4 ms·
>will it stifle progress by removing incentives for inventors? my guess is it will pressure companies who currently hold on to their secrets without innovating
by chii 11y ago
>will it stifle progress by removing incentives for inventors?
my guess is it will pressure companies who currently hold on to their secrets without innovating (because they are the incumbent) to start innovating. If your competitors are on an even playing field with you, the only way to survive is to innovate.
- Cieplak 11y agoTrue that. It sucks that the people at the top use the government to stifle innovation for everyone else. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semiconductor_Chip_Protection_Act_of_1984 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semiconductor_Chip_Protection_... Edit: The context for the Chip Protection Act is actually in Intel's primary wikipedia page: "During the late 1980s and 1990s (after this law was passed), Intel also sued companies that tried to develop competitor chips to the 80386 CPU.[32] The lawsuits were noted to significantly burden the competition with legal bills, even if Intel lost the suits.[32] Antitrust allegations had been simmering since the early 1990s and had been the cause of one lawsuit against Intel in 1991. In 2004 and 2005, AMD brought further claims against Intel related to unfair competition." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel
- sitkack 11y agoThe Chinese have no need to make x86 compatible parts. Riscv or a home grown arch would work as well or better
- chii 11y agoif they intend to sell to foreign markets, they sure do. RISC custom chips may be useful for homegrown tech, or embedded systems, but the consumer market cant possibly be like that - every one expects their software to work everywhere!
- zanny 11y agoAndroid iOS and Chrome OS have been very popular despite not running Windows x86 binaries.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoWhat's their market share for desktops in office, entertainment, and business sectors? Probably almost nothing in favor of mostly Windows and Mac OS X desktops running Intel or AMD processors. Legacy compatibility, both OS and popular software, is extremely important for marketing a CPU. Notice how iOS and Chrome OS specifically targeted a sector where that didn't matter. Of course, now the effect applies to those two where people wanting iOS were stuck with ObjectiveC and ARM while people targeting ChromeOS had to support its ecosystem/model. Legacy effect just shifts here. Truly portable and self-contained software is rare these days. Mostly only OSS stuff.
- tn13 11y agoProblem with copycats is that they remain copycats forever.
- chii 11y agoit's ok to remain a copycat - generic pharmacuticals are cheap and make a drug plentiful and available. It's a balancing force in the competition, and is needed for innovation.
- CamperBob2 11y agoEverything people say about China today, including your post, is familiar from my childhood... except my old man was talking about Japan.
- _nedR 11y agoand from my childhood too.. except people were talking about South Korea. I am pretty sure most people/countries started off mimicking and copying, before innovating. Also the Chinese might catch up faster than people think. Two small examples:- Xiaomi's MIUI has really been one of the most innovative android ROMS out there balancing usability and functionality. Another one, we use multitouch IR-based components. Right now the top 2 most innovative and competitive providers are both founded by Chinese, although one is headquartered in the US. Basically, the whole "Chinese know only how to copy" argument is an excuse to be complacent, made by people thinking their culture or genes or whatever will protect them.