17 ms·
MIT dean to start new university: “No majors, no lectures, no classrooms”
- TheMagicHorsey 11y agoSounds like a hacker house. Why call it a university if it doesn't grant degrees?
- skizm 11y agoHonestly it probably makes it more acceptable to the "everyone needs to go to college" crowd. Trade schools have been around for a while, but for some reason people think you need a "university degree" to get anywhere. I assume they are trying to bridge that mental gap by using similar language to that of traditional colleges / universities. Also "trade schools" and / or specialty schools rarely have the same social aspects of a traditional school, which (even if you personally don't value that) is a big selling point for traditional schools. Maybe they are trying to capture some of that and mix it with the specialization of a trade school. All speculation of course, but seems reasonable I think.
- gravypod 11y agoHonestly, I wish there were major respected trade schools that taught CS/Software Engineering/IT/IS. The university environment, in my opinion, is adverse to the development of good CS knowledge. Most of us on here, I'd say, have learned through trying and experimentation and that is why we are fairly good at what we proclaim to do. University doesn't foster that kind of understanding. I also hate that currently I need to take 5 physics classes, an accounting class, a social sciences class, and 3 "study" classes to get my major.
- adrianN 11y agoI guess that depends on what you call "good CS knowledge". It's true in my experience that universities are not particularly good at teaching the actual engineering part of software engineering. But I that that is because the major is called "Computer Science", not Software Engineering. In my opinion, universities' main focus should be on educating potential scientists, not churn out workers for the industry. That implies a heavy focus on theory, with the practical parts being mostly self-taught when necessary.
- brodawg 11y agoI think you're missing the point here. Those physics classes will teach you to think about problems abstractly. In my experience, my knowledge of physics has helped me think about algorithmic problems significantly. Even if you don't use the physics itself, it's good to learn. The accounting might not help you so much for CS, but it could be useful. And a few liberal arts classes are always good for breadth of education, and making you realize that you can always pick up a good book and read it, and that not everything you do has to be so math and science oriented. Also, for the record, what you would learn at a trade school would be "programming". What they teach at university is "computer science". There is a pretty serious distinction, and I don't really believe you can learn computer science properly without a formal education (even if that comes from self-studying formal books - but teaching yourself javascript is not computer science).
- saint_fiasco 11y ago>Those physics classes will teach you to think about problems abstractly So do the classes on computer science and algorithms. The reason universities choose to teach those things using physics classes instead of logic class or algorithms class are just historical accidents. >And a few liberal arts classes are always good for breadth of education, and making you realize that you can always pick up a good book and read it You can get that for almost free at a bookstore or a library.
- brodawg 11y agoYes, the traditional courses do teach you that as well - to some extent - but the point is it's important to see how different fields do it. I think my classes in algorithms are as useful to my research in physics as my classes in physics are to my research in algorithms.
- MattSteelblade 11y agoI disagree. One of the most enjoyable classes I took was Weather and Climatology. Completely irrelevant to my current work and I paid a significant sum of money to take that required science credit.
- logfromblammo 11y agoStandardized tests can get you out of most "breadth requirements". That's how I picked up minors in both chemistry and cognitive science. Had I known then what I know now, I would have skipped even more of the fluff and spent my last two years splitting my time between classes and internships instead of learning additional facts and skills that ultimately had no marketable value. I can count on zero hands the number of times I have profited by taking those university classes not directly relevant to abstract mathematics, computer software, or electronics hardware. The supposed value of "well rounded graduates and alumni" seems very much like self-serving propaganda now. How about instead of spending three hours a week writing literary analyses of famous books, the university sponsors and organizes three mandatory hours of weekly networking events with real workers from relevant industries? That would have been worth the tuition. To this day, I still can't understand why anyone would want to read _Walden Two_ instead of doing something more useful, like separating and categorizing all the marshmallows from a box of Lucky Charms, or removing potential airway blockages in the nasal passages with the fingers.
- wfo 11y ago"Good CS knowledge" isn't 'learning git'. It's mathematics, theory of computation, recursion theory and type theory and PL, compilers, complexity theory and algorithms, advanced data structures, concurrency and distributed systems etc. If you know these, you should be able to pick up more applied subjects on the job quickly. You very much need a university to teach you this. Social sciences will make you a more well-rounded person able to see past just technical concerns. Physics and social sciences will help you understand the world around you. And it sounds like you want university to help you write business logic for accounting software, so an accounting class will do you well. If all you want to do is write simple code for say CRUD applications then you're right University isn't the place to learn that and a trade school would be better. In tech you already have the best trade school in the universe, the internet, and the best resume in the universe, a github. We have learned a long time ago that letting students decide to study exactly what they want when they are 18 gives you lopsided uneducated graduates who know a tiny bit about the things they were good at already; being well-rounded is EXTREMELY valuable, even more valuable than being an excellent programmer even in tech. The hard parts of software in practice are not writing the code, they are understanding what the user/client wants and how to translate that from vague fuzzy human communication to something specific and technical.
