23 ms·
A house that costs $20k
- avelis 11y agoIt's fascinating to see innovation in this space. I am also curious to see how the mortgage and realtor industry responds to this type of demand in the future.
- SwellJoe 11y agoAs noted in the article, the current mortgage situation isn't good at all. I wanted to buy land a couple of years ago, to build a tiny house on. I went in willing/able to put a 30-40% down payment on the property, with plans to build my own tiny house completely self-funded over the next year or so. The banks were simply not at all equipped to address that. Despite my excellent credit (high 700s) and low debt, and the cash to make the down payment and good income, they made it clear that I would be able to get a loan on a regular sized house with much less money down, but would not be able to get a loan on just a piece of land with plans to put a tiny house on it. They were also willing to talk about loaning money for the land, if I could show how I was going to afford to build a "regular" house on the property (requiring going through a builder and getting a loan on the future house). In short, the was no way, short of paying for the property entirely out of pocket I would be able to buy land and build my own tiny house on it. It was incredibly frustrating. I mean, I'm talking to these folks and they are, with a straight face, saying, "Well, as a first time home buyer, you could put 5%-15% down and buy a house, with the bank loaning you the other ~$160,000." And, I'd say, "OK, but what if I put $25,000 down, and only borrow $50,000 from the bank, and buy a piece of land, and over the next year I build myself a house on that land." And, they'd reply, "That's just not gonna happen." So, several banks would have been happy to loan me $160k with $16k down on a full-sized house, but no one was willing to loan me $50k with $25k down on land for a tiny house. I gave up on buying at that time. Will save up and pay cash for a plot of land in another year or two, and build my tiny house then. I doubt it will change any time soon. Home builders have no motivation to build smaller, banks have no interest in betting on self-built homes. Which is understandable to some degree...but, the sheer hardheadedness of the response was really surprising, to me. I'd always assumed I would have no trouble getting whatever kind of loan I wanted, as long as I brought enough cash to the table. But, for land-only deals, many banks want to see 50% or more down payment, which is silly. So, tiny houses remain mostly the privilege of those wealthy enough to afford to buy land without a mortgage, or those who don't mind living in places where land is very, very cheap. It's also possible to park a tiny house in a trailer park or RV park (and I know some folks who do that), but that misses the point of home ownership, for me.
- techsupporter 11y agoIf you're interested in knowing why, it's because mortgages are sold as securities these days (and have been since before the Big Collapse). If your mortgage is significantly not like the other mortgages, it can't be bundled and sold into the pool of other securitized mortgages. That means your lender has to carry the note itself and the overwhelming majority of lenders--banks and brokers--don't do that. The other problem: banks need a property that, if foreclosed upon, can be sold to recoup their investment. A friend of mine is having this exact problem. He has a house that could withstand a bomb being dropped on it but it is built to his preferences and the banks he has visited to inquire about refinancing have all said that a sale would be difficult. Too risky to use as collateral since they can't be relatively certain of recovering against loss. What you're looking for is a "portfolio loan," where the financial institution keeps your loan on its own books. Some credit unions do this (mine does) in situations like yours. The interest will be commensurate with the credit union's guess of how easy your property will be to resell (both in the opinion of the underwriter and of the outside, independent appraiser) to pay for the risk but it can be done.
- SwellJoe 11y agoThanks for the explanation, and it mirrors the explanation I got from the loan officer at my credit union. On this point: "What you're looking for is a "portfolio loan," where the financial institution keeps your loan on its own books. Some credit unions do this (mine does) in situations like yours. The interest will be commensurate with the credit union's guess of how easy your property will be to resell (both in the opinion of the underwriter and of the outside, independent appraiser) to pay for the risk but it can be done." It was the credit union that said, "We could maybe get you a loan on the land if you can put 50% down." The bank I've been using for 20 years flat out said "no way, we only do land loans for businesses for new construction, and they have to have a plan and funding lined up to complete the construction". It all seems vaguely rotten and corrupt, to me...but, well, I don't know the motivation for it. I'll just keep saving, and pay cash. Or maybe I'll buy land where it's cheaper. Maybe I won't always value living within biking distance of a city with good live music as highly as I do now.
