17 ms·
Federal cops gets pulled over by TN cops, car illegally searched
- mindslight 11y agoIf police departments were responsible for paying for the collateral damage they create and even deliberately exacerbate (time wasted, damage to the car, and emotional distress from assault), this problem would fix itself overnight. "Probable cause" is not a justification for evading responsibility to their victims.
- prawn 11y agoNot sure that's the solution as they'd probably then be paralysed to inaction in valid cases too.
- smileysteve 11y agoThat seems in line with innocent until proven guilty. "Probable cause" without any repercussions if it's wrong, probably isn't very probable.
- newjersey 11y agoWASHINGTON, June 27 [2005] - The Supreme Court ruled on Monday that the police did not have a constitutional duty to protect a person from harm, even a woman who had obtained a court-issued protective order against a violent husband making an arrest mandatory for a violation. http://nytimes.com/2005/06/28/politics/justices-rule-police-do-not-have-a-constitutional-duty-to-protect-someone.html http://nytimes.com/2005/06/28/politics/justices-rule-police-... But city lawyers are arguing that the police had no legal duty to protect Joseph Lozito, the Long Island dad stabbed seven times trying to subdue madman Maksim Gelman — a courtroom maneuver the subway hero calls “disgraceful.” http://nypost.com/2013/01/27/city-says-cops-had-no-duty-to-protect-subway-hero-who-subdued-killer/ http://nypost.com/2013/01/27/city-says-cops-had-no-duty-to-p... I'd say they're already doing a good job of inaction.
- mindslight 11y agoThe case can't be too valid if the police aren't confident the person is guilty. It sounds exactly like more detective work would be advised, to avoid harming innocent people. But yes obviously it would be less efficient to fund the true cost of policing, rather than leaving it the reverse lottery we have now. But not doing so is essentially a violation of due process, as the victims are extrajudicially punished based on mere suspicion.
- tajen 11y agoInnocent suspect indemnisation might lead to every pull-over resulting in a charge.
- mindslight 11y agoTime wasted in court and lawyer fees would be added to the list of damages when the victim is finally found innocent. The police and the prosecutor might argue over which one is responsible, but I'm sure after the first few cases of malicious persecution they'll have it figured out.
- brbsix 11y agoPrivate (rather than public) law enforcement would be a good solution. The end result is cost and quality competitive service. The lack of immunity results in much more conscientious policing.
- blin17 11y agoI hear of a lot of startups working on image detection and sound detection, but I'm wondering why there isn't anything done for scent detection. Maybe A2D for scent doesn't really exist yet, but it would limit the need for drug sniffing dogs
- Xcelerate 11y agoI too have wondered this. It seems like it would be relatively simple to create a device that can detect drugs more accurately than a dog. The only problem might be that creating such a device might cost significantly more than training a dog.
- brazzledazzle 11y ago>It seems like it would be relatively simple to create a device that can detect drugs more accurately than a dog. It could be simple but tied up in patents I suppose. I have a feeling if it was even remotely simple it would be prevalent in airports though.
- wallflower 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_nose https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_nose Electronic noses in specialized niche use cases is past startup phase and well into industrial implementation. However, the nose of a trained dog exceeds electronic capabilities. In fact, an electronic nose that good might be equivalent to a Star Trek tricorder. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Detection_dog https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Detection_dog http://mythbustersresults.com/episode74 http://mythbustersresults.com/episode74
- DanBC 11y agoIf they can accurately smell drugs they lose probable cause to search cars and confiscate cash. They are incentivized to have false positives.
- hyperbovine 11y agoOlfaction is really amazing. (Even the crappy human version, to say nothing of e.g. canines.) We can build cameras that see better than eyes, microphones that hear better than ears, but there is no technology that comes close to matching a nose. Sure there are some special-purpose sensors that measure the precise concentrations of particular gases, but nothing so general as a what's found in all sorts of different animals. It's not even clear how to quantify smell, for that matter.