- gravypod 11y ago> theory of computation, recursion theory and type theory and PL, compilers, complexity theory and algorithms, advanced data structures, concurrency and distributed systems etc All of those are fairly basic topics that most people can pick up in an afternoon or two. These are all things that anyone who has been programming, reading, and interacting in the field of computer science understand. I could understand someone requesting that knowledge be provided to them in a college environment. What I object to is universities charging for the "well-rounded"-ness that you speak of. Can you please define for me what it means to be well rounded? From what I have seen is that no, no one can define what it means to be well rounded. What do you have to do to be well rounded? No, no one can tell me that either. Some how having gone through a university you are proscribed this trait of being in the "know". You automatically are transformed into a scholar, a person who is now magically "well rounded". Don't get me wrong, I think that there needs to be a structured curriculum, but only of things you need to understand make it in your respective specialization. For me, I'd love to get into building compilers, operating systems, digital signal processing, and general software development. For me, I'd say this is the perfect regiment for me: * Full understanding of the computer booting process, understanding of modern processor features. - Write a self hosting operating system, bootloader, and learn to write a BIOS for an example computer * Software maintenance and revision control - Following the current industry best-standard practices * High level math with a focus in signal processing * Familiarization with X top programming languages at the time of graduation - This should include standard formatting for each language, understanding implementation details, and full familiarization with X top used libraries and standard library * Understand logic and problem solving You may notice that I have annotated some of the things I feel I should learn, others I have not. If I have annotated it, it is because I have learned to do this on my own time and I want to expand that knowledge and I know it will help me professionally. The things I have not annotated are things that I have a basic understanding of, but I need someone to teach me although I am not getting that at a university. I don't know, maybe I'm wrong about this. I think these are fairly rational claims that I am making. Maybe I'm completely wrong and being able to quote shake-spear will help me when I need to learn the documentation for int 0x13 when I need to load a file on a 30 year old IBM PC when fixing a kernel level bug at some company, or when I need to write software to process data coming from sensors at 100GHz. Edit: Updated formatting.
- sologoub 11y agoThe accounting and other non-concentration classes are meant to give you a broader base of knowledge and better prepare you for adult life/career. Understanding basic principles of account is pretty important, if less fun. While this not realistic, if people were better educated about finance and understood that there really is no free lunch, the 2008 financial crisis wouldn't be as bad. Unfortunately, human nature is to say that this time it's different...
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoFive physics classes? Really? So... what subjects are those? Because you should definitely be taking at least a little physics and quite a lot of math.
- gravypod 11y agoI can opt out of the physics, but I'd have to take something like chemistry or biology. I'm taking the physics route because I feel that will benefit me specifically based on the carries that I'd like. I just rechecked, I think I need to take Biophysics, Astronomy, and nuclear physics with 1 bridge class between the three. Why? Because. I'd love to take the nuclear physics because that sounds fun, but and biophysics will make me claw my eyes out. Also, for my university I for some reason need to take 3 random 300 level classes and three electives as well as 3 PE classes, 8 social science classes. I can't for the life of me justify these in my situation. To be honest, I'd trade the time I would waste on this with CS classes branching into different fields. Maybe it's just me and that I know exactly what I would like to do with my career but this seems useless to me.
- selimthegrim 11y agoI'd pass on the nuclear physics, biophysics is where it's at these days. (Now if you meant particle physics you might have a point). But nuclear physics itself is kind of considered as a field whose heyday is past.
- gravypod 11y agoOr I can take thermodynamics hate my life. I have a few options, I just don't like many of them.
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoSpoilers: if you learn statistical thermodynamics, machine learning is easy.
- MisterBastahrd 11y agoThis isn't even a trade school. Trade schools definitely have classes and lectures.
- dragonwriter 11y agoBecause "universities" are primarily about research -- which is why that's the main criteria in hiring faculty -- and secondarily about credentialing students by granting degrees, and this new experiment is jettisoning the secondary function (leaving project completion -- including, e.g., research publications) as, apparently, the main concrete résumé-applicable output.
