7 ms·
Google usually operates in high-margin industries. This is the opposite. I've had the "privilege" of working in this one. You're talking all kinds of players wo
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Google usually operates in high-margin industries. This is the opposite. I've had the "privilege" of working in this one. You're talking all kinds of players working against each other for perceived self-gain with individual companies constantly pushing costs down to the point their staff can barely break even. And Google intends to compete with that using something with higher cost?
Pretty crazy. I was unsurprised they'd use Costco and Whole Foods while targeting two areas that already pay too much for stuff. Love to see them try that in my area where people go for whatever costs the least most of the time. Lots of true premium services have gone out of business with what's left being those that approximate premium with right compromises to keep cost down. That's probably true across most of the States.
The biggest flaw in all this is what these companies keep ignoring: impulse buying. The big stores put what you need as far away from you as possible. Then, you have to exert physical effort to get to good deals while seeing, at arms reach, all kinds of profitable items. This is a hard to quantify, but big, chunk of grocery revenues. So, these companies doing online deliveries or personal shoppers have to make more money than the competition while leaving out one of most powerful techniques for making money.
Always operating at a disadvantage, there. So, we're not going to see such things proliferate. Those with the most capital, negotiating power with manufacturers, and proven techniques win here. Almost always.
- ISL 11y agoWhen I was laid up in bed with an injury and used Amazon Fresh for groceries, the impulse-buy was extremely powerful, and took a different form. Groceries would sometimes be delivered within hours, and plenty of pricey electronics and media could be had simultaneously. Prime now covers much of that draw. Speed is critical to capturing that impulse now.
- Outdoorsman 11y agoSo, maybe they're diversifying?...and maybe they're betting on being able to provide a more reliable service...? They certainly have a bit of capital to burn...
- nickpsecurity 11y agoCompanies in the grocery market have already gone bankrupt because they couldn't be competitive at billions in sales. I'd have either partnered with a strong company to invest in new stores with a profit cut plus discounted Google tech to make them competitive. Or straight up bought companies that produce things like salt, sugar, or key brands that fuel grocery sales. That's what the elites, esp Koch Brothers, are doing. It's recession-resistant, too.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Companies in the grocery market have already gone bankrupt because they couldn't be competitive at billions in sales. Google isn't entering the grocery market, its expanding its existing presence in the delivery market partnering with existing stores that are in the grocery market (some of which are already retail partners for Google Express, which has been around for a while for dry goods, and is just expanding to include fresh groceries.)
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThat's a good distinction to make.
- skewart 11y agoI suspect there's another reason they're doing this, and they don't actually think this will be a profitable business opportunity. Delivering groceries in 2016 is probably a strategic move in support of a larger effort that will pay off in 2019. Perhaps it's about gathering richer data on consumer preferences and behavior. Or maybe it will help them develop autonomous vehicles in some way (having already been operating a delivery service for a while might be helpful when they start rolling out new tech). Or maybe they're just throwing spaghetti at the wall to see if it sticks.
- tiglionabbit 11y agoWell they do have self-driving cars. Maybe this is the most impressive way to start delivering stuff with them?
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoYeah it seems reasonable to me that they take on the whole job in order to find where/if they might fit in to generate long-term profits. One might even conceive that they'd do it just to stir up the market and, like you say, see if anything sticks.
- Dwolb 11y agoYup this is it. Google's bleeding money on these initiatives to preserve its crown jewel: search. More and more people are using Amazon and other services first to find stuff they need - which means lower engagement with search and lower effectiveness of paid ads. If Google can build some of these services themselves it could potentially maintain its reputation as the first stop on the customer journey.
- _asummers 11y agoAs a slight anecdotal counterpoint to your comment about Amazon, while I often buy the product eventually from Amazon, I initially search "amazon $productname" on Google because I don't like Amazon's search.
- 11y ago
- Outdoorsman 11y agoThey're not selling groceries... They're selling convenience... The margin on convenience is what matters...
- derefr 11y agoIs Google Fiber a high-margin business? It seems like Google has this secondary set of strategies emerging, now, involving pushing various basic services into markets, steamrolling over whatever has been holding those services back, in order to "uplift" everyone in those markets into the sort of SV yuppies that Google makes most of their money from.
