7 ms·
What the diamond industry is really selling
- facepalm 11y agoWhat articles like this miss is that useless products like diamonds actually serve a real need: they enable signalling of commitment. Especially if it costs several months of income of a potential partner, it might be a reasonable indicator for a serious investment in the relationship. You can not achieve the same effect by buying something useful instead, because then the money would be spent on something useful, not on proving commitment. Not saying it is the only way to prove commitment, but "it's all just marketing" doesn't catch the whole story imo.
- lotsofpulp 11y agoGenerations before me, including my parents, didn't need to buy something worth a considerable portion of one's disposable income to display commitment. It's all about egos, and the feeling a woman gets about the ability of her partner to provide an expensive trinket, especially to show off to friends and display status. It's a terrible misuse of funds at the beginning of a couple's journey, one that could prove far more productive as an investment somewhere.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- facepalm 11y agoI am not advocating diamonds, just pointing out that they serve a need. Generations before us had a very different way of getting into relationships. Maybe our modern lifestyle made diamonds more important. I am also not saying that diamonds are unavoidable. Edit: somebody else posted a more educated comment. Prior to 1935, apparently women were entitled to compensation when an engagement was broken off - http://homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~siow/332/rings.pdf http://homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~siow/332/rings.pdf
- lotsofpulp 11y agoCompensation actually makes sense and is useful after receiving it. As diamonds are an extremely poor store of value, the only purpose it provides is a show of status, as far as I can deduce.
- nostrebored 11y agoBecause investing in something that's only useful to the two of you doesn't create a store of value in your relationship? Think of it as a sunk cost if you're a cynic, or literally a monetary non refundable deposit into your relationship otherwise.
- hueving 11y agoAre you advocating that women cannot care for themselves and we need to consider sexist traditions of men being forced to provide for them in the case of a failed engagement?
- tomp 11y ago> diamonds actually serve a real need: they enable signalling of commitment This statement is logically inconsistent with reality. If "signalling of commitment" was a real need, why would only one party need to provide this signal? And not just one party (random), but a specific party (predetermined) - the man. You're right, however, that in the broader context, diamonds are an honest signal of affluence - by buying expensive, but useless stuff (conspicuous consumption) we send a strong signal about how much we can afford and how rich(-er) we are.
- hammock 11y agoWhy does the male peacock have a colorful tail and the female doesn't?
- tomp 11y agoI mean, if we're reducing people to animals, we might as well ask, why does a new alpha male kill offspring of previous alpha males? In the past, women had to have a dowry to get married. There was probably a reason for that (economic or market reason, I guess). It probably wasn't a very good reason, and likely isn't very relevant today.
- infinite8s 11y agoDowries are still required in many cultures today, particularly rural ones.
- facepalm 11y agoWhat makes you think it wasn't a very good reason? I think most problems of that kind boil down to economic issues. In some cases traditions might live longer than necessary (original reason has ceased to exist), which is another problem.
- tomp 11y ago> I think most problems of that kind boil down to economic issues. Probably, yes. But whatever "economic" reasons there are, the cultural reasons were probably much more powerful. Maybe men were more scarce in the past than women. Wars might have accounted for that, but on the other hand, men have longer "expiration date" (when it comes to mating). Also, if men were so much rarer, why didn't polygamy develop? You could claim that women are weaker, so they were less "useful" in the past (when most labor was manual) and hence less valuable. On the other hand, without a woman, there would be no next generation, so each man needed a woman to ensure his survival in old age. These are the most obvious justifications I could come up with, and they don't sound very convincing. Let me know if you can think of any more.
- teekert 11y agoYou could invest it in a house together? Or a savings account for your children?
- NEDM64 11y agoWhile I 100% agree with your pragmatic view. It's bad that these commitment indicators are used to finance conflicts.
- rpgmaker 11y agoThe diamond obsession in the US doesn't seem very healthy though.
- dyeje 11y agoBut it is all just marketing. Before 1938 no one cared about diamonds, and people were able to show commitment just fine. If I'm not mistaken, the divorce rate was also significantly lower.