- gravypod 11y agoThe only point of a modern day university is that they are (a) exclusive, and (b) "guarantee" that students "know" what they are "taught". That's at least what people who hire think. I remember someone saying "It wouldn't matter if MIT only taught basket weaving as long as they still had such a thorough selection process". This holds true here. People only care about the pedigree of your degree, it's substance comes second in my experience.
- legutierr 11y agoBy this reasoning, you should put a list of the universities you were admitted to on your resume, not the university that you actually attended. Under these terms, what's the difference between going to Harvard for a couple of semesters and dropping out, and getting admitted to Harvard but deciding to attend Dartmouth instead?
- andreasklinger 11y agotbh i had more than one (young) application who mentioned the universities that "were their options" in job interviews
- gravypod 11y agoIf you have not joined the university you are not part of the "in" group. There is a perception among people that if you attend a "prestigious" university that you are smarter than someone who attends a community college. I find that crazy. Both teach basically the same thing. If they are both accredited, then it is almost indistinguishable. Who would you think is smarter off the cuff, a Harvard graduate, or someone who attended an accredited community college and followed it with a masters from an accredited online school? I'm sad to say that I've been programmed to assume that the Harvard graduate is smarter. It is just a bias that we are all taught as we are young.
- tedmiston 11y ago> I find that crazy. Both teach basically the same thing. If they are both accredited, then it is almost indistinguishable. Speaking just on computer science here, but the depth of CS courses varies radically across universities. Sure they all might follow the ACM model curriculum, but how much of the book you're actually reading (and which book you're using in the first place), the number and difficulty of practice problems you're assigned, etc. is definitely not basically the same. I went to an average engineering school, and also took a handful of grad classes. Many of the assignments in Master's classes were a similar difficulty level to the assignments in undergrad MIT classes on OCW. Not all of the courses were this way, but many were.
- pg_is_a_butt 11y agoher main focus was getting more minorities into the program. that is racism and sexism, and i'll be damned if i sit back and let some spic bitch ruin academia through prejudice.
- kania 11y agoSounds quite a bit like a more radical version of Olin College of Engineering not too far from MIT. From what I've seen that sort of education is more accepted by industry than academia so its a good solution for me. Having an expansive portfolio to show is a very powerful thing.
- ludamad 11y agoNow project based learning is fine, but CS for example has lots of wonderful theory, where does that fit in?
- tedmiston 11y agoThat probably depends on which parts of CS theory you're thinking of... the way my university taught CS theory for topics like data structures, algorithms, state machines, applied machine learning, etc. was fairly interwoven with programming projects.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoHow much of that theory do you have to understand in order to be a competent professional programmer? Some, sure. The more the better, sure. But much of it can be learned independent from much of the rest of it - you don't need one mammoth 4-year curriculum to "master" CS.
- ludamad 11y agoI learn a lot faster from the people who teach it well at university, and from focusing on the subject. But yes if you're goal is to become a competent programmer it is not strictly necessary.
- WhatsName 11y agoI personally think that's a highly interesting project. Is there any way to get regular updates on the progress?
- matt_wulfeck 11y agoWe don't need a "new" university system. We need to update our expectation about higher education and the work force. Let's start but dropping our mantra that everyone should go to college. Here's another: Maybe not everyone should even go to high school.
- Pharaoh2 11y agoBut everyone should go to high school. Hell, if you aren't going to college I do hope there is an extended high school. I don't care if its taxpayer sponsored but even high school is not enough to foster a critical thinking process. I picked that up somewhere between high school and end of college. Some people may be faster than me but that skill is really important. Either that, or you don't get to vote. Edit: The last statement was more about the ability to think critically and less about if you finished high school/college.
- matt_wulfeck 11y agoWhy do you think the only environment people can learn these skills is sitting at a desk for extended periods of time?
- Pharaoh2 11y agoI don't know what you did in your college, but I wasn't sitting at my desk for extended period of time.
- such_a_casual 11y agoWell in most highschools and universities children/people sit for hours at a time behind desks while someone talks. Did you stand for your lectures? Did you not have lectures? Is 6 hours a day not an extended period of time?
- Pharaoh2 11y agoHonestly, 6 hours a day in high school is nothing. For most of us that is the best use of the time that we have in a day when we are in high school. But it does provide the required base that is needed in college for a majority of the population. Are you saying we should stop the whole system for the benefit of the 0.1% (3 sigma)? In college lectures was from a minimum of 3 hours to maximum of 5 hours depending on how many credit you took in the semester. But the actual learning happened outside of those hours and once again lectures were important only to create the base, maybe even only to provide an introduction to the base.