- ascorbic 11y agoI love things like this, but also saddened that in the UK the land to put it on would cost at least ten times that amount. The planning system here is a disgrace.
- rwmj 11y agoUK housebuilding companies are sitting on (by various estimates) 400,000-600,000 plots of land which have planning permission, but they haven't built on. That's about 3 years' worth of new houses. The reason is to hold up prices, and because (with "ever-rising" prices) if they build in the future they will make more profit. There are problems in the planning system, certainly, but at the moment we need an undeveloped land tax to stop this behaviour. Sources: http://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/dec/30/revealed-housebuilders-sitting-on-450000-plots-of-undeveloped-land http://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/dec/30/revealed-hous... http://www.local.gov.uk/media-releases/-/journal_content/56/10180/7632945/NEWS http://www.local.gov.uk/media-releases/-/journal_content/56/...
- mdw 11y agoI really hope housing becomes a key electoral issue for the next government. The current housing crisis in the UK is impoverishing an entire generation.
- ascorbic 11y agoThe trouble is young people don't vote. Old people do vote, and they get free bus passes, TV licences, ridiculous pension protections and planning laws to protect their house price windfalls.
- makomk 11y agoThe trouble is that young people don't believe the major political parties will fulfil their promises even if they do vote for them (and they're probably right).
- dazc 11y ago
- noja 11y agoExcluding all costs apart from material. Yeah, it doesn't cost 20k.
- rgbrgb 11y ago> How do you design a home that someone living below the poverty line can afford, but that anyone would want—while also providing a living wage for the local construction team that builds it? Material is $14k.
- noja 11y agoThe articles says "Originally, the project aimed for a house that would cost $20,000 in total, including construction, though they now believe that more money may be needed to provide a living wage for builders." So more than 20k. Plus land. How much does the land cost?
- morganvachon 11y ago> Plus land. How much does the land cost? According to the article[1], it's in a development area with "million dollar homes", so I'm guessing (based on similar developments near me, also in the Atlanta area) around $200k for a half-acre plot. So in reality, it's a $220k home for "poor people". Granted this is the pilot program, but it's nearly impossible to find decent land in the right location and conditions to build a home upon for under $20k/acre, at least here in Georgia. So let's say you're lucky enough to find a five acre plot (the minimum for what this kind of home requires to comply with zoning laws near me) for $50k. You buy this kit for $20k, take a leave of absence from work for six weeks to build it (~$6k, if your blue collar job doesn't give you paid leave), hire a licensed electrician ($8k) and licensed plumber ($10k) to handle those jobs because it's not included in the kit and building permits require licensed work. Now we're at ~$94k for a home that will not be as nice as a traditional home that costs the same. Not to mention, $94k is at the upper end of what someone with a $50k/year income can afford. I get the intention behind the program, but right now it's no different from any other "sustainable initiative" out there: It's a great theory but only applicable in near-perfect conditions or as a prototype. All of that said, I'd love to tear down my house and build something like this, if only the zoning laws here would allow it. [1] "The development near Atlanta might at first seem like an unlikely place to build the pilot homes—it's a lush planned community that includes million-dollar houses."
- rgbrgb 11y agoAesthetically not really sure, but definitely a cool idea. Here's hoping they build some of these in the Bay! I can see people buying these in expensive areas to offset the cost of the land. Kind of reminds me Modern Shed [0]. [0]: http://www.modern-shed.com/ http://www.modern-shed.com/
- Ao7bei3s 11y ago> How do you design a home that someone living below the poverty line can afford Why not rent a flat instead? Wouldn't that be much more economical (no property prices, lower heating costs, less maintenance work, less risk, not built on the cheap)? I don't understand the fixation on owning a house / living in a single-family house many americans seem to have.