- facepalm 11y agoHooking up might have worked very differently in 1938, though. I don't think relationships and marriage were the same as today. Maybe because we have more freedom in our relationships now, we need diamonds. As an extreme case, take a culture were arranged marriages are the norm. Then it seems obvious that you wouldn't need diamonds because you wouldn't have much of a choice to not commit to the relationship anyway. I don't know enough about 1938 to make a proper comparison, though. Edit: somebody else posted a more educated comment. Prior to 1935, apparently women were entitled to compensation when an engagement was broken off - http://homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~siow/332/rings.pdf http://homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~siow/332/rings.pdf
- BostonEnginerd 11y agoThe divorce rate was likely lower for many reasons not involving diamonds.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoMarriages may have ended at a faster rate, but due to greater mortality, maybe?
- lmm 11y agoIsn't the argument the opposite direction? Before 1938 the divorce rate was significantly lower, so no-one needed to show commitment and no-one cared about diamonds.
- msvan 11y ago(Meta: This comment is not inflammatory, poorly written or gratuitously negative. Disagreement ≠ downvote)
- enlightenedfool 11y agoYou seem to be the dream consumer for their marketers :-)
- mcv 11y agoI've got a wedding tattoo. That's more permanent than any ring, and a better proof of commitment, at much less cost. Though the best proof of commitment would be to invest in and provide for a common future. Buy a house, take care of kids, etc. That's real commitment, not just some hollow symbol at extravagant cost. But if you do want extravagant expense as proof of your commitment, you could also spend it on the wedding itself. Why not go for a $10K wedding instead of a $10K ring?
- dangerpowpow 11y agowhat brilliant marketing then
- jgalt212 11y agogreat further reading, from The Atlantic Monthly (1982) http://www.theatlantic.com/past/issues/82feb/8202diamond1.htm http://www.theatlantic.com/past/issues/82feb/8202diamond1.ht...
- iolothebard 11y agoFirst wife got an amazing diamond/platinum ring (and wedding band). Second wife got a Claddagh ring which cost ~500x less. Whatever makes them happy :-)
- bluedevil2k 11y agoThe diamond industry has a long history of marketing its goods that continues even today. 20 years ago, an engagement ring was 1 solitaire diamond. Now, it's much more common to buy a ring with 1 big diamond, 2 smaller ones on the side, and small diamonds around the ring. That's from marketing (and the lower cutting costs). 7 years ago, black diamonds were ground up and used on drill bits and saws, now they're sold in the US as "chocolate diamonds" for a nice premium. The diamond industry laughs at consumers in the US for that one. You can see it in the last 2 months as well - there's a big marketing blitz in the US right now that you need to buy a 2 diamond ring for your woman, one to symbolize love, the other to symbolize being a best friend. So I guess 1 is no longer enough. Each culture, naturally, responds to marketing in different ways. In the US, the marketing push has been to measure love by the size of the diamond. In Japan, it's measured by the color/clarity of the diamond. In the US, 2 months salary is the "rule". In Japan, it's 3 months salary.