- mywittyname 11y agoThis kind of hippiesque, free-spirit approach sounds fine for MIT-level students, but I have my doubts that this model can be effective beyond those highly driven individuals. Also, while I agree that you don't need a college degree to be a successful programmer or business person, most other science professions require some sort of structured learning environment and equipment to effectively teach students. Maybe I'm dumb and this professor is onto something. She has a degree in material sciences, so perhaps she knows first-hand that all the knowledge you need to learn advanced chemistry can be gained by someone with a garage and aspirations.
- Alex3917 11y ago> I have my doubts that this model can be effective beyond those highly driven individuals. C.f. Punished By Rewards.
- ohitsdom 11y agoI love projects, I hate school. Lots of details to work out (and questions of scale), but still sounds very promising and exciting. Not sure I understand the "no majors" bit though.
- paulojreis 11y agoMaybe I'm wrong - and I kind of hope I am, as there's a noble motive behind this movement - but I always feel that people are focusing too much on IT and the stories of a guy who became a full-blown IT professional learning by himself, Google and open courseware. I think this kind of approach to learning works for IT, because a) the logistics to learn it are easier to handle; but mostly because b) most IT jobs actually don't require a degree - or "degree-deserving" knowlege; most programming is "trade-school"-like knowledge.
- such_a_casual 11y agoSo all of those people with psychology and business degrees are going into jobs that require "degree deserving knowledge"? If you're going to say something special about a particular field, at least compare it to something else otherwise the statement is meaningless.
- paulojreis 11y agoI didn't mean to talk about the field in general. Computer science is, beyond doubt, "degree deserving knowledge". I just meant that most IT jobs don't require such knowledge and, in my opinion, would benefit from a more flexible approach to teaching. Something more trade school-like.
- thorntonbf 11y agoIt's exciting to see some thought and movement at this level. The existing system is broken when it comes to actual student knowledge. A lot of systems are to fault, but as the modern university has bowed to their corporate overlords in filling the pipeline of modern corporate key punchers, college has essentially become tech school for Power Point and Excel in a lot of cases. So many of our current college students would be so much better served by tech school. Heck, so much of this community often ends up eschewing college at large to go build something - often because the value proposition of the university model right now simply doesn't make sense. We're always going to need people who can think - maybe a bifurcated path where a lot of our university experience returns more to a true liberal arts education. This experience-based model wouldn't have been out of place historically. That it appears so revolutionary to us today shows how broken the current model is. Something has to change. I'm excited to see some movement around the borders.
- qwertyuiop924 11y ago...So long as she wasn't the one that killed SICP.
- beambot 11y agoA one year sabbatical to start a new university, where her long-term commitment depends on its progress after just one year. Doesn't inspire much trust to prospective students...
- systems 11y agoThe only point of a modern day university is socializing
- bobby_9x 11y agoThe current system was created for a reason: because for most people, it works. I ran a language learning group for a couple of years and we tried many different styles of learning. With no structure, most people flounder. Unless you already learned the material and just need it for review, it really doesn't work well. The best was complete structure: tests, lesson plans, and homework. Most people are passive. They want a teacher to lead them and guide them through the learning process. No structure will work with people that have the same discipline required to start a company, because they don't need someone telling them what to do.
- ausjke 11y ago"most people are passive", that's probably true and why we have lessons for all subjects for the majority.
- fao_ 11y ago> With no structure, most people flounder. I find the opposite -- it is impossible for me to get any kind of complex learning done while I am on a structured course. It's telling that I learned more in three weeks of being ill and choosing to passively read books on mathematics (While coughing my guts up, of course), than I did actively participating in a course. (The only reason I am participating in the course is because I need a bit of paper that says I can do foo. A few people working in foo field have said I am at their level, it's just mindless inane hoop-jumping.) > Most people are passive. They want a teacher to lead them and guide them through the learning process. Exactly, but IMO that is the fault of the schooling system itself. They've never had to learn anything themselves, because everything they know has been spoon-fed to them by their teachers. If we had a better (Differently structured) education system, then this would not be necessary. Although I do not see much hope for this happening, both Russell and Whitehead made attempts to improve the learning systems in the UK, neither prevailed. Apologies if this came across as a rant.
- tanker 11y agoI too learn more deeply outside of the confines of a structured class. However, I find the structure of an OCW course nearly ideal for many subjects. For me it seems to be at least partially a function of my ability in an area. The stronger I am in a subject, the less structure I need. I suspect the optimal amount of structure varies from person to person and within a person from subject to subject. People learn differently.
