5 ms·
“The evidence suggests I was completely wrong about UK tuition fees”
- spxdcz 11y agoI'm not convinced the "evidence" is suggesting anything without further data, and this article is glossing over "correlation != causation". Without a baseline (a situation where, over the same years, tuition fees weren't introduced/raised), how do we know what the equivalent situation would be? Perhaps there would have been even more people from poorer backgrounds applying.
- Pitarou 11y agoIt is evidence. No need to put it in scare quotes. We can debate the correct interpretation and applicability, but it's certainly evidence of a sort. It's impossible to run the kinds of controlled large scale socio-economic experiments you describe. If we ignore the evidence that doesn't meet your high standards, we'll have no real world data.
- MrTonyD 11y agoRecently it was discovered that working 20 hours a week while going to school results in worse grades - after decades of believing the exact opposite. When they did better studies - comparing like students (same school, same background, and other characteristics), they discovered that all the prior studies were just showing the success of students who really should have been even more successful. So I prefer to think of most studies such as this as a datapoint, rather than any type of evidence.
- icebraining 11y agoA datapoint is evidence, just not proof.
- MrTonyD 11y agoYou might want to look up the definition of evidence. My reading of three definitions just doesn't quite match your definition. But no big deal. I think we agree, and this has become about word interpretation.
- lotsofpulp 11y agoIt's better to recognize the lack of good data and the limits of our knowledge than to come to incorrect conclusions. There's things you know, things you don't know, and things you think you know but you don't know. It's the last one that harms the most.
- jevgeni 11y agoSooo... What's the actionable decision here?
- peteretep 11y ago> If we ignore the evidence that doesn't meet your high > standards, we'll have no real world data. I would also add that variable standards of evidence are a good way to allow your strongly cherished beliefs to remain unchallenged for a long time.
- tom-lord 11y ago* No comparison with other time periods, and their respective tuition fees. * No comparison with other countries, and their respective policies. * No data on where these students graduate from, or in which subjects, or with which grades, or what their average salary is X years later, or whether they'll actually be able to pay back the loan. It's missing a huge amount of important information; you really can't justify the conclusion "tuition fees are good" from this alone.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- icebraining 11y agoI don't think the claim is "tuition fees are good," but that reducing them may not be the best use of the allocated money.
- MatthewWilkes 11y agoI'm relatively convinced that tuition fees don't promote inequality, based on stats I've seen over the last 10 years or so. Also, as a student, some of the richest people I knew didn't pay tuition fees due to creative accounting of their parents' personal finances. That said, £27,000 for a bachelor's degree represents terrible value for money in most cases. The UK's old targets of getting everyone into higher education have had a terribly negative effect on universities; they now chase student numbers and have a 'grow or die' mindset. The improvement of apprentice systems over the last few years is a step in the right direction, but I fear the damage has been done. Students don't want a challenging experience for £27k, they want the piece of paper they've paid for. For best value for money, I personally would rather take out a student loan without attending an institution and undertake self-guided learning at a slightly later age.
- Pitarou 11y agoI totally agree with you about Britain's obsession with academic qualifications at the expense of practical apprenticeships.
- realusername 11y agoWhile I agree with you (French guy living there now), It's even worse on the other side of the Channel.
- lucaspiller 11y agoAlso take a look at Spain, where higher education is basically free (compared to the UK). In a lot of cases, jobs that don't need a degree are requiring candidates to have them, before they are even considered for the position. I like how things work in Eastern Europe, where education isn't expensive but you need to actually work hard and be good (and get kicked out if you aren't) to get a degree.
- realusername 11y agoI don't really know for Spain, but the price of education is not always the whole picture. In France it's mostly free (or really close to free) but the culture regarding degrees is vastly different compared to the UK. For engineering for example, you have an official definition of engineer and if you don't have the official engineering degree, you will never be considered an engineer, whatever you do (even 10 years after graduation).