- mikestew 11y ago"If you look in slow-motion, the dog passes an open window on the passenger side with no alert. The handler then leads the dog around the front. Then, on the driver's side, he turns his body around and gestures toward the window. Suddenly, the dog sits. That's the alert." As I've always suspected. I could take just about any random dog from your local animal shelter and train them to do that in about 20 minutes (look up "clicker training Zach" on YouTube, watch what he can teach in half that time). And point at the window is the cue? Amateur hour. Given the amount of time given to train a K-9 unit, I could come up with something much more subtle, and I only train dogs as an amateur volunteer, not a professional K-9 trainer. Alternatively, many dogs that I've trained long-term will default to "sit" when they can't figure out what you want. Could have been that the dog didn't know what "point at window" means, but the mutt knows it means something. Doggy runs through his mental database, comes with no match for "point at window", defaults to "sit". TL;DR: the more time I spend training dogs, the more I'm convinced that drug dogs are about as reliable as polygraphs, if not worse because the handler can game it.
- stordoff 11y ago> many dogs that I've trained long-term will default to "sit" I've definitely seen this with my dog. Say her name, and see just looks at you. Say her name and raise your hand up flat, and she'll sit straight away. Say her name, and do some other hand gesture, and she'll pause for a few seconds and usually (90% of the time I'd guess) sits down.
- duncan_bayne 11y agoI've seen that. We did some obedience competition with one of our dogs. If she didn't understand a command, she'd cycle through the first three things she learned (sit, down, roll over) until stopped :-)
- tonyarkles 11y agoGlad to see that our dog isn't too weird with that behaviour! When she doesn't know what to do, she cycles between sitting and laying down, pretty rapidly. Great entertainment!
- greenleafjacob 11y agoCan't wait to see these officers hailed into court on a 1983 action.
- stonogo 11y agoWon't happen. Rural cops are entirely autocratic.
- jmiwhite 11y agoConfusing title - to add some clarification from the article: > He's a federal police officer at the Marine Corps Air Station-Miramar in San Diego. Ronnie, the male passenger is employed as a Federal police officer, but his wife (driving) does not have her employment specified, nor are they driving an official vehicle or on Federal business. He also sounds more worried about losing his job than having his employer go to bat for him: > "It makes me angry that someone would attack my character because not only do they attack my character, but that could cost me my job," Ronnie said.
- meric 11y agoIf there were two tiers of citizenship - the police and the non-police - and the former has an implicit right to confiscate assets from the latter, of course anyone would worry about losing their police job.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoEven off duty cops (from different jurisdictions) aren't immune.
- newjersey 11y ago>> Watts is also off the road, but by her own choosing. She remains with the Florida Highway Patrol but no longer looks for speeders because she is afraid her fellow officers would no longer back her up in an emergency. http://miami.cbslocal.com/2013/11/26/fhp-trooper-donna-watts-last-stand/ http://miami.cbslocal.com/2013/11/26/fhp-trooper-donna-watts... even on duty officers doing their jobs aren't immune... if you don't follow the blue code of silence, the blue code will stalk you.
- LordKano 11y agoI hadn't heard of this case before but it'd not a surprise to me. It's completely tangential but I have taken great delight in the reaction of people to Making a Murderer. I have talked to people who are in absolute disbelief that police officer can and do act that way. I tell them that they're only surprised because they haven't been paying attention.
- rubberstamp 11y agoAgain, why is there a loop hole for illegal search and seizure? There have been lots of news coverage on illegal search and seizure for last couple of years, but it still happens very frequently. How can it be solved? May be a new constitutional right should made it to law that guarantees a no fuss recourse path for every law if you believe you have been wronged. Without people actively participating in democracy, its going to rot.
- such_a_casual 11y agoYou'd have to get rid of the war on drugs. And then you'd have to prevent the government from pulling the same thing with a new "enemy" like terrorism.
- puredemo 11y agoConsidering how ingrained authoritarianism and hierarchical thinking is to humans, good luck.
- rubberstamp 11y agoCurrently laws doesn't have alpha or beta testing phase during which problems with it are identified and fixed. They go straight to production and then they are not maintained with changing times.
- SapphireSun 11y agoThat's not totally true. Very often the congress will authorize pilot studies or regulatory agencies will grant waivers to run experiments. Additionally, congress will put in sunset clauses into laws so that they must be reviewed periodically or automatically expire. However, these tools are not necessarily used consistently at any level of government....