- techsupporter 11y agoOne facet of it is cultural: For a lot of people, someone isn't seen as a "real adult" until he or she owns a residence. (Obligatory "if you have a mortgage you're just renting from the bank and have to fix the water heater yourself" line here.) Another is financial: There are heavy tax incentives towards ownership, though this is lessened in the era of cheap money. (On the other hand, if a mortgage can be had for cheap, that puts upward pressure on house prices because fewer units of currency go towards borrowing costs.) Still another is logistical: Most areas of the U.S. have very few renter protections. If your landlord wants you out and you're not under a current lease, you're out (property rights of the owner and all). This goes double for the desirable places to live. For those who can manage it, the stability of "my housing cost is a known quantity that varies only a little bit outside of my control" (obligatory "did you save for a new hot water heater?" goes here) outweighs the relative immobility of property ownership. Plus, a somewhat high price is put on the ability to paint one's own walls, have a pet, and do minor renovations without asking for permission. Witness the plethora of "home remodeling" shows and TV channels. In many rental units, doing this is not just frowned upon, it is actively forbidden by the lease. As always, to stave off the inevitable replies of "but my rental experience has never been like that," your miles may vary. I lived in one apartment in Texas that let me do everything short of bulldozing my unit. I lived in another in Seattle that charged me $300 because I got a drop of orange drink on the carpet in a bedroom.
- creshal 11y agoSo, the US favours owning residences because renters have nigh zero legal protection?
- rplnt 11y agoYeah, there's no way I'm clicking on this clickbait title.
- adrianN 11y agoI would be scared to buy a house that uses non-standard construction methods. Not because I don't trust the plans, but because even with cookie cutter houses, the construction people mess up a lot of things and you really have to pay an additional person to check the construction. Trying to get construction companies to build a house using novel techniques and do it without major errors is, I imagine, quite an undertaking.
- keithpeter 11y agoUK: we had big problems with 'system build' council housing in the UK in 1960s and early 1970s. Google 'Bison' and 'Ronan Point' for background. I'd hope that we have (all) learned a bit about pre-manufactured sections and assembly since then and perhaps pre-manufactured units with quality control/JIT manufacturing techniques would be better than the current bricks on site based construction. UK: the problem would be the land to build on anywhere near population centres and utilities by the way...
- derefr 11y agoUnless, perhaps, one of the advantages in these alternative construction techniques is that they're more construction-error-tolerant. That's, for example, one of the key advantages in suspension bridges: any individual support cable can be installed in a stupid out-of-tolerance way, because load is just redirected evenly to all the other cables. Usually, in fact, "cheaper to build" almost always means "because the materials and techniques used mean that even a sloppy construction process will still produce good results."
- petecox 11y agoWell it sucks to be an early adopter but the students are currently on 20Kv20. Hopefully after 20 iterations the designs are getting better each time, incorporating real world feedback from the people who built the previous ones. Perhaps these 'novel techniques' over time might be adopted by industry.
- flexie 11y agoThey say it's nicer than my house, but apart from the price I don't see anything nice about it. Honestly it looks really bad. $20,000 is impressively cheap, but like with the iphone making smartphones popular or the Tesla making electric cars popular, I think smartly built houses aren't gonna take off until their design and specs are top notch.
- yitchelle 11y ago20K? Would love to see the itemised material costs, labour cost, adminstration fees for building this. Also have a projected on-going maintenance costs as well. At the end of the day, the aim of this house is "a home that someone living below the poverty line can afford."
- Already__Taken 11y agoThe article pretty clearly states it's just material costs.
- jonnycowboy 11y ago14K for materials, 6K for labour was the goal.
- yitchelle 11y agoMy point is what is the real cost of living in this house, can the folks living under the poverty live really afford to live in it?
- ACow_Adonis 11y agoIt's kind of hard for me to tell whether the house is nicer than mine when there's so little detail in the article on the actual house. Look, i'm more than supportive of innovative design and doing things cheaply, but for an article that was heavy on "the house is so cheap", and "its built kinda more like a airplane", and "it uses all this innovative stuff", there's a startling dearth of information. Sqm, plans, insulation, facilities, utilities, safety? Is it a house I'd want to live in or build, or is it a $20,000 shed with furniture? I'm not being snarky, I really want to know!
- vacri 11y agoSame here - annoying to see the same 'corner angle' photography tricks that real estate agents use to hide shortcomings.