- adaml_623 11y agoNo real mention of Scotland here which is interesting because it doesn't have tuition fees (I think). So surely it would stand as an example that either supports or disproves the theory in the article.
- arethuza 11y agoNo tuition fees for Scottish students attending Scottish universities.
- adaml_623 11y agoThat's correct
- DrJokepu 11y agoThe be precise, Scottish and non-British European (EU/EEA/CH) students.
- k-mcgrady 11y agoAlso, I'm not sure if they've closed it or not but there was a loop hole a few years ago that allowed students in Northern Ireland to go to Scottish Universities without paying fees due to dual Irish/British citizenship.
- AlphaSite 11y agoIT does make small mentions of them: "“In 2006 advantaged UK 18 year olds were 3.7 times more likely to apply that disadvantaged 18 years olds.” By 2014 the ratio had fallen to 2.4. “A similar fall is seen for each country of the UK.”"
- lunchladydoris 11y agoI see a lot of talk in the piece about applications to university but no data on attendance or graduation. I'd be more interested in those numbers. Does it really matter how many people apply?
- peteretep 11y ago> Does it really matter how many people apply? When a key argument against tuition fees has been "it'll discourage poorer students from applying", yes it does.
- pigpaws 11y agoThen the question is skewed. Technically, it costs NOTHING to "APPLY" to a school, whereas it costs tens of thousands to COMPLETE school. In the US, the ROI on a degree is sad. with hard numbers to back it up - especially from a 'private' school. $100k debt to get a $45k/yr job - and thats if you can find one in your field of study. It doesn't seem (to me) that people think about the ROI on these things. At this point it makes more sense to pay < $10k to become a plumber or electrician - things people will need no matter the economic situation, with an ROI through the stratosphere.
- derEitel 11y agoCompletely agree. Yes many people from less educated households have realized they have the chance to improve their situation by pursuing a degree, hence the increase in applications from that segment. But how many of those actually attend university and graduate? I am currently enrolled in the EIT Digital master school. Funded by the EU, with scholarships for both EU and non EU citizens there was a huge amount of applicants from outside the EU, mainly "poorer" countries. Turns out, of those very few remainend and mostly those that got a full scholarship. Applicants != graduates;
- gambiting 11y agoHow about looking at countries which actually have no tuition fees and learning by example, instead of guessing what might or might not happen? Scotland is the most obvious example, but if you want a larger one, Poland does not have any fees for higher education eiter. I know a few people who started from really poor families and went on to become doctors and engineers, mostly because education didn't cost them anything.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y agoAustria: no tuition fees, terrible social mobility. Uneducated parents cause uneducated offspring.
- ccozan 11y agoGermany is very bad either. You have to take the decision if you want to go to university at the age of 10. In classes the children are discuraged to go that path, because "is very hard, and no time to play". Obviously, a lie, but very effective. It seems, children with academical parents will likely pursue that academical path, due to pressure but also the benefits. The others are required to support the professions for industry. This doesn't mean you don't make a ton of money, you can with the right entrepreneureal skills. Tuition is actually not homogene, some german lands have it some not. But in the last years, they have been gradually reduced or removed ( in Bavaria for example).
- rbehrends 11y agoBoth Germany and Austria have higher intergenerational mobility than the UK (though that probably has very little to do with tuition). > You have to take the decision if you want to go to university at the age of 10. While I'm not a fan of Germany's tracking system, this really isn't true anymore. Leaving aside the fact that at least one state (Schleswig-Holstein) has pretty much killed tracking, your choice after fourth grade no longer locks you into one track. It's still pretty wasteful, but there's a lot of flexibility now (example: my niece is about to do her abitur after having already done an apprenticeship, and this was fully financed by the German government).
- Toenex 11y agoDoes anyone know what percentage of these loans are being repaid? I recall that a couple of years ago the press were quoting figures like 85% will never be repaid.
- lyschoening 11y agoThe argument here is that highschools are underfunded, therefore any money that would have to be spent on scrapping university tuition should be spent on highschools instead. This would be a sound idea if the government weren't conservative and hadn't elevated austerity to a quasi-religion.