- rubberstamp 11y agotake the case for usa freedom act or patriot act or any law that snoopers cite in their support. i've never seen any pilot studies on them whatsoever. please dont cite private studies or studies conducted by snoopers themselves. all laws needed to be tested, not just some or atleast when its abused massively, the law should be reviewed.
- stordoff 11y ago> [We] took the dashcam video to a nationally respected respected expert Redundancy aside, this seems like a pointless thing to include in the article if you don't even name the field in which he is an expert.
- anon4 11y agoSounds like he's an expert on respect.
- rdtsc 11y agoThis has been known for a many years and many people who have been searched figured it out. Dogs are a key element in letting them rob people on the side of the road. We hear those K-9 are treated as officers, someone shoots one, and the sentence for that is usually pretty harsh. It takes years and many tens of thousands of dollars to train them. But they are worth their weight in gold. They are the the magic voodoo doll that hacks the 4th Amendment. You say 'no', but, the puppy says 'yes' and there go your rights. It is pretty magic. What is interesting here is that person who was searched got to present his story to the news and it was published as is. --- "NewsChannel 5 Investigates asked Ronnie, "You are convinced that they cued that dog to hit?" "Yes, 100 percent," he said. "There is no doubt they cued that dog." --- Usually traditional media takes the side of the cops. At best, they would make the cops' version sound just as plausible as that of victim of the robbery (hrm ... I mean, the person who was detained). So, of course, what makes this story, is the occupation of one of passengers -- he is both a cop and a veteran. That is front and center in the article. It is emphasized mutiple times, even in the HN title. We don't want the audience to forget that and think he is just a regular janitor or plumber here! I believe that says a lot about the beliefs that go around -- that cops are somehow more honest, and noble (and so are the troops). This aspect, is just as interesting to look at as the story itself. In order to stop this behavior, it is important to change that attitude, first, and then it would be possible to talk about fixing the laws that allow this to happen.
- mason55 11y ago> It is emphasized mutiple times, even in the HN title. We don't want the audience to forget that and think he is just a regular janitor or plumber here! I believe that says a lot about the beliefs that go around -- that cops are somehow more honest, and noble (and so are the troops). Interesting thought. My reaction to the headline was "good, as a cop people will listen to him and he's in a better position to help change this." I'm sure plenty of people out there are more likely to believe him and, while I'm not, he could become a useful spark for change. Even if he's lying there are thousands of other people who experience the situation for real.
- rdtsc 11y ago
- emcrazyone 11y agoI'm a little surprised that Ronnie even engaged in an apparent argument or conversation with the cop. A very good friend of mine who is an attorney and has given me the following advice which I give to an officer anytime I'm stopped. It goes like this: Officer, please understand - after I identify myself with my name and date of birth (and proof of insurance if I am driving a motor vehicle) I am refusing to answer any questions until I have a reasonable opportunity to consult with my attorney. I refuse to take any field sobriety tests including: reciting letters and counting numbers, letting you look into my eyes with or without your flashlight, or any other physical tests performed outside my vehicle until I consult with my attorney. I refuse to get out of my car unless you order me to do so. However, I still refuse all field sobriety tests. I will show you my hands at all times so that your safety will not become an issue. I refuse to consent to the search of my vehicle, my person, my belongings, or any premises with which I have an expectation of privacy, including my residence, hotel room or any other rented room without the reasonable opportunity to consult my attorney. If you have probable cause to search you do not need my consent anyway. If I am not under arrest but you are going to issue a traffic citation please do so immediately so that I may go about my business. If I am not under arrest and no citation is going to be issued please tell me if I am free to leave so that I may go about my business without further interference with my liberty. If I am under arrest, please tell me immediately so that I can cooperate by submitting to your authority because I do not wish to resist or obstruct your official duties. If I am under arrest I wish to invoke all my rights under Miranda. I want my attorney. I won't answer any questions, perform any field sobriety tests or consent to any search without a reasonable opportunity to obtain the advice of my attorney. Then I shut up!
- RealGeek 11y ago> Then I shut up! What if the cop feel threat to his life by your long speech and verbal resistance?