- JumpCrisscross 11y ago> 20 years ago, an engagement ring was 1 solitaire diamond. Now, it's much more common to buy a ring with 1 big diamond, 2 smaller ones on the side, and small diamonds around the ring My favorite article on the diamond business is this 1982 print from The Atlantic, "Have You Ever Tried to Sell A Diamond?" [1]. I excerpted two relevant passages below. "The diamond market had to be further restructured in the mid-1960s to accomodate a surfeit of minute diamonds, which De Beers undertook to market for the Soviets. They had discovered diamond mines in Siberia, after intensive exploration, in the late 1950s: De Beers and its allies no longer controlled the diamond supply, and realized that open competition with the Soviets would inevitably lead, as Harry Oppenheimer gingerly put it, to 'price fluctuations,' which would weaken the carefully cultivated confidence of the public in the value of diamonds. Oppenheimer, assuming that neither party could afford risking the destruction of the diamond invention, offered the Soviets a straightforward deal -- 'a single channel' for controlling the world supply of diamonds. In accepting this arrangement, the Soviets became partners in the cartel, and co-protectors of the diamond invention. Almost all of the Soviet diamonds were under half a carat in their uncut form, and there was no ready retail outlet for millions of such tiny diamonds. When it made its secret deal with the Soviet Union, De Beers had expected production from the Siberian mines to decrease gradually. Instead, production accelerated at an incredible pace, and De Beers was forced to reconsider its sales strategy. De Beers ordered N. W. Ayer to reverse one of its themes: women were no longer to be led to equate the status and emotional commitment to an engagement with the sheer size of the diamond. A 'strategy for small diamond sales' was outlined, stressing the 'importance of quality, color and cut' over size. Pictures of 'one quarter carat' rings would replace pictures of 'up to 2 carat' rings. Moreover, the advertising agency began in its international campaign to 'illustrate gems as small as one-tenth of a carat and give them the same emotional importance as larger stones.' The news releases also made clear that women should think of diamonds, regardless of size, as objects of perfection: a small diamond could be as perfect as a large diamond. ... As American consumers became accustomed to the idea of buying smaller diamonds, they began to perceive larger diamonds as ostentatious. By the mid-1970s, the advertising campaign for smaller diamonds was beginning to seem too successful." http://www.theatlantic.com/past/issues/82feb/8202diamond1.htm http://www.theatlantic.com/past/issues/82feb/8202diamond1.ht...
- mseebach 11y agoHere's an alternative (and actually academic) look at it. http://homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~siow/332/rings.pdf http://homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~siow/332/rings.pdf TL;DR, the data doesn't back up the advertising thesis.
- RodericDay 11y agoDude, come on. That's from George Mason University- basically a libertarian think-tank.
- pionar 11y agoI wouldn't exactly call the author a libertarian mouthpiece[0]. But I wouldn't call her an economist, either. However, if this was truly a libertarian talking point, I would posit that libertarians would see the topic "Diamonds are expensive because of marketing, not inherent value." and think, "So what?" That's the free market. If the diamond has no value to you, don't buy the diamond. It's not a necessity. Note that I'm not an economist and definitely not a libertarian. 0 - http://law.nd.edu/directory/margaret-brinig/ http://law.nd.edu/directory/margaret-brinig/
- pionar 11y agoThe change in demand for diamond engagement rings may therefore be explained by an increase in need for such a bond because of the abolition of a cause of action for breach of marriage promise. My guess, having apparently found a reason for the change in demand for diamond engagement rings, is that many other mysterious demand changes could be accounted for as well, given some though as to what the commodity might mean to consumers and some exploration of the legal or other changes of the time during which the demand change occurred. Interesting, indeed. Thanks for the read!
- mcv 11y agoIs this something that units the US, Japan and China, and distinguishes them from Europe? I have my doubts. Also, I don't understand the supposed logic behind a change in marriage law and a rising demand for diamonds.
- billpg 11y agobzzz Evil.
- SeanDav 11y agoHaving recognized the fact that scarcity and value of diamonds are almost completely company made constructs, I did not get my wife an engagement ring, but I did get her a beautiful wedding ring (non-diamond of course). Having a close mechanical engineering friend involved in the business of artificial diamond manufacturing, helped make the decision easier as well. The money saved by this and by having a small wedding, made putting together a deposit for a house, far easier.
- mcv 11y agoYour wife is lucky to have you. You can't live in a diamond ring. Surely a man who makes sound financial decisions should be far more attractive than one who falls for silly marketing tricks?
- spacehome 11y agoStereotypically, it's the woman, not the man, who falls for the silly marketing trick.
- dghughes 11y agoOur ancestors were drawn to diamonds and gold obviously because of their sparkle but also their immutable nature; no rust or decay. But this modern spurn of diamonds reminds me of people who say "I'm a vegan", "I do Crossfit", "I don't own a TV" if you don't like diamonds don't get one.