- ausjke 11y agothese days you can learn from online and books and forums if you're a self-driven learner, however the best universities do still provide a place for the like-mind people to get to know each other, which is important and hard to replace.
- digikata 11y agoIt would be interesting to compose your own 'major' program out of smaller granularity subject modules. So e.g. if one were interested in majoring in robotics, you could assemble a study program of something like basic CS, basic MechE, basic EE, then stack some other intermediate level subjects modules on top... Controls, Visual processing, etc...
- kedean 11y agoInteresting, but maybe not all that useful. The purpose of a major is to give others an implicit idea of what you studied. If I say I have a major in Robotics, then everyone can infer what that consisted of, even if it varies across universities (in which case that knowledge usually disseminates). What happens when I say I majored in robotics, but I failed to actually include anything on the hardware side of it and only really studied AI and control algorithms?
- digikata 11y agoA company hiring someone out of this new kind of university would look at projects the student worked on as well as their subject modules. But large projects can get fuzzy as to what the specific contributions might be, and the subject modules then give you an idea of that candidates background skill spread. So if the company were looking for someone in robotics for more of the software side, then it would be apparent from the studied modules that they might be a good fit. But more than that, it would give universities a model to continue creating a range of advanced or specialized subject modules. This would allow students or employees to come back and pickup new subject modules in a more integrated way to how the whole university operates.
- st3v3r 11y agoUnless it becomes the norm, what's more likely is that they'd just ignore people from that university unless they had a good reason not to.
- nurblieh 11y ago"I’m looking at a new model, where the whole sort of vocabularity is different" Impressive! Creating a new word in the same sentence you declare you'll be using new words. Assuming I understand her cromulent new word.
- joeblau 11y agoSo... Y Combinator?
- daveloyall 11y agoThey are talking about this, right? http://4pt0.org/programs/startup-weekend-education/ http://4pt0.org/programs/startup-weekend-education/ EDIT: No, probably not. Different Christine Ortiz...
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoThis sounds overly dreamy. At the very least, their new "university" should bother to award degrees when specific breadth-and-depth levels of knowledge are adequately demonstrated.
- rubicon33 11y agoDo you have an email address I could use to get ahold of you. I have a question about a post you made a few years back.
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoI do think my HN profile lists my email address, but if it doesn't, it's "$FIRSTNAME$LASTNAME@gmail.com".
- tanker 11y agoI like the idea of project based learning. I think it will end up being a more lasting method of instruction. I am interested in how they will still teach the breadth of the subject matter. For example, you can get a lot of work done with linear algebra without really understanding vector spaces. I assume this method of instruction would require more teacher-student interaction to be effective. The teacher could review the student progress on a project and make a note of where the application of a new technique would be helpful. Guiding the student towards a more complete understanding of a subject.
- danieltillett 11y agoYes you are right. This sort of teaching is very effective, but very expensive. The reason we have the current system we do is because it is the cheapest solution that somewhat works.
- CardenB 11y agoExcept our current solution has become very expensive. Perhaps we need to move out of our local maxima of education if people are willing to pay so much.
- danieltillett 11y agoYou can basically do this now if you really want. There are heaps of adjunct lecturers who will provide one-on-one or small group tutorials for cash. Wave a few thousand dollars a term in front of some starving adjunct and you will get exactly the education you desire.
- known 11y ago"You are a product of your environment." --Clement Stone
- bachmeier 11y agoSomething that concerns me, unless I missed it, is that there is no mention of the liberal arts. What is described here is closer to my view of what a university should be. (I'm in year 14 as a professor.) I think it would be a huge mistake, though, to not have a liberal arts core.
- manyoso 11y ago... "no grades, no teachers, no students, no books, no learning!"
- BatFastard 11y agoPersonally I love this idea. If I could send my high junior there I would in a heartbeat. But I learn by doing. Pattern for me is do, learn, do learn, repeat until complete. Never cared for the learn learn learn, forget 90%, now do.
- D3_4dl1N3 11y agoThe "42" (school) seems very promising, it's a private French computer programming school created and funded by Xavier Niel. To apply, there is no degree or diploma requirement, and it's completely free. The training focuses on project-based learning via a peer-to-peer pedagogy and allows students to set their own pace for learning. IMO The 42 school is not research-oriented, but rather emphasizes practical training suited to the needs of startups. www.42.fr
- st3v3r 11y agoSounds like a cool idea, and I wholeheartedly support attempts to distribute education so that all can benefit and contribute to the sum of human knowledge. However, one of the primary reasons for higher education (for better or for worse), is to get a job. Currently, most places are going to ask for your degree, or experience. What's someone coming out of this program going to have? And how long until most employers accept it?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- csense 11y agoFounding a new university can't be cheap. Who's going to pay for this? Does she have funding lined up?