- michaelt 11y agoAnd Google intends to compete with that using something with higher cost? The UK already has at least one mass-market grocery delivery company that is profitable (albeit barely - a pre-tax profit of £11.9m on sales of £1,202.9m). The CEO, Tim Steiner, believes in the long term they can be more efficient than bricks-and-mortar retailers by having a few large, automated warehouses fulfilling orders for the entire country. This leads to better power efficiency (no need for things like open-front refrigerators retailers need) and reduced waste (trying to keep an item in stock in 3 warehouses results in less over- and under-ordering than trying to keep the same item in stock in 300 walk-in stores). There's a £40 minimum order, and a delivery charge (£0-£5 depending on time of day and day of week), but groceries themselves are price-matched to a major bricks-and-mortar retailer. Of course, to get great prices from suppliers you need a large enough market share to get economies of scale / negotiating leverage. And to get that market share you need reasonable prices. Mark up the items a lot or charge too much for delivery and you'll always be a niche competitor getting poor prices from your suppliers. (Disclosure: I work for them. And we're hiring! If you're near north London, or in Barcelona, check out https://careers.ocado.com/Search.aspx https://careers.ocado.com/Search.aspx )
- toomanybeersies 11y agoIt certainly does make sense if you're looking at places with expensive property, like London. A supermarket takes up a huge area, and usually in areas where land tends to be expensive. Nobody wants to go to a supermarket in the middle of nowhere. I think that's where online supermarkets are going to win out over conventional supermarkets. Personally, I prefer to go to supermarkets than shop online, even if it was cheaper, I'd still probably go to the supermarket, but that's usually because I decide what I want to cook for tea on the way home from work, so I'll stop by the supermarket and grab some stuff, I enjoy the experience.
- tfgg 11y ago> A supermarket takes up a huge area, and usually in areas where land tends to be expensive I think this is a particularly good point about their success, especially in London. In London, there aren't really many huge supermarkets (the closest one to me is about 5km away through dense built-up areas), and most people don't own cars. Hence, if you want to do a big shop, online delivery is pretty much the only way.
- dzhiurgis 11y agoIt works for Amazon though. They are obviously paving the way for self-driving cars and they start with self driving deliveries. Yes, impulse buying is big, but that is one of the reasons I do not like going shopping. It is a huge time waste to go thru all isles.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThat's like saying desktops work for Microsoft so BeOS or Linux have a major chance. ;) Ecosystem, partner deals, existing base for logistics, strong brand with consumers, massive revenue... all things Amazon has to make its grocery play more successful. Not to mention they're the leader in online retail. Google's effort looks more like how a startup would do it. No direct comparison here.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- JPKab 11y agoAgreed. Additionally, this decision by Google to jump into this game has now completely screwed a big project I was working on. How? I work with retail data on behalf of large companies, and companies like Walmart and Target don't want any of the point of sale or inventory feeds they provide to their suppliers hosted on cloud infrastructure owned by a competitor. In the past, this meant absolutely no Amazon options for cloud infrastructure. I was happily using Google Cloud. Now, thanks to this certainly ill-fated business decision to get into grocery delivery, I'm going to be forced to move my data to Azure. Thanks Google. I sure wish you would try to focus for once instead of latching on to every single niche you see small startups in. I feel sorry for Instacart on this one as well. They were just starting to hit profitability in a few cities.
- skyyler 11y agoSo Google should consult you before they take on a new product, just to make sure you're ok with it?
- rhino369 11y agoWell that would be the considerate thing to do.
- cubano 11y agoWhile it made me laugh, isn't snark like this often buried here on HN? Just wondering.
- JPKab 11y agoOf course not. I won't have a hard time moving my stuff, although I would have preferred to stay on Google. I was a bit pissed off when I wrote the original comment due to this unexpected twist. Obviously not their fault, but it sucks that the two most viable cloud providers are now both in the fucking retail world. Honestly, I love Google, and just wish they would TRY to focus a bit before branching out into anything and everything. My main gripe is that I don't think they will AT ALL succeed in grocery delivery. It's complicated and requires focus.
- amelius 11y ago> Google usually operates in high-margin industries. This is the opposite. Perhaps groceries are a great way to obtain valuable customer data?
- nickpsecurity 11y agoMaybe. Prevalence of collection and brokering means data on individual customers is pretty cheap AFAIK. Grocery infrastructure and deals aren't. If this is their goal, they'd be better off partnering with a major chain doing analysis for them in return for a copy of the data.
- nibs 11y agoIn Canada, our grocery stores are so competitive on price that most of the actual bottom line profit derives from fining suppliers for all kinds of things (products not selling through, mislabelling, late shipments, short orders, back orders, lack of responsiveness, food safety infractions). Even the impulse items are only marginally if at all profitable. I only know this because we make financial software for the industry. It is a strange byproduct of competition.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThat's really wild. Here in the U.S., the industry does a bit of that in terms of short orders. The rest I don't recall being big issues. Companies do whatever is good for business then use lawyers for the rest. ;)