- mathgladiator 11y agoI want to know too; having somewhat recently bought a house, and I've started to upgrade it. I can see $20,000 going really fast for simple things.
- morganvachon 11y agoIndeed, I bought a "handyman's delight" (i.e. money pit) for $43k just outside Atlanta during the recession in 2009, and to get it to roughly the same condition as my neighbor's house, I'd have to spend another $40k. It's mostly cosmetic work that it needs, but there are some structural and functional issues that need to be addressed as well. We're still debating whether we should hold onto it and fix it up (it currently appraises for $80k with the few improvements we've done, mostly due to the location) or just sell it for what we owe and buy a better house.
- Someone1234 11y agoMight be worth talking to a realtor, or even going to look at a few houses for sale close by. Certain improvements can be literally profitable when you sell the house (e.g. $2K in painting nets you $10K in additional sale price). If you go look at the comparable homes in the area (similar square footage, no. of bathrooms & bedrooms, etc) and they're nicer but selling for $120K+ than your home can likely be made to turn a huge profit by fixing it up before you sell it. Just make sure you only fix/improve things which a buyer would care about, and not get bogged down in your own niche requirements.
- jernfrost 11y agoProbably nice for the US, but in much of the rest of the world, it is the price of land which dominate the price. Any system that aims to reduce house prices really need to deal with limited supply of land to build on. Even on Iceland which has vast amounts of space and tiny population, house prices are high because the areas where people want to live is in high demand. Now if you could just build your house at any arbitrary location on Iceland then that would not be a problem. But people needs schools for children, hospitals, jobs etc. That limits the options. The US has fairly cheap land because it is flat, it is easy to build infrastructure and there are a lot of roads everywhere which you can connect to. The city planning also space out things a lot leaving a lot of land for building.
- raggiskula 11y agoIcelander here, I'm more concerned how well does this house work in icelandic conditions? Does it handle earthquakes well? What about regular storms? Being wet for months end? Constant freezing and thawing? Can you put it in an active volcano? Does if float on magma? There are lot of questions here!
- luisramalho 11y agoDoes it float on magma? Do houses in Iceland really do that?
- david-given 11y agoOnly briefly.
- logfromblammo 11y agoIf you built a boat from SiC attached to enormous heat sinks radiating into empty space, it would float for longer.
- DrScump 11y agoBut air-conditioning expense makes it cost-prohibitive.
- yusufp 11y agoI think the idea of approaching things like this from first principles is a great way to create change. Everything we take for granted could potentially be made in a much better way for a lower price. It will be interesting to see applications of this thinking in other areas.
- kriro 11y agoIt doesn't look very sturdy, which seems to be a wrong assumption on my part [1], but 20k for a decent house is nice...assuming you own the land already. For comparison, how much do the Amish-houses cost (materials) and how long do they take to build them? I only know them from movies but they seem like low-cost/quickbuild type houses, too. Edit: Building instructions for this could be a good application for a VR-based tutorial :) [1]: "They're built more like airplanes than houses, which allows us to have them far exceed structural requirements. ... We're using material much more efficiently. But the problem is your local code official doesn't understand that. They look at the documents, and the house is immediately denied a permit simply because the code officials didn't understand it."
- huuu 11y agoMaterial cost of houses is already 'cheap'. But you also need a place to build it. In The Netherlands ground prices range from $100 - $500 per m². Then you need sewage, electricity, gas, labor, and so on. I don't think you could make those much cheaper.
- rubidium 11y agoYes, but this is the state of Georgia in the United States. You could buy a nice sized lot plenty big enough for this house in a poor part of the city for $0.5-3K.
- jdc 11y agoLooks like a PR piece. http://paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://paulgraham.com/submarine.html https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=Rural%20Studio%27s%2020K%20House&tbm=nws https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=Rural%20Studio%27s%202... http://www.prweb.com/releases/ruralstudiosept15/artfarmserenbe/prweb12940933.htm http://www.prweb.com/releases/ruralstudiosept15/artfarmseren...
- rloc 11y agoIt worked, the story is ranked 3 right now on HN.