- lyschoening 11y agoThe argument here is that highschools are underfunded, therefore any money that would have to be spent on scrapping univerdity tuition should be spent on highschools instead. This would be a sound idea if the government weren't conservative and hadn't elevated austerity to a quasi-religion.
- quqqo 11y agoA definite mix up of correlation & causation. There's no definition on disadvantaged / advantaged areas. Might be that the given figures: 72% 63%, 39% and 36%, just reflect the relative populations. Combined with the ongoing trend of people getting more educated, this might account for all of these figures. Also the article simply dismisses the size of tuitions. A tuition of say < 10000 £ / a year probably won't be a strong inequalizer. But the whole notion that Ivy league tuitions vs. no tuitions wouldn't effect the possibilities of people is foolish. The second point / infograph was more interesting though, and might bare more fruit for thought. Resources probably would be better allocated to pre uni. times.
- gabemart 11y ago> In England, 18 year olds living in disadvantaged areas were a staggering 72% more likely to apply for higher education in 2015 than in 2006. In Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland the figures were 63%, 39% and 36% - lower, but still a huge increase. As other commenters have pointed out, students from Scotland who are studying for their first undergraduate degree at a Scottish university don't pay any tuition fees.
- adventured 11y agoInteresting premise given Britain now has the most expensive public university system on the planet: "While student fees can be higher at many ivy league and other top colleges, the £9,000 annual charge for attending an English institution pushed the British average above the US’s public colleges for the first time, the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development said. OECD data showed that fees for a bachelor or equivalent degree on average in public institutions was $9,019 a year in the UK compared with $8,202 in the US. Fees at private institutions – attended by 40 per cent of students -- in the US are on average $21,189 a year." http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/62a1d4e0-9213-11e5-bd82-c1fb87bef7af.html http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/62a1d4e0-9213-11e5-bd82-c1fb8... http://www.theguardian.com/education/2015/nov/24/uk-has-highest-undergraduate-tuition-fees-in-industrialised-world-survey-finds http://www.theguardian.com/education/2015/nov/24/uk-has-high...
- cornholio 11y ago"In the last decade, in spite of rising tuition fees, students are more likely to apply for university, poorer students are more likely to apply for university, and the inequality gap – while still a problem – has closed." That's just ridiculous. What we are actually seeing is a very strong sheepskin effect where not having a university degree pretty much guarantees you a menial, low paying job. The poor push for a degree but that does not "the inequality gap has closed", because there is still strong inequality among degrees themselves. People go to university not to learn (that's just a side effect, in some schools, for some students) but to signal to society and to a future employer they are the type of person willing to commit themselves to a career in the field, by irreversibly burning money and years of their lives doing busywork. So clearly, a more expensive or exclusive school is a better signal. Everybody goes to university nowadays but that does not mean degrees are equivalent. I agree throwing public money at this mess is not a solution, we have to devise more efficient ways for people to signal their competence and willingness to learn.
- petewailes 11y ago"having a university degree pretty much guarantees you a menial, low paying job" Evidence?
- arethuza 11y agoAs the parent of a teenager who is starting to think about applying to University I am extremely conscious of the fact having a degree today guarantees nothing, not even a menial low paying job.
- dTal 11y agoRead it again; I think you missed the "not".
- petewailes 11y agoI missed putting the not in the quote. My bad. I'm still sticking with it though - I don't think having or not having one makes much difference either way.
