13 ms·
This is the ultimate problem with "trickle down" economics. Capital doesn't drive growth. Lack of capital limits growth, but excess capital doesn't generate a
by jandrese 11y ago
This is the ultimate problem with "trickle down" economics. Capital doesn't drive growth. Lack of capital limits growth, but excess capital doesn't generate additional growth. Demand drives growth and 35 years of stagnant wages (wages are basically where they were in 1981) have put a chokehold on growth.
This is why you have the seemingly incongruous effect of high taxes encouraging growth and low taxes stifling it. Ultimately "high taxes" tend to effect the rich a lot more than the poor, and the money ends up being redistributed somewhat equally, spurring demand as the poor can suddenly afford a lot more good and services.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- partiallypro 11y agoThat's not "trickle down" economics, which is not actually a real thing at all. That's a nonsensical political term that the Democrats seized upon during Reagan's "supply side" economic policy; which has beginnings much earlier than Reagan, and likely older than Jean-Baptiste Say's formulation. There isn't an idea that alone "capital drives growth," that's an idea that Keynes came up with by misreading Jean-Baptiste Say. Paraphrasing him to say that "supply creates its own demand," which we all know is nonsensical, but that's not what Jean-Baptiste Say was saying. The idea is far more complicated than your simple explanation offers, though I sympathize with your view (though, at least the second paragraph is almost entirely wrong), it is narrow in its scope to the study of economics.
- ricardobeat 11y agoIt doesn't really matter who said or misunderstood what, does it? I don't mean this as a personal attack but your comment is devoid of content.
- Animats 11y agoThere is a school of economics, sometimes called the "freshwater school" (from the Chicago School and Milton Friedman) which claims you can't run out of demand. This is a classic position. But productivity is now so good that we can run out of demand. Classically, countries ran out of land, labor, capital, or management before they ran out of demand. There were occasional recessions, but that wasn't a permanent condition. That's over in the US. Plenty of land outside NY and SF, lots of workers (some might need retraining, but it's not like the real labor shortage of WWII), oceans of capital, and lots of experienced managers. But nothing to do with it, because the demand isn't there. This is an alien concept to many people and economic policy makers. See the parent article. They report on a capital glut, but are puzzled that it exists. The Fed keeps pumping capital into the economy in hopes it will fuel growth. But pumping capital into a capital glut doesn't do much. Look at Japan since 1989. Japan hit this about two decades before the US did. They never really figured out what to do about it. That's discouraging, because if Japan had a solution, we'd have a success to look at. So nobody really knows what to do about a capital glut and a demand shortage.
- duderific 11y ago> But pumping capital into a capital glut doesn't do much. I believe this is a phenomenon captured by the term "Pushing on a string."
- jmorrow977 11y agoInstead of injecting money top-down through the Federal Reserve and large banks, they could inject it bottom-up in selected industries. Invest $1 trillion in biotech. Some will succeed and produce amazing advances. Most will fail, but they'll still drive employment, education, services, etc. targeting that industry, driving down the cost of inputs to the biotech sector for decades. Of course, this can be done not completely blindly, by investing 10 to 1 with existing investors, or providing a guarantee to return 50% of lost capital, or having milestones companies need to hit, or have experts in the field provide "votes" toward getting higher levels of funding after examining their progress so far.
- nradov 11y agoWe don't want governments trying to pick winners, or generally even having an industrial policy at all. Their track record has been far worse than private investors. And politically it's impossible to justify when a large government investment fails. For example, look at Solyndra. At better approach to stimulating demand would be to offer a cash prize or a guaranteed purchase contract for specific innovations that meet defined criteria. For example, what if the US federal government offered to purchase 10 million doses of a 90%+ effective Zika virus vaccine at $100 per dose? I'll bet that would encourage private investors to take a gamble.
- betenoire 11y agoYou are suggesting what already exists, plus a guarantee. How does your guarantee change behavior? We already have the expectation of payoff for success, that's how we got to this point to begin with.