- rayiner 11y agoThe article spins a yarn about DeBeers single-handedly inventing the tradition of giving expensive engagement gifts, but stumbles when it gets to talking about India, where it has to clumsily avoid mentioning that Indians have been spending huge amounts of resources on (gold) jewelry for marriages since time immemorial. I find a lot of anti-diamond talk hypocritical. Folks who will drop a ton of money on a fast car that spends 99.9% of its life sitting in traffic suddenly becoming ascetics when talking about buying diamond jewelry.
- lotsofpulp 11y agoCompared to diamonds, gold is a very good store of value, especially when paper currency and governments aren't reliable, as it was in relatively recent Indian history.
- rayiner 11y agoIf that was the justification, people would be giving gold bars, not gold jewelry.
- S_A_P 11y agoI initially came here to disagree. My argument was that if someone was going to give something "pretty and shiny" to someone, at least gold holds its value second hand over diamonds. However, I think of the Cash4Gold type scams out there and cant help but think that selling jewelry of any type second hand is going to get you screwed.
- ConroyBumpus 11y agoDepending on the legal system that one finds oneself subject to, jewelry is often considered a "personal effect" rather than an asset to be seized, such as gold bars, coins, or currency - and is therefore not subject to forfeiture.
- thewarrior 11y agoI'm from India and let me tell you that gold jewellery is primarily viewed as a store of value and not as a romantic gesture. Buying gold is the main way that Indians save.
- Loic 11y agoThis post is basically a rewrite of this one from 2013: http://priceonomics.com/post/45768546804/diamonds-are-bullshit http://priceonomics.com/post/45768546804/diamonds-are-bullsh... They could have linked to it I suppose.
- jkraker 11y agoThe saddest part of the article for me was the ad--"you can't look at Jane and tell me she's not worth 2 months' salary". There's so much wrong with that statement. The worst part is that a lot of people buy into it to some extent.
- shasta 11y agoSomeone should sell an investment-backed artificial diamond ring. So, for example, you could take a $500 ring and back it with a $10K investment that's tied to the ring. The only reason anyone buys a real diamond ring is to avoid the embarrassment of a cheap ring - on the part of the guy giving it or the woman showing it to her friends. Being able to talk about it as a "$10K ring" would go a long way to making it less embarrassing.
- softawre 11y agoI like the way you think.
- mcv 11y agoGood idea. A ring that's still worth something after purchase would be a much more sensible than a ring with a piece of carbon that can't be sold. But personally I don't see why anyone would care about a $10k ring. Different cultures, I suppose.
- SerisCo 11y agoThat's a great original idea, but it's still predicated on the assumption that more money = more love, that the purpose of the ring is to impress others, and that there's reason to be ashamed of a $500 ring. It's sad that American culture assumes that the man who spends $10K on a ring loves his fiancée more than the man who spends $500. Several companies that produce diamond alternatives, such as lab-grown diamonds and silicon carbide stones, are growing and rapidly expanding their product lines. I think the reason for this is that people are questioning the wisdom of spending a ton of money because marketing campaign have told them they must if they love their partners.
- rayiner 11y ago> It's sad that American culture assumes that the man who spends $10K on a ring loves his fiancée more than the man who spends $500. That presupposes that marriage is solely about love, which is itself an odd and mostly western concept. Marriage is, just as much, an economic arrangement in which people make often very significant sacrifices in order to create a household and potentially raise and support children. It necessarily entails a significant commitment on both sides, including the commitment to stick with each other in the case of hardship or sickness. When you account for that aspect of marriage, it makes total sense to require some showing of financial wherewithal.
- mcv 11y agoInteresting how the article focuses on the diamond engagement ring market in the US, Japan and China, but doesn't mention Europe. As far as I'm aware, very few people use diamond engagement rings here. If engagement comes with a ring at all, it's generally the future wedding ring, which is traditionally plain gold. The idea that people are willing to spend 2 months' salary on a ring is beyond ludicrous to me.
- eximius 11y agoOh, oh, I know this one! Tiny, hard rocks?