? I took a few cabs around shanghai in 2008 and was floored at how cheap their prices were. If Didi Kuaidi is undercutting taxi prices, and Uber is trying to undercut them... ridesharing must be almost free in major chinese cities at this point I'm assuming?
- mahyarm 11y agoGo move your uber app to various cities in the world, and you soon learn a 30 minute ride in a developing country costs about $3 in general.
- dingo_bat 11y agoMy Uber (pool) ride to office costs ~$1 in Bangalore. $3 as tip is not less.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoSo didi offers a couple of services: a taxi service, it just helps you hail a normal metered cab. I use that service every day, and it is no more expensive than doing it the old fashioned way...but during peak, I can input a tip (up to 20 kuai, or about $3), which helps me get a cab when I would otherwise not be able to. Call that "surge pricing" I guess. The black car service, my wife uses that more. I have trouble using it since I can't epay (no chinese ID number to link to my unionpay card). But the cars are nice, the prices are a bit higher than taxis but we often get coupons that bring the price down. Still nowhere near to the cost of a taxi in the west.
- pfarnsworth 11y agoHow does this compare to Uber?
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoI actually haven't used Uber in China. It isn't that big in Beijing, but I hear in places like Guangzhou it has much more of a presence. As far as I can tell, they have about the same cars working for them (they can take hails from both); I'm guessing the only difference is in the subsidy.
- mayneack 11y ago> "We're profitable in the USA, but we're losing over $1 billion a year in China," Uber CEO Travis Kalanick told Canadian technology platform Betakit. I didn't realize they were profitable here. When did this happen?
- jka 11y agoThere's a chance it's a carefully worded statement - perhaps they're profitable in specific places within the US?
- kagamine 11y agoI can't find the article where i read the numbers (it was on the Guardian news site) but Uber's reported loss for 2015 was in the billions, however, that included income also in the billions. The loss as others here have noted comes from growth and investment. If you segment their operations they appear to be profitable in some regions.
- iaw 11y agoLast funding raise was something like $2.1B. I suspected uber's burn rate was high but this implies that they're going to be hitting some hard liquidity issues within the next 18 months if they can't perpetually raise capital.
- javiercr 11y ago> "We have a fierce competitor that's unprofitable in every city they exist in, but they're buying up market share. I wish the world wasn't that way." (Uber's CEO) I'm sorry but... isn't this exactly what Uber has been doing to their competitors for a long time in most markets?
- n-exploit 11y agoIt's only unfair if it's someone else doing it.
- EGreg 11y agoThey didn't say it was unfair
- maratd 11y ago"I wish the world wasn't that way." = unfair
- hyperbovine 11y agoYou and your "facts"
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mhaymo 11y ago
- anon8418 11y agoHN commentators are missing the point. Uber's strategy is lifted straight from Groupons playbook: they're expanding aggressively internationally to drive home the message that "HEY LOOK WE'RE A GLOBAL PLAY. WE'RE IN 42 CITIES IN CHINA!" This will drive up the IPO value. By the time they get steamrolled by the local competitors or by the local regulators (likely both) they'll have sold off their shares to the dumb retail investor. The fact that the heads of Uber China and its main local competitor are literally family members is very telling....
- kagamine 11y ago> The fact that the heads of Uber China and its main local competitor are literally family members is very telling.... More on this please?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- zouhair 11y agoThe gall in that psychopath.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dang 11y agoPlease don't throw around the word 'psychopath' as a personal slur on HN. Personal attacks are not allowed here. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11129670 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11129670 and marked it off-topic.
- tomkat0789 11y agoI'm surprised (not that surprised) to hear there's ride sharing apps in China at all. I lived in Beijing for a few months several years ago and the taxis are (for a foreigner) pretty reasonable and efficient. Besides better public transport, taxis were everywhere, some were just motorized three wheeled motorbikes with a little chair on the back. Besides those, one night while getting a taxi to a bar, a random person stopped by and offered us a ride. My Chinese friends negotiated a pretty reasonable price to get across the city. The point is, I think ride sharing apps have much more competition in China/Asia. It's not just terrible bus systems and inefficient taxi services like in America.
- mikeash 11y agoTaxis are indeed cheap and plentiful, but the ride sharing services are somewhat cheaper and somewhat easier to hail. Plus, the customer base is so gigantic that there's room for many players. It's not like some US cities where Uber is displacing traditional taxi services that charge $400/mile to ride in a broken-down Chevy driven by an escaped axe murderer, but you don't necessarily need that much of an edge.
- patmcguire 11y agoTarget runs a store in Rogers, AR just to spite Walmart. http://www.reuters.com/article/us-walmart-target-idUSTRE73K6QA20110421 http://www.reuters.com/article/us-walmart-target-idUSTRE73K6...
- 50CNT 11y agoHonestly, I'm not surprised. 滴滴出行 is throwing a lot of money at buying people. I downloaded the app in case I can't get a cab in Beijing, and they keep bombarding me with "15RMB voucher", "50RMB voucher", "50RMB voucher", "25RMB voucher" just to get me to start using the app. Regular cabs are cheap and plentiful over here. I can go from here to Sanlitun for about 150RMB, which is about 30km. Within 4th ring road, flagging one down (outside of rush hour) is trivial. Public transportation is cheap as well (1RMB for a bus ride, 3-10RMB for a subway ride all over the city). That means that neither Uber nor Didi are competing on convenience, they're competing on price till they've got the market cornered. And every app over here does it. Wechat pay got themselves advertising spots during the New Years Festival Broadcast last year and has been offering discounts EVERYWHERE last November. McDonalds, Subway, Paris Baguette, literally everywhere. This year Alipay got to sponsor the New Years Festival Broadcast, so they're in catchup mode right now. Uber may have used the strategy first, but they're late to the party in China. As a foreign company in China, they should have positioned themselves as a premium provider. Look at what Apple did. It's a thing of beauty how obsessed Chinese people are over their iPhones. So how would Uber have gone about that? Offer premium rides first. Nice climate controlled cars with properly screened chauffeurs. Aim for the people that aren't quite able to afford a full-time driver. Didi can be nicer than cabs, but it's a little hit or miss sometimes. Remove that ambiguity. Open up an Uber store in Sanlitun. Does an Uber store make sense? No, but then a lot of things do not make any sense here in china, and they still work somehow. Nice modern store, a fancy car somewhere on display, and what would it sell? Gift rides and vouchers. Exploit the Chinese habit of giving gifts and regifting(you can buy fruit in boxes for Chinese new year, why not Uber rides in boxes?), and go wild with it. Wooden box with a red sleeve, containing a scale model of a car with minimal uber branding, some assorted status object and then a red envelope that folds open to reveal an Uber voucher in the X000RMB range, or some fancier rides you can't book through the app (eg. armoured cars/vintage cars/sports cars/helicopters/etc.). In a sense, Didi is already doing some of these. The point is, if you're trying to get into the Chinese market, don't get into mudfights with Chinese competitors. They'll fight dirty, and if you fight dirty, they'll fight dirtier. Apple didn't come out with a discount phone to beat Xiaomi (which btw, fights REALLY dirty. They sell to distributors ABOVE MRSP to cut their margins. the distributors have to put up with it). No, go premium, and come early. There's an entire part of the Chinese tech industry that calls itself C2C - Copy 2 China. The moment your startup hits techcrunch, there'll be a Chinese copy of it. That is a law of nature. It will happen to you. Uber should have known this before throwing down the gauntlet over here. It's not going to be a fun ride for 'em.