- jmorrow977 11y agoWell, if the government is going to drop money from helicopters, I would at least prefer they ATTEMPT to do so in a way that might lead to some scientific advancement. They could also just send everyone a check for $1000, but although that would create some demand, it wouldn't likely lead to investments in long-term payoff high-risk science. I understand and somewhat sympathize with the idea that we don't want the government telling us to do with our money, and maybe we should let people spend that $1000 however they want, but I'm proposing trying to kill two birds with one stone here and also at least ATTEMPT to put the money initially in the hands of people trying to create something rather than just consume some basic goods.
- mehwoot 11y agoThere isn't an idea that alone "capital drives growth," that's an idea How is it not an idea and an idea simultaneously
- twic 11y agoEconomics.
- ubernostrum 11y agoThe fundamental concept of "trickle down" -- legislate to further enrich the already-wealthy, and those less well-off will become more well-off as an indirect effect -- is way older than Reagan. William Jennings Bryan bashed on it in his "Cross of Gold" speech in 1896.
- grahamburger 11y ago> money ends up being redistributed somewhat equally, spurring demand as the poor can suddenly afford a lot more good and services. Does it? Maybe I'm just cynical but the idea of raising taxes on the wealthy sounds to me like just moving money from one set of rich white guys to another set of rich white guys. I vote one of them in to power at the local elementary school and the other every time I pull out my wallet. I'm not really convinced that either group as a whole spends their money more responsibly. If we already had a social safety net reform in place, knew how much it was going to cost, and then pushed for higher taxes in order to directly fund the new safety net, that would be different. I think that's what PG meant recently when he said something along the lines of 'focus on poverty, not on income inequality'.
- Retric 11y agoGovernment spending often involves a huge number of well paid workers. The phrase "Good enough for Government work." started because governments often have very high standards. ex: Compare accessibility on the web between government websites and startups. It's been diluted for various reasons that basically boil down to indirect corruption. PS: One of the odd things is just how poor people used to be. Work minimum wage for 1 week and you can avoid starvation for ~1 year. Yet, people used to regularly starve.
- hueving 11y agoThat's not what that phrase means at all. "good enough for government work" is akin to "close enough", a reference to the half-assed nature of most government work.
- Retric 11y agoThat's what we take it to mean today. And sure it was used in a negative context as early as 1960, but was first used in 1906. Remember historically most people where poor by our standards. Yes, the things that survive where of high quality, but a lot of junk did not make it. Consider what a 'sod' roof meant. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sod_roof#/media/File:Norskfolkemuseum_1.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sod_roof#/media/File:Norskfolk... Now picture such a thing without modern materials to keep dirt from falling on you. Granted, the floor is often hard pack dirt anyway and done well it's ok. But, again poor and minimally trained. PS: Sure, if you where rich or competent you could go beyond that standard and there was plenty of high quality stuff made. But, the average farm house, private trail, foot bridge etc... was crap.
- seivan 11y agoCapital seems to drive a lot of jobs to create startups that hire people. They might make it or they might not but at least they produced something that might eventually grow. Without capital dev jobs. No dev job, no sale job, no marketing jobs and etc. What we both want is basic income. But I'm not sure about taxing "rich" who could easily leave. Then you're not taxing the "rich" any more.
- vkou 11y agoThis is only the case in frothy markets, like the Valley.
- hfourm 11y agoI hate the argument of the rich "leaving" Where are they going to go? And once you come to the logical conclusion that only a few outliers will actually "leave", they will leave a void that someone will fill, and be taxed.
- seivan 11y agoI'm not sure about American prefences but in Europe people tend to use Switzerland, Monaco and Malta. In Asia, you have Hong Kong and Singapore, both relatively safe and decent countries. Maybe Macau, but I'm not sure. You're also assuming the government can just "implement" the "ideas" you have and everything will be alright. As if they really rich will give in without resistance. It doesn't work with drugs, it won't work with money. You add laws, they find loop holes, and I'm pretty sure the private sector can afford smarter people than the government. The government will be too slow and inefficient to tackle this, unless you turn into Germany BOM ;-). So now you're spending resources to gain resources, which... might stimulate the economy, sure, heh gotta spend money to make money, aye? Jokes aside, to make things easier, imagine the war on drugs. It doesn't work no matter how much you yell drugs are bad. You can tell "tax" the rich, but as an idea it doesn't mean shit, unless you manage to implement it, which I have my doubts. The best solutions are always the most pragmatic ones, it can be hard to see it when ones views are clouded with personal feelings. I can admit I that there are some things I wouldn't want to compromise on.. again, Germany. I'm also suspecting you're assuming leave as in physically leaving, you're in for a surprise when you find out that the truly rich can have the cake and eat it so no one would "fill" their void if there are options, and there will always be options for someone who is truly rich. Otherwise you just end up taxing the shit out of regular employees, some who makes higher salaries in volatile markets. Your conclusion isn't logical. Human nature, machines, etc etc.
