12 ms·
Unsafe Lead Levels in Tap Water Not Limited to Flint
- staunch 11y agoAncient Romans knew that lead water pipes were unhealthy and so they preferred terracotta pipes. It's hard to imagine why the U.S. ever had a single lead water pipe, let alone huge numbers of them. Updated with a reference for the downvoters: Sheets of lead were used to line Roman aqueducts (as was cement) and lead pipes to convey water. But lead also was known to be unwholesome and, for that reason, pipes made of clay were preferred—as Vitruvius, who wrote during the time of Augustus, explains. "Water conducted through earthen pipes is more wholesome than that through lead; indeed that conveyed in lead must be injurious, because from it white lead [ceruse or lead carbonate, PbCO3] is obtained, and this is said to be injurious to the human system. Hence, if what is generated from it is pernicious, there can be no doubt that itself cannot be a wholesome body. This may be verified by observing the workers in lead, who are of a pallid colour; for in casting lead, the fumes from it fixing on the different members, and daily burning them, destroy the vigour of the blood; water should therefore on no account be conducted in leaden pipes if we are desirous that it should be wholesome. That the flavour of that conveyed in earthen pipes is better, is shewn at our daily meals, for all those whose tables are furnished with silver vessels, nevertheless use those made of earth, from the purity of the flavour being preserved in them" (VIII.6.10-11). http://penelope.uchicago.edu/~grout/encyclopaedia_romana/wine/leadpoisoning.html http://penelope.uchicago.edu/~grout/encyclopaedia_romana/win...
- detaro 11y ago>Ancient Romans knew that lead water pipes were unhealthy and so they preferred terracotta pipes. Do you have a source for this? At the same time, they used lead acetate to sweeten wine and food, which is way more dangerous. If they made the weaker connection between health and water pipes, they should have been able to connect health and this as well.
- USAnum1 11y agoNot only that, up to the late 20th century many products other than pipes contained lead. Lead paint, leaded gasoline, etc. The jury was out on lead in everyday use until quite recently. I doubt the poisonous nature of lead was well known when these cities were built.
- maxerickson 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead_paint#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead_paint#History
- USAnum1 11y agoMost homes built before 1960 contain heavily leaded paint[0]. My assertion isn't that lead wasn't believed to be dangerous, rather that no one saw it as "seriously" dangerous. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead-based_paint_in_the_United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead-based_paint_in_the_Unit...
- roywiggins 11y agoFrom the above wikipedia entry: > In the July 1904 edition of its monthly publication, Sherwin-Williams reported the dangers of paint containing lead, noting that a French expert had deemed lead paint "poisonous in a large degree, both for the workmen and for the inhabitants of a house painted with lead colors." "Poisonous in a large degree" seems pretty serious to me. People were regularly dropping dead due to lead poisoning in factories by the turn of the century, and it looks like lead was recognized as being capable of doing significant, though hard-to-recognize, harm: "Although plumbism is usually easy to diagnose, lead occasionally induces obscure affections of the nervous system, the cause and true nature of which are not always easily recognized. As a cause of poverty, too, its influence is not sufficiently known nor the role it may be playing in the physical degeneracy of the race." https://books.google.com/books?id=gQY9AAAAYAAJ&lpg=PA29&ots=OxI1XdfNZq https://books.google.com/books?id=gQY9AAAAYAAJ&lpg=PA29&ots=... Lead paint looks to have been largely banned in Europe in favor of zinc-based paint by 1911; it was clearly viewed as a public health threat, not least by housepainters themselves, who were dying of lead poisoning (see the table on page 25).
- DamnYuppie 11y agoIt is also most likely that terracotta pipes were easier and cheaper to manufacture then lead pipes.
- uptown 11y agoTerra cotta pipes are way more susceptible to breakage and penetration from things like tree roots.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y agoAnd broken easier and required to be replaced. So I doubt that they would have preferred it without reason.
- DamnYuppie 11y agoAnd your are implying that decreased cost and ease of manufacturing aren't viable reasons??
- voltagex_ 11y agoDoubtful: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/23o92d/on_cosmos_neil_degrassetyson_said_some_historians/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/23o92d/on_co...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- the_mitsuhiko 11y agoThat one specifically mentions that the Romans knew about problems with lead?
- voltagex_ 11y agoOops! Thanks. Can't edit my original comment. Oh well.
- manachar 11y agoMost houses in the U.S. built prior to a few decades ago have lead paint and many have asbestos. Then there's the whole leaded gasoline fiasco. The world has known of the danger of lead and many other dangerous substances, but often still chooses to use the dangerous substance. Sometimes it's because there weren't alternative substances that could do what needed to be done. Sometimes it was just a matter of expense. Sometimes it's because the dangerous substance was supposed to be used in a safe fashion, however reality proved the safe fashion to be overly optimistic. Course, then there are cases like the leaded gasoline that should be considered one of the greatest crimes of all time.
