6 ms·
Do you remember when the WSJ first started really dismantling the Theranos house of cards last fall, how a bunch of prominent VCs and publications like TechCrun
by Analemma_ 11y ago
Do you remember when the WSJ first started really dismantling the Theranos house of cards last fall, how a bunch of prominent VCs and publications like TechCrunch, with a lot to lose if the startup bubble pops, immediately circled the wagons? There was a lot of "this is a media hit piece", "we need time to evaluate the technology", "Liz Holmes is a visionary", etc. I wonder if we'll be getting retractions and apologies from those people.
- kwisatzh 11y agoI don't think so. People behind Theranos from the VCs to the media are too powerful. Nothing much would change, I reckon.
- w1ntermute 11y agoRupert Murdoch is also very powerful, and he's no doubt personally OK'd this WSJ-led takedown of Theranos, even though Kissinger and pals can't be too happy.
- randycupertino 11y agoI've been very impressed with the WSJ coverage of Theranos. The same reporters broke the CMS Medicaid Fraud in 2014 and won a Pulitzer Prize. http://www.wsjplus.com/invites/medicare http://www.wsjplus.com/invites/medicare
- mnglkhn2 11y agoI think WSJ got to play the role where they finally pull the trigger on this company, to help it move along to its demise. Sometimes you hope the management and the board get the message and unwind things when the reality shows you that that particular game is done. And if they don't, then somebody has to come along and provide the kick. Theranos is done, for all intents and purposes: no proven new technology and nothing interesting at all on the business execution side. Just pure founder ambition and aggressive PR/marketing. Not enough to string things along too much.
- CPLX 11y ago> Rupert Murdoch is also very powerful, and he's no doubt personally OK'd this WSJ-led takedown of Theranos You're aware that you're accusing the editors and reporters at the WSJ with a massive violation of professional ethics right? Is that your intent?
- escape_goat 11y agoI may be mistaken, but I took the intent to be ironic speech. A happy accident, if not.
- melling 11y agoIt's a little unclear how this letter changes any of that. You seem to be jumping on the "attack bandwagon" without actually examining the details of the letter. "Must mean the company is a fraud."
- dekhn 11y agoI examined the letter; here's what it says: Theranos's lab isn't CLIA-compliant in a way that potentinally puts patients at serious risk. DHHS is giving them 10 days to remedy some serious noncompliance issues (without reading the CMS-2567 form, I can't see for certain what magnitude they are), but this is very serious. If Theranos doesn't reply satisfactorily, DHHS will fine them daily and possibly revoke their CLIA certs as well as their ability to take Medicare money. I think most people had already concluded that the company, if not outright fraudulent, was being very careful to hide a number of negative facts about their product's deficiencies. At this point nearly every scientist I know thinks their tech doesn't really work as well as they claimed, so it seems unlikely the company should have the valuation it does.
- aminorex 11y agoSections 1215 and 1250 say that they don't follow manual procedure requirements. Not surprising, given that the focus of the enterprise is automating laboratory procedures. The remaining sections cited are requirements on the staff operating the lab. The letter infers that the staff do not conform to regulatory requirements. Again, this is not surprising given that the function of the enterprise is to remove humans from the process. I find the outrage a bit outrageous.
- dekhn 11y agoNote that any automated lab today still requires many manual procedures, and the staff have to conform. It's totally inexcusable, within the current legal environment, to not satisfy those conditions. Their lab isn't some gleaming, hermetically sealed iLab with only mechanics and computers inside. I will note that I placed a caveat that I didn't know the magnitude of the violations, but be aware, this is an extremely serious problem for Theranos, they have no excuses, they would have known what to do ahead of time, and they certainly wouldn't use the reasoning that their lab is partially automated so they don't need to comply with manual procedure requirements.
- argonaut 11y agoWhat I saw was a lot of tech people and VCs cautioning against a rush to judgment. Which is totally reasonable. I for one will leave this up to the regulators to figure out. The people who invested in the company will lose (some/most/all) of their money. No need for us to get whipped up into outrage.
- timr 11y agoI'm not outraged by Theranos, but I do feel that stuff like this makes it all the harder for legitimate science to get investment, by "raising the bar" on the number of stupid, oversimplified, breathless claims you need to make to get noticed. Real science is too messy to be able to compete with a press release from a sufficiently motivated huckster -- and investors love a huckster in lab coat.
- yeukhon 11y ago> by "raising the bar" Don't worry. Theranos failed even some of the simplest tests so how is that going to raise the bar at all? Work safety should not be a casual business gesture. It is as if you expect you raise money and you don't provide some insurance for your startup hires. No way. Anyone doing laboratory work should be careful with regulations. Wearing goggles and no smoking in the lab should be really basic. I don't expect anyone following the whole manual, but common sense yes. Simple tests, yes. Standard procedures should still be practiced.
- andygates 11y agoDoesn't real science ... publish real papers? Or at least file patents. It's the secret sauce that's so suspcious. To a skeptical outsider, it whiffs of e-Cat.
- timr 11y agoYeah, but investors don't often read papers...let alone have the expertise to know if they're any good. It's pretty common for investors to commit money based on good spin and social proof. Theranos has excelled at both.
- VeilEm 11y ago> if the startup bubble pops Therano's problems neither indicate a "startup bubble" exists nor would it pop it if there was a bubble. The bay area economy is larger than the economies many countries and one company that doesn't yet have significant revenues doesn't have make much of an impact. Theranos isn't the Bear Sterns of San Francisco. The problem many troubled unicorns face is that they guaranteed results to get high valuations in their late stage investor financing. Their problems are exactly that, just their problems.
- lvs 11y agoOh yes. This company exists in a vacuum, just like all the private capital that's propping up your local economy. I can't possibly imagine the mechanism by which the perception of failure might cause private investors to stop investing in things. Certainly, most investors don't read the news or sites like this one, so there's no way they might know that the unbridled optimism that fuels growth of unproductive companies could be approaching a precipice. Investors will obviously stay the course, continue dumping ever more capital into pointless apps and SaaSy startups, not to mention mysterious vaporware technologies like the one in question. It's nothing like that shameful bubble from the late 1990's when more public investment was involved, since everyone knows that perception requires a public market.
- Asparagirl 11y agoIt is unlikely that this is the only start-up with such large problems, it's just that this is one of the more obviously fraudulent ones. There is rarely just one cockroach.
- pbreit 11y agoNope. All I remember was hit after hit. So many, I actually started to feel sorry for Theranos. Despite that it's looking more and more like it doesn't have the goods and may not get there. And has operated very oddly.
- jfb 11y agoI mean, talking your own book is a thing. Did anybody really think that the money hovering over Silicon Valley wouldn't do this? I am put in mind of the parable of the scorpion and the frog.
- Asparagirl 11y agoIf you want to see a long list of those "Theranos should ignore the haters" statements, just check out Elizabeth Holmes' own Twitter feed's Likes. She basically curated her own handy list of everyone who was holding their fingers in their ears and saying la-la-la-can't-hear-you: https://twitter.com/eholmes2003/likes https://twitter.com/eholmes2003/likes