- bhewes 11y agoEverything about this sounds like how an university use to work. I for one will back this idea. Nothing will stop a person from getting a 'real world' job after completion of the program. But it is clear that the program is not just specialist training, but geared to moving up the abstraction and generalization layers.
- melted 11y agoI think what we need are apprenticeships. I.e. a prominent research group hires kids after the remedial first two years of traditional college curriculum (or something like it plus a couple of years in an entry level job), and has them work on the actual problems at hand, filling the knowledge gaps as needed. It is no longer possible to know much of anything, so we should specialize and diversify at the same time, meaning that these students should be working at the seams between the fields: EE/CS, CS/Statistics, CS/Genetics, CS/Mechanical engineering etc. Further specialization should occur along the lines of whether the student would like to be a researcher, or have a more employable and practical set of skills. I never got much value out of lectures: few people can sustain rapt attention for hours a day. Most of what I know comes from the books. What I did get a lot of value from is working with people who know what they're doing, and from doing things myself, perhaps with their guidance and help. If this is heavily emphasized in this new model, I'm all for it.
- kaishiro 11y agoI could not possibly agree with you more, having basically lived through this. When I look at the current tuition rates for my alma mater, Northeastern University, it makes me cringe. However, the fact that the default experience at Northeastern requires a student to undergo multiple "co-ops", 6 month paid internships, is genuinely a smart thing in my mind. By the time I had graduated, I had work experience in embedded systems, a criminal justice stats analysis lab, the Red Sox, and a counter terrorism research center in DC. And that's all well and good, but the most important thing I took from it was that it taught me very quickly which sectors I did not want to work in. You often come out of high school with this idealized version of what it would be like to work in X field. To learn what that field is really like, and to learn if it's something you truly want to pursue, is a huge win in my mind for an undergraduate.
- melted 11y agoAnother thing that could be helpful is not forcing kids to go to school when they're 18. They have no clue whatsoever what they want to do with their lives and by and large motivation to truly learn something is very much lacking. Or at least I lacked it. My MSc with honors is a feat of willpower more than anything else, I ended up using maybe 10% of the knowledge I acquired in those years. Now if my career started in some kind of an apprenticeship situation, you can bet I'd have plenty of motivation to master the field. That's more or less what happened after college, except it's completely backwards from what it should be, and it's extremely wasteful: I ended up learning (and then, of course, forgetting) a ton of not even remotely useful stuff in hopes that I'd need it when I actually have a proper job. Some might say this is well rounded education, but I'd rather do it by choice, and not arbitrarily. The meta point is, traditional education is really broken, and it has been for decades. It's good that someone has the guts to go against the flow and do even a modicum of rethinking. Academic community is extremely clique-y and conservative, so it takes non-trivial courage to pursue something like this.
- cylinder 11y agoI have had the idea lately that liberal arts universities should be replaced with a year or two of critical thinking, logic, and emotional intelligence training. These are the skills necessary to enter the "modern" economy outside of STEM and trades, where the most valuable skills are thinking and emotional intelligence (relationship development and management). Link up with progressive employers who recognize the value of this training and are willing to take on young graduates and unleash them on their own internal domain knowledge for a couple of years.
- ajslater 11y agoSounds similar to Hampshire College in western Massachusetts. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hampshire_College https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hampshire_College The College is widely known for its alternative curriculum, socially liberal politics, focus on portfolios rather than distribution requirements, and reliance on narrative evaluations instead of grades and GPAs. In some fields, it is among the top undergraduate institutions in percentage of graduates who enroll in graduate school. Fifty-six percent of its alumni have at least one graduate degree and it is ranked 30th among all US colleges in the percentage of its graduates who go on to attain a doctorate degree (notably first among history doctorates).
- WalterBright 11y agoI wonder how she plans to teach them mathematics. I've yet to see anyone learn math on the job. The difference between a technician and an engineer is the latter knows the math.
- EGreg 11y agoI think degrees and accreditation are fine, but the classroom should be inverted. Universities should be a place for labs, socializing, and individual tutoring and exploration. Not lecturing. Unless it is just to give a talk that will later be put online.