- jmorrow977 11y agoI'm coming around to the opinion that taxes on income are a bad idea. Income flows to people as they're trying to accumulate wealth, trying to climb from lower to middle to upper class. Higher taxes on income, especially highly progressive taxes, make it harder for people to move between social classes. The focus on income tax creates a situation where the person who makes $200k/yr but has a net worth of $0 gets taxed far more than the person whose investments bring them $100k/yr and they have a net worth of $2,500,000. Oh, and their lifestyle might be about the same despite the disparity in income, because one of them needs to work for a living so they'll need to live somewhere close to jobs, pay more for transportation, etc. Higher income tax is great, if you're already wealthy. If I was wealthy, I'd be very happy people if stay focused on that. But I think taxing accumulated wealth is a much better way of leveling the playing field over time and also making sure capital stays in productive use. France already has something like a 0.5-1% "solidarity tax" on wealth, and it's a progressive tax. According to Piketty, the return on capital has historically been around 5% per year, and returns are better at scale. For multi-billion dollar funds, the rates are around 9-10%. The "Financial Independence/ Retire Early" people who plan for pessimistic scenarios say to expect 4% return. Let's say it's reliable to expect 2-3%. At $10M a person can expect about $200-300k in income. If we have a wealth tax of 1% their investment income after taxes reduces to $100-200k. If they want to maintain their previous standard of living, they need to make about $100k per year. At $100M let's say economies of scale start to happen and even in a pessimistic scenario you can expect a 4% return. If we have a 2% wealth tax at this point, the person can still expect an investment-only income of $2M per year. You can see where this is going. At $1B with a 5% pessimistic return, 3% wealth tax, $20M investment income. At $10B with a 6% pessimistic return, 4% wealth tax, $200M investment income. The nice side effect of this is that the mere scale of capital doesn't provide competitive advantage. The wealth tax should be designed to even out the advantage of scale so that larger accumulations of capital need to be put to best use. Putting some numbers on the napkin... The US has an aggregate net worth of $85 trillion dollars. The federal budget is $4 trillion. Assuming a power law distribution of net worth, let's guesstimate an average 2% tax on that $85 trillion, which comes out to $1.7 trillion. We could roughly cut income taxes in half or eliminate them except at very high levels ($1M+) if we used a wealth tax instead. The important thing to note here is that the wealth tax still leaves about 2% investment income, it doesn't reduce the total over time. I think it's great that people can accumulate wealth and then live on it, or pass it on to the next generation. But it would be great if we can keep the income at around 1-2% so that the nearly guaranteed increase in accumulated wealth is the same or less than the growth rate of the economy, meaning that people who build businesses today have the ability to reach the same heights as those who built businesses yesterday, without extraordinary luck or blunders by those with wealth.
- kobayashi 11y agoJust for clarification, and I know you did not mentioned the GOP, but Republicans did not champion the idea of "trickle down economics". http://rare.us/story/memo-to-liberals-theres-no-such-thing-as-trickle-down-economics-you-made-it-up/ http://rare.us/story/memo-to-liberals-theres-no-such-thing-a...
- tomcam 11y agoThis is the ultimate problem with 'trickle down' economics. What economists/politicians promote something called "trickle down" economics? This is why you have the seemingly incongruous effect of high taxes encouraging growth and low taxes stifling it. Reference, please?
- evbots 11y agoThe money gets distributed somewhat equally? I beg to differ... I live in DC and if there's one thing government spending does, it increases the number of Lamborghinis on the road. A lot of the new money around here comes directly from government defense spending going to consulting firms which has a strong tendency to make the rich even richer.