- emcrazyone 11y agoI don't recite that. I have it printed on a piece of card stock about the size of a business card and I hand it to them along with my driver's license, proof of insurance, and registration. I simply tell the officer I am exercising my right to remain silent as I hand him/her these items - then I shut up. I've only used it once and it seem to work. So I guess I can say I have one data point where it was used. My attorney friend has this printed on his business card and this is the advice he gave me - to do the same.
- metasean 11y ago>(Story originally created Nov. 10, 2014) >Posted: 12:20 AM, Jan 18, 2016 >Updated: 4 hours ago Does anybody know what the update was?
- geggam 11y agoWhat amazes me is how people are putting up with this. Why arent we putting the highway robbers ( police ) in prison and having emergency elections for new sheriffs so they can deputize honest people ?
- tck42 11y agoThey target out of state drivers; presumably the people who have the power to elect new officials don't care.
- mahyarm 11y agoYou start getting special police attention if you try to start a political movement against them. Most people don't have the time and inclination to do so, and the ones that do are often incoherent or do things that shoot themselves in the foot, like the people who blocked the SF bay bridge on MLK day.
- joesmo 11y agoThis is what happens when you let dogs make legal decisions. Thank you Supreme Court.
- kordless 11y agoI had this exact same thing happen to me coming into Oklahoma from Texas, while I was living in Dallas for a few years. I'm actually from Oklahoma, so I was going back to my Dad's at the time so I could renew my license plates. One thing I will note is that I won't allow someone to tell me they think I am lying, if I'm not lying. I don't have to rationalize with someone who blames and speak for others. The best possible thing to do is get of of the car and lock it behind you and stuff your keys in your pants the absolute second you are stopped. When they start blaming and speaking for you, tell them they are doing so and you won't allow it. You can then keep your mouth shut until the officer makes a choice between hauling you in and towing the car, or letting you go. Nobody has to make things "right" when there's nothing wrong to begin with. By keeping the amount of stuff you say to one of these jackasses, and what they have access to, greatly limits their ability to fuck with you.
- socrates1998 11y agoWhat I don't get is why isn't the dog "search" considered a search? I mean, if you don't concede to a search and they don't have probably cause, how can they have a dog then search your car? It seems like having a dog search and smell around your car would constitute a search by every legal definition? And this would be a breach of your rights against illegal search? What am I missing?
- wnevets 11y agoThe dog smells the outside of the car (the public part) and if the dog "finds" something they have probably cause.
- ssanders82 11y agoIt's the same as if the cop looked through the window and saw a baggie full of weed on the dashboard. Anything which is exposed (sights/sounds/smells) to the outside world isn't considered a search.
- mmaunder 11y agoYet another reason it's a great idea to get your own dash cam if you're doing long road trips.
- danso 11y agoThe submitted story has a confusing timestamp. It's dated January 2016, but there's a line that says "(Story originally created Nov. 10, 2014)"...I suspect it's a problem with the news site's CMS (which is probably shit, a situation most news sites have to deal with)...they probably created a new URL to package this story in their larger ongoing investigation. In 2014, Radley Balko blogged about this incident: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-watch/wp/2014/11/12/policing-for-profit-in-tennessee/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-watch/wp/2014/11/12/... Obviously doesn't change the impact or interest in the story (if anything, goes to show how much interesting news you can forget about or not know about when it was originally published), but the submitted title needs a "(2014)" in it. I was interested if this story went anywhere, but a Google search for Ronnie Hankins name didn't turn up much.
- ipsin 11y agoIs there anything in the article to support the claim in the title, that the car was "illegally searched"? As much as it galls me, my understanding is that this kind of thing is procedurally legal. Drug dogs can "alert" based on nonsense, and that forms the pretense for a legal search. The Supreme Court seems willing to say "you can't be held waiting for a drug dog" (Rodriguez v. U.S.), but doesn't seem to be willing to adjudicate the accuracy of those dogs. My personal belief is that they should be banned, unless we're willing to hold them to a very high accuracy rate. Like, if consequences of a false alert are "career-ending", and not just "Tuesday afternoon". But as much as I hate this, describing it as "illegal" seems inaccurate.