- jensen123 11y agoI think it's really impressive that they were able to build a house like that for only 20K. The article mentions zoning laws and size requirements, which I found odd. Do many places not allow houses below a certain size to be built?
- NoGravitas 11y agoIt's extremely common in the US.
- jensen123 11y agoHuh, that doesn't make any sense to me. Smaller houses would make cities more walkable/livable and thus be better for people's health and the environment. Do people want those kinds of laws in order to protect their "investment"? I mean, I guess maybe your house will be worth more if all the other houses nearby are large and thus expensive? Of course, now in the digital age, I guess such laws seem sillier than they did earlier. You no longer need a huge amount of books, music records, train set, pinball machines, billiard table etc., since you can fit all those things in a small computer.
- zanny 11y agoZoning and construction regulation has obviously not kept pace with the changing social expectations of housing nor innovation in building construction. And you are right, a lot of it was enacted (especially minimum square footage zoning) in response to trying to keep "undesirables" out of areas in the aftermath of white flight from urban centers in the 50s / 60s and has remained ever since, since the children of the generation that enacted those laws grew up being preached to how bad non-conformance is and they are now the largest voting block in America.
- JBReefer 11y agoA lot of suburbs actively don't want to be cities - though that's changing now that this is negatively impacting house values. I never understood suburbs - why not live in the country if you can't walk anywhere anyway?
- chvid 11y agoReads too much like an advertisement piece. Building a 60 m2 wooden shack have always been cheap compared to a proper house. Much of the cost of a house lies in the cost of land and the cost of connecting it to water and electricity. These costs are high because of scarcity and the policies of cities. Policies that ensures that values of houses do not fall and people do not go under water in debt, that areas are filled with proper gentry, that there are nice open spaces, nature, farmland etc. Even if you could build a house for 0 dollars many places would still have an affordability issue.
- ben_bai 11y agoI like the concept of small and cheap houses, unfortunately in my country, Europe/Germany this would not qualify as a house built to the newest regulations. It's just a shack.
- evthewolf 11y agoIf you consider the cost of land (in Ireland) you'll still spend a fortune and end up with a pretty small place. For one / two this could work, imagine having a family in there!
- lukasm 11y agoThere was a company in Poland that was building houses like that - they went bust. The main problem is cultural. People look at it and see a shed and they want a "proper" house. "Can I retire here?" "Is it an investment?". What is more, there is a segway syndrome (you like a dork). You will be that weird guy that lives in this weird house. And there is a liquidity problem.
- rubidium 11y agoThis house is not for you. This house is for poor people who live in rural or urban decaying homes. Their roofs leak and collapse, their insulation in non-existent, their plumbing doesn't work. This is a big issue, and having worked with a number of situations like this, being able to get someone a new house for $20K that functions would be huge. $20K (or even $30K) for a functional, well-designed, "tornado-resistant" house would be a big help to many in the rural and urban south.
- dsfyu404ed 11y agoTornado resistance can be accomplished with a trailer home, some design tweaks, a big concrete pad and a lot of big lag bolts. structural interior walls that act similar to the bulkheads of a ship) to prevent the structure from deforming and folding over/apart
- vox_mollis 11y agoThis house is not for you. This house is for poor people Not everybody who earns a good income is required to spend it on pointless status-signaling. Some of us enjoy inexpensive, low-footprint, low-consumption living.
- delbel 11y agoRoof looks good to me. If its the same delta rib panels I installed, I had a choice of a 83 year warranty or a 100 year warranty. Snow load angle looks good also. They are off the ground and the roof extends out a bit so that the water stays off the side. I think they are built fine.
- garrettgrimsley 11y agoThey were referring to poor people's homes.