- rbehrends 11y agoThat a reasonable amount of tuition combined with manageable payment options does not deter low-income students (at least not statistically) is not new [1]. That said, the potential deterrent effect is not the only thing to be considered. We also have to look at fairness. Normally, a fixed [2] benefit paid out of flat or progressive taxes is itself progressive (because it provides proportionately more financial relief to low-income recipients). However, in the case of free tuition, middle- and high-income households are more likely to be recipients; this makes it potentially regressive and is one of the major arguments for not having free tuition; you might end up with low income households paying tuition disproportionately for high income households. Yet the UK's system (paying back tuition as an additional tax on your income, but only if you earn enough) does not really fix it; while it addresses the low/middle income disparity, it creates a regressive bump in the middle of the income scale; the cost hurts middle class students the most. Once you hit a point where you will pay your entire tuition, it's a fixed cost that is borne by everybody and then it becomes regressive. Creating a flat or progressive hypothecated tax for college graduates might address the issue of social fairness, but at this point it's not clear whether it's worth the complexity or whether just financing tuition (and also other forms of tertiary education) out of a sufficiently progressive income tax might not be easier. After all, governments do a lot of things that are likely to benefit richer people more and we don't create convoluted hypothecated taxes for all of them. The article is of course right that the problems that cause unequal access to college occur a long time before you worry about tuition, but this is really not an either-or situation. Free or affordable tuition isn't all that expensive (by the standards of the budgets of Western countries), not to mention that investing in human capital is generally a good idea. And, obviously, providing options for tertiary education and careers other than college is also a primary concern. [1] That said, I'm pretty sure that on an individual level, there are still plenty of cases where it does deter potential students – I know some myself – and there are other detrimental effects, such as the financial burden on dropouts. [2] Tuition varies by university, of course, but on balance it's close enough to a fixed expense to call it that.
- surfmike 11y agoCompletely agree that subsidizing university tuition is a regressive policy - taxing all of society to benefit the 33% of the population or so who go to college. However, upfront fees of course are a big deterrent to poorer students, and that's not the only way to charge for tuition. I like Milton Friedman's proposal to tax a certain percentage of future earnings of students in exchange for paying for their fees. Australia has a similar income-contigent repayment system which has been very successful. I think it's fair that college graduates pay for the bulk of (all of?) their education, but I think it would be much better for college graduates (and society) if those fees were collected later in life and didn't cause crippling debt.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- aprdm 11y agoI am leaving UK mainly because of tuition fees. It's really expensive for overseas, I am just a regular software engineer and someone from my family wants to finish the studies. £24k p.a...
- surfmike 11y agoI was curious, looked up the numbers for the US vs UK: UK annual tuition: $9,000 - $13,440 (the max for public) [1] US avg annual tuition, public: $9,410 [2] US avg annual tuition, private: $32,405 [2] It's possible fees might not matter too much up to a certain range... investing in yourself could be justified economically up to a certain amount, after which the fees could be too much to justify (unless you have wealthy family to help out). [1] http://www.topuniversities.com/student-info/student-finance/how-much-does-it-cost-study-uk http://www.topuniversities.com/student-info/student-finance/... [2] http://trends.collegeboard.org/college-pricing/figures-tables/average-published-undergraduate-charges-sector-2015-16 http://trends.collegeboard.org/college-pricing/figures-table...
- jld89 11y agoCompare that to France where it's $500 annual tuition (health insurance included).
- maxerickson 11y agoI think supporting young people, up to a point, is a great idea, but comparing the numbers there is meaningless. France has chosen a higher amount of support, but that means that society at large is bearing the costs, not that France is educating students for $500 a year.
- jld89 11y agoWell comparing expenditures in education in both countries France spends less than the UK. So both societies are bearing similar costs with differing benefits. Education expenditures in France: 5.9% of GDP UK: 6% Source: CIA World Factbook.
- maxerickson 11y agoMeaningless was a poor choice of word. The $500 a year will obviously impact the decisions made by students. But I think it is useful to compare the total costs, not just the costs observable by the student. The outcomes in the US certainly aren't impressive, college degrees are becoming basic credentials, with little consideration of their utility. Not all academic pursuit needs to be measured against the economic utility it provides, but at a systemic level you probably want it to be at least roughly balanced against that utility.
- jld89 11y agoThis article is such bullcrap. The writer needs to see the situation in France and Germany (better but not without problems).