- colin_mccabe 11y agoCourse, then there are cases like the leaded gasoline that should be considered one of the greatest crimes of all time. Yep, and it's still going on. Some small planes still use leaded fuels. http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/121-a54/ http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/121-a54/
- paulmd 11y agoYep, most of the small piston-engine aircraft are designed to run on 100-octane fuel. The only practical way to get the octane that high is leaded gasoline. However, the lead levels are lower than they used to be (avgas is typically 100LL for "low-lead"). Also, general aviation only consumes about 0.1% of the transportation fuel supply, so we're talking about a minuscule fraction of the fuel consumed. More modern aircraft can often get by with 94-octane premium unleaded. However, they cannot tolerate ethanol in their fuel, and due to congressional mandates for ethanol blends it's become increasingly difficult and expensive to source ethanol-free premium gasoline. Paradoxically, this pushes general aviation back to 100LL, which can easily be sourced without ethanol. Modern aircraft also have a trend towards diesel engines (often adapted from automotive diesels) that can be run on Jet A-1 fuel. These are actually very promising because they have good performance-to-fuel economy. See the Diamond DA62 for an example. http://www.gami.com/g100ul/avgas0211.pdf http://www.gami.com/g100ul/avgas0211.pdf http://www.aci-na.org/static/entransit/smallairports2011conf/WDerosier.pdf http://www.aci-na.org/static/entransit/smallairports2011conf... The root problem is that the general aviation fleet turns over incredibly slowly due to intensive maintenance requirements imposed by the FAA (eg annual total overhauls). It's pretty normal for your average single-engine aircraft to reach a lifespan of 40-50 years, and there's still plenty of aircraft that are pushing 70 or 80 years old. As such it's very difficult to achieve a phase-out of a fuel type within timeframes that people consider reasonable. Like I said, the shift towards 94-octane premium unleaded and diesels is already happening, but it will probably take another 20-30 years for the fleet to naturally rotate to engines that support alternative fuels. FAA oversight requirements (parts sourcing and mechanic labor) make everything airplane-related insanely expensive. You could mandate engine replacements, but this would be so expensive it would basically total 50% of the general-aviation fleet in an instant. At the end of the day we're talking about <0.1% of the transportation fuel supply so it's just not that big a deal.
- sdk77 11y ago>It's hard to imagine why the U.S. ever had a single lead water pipe, let alone huge numbers of them. I always supposed that that's where the word 'plumber' came from, or 'loodgieter' (lead caster, Dutch). Both words strongly refer to lead. Growing up in Holland in the early 80's our house had lead pipes. When I bought my first house in 2003 it too still had a lead water main. I drank a lot of that water, tap water over here has the same purity (basically actually is the same) as mineral water, with no side effects.
- tarsinge 11y agoJust noticed that in french lead is "plomb" and plumber is "plombier"
- rangibaby 11y agoThat's from Latin, which is why the periodic table symbol for lead is Pb.
- crottypeter 11y agoWhether or not the lead gets dissolved in the water depends on the water itself. If you have hard water lead pipes are low risk.
- gozur88 11y agoYes. Lead pipes in Flint weren't a problem until the city switched from Detroit municipal water to the corrosive Flint river water.
- mirimir 11y ago> It's hard to imagine why the U.S. ever had a single lead water pipe, let alone huge numbers of them. Lead has some advantages. Its melting point is low, so it's easy to weld. It doesn't corrode quickly, so pipes last a long time. And it's malleable, so pipes don't break when soil and foundation shift. But yes, it's very poisonous, so the advantages are moot for drinking water. For corrosive waste plumbing, on the other hand, it can be a good choice. It even tolerates HF, which glass doesn't. Glass is sexier, however.
- dmm 11y agoNassim Taleb taught me that the absence of known danger is not the same as safety. Repeat that to yourself the next time you read your cities water report. It's not "I know my water is safe" it's "I know I don't face these specific dangers. What else could be in the water that they don't test for?" Look into reverse osmosis.
- overcast 11y agoDrinking distilled water is not a good idea, which is basically what reverse osmosis gives you stripping out essential minerals. It's also an incredibly wasteful 4:1 process. Look into three stage filtering, that's all you need.
- lzlarryli 11y agoThat does not help with hard water, which I found is a big problem in midwest. RO is more or less the only reasonably cheap way to reduce TDS.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoSoftening water with sodium or potassium also works (to resolve hard water). Its an ion exchange process.
- davideous 11y agoWe have an reverse osmosis unit that has a "remineralizer," which adds back in minerals. It's basically a filter canister with minerals in it, which mineral-free RO water dissolves.