- jonstewart 11y agoThe article doesn't mention this explicitly, but it sure seems as though this tiny house project is geared towards Appalachia and the rural South. Appalachia is generally the mountainous parts of Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Virginia, Kentucky, Tennessee, and North Carolina (maybe some parts of Ohio, too). It has its own culture and dialect. It is also the poorest region of the United States; Appalachia is a huge component of why the US is not like other first world countries. In Appalachia, it is not uncommon for desperately poor families to live in shacks or horribly broken down mobile homes, on land that's been passed down for generations, sometimes predating US independence. So, this house helps to solve the safe, modern, cheap problem for housing in Appalachia. Also note that one of their goals is making it sustainable for contractors to build and providing lots of instructions--that's to help provide jobs. There aren't a lot of jobs in Appalachia. So, this is why the house is not an apartment building. It's not built for Germany.
- jonstewart 11y agoIt even has a porch with rocking chairs. That is a clue.
- sageabilly 11y agoMy first thought when reading the article and seeing the pictures is that there's no way this design (as depicted) would work in Appalachia without enclosing and insulating around the bottom of the house. Otherwise, your pipes would freeze and the house would be way, way too cold during the winter. I was also disappointed that the article didn't go into the R-value of the house itself as that's going to be extremely important with regards to where the home could be built. I'm assuming it's probably pretty good, given that it's new construction materials, but I would not want to weather out an Appalachian winter in one unless it had been properly designed to withstand a harsh winter.
- logfromblammo 11y agoAuburn University is in Alabama. These houses are designed for the rural South. You don't have to dig down too far to reach the frost heave line (14" or less). The primary climate concerns are therefore summer cooling, storm drainage, and tornadoes. When there is a freeze warning, people let their faucets drip. These designs could be used in Tennessee and North Carolina, but that's as far north as I'd be willing to try them. But then again, it's a lot easier to dig deep holes for piers than a full basement, and you could insulate the underside of the house more thoroughly than is usually done.
- brianbreslin 11y agoSlightly off topic, but what would a modern looking pre-fab house cost? I've always wanted to buy a piece of land somewhere rural and have a house built so I can take mini getaway vacations with my dog.
- gravypod 11y agoI have always wanted to toy with this idea. I'd love to save up a nice chunk of change and build something like this. I'd like a small house out in the middle of the country. A bathroom with shower, a kitchen with a stove, and a single living space. Solar panels, backup batteries, well with pump and filter, and a internet hookup (satellite/landline). I was hoping to find that this article would talk about the prospects of building something like that, but unfortunately this article is not exactly what is in my "dream".
- sageikosa 11y agoAll other things aside, the cost of buying a home in densely populated region with situational amenities such as subsidized schools, hospitals, fire stations, zoned shopping districts, reliable power, water, sewer and communication network access is also largely about the real estate market in the area.
- protomyth 11y agoI would love to see a bit more of these. I do wonder if they have a version with insulation that would work in a northern climate. This would be a great project for the reservation I work on simply because it is impossible to get a home loan on the reservation. It would be interesting to see mass production.
- fweespeech 11y agohttp://www.artsatl.com/2016/01/serenbe-rural-studio-artist-residence/ http://www.artsatl.com/2016/01/serenbe-rural-studio-artist-r... > And $20,000 is still an aspiration. These two cottages and the deck between them cost $135,000 to build. Smith is hoping that if a contractor understands process, he can bring it in more cheaply. Smith will be able to test that hypothesis: Nygren is invested in the collaboration and the concept. He intends to build more cottages and will be raising funds to do so. He says, This title is misleading. It is $67,500 / house and the costs are on par with new construction for a similar structure. :/
- beat 11y agoPeople have been building homes cheaper than that for a long time now. What makes this different? When I was a kid, I spent a lot of time on my grandfather's farm in southern Kentucky. I didn't realize it, but it was rural poverty. He didn't have electricity or running water (this was the early 1970s). But at least it was a wood house, with glass windows and doors and a decent fireplace and a coal-burning stove. Back in the far back of the same property, up a dirt trail in the woods, an old black man lived alone in a shack. One room, walls made out of tar paper and corrugated steel. That's a house that can survive in that kind of terrain, and it cost a lot less than $20k. (Interestingly, my father treated that old man with great respect and deference. My father didn't respect anyone, so it boggled me, even as a small child.) Around the world, entire neighborhoods of "shantytowns" arise around cities, made from the discarded junk of richer people. Shelter is shelter. People build it because they can't make a living wage and pay someone else to build a house for them...
