3 ms·
Well, At best, this is an argument for postponing layoffs at long as practical. If you in a declining industry, for example, layoffs are inevitable. Indeed, t
by joe_the_user 17y ago
Well,
At best, this is an argument for postponing layoffs at long as practical. If you in a declining industry, for example, layoffs are inevitable.
Indeed, the goal of keeping as many employees as possible is nice but if it causes the entire corporation to go bankrupt, you haven't avoid layoffs.
It seems like the best policy for an organization would be maximum honesty, minimum practical layoffs and giving all employee a shot at switching positions within the organization.
But these generalization really are hard. Intel has profited while laying-off people through continuous internal competition. It could be brutal but it worked for keeping the company profitable.
- _delirium 17y agoSome can be avoided by not doing cyclic shedding/adding of workers. The justification for layoffs in a downturn followed by hires in an upturn is that it cuts costs: if you fire someone today and then hire someone else two years from now when things pick up, you've saved two years of salary/benefits over just keeping them on payroll through the downturn. I see this article as providing an argument that maybe saving that two years of salary isn't worth it. (There are other problems in that particular case, like companies that follow that hiring/layoff model always being a step behind in recoveries--- they're never well placed to catch booms early, because they spend the first year desperately scrambling to hire talent instead.)
- Mz 17y agoif you fire someone today and then hire someone else two years from now when things pick up, you've saved two years of salary/benefits over just keeping them on payroll through the downturn. The problem with that thinking is that there are costs involved in laying someone off and hiring anew two years later. And you have paid those costs to get no productivity out of them. I read an article some years ago that indicated that one company which paid top salaries for its industry saved money by doing so because they spent so much less on the hiring process and on training, and also because of general quality of work and customer satisfaction, because their employees tended to stick around. I have also read that one company/industry which laid people off suffered 10 years down the road when they found they had no one in the pipeline to fill managerial positions as they came open. So the (potential) costs involved here are not just the salary involved.
- joe_the_user 17y agoThe problem with that thinking is that there are costs involved in laying someone off and hiring anew two years later. And you have paid those costs to get no productivity out of them. Uh, suppose that when you originally fired the person, you simply didn't have the money to pay their salary? At that point, there is no thinking involved, just a decision that's forced on you. And like a lot of desperation cost-cutting, it might indeed cost you more money in the long run. But saving that long-run money won't help if you can't pay rent and buy food next month. I read an article some years ago that indicated that one company which paid top salaries for its industry saved money by doing so because they spent so much less on the hiring process and on training, and also because of general quality of work and customer satisfaction, because their employees tended to stick around. That is if a company is in a niche producing items which haven't simply become commodities.
- jimbokun 17y ago"If you in a declining industry, for example, layoffs are inevitable." In other words, layoffs are often an indicator of a failing company, so it's no wonder that layoffs do not lead to an increasing stock price.