- ohthanks 11y agoCarbon filtration will not remove dissolved solids (lead, heavy metals) without added ion-exchange resins. RO is generally the most effective broad spectrum treatment method for drinking water. The mineral issue is pretty much bunk, if the lack of trace minerals in your water is a concern you need to see a doctor. Food is your body's preferred source of minerals, you have to drink a lot to have much effect on your daily mineral intake. The waste water is real, 4 to 1 is about average, it can be improved but it's pretty unavoidable in the process. They are water using appliances, we use 20-40 gallons of water to wash a load of clothes and most people don't think twice about it.
- voltagex_ 11y agoIf I travel to the US (Let's say Los Angeles, Seattle and New York) how do I know if the tap water is safe to drink? In the EU I normally just ask a local. In Germany it's safe to drink but in the Czech Republic you might be better off drinking bottled water (last time I checked was ~10 years ago, sorry if it's changed).
- toomuchtodo 11y agohttp://ofmpub.epa.gov/apex/safewater/f?p=136:102::::: http://ofmpub.epa.gov/apex/safewater/f?p=136:102::::::
- e40 11y agoIt seems to be broken. Every city I enter gives me no results.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoNot every city makes their reports available. Might need a FOIA request to get it.
- nommm-nommm 11y agoThe safe drinking water act requires water supplies to not only create reports but also distribute them to their customers. My water company mails them out, thats probably par for the course. Putting them online might be optional, but they have to distribute them to their customers.
- akg_67 11y agoDefault to not drinking from taps directly. I live in Seattle. We only use tap water after filtering with a Brita Filter for drinking and cooking. When we are outside home, we either bring filtered water with us or buy bottled water. At restaurants, if in doubt we ask if water is directly from tap. Since the flint lead news, I have been exploring how can I get my tap water tested on a routine.
- mc32 11y agoIf it's a wider problem than just Flint, why isn't it being presented as such by and large in the media and by politicians? Is it because that's where the political shenanigans were caught first, when will it get addressed as the more wide-spread problem it appears to be? Or is it more like an opportunist PR stunt [i.e. "we care a lot about..."] or the issue du jour which they'll abandon after they "address" Flint?
- minikites 11y agoFlint was 100% avoidable and motivated by greed.
- fennecfoxen 11y ago100% avoidable, yes. Motivated by greed? No, by indifference. No decision-maker here made a decision about the water supply in order to make money off of it.
- minikites 11y agoWhat? Money was literally the reason: http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/01/what-did-the-governor-know-about-flints-water-and-when-did-he-know-it/423342 http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/01/what-did... > To save money, the city began drawing its water from the Flint River, rather than from Detroit’s system, which was deemed too costly. But the river’s water was high in salt, which helped corrode Flint’s aging pipes, leaching lead into the water supply.
- fennecfoxen 11y agoMoney being the reason and greed being the reason are two different things. The $5 million in question would have never benefited the decision-makers who elected to make the switchover to river water. They were attempting to be thrifty with money that belonged to the city, which is just doing their jobs (badly).
- alanwatts 11y ago
- tn13 11y agoYou can cheap water testing kits on amazon which you can use. Also not water is 100% safe and it makes a lot of sense to diversify the water sources. We use tap water for cooking, bottled water from different brands at home and workplace. That probably is good enough. I have tested water at home for lead and pesticides and found it to be safe to drink. [Sunnyvale]
- colin_mccabe 11y agoIt used to be that we got all Hetch Hetchy water in the south bay. Since the California drought hit, they have started getting creative with where they pull water from. Some homebrewers that I talk to say that the water chemistry changes periodically, even over the course of a week. It matters for homebrewing because things like the calcium salts present in the water can change the pH of the wort. So I wouldn't assume that just because you tested the water once, that you know what it will always be like.
- maxxxxx 11y agoDo you have an amazon link for one of those?
- tn13 11y agohttp://www.amazon.com/First-Alert-WT1-Drinking-Water/dp/B000FBMAVQ/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&qid=1455081237&sr=8-3&keywords=lead+testing+kit http://www.amazon.com/First-Alert-WT1-Drinking-Water/dp/B000...
- such_a_casual 11y agoGoogle says 45% of bottled water is just tap water. I will never understand this phenomena.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y agoOne of the problems is water pipes which are largely untested. Soneven if you drink the same water, bottled water might still be safer. In theory. Practically I doubt it matters for most people.
- kevindeasis 11y agoMy hardware guy and I are building fun weekend projects. What raspberry pi sensors can you use to figure out if our water is polluted, etc. It should be noticeable, I'm just asking for basic testing. Nothing too crazy.
- fennecfoxen 11y agoYou're thinking inside a rather small box here with the Raspberry Pi angle. Usually detecting harmful chemicals dissolved in water involves running some chemical reactions that consume their reagents, not just some reusable electronics. There's a reason the kits are like this, instead of an electronic device: http://www.amazon.com/First-Alert-WT1-Drinking-Water/dp/B000FBMAVQ/ http://www.amazon.com/First-Alert-WT1-Drinking-Water/dp/B000...