- pbreit 11y agoThe unfortunate thing about "modern prefab" is that it is so dang expensive when the minimalist designs with builds in a controlled environment should be inexpensive.
- dharma1 11y agoNot of personal use for me, but they should just put the plans on github or even a blog. Couldn't find any detail on the site (http://www.ruralstudio.org/ http://www.ruralstudio.org/)
- pkaye 11y agoSo the location is in a small town somewhere so likely not many job around. That means either you are okay with a homestead type of living or are rich enough to buy this as a second home.
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoThe $20k is an aspiration (read, total bs atm), the pictures you're seeing are for a house that cost $135k. http://www.artsatl.com/2016/01/serenbe-rural-studio-artist-residence/ http://www.artsatl.com/2016/01/serenbe-rural-studio-artist-r... It must be mentioned that houses carry a huge location premium, everyone knows this. You can buy a big beautiful home in the middle of nowhere for the cost of a studio in the middle of NY or SF. Living isn't all that expensive, living close to where jobs are, or close to the 'heart' of a vibrant local culture, that's expensive, and it looks like the actual cost of building isn't the most significant part of that equation. Land is expensive, so you need to go up, and building up and space-efficiently (i.e. reasonably tall buildings with smart, space efficient units) is where a lot of these 'open-source plans for cheap rural houses with materials from Home Depot' completely do not apply. It's a bit like building your own PC. Yeah you can build a much more powerful machine at a cheaper rate than a Macbook... but you're forgoing all kinds of factors like mobility which are extremely essential to many of today's consumers. Similarly, you can build a cheap rural home and completely forgo on extremely essential factors like proximity to jobs, culture and infrastructure. It's great for some people, but not for most.
- tejohnso 11y ago"pictures you're seeing are for a house that cost $135k" yet "Smith says they have priced materials for these homes, each under 550 square feet, at Home Depot, at about $13,000." So it would be nice if they had detailed the real costs. As indicated, the material cost is relatively insignificant.
- up_and_up 11y agoThey said the actual cost for building the structure is $67,000. Not sure if that includes items like well and septic, etc which are 1000's of dollars.
- thesz 11y agoAfter surveying the house designs, I can't help but share this: http://inhabitat.com/magical-dome-house-in-remote-thailand-constructed-in-six-weeks-for-just-8000/ http://inhabitat.com/magical-dome-house-in-remote-thailand-c... $8000 for 3 room house with small pool, which is so fun that it looks like toy.
- apurvadave 11y agoIt seems like there are lot of comments about how this kind of house wouldn't work (yes, this won't work in downtown NYC). But it also seems like there are lots of communities - poor, displaced - that would benefit massively. I'm a big fan of projects like this, even if they only serve to push the innovation of affordable housing further.
- robotresearcher 11y agoBut it cost nearly 7X that amount. From another article about the same property: > And $20,000 is still an aspiration. These two cottages and the deck between them cost $135,000 to build. http://www.artsatl.com/2016/01/serenbe-rural-studio-artist-residence/ http://www.artsatl.com/2016/01/serenbe-rural-studio-artist-r...
- donatj 11y agoIt's not nicer than mine. Maybe on dollar to metric niceness, but it's much smaller and offers fewer amenities.
- no_wave 11y agoTerrible article... no mention of plumbing, toilets, heating, ductwork, or electricity, which are the main factors that dictate how normal houses are designed (which is why materials like cob aren't the game-changers that their devoted proponents claim).
- listic 11y agoHistorical weather records in the vicinity: http://en.tutiempo.net/climate/2015/ws-722286.html http://en.tutiempo.net/climate/2015/ws-722286.html
- badthingfactory 11y ago"This House Costs Just $20,000—But It’s Nicer Than Yours" later: "In Serenbe, their first problem was a zoning issue: The houses were too small." It sounds like this house is probably not nicer than mine. Titles like this really annoy me for some reason.
- Raticide 11y agoAround where I live it's the land that costs you the most, so it doesn't really matter what the house costs. Hell, some people buy a property and give away the building for free to anyone that's willing to move it off their land.