- SixSigma 11y ago> "You felt violated?" NewsChannel 5 Investigates asked. > "Yeah, I felt violated. He didn't want to hear it." Objection your honour, leading the witness.
- sheraz 11y agoThis makes me think there should be an app / GPS plugin that will alert all drivers which stretches of highway are prone to this type of search. Then it would automatically reroute as if that stretch were under construction.
- cmurf 11y agoPolice as the highwayman.
- tobyhinloopen 11y agoI read these kind of articles for years now. Why isn't there anything done about this? The Police in the US is just corrupt and must be dealt with. I would love the visit the US sometimes, but stories like this just make me feel like the US is just a very dangerous place to be. Not because of the people with guns, but because of the police that is as corrupt as any 3rd world country's police.
- pjc50 11y agoI say this as a non-American, but there seem to be two Americas. The first one is the Norman Rockwell vision of plenty and freedom. It really is like that - for some people, mostly white (or at least not black), in some places. Given how big America is, that means there are tens of millions of people who never see the bad side. Or when they do, assume that those involved deserved it. The other side of the coin is for the people who end up on the wrong side of the internal colonialism. There's a lot of brutality there, but (like with many 3rd world or marginal countries) it's avoidable as a tourist. The one thing you do have to make sure as a tourist is not to get in trouble with the border check agents.
- vinbreau 11y agoI have a friend, ex-military, very clean cut, pretty 'normal' guy. His brother is a cop. We both grew up in the same rural area. I used to be a punk kid, crazy hair and clothes, but a good kid, definitely not a criminal. I was constantly harassed by police, even had to file charges once against a cop who assaulted me on private property at my father's place of employment. My view of the cops is very different from him. He gets absolutely offended if I talk bad about cops. He really sees them as noble people with only a few bad apples. He says people like me just like to talk up the bad cops to make the rest look bad. Or it was my own fault for being so outside societal norms that of course I would be the target of constant suspicion.
- vetler 11y agoWhat was the turning point when cops became the bad guys in the US?
- tyingq 11y agoThe turning point is probably not that their behavior changed, but that it began to be exposed. First, when video cameras became easily attainable by regular people (Rodney King), then later, when almost everyone starting carrying a video camera (smart phones).
- NoGravitas 11y agoFrom the beginning[0] (follow the link to chapter 2). [0]: https://books.google.com/books?id=QWNhCgAAQBAJ&lpg=PP1&pg=PT44#v=onepage&q=2:&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=QWNhCgAAQBAJ&lpg=PP1&pg=PT...
- CPLX 11y agoIt happened right around the same time that every citizen was issued a portable audio/video recording device of high quality and the means to share the results. A phenomenon that coincided with a sudden drought of UFO and Bigfoot sightings, coincidentally.
- slaxman 11y agoAs someone from a developing country, it really shocks me to read stuff like this about the US. Mainly because we kind of look up to their justice system to be better than ours. Yes, there are police harassments in my country as well. But it's not this bad. And apparently what they did is legal, which is really shocking.
- goodcanadian 11y agoI am virtually certain that it is illegal on a lot of counts, but that circumstances and the law make it very difficult to fight in an effective manner.
- Pxtl 11y agoSimple solution: track the accuracy rate of drug dogs. If a drug dog has a false positive rate of over 50%, then it can't really be callse "probable cause" can it? Probably not, more like.
- TheCoelacanth 11y agoYour simple solution has already been tried in Florida v. Harris. The actual false positive rate was ~80%, but the court still found that it could be used as probable cause.
- addicted 11y ago"So why not say yes?" This is how the article frames the situation, somehow insinuating that the default is to let the cops violate your privacy. However, the law is very clear on this aspect. The default is No. The cops have to find a valid reason to be able to search. There is absolutely no reason why a citizen should allow for a search, and doing so can only hurt, not help, them.
- mattdeboard 11y agoPretty sure the article wasn't insinuating anything like that. It was just a journalist asking an obvious question so the interviewee explains their thought process in more detail.
- kelvin0 11y agoBandit de grand chemin (highway robbery): https://translate.google.ca/translate?hl=en&sl=fr&u=https https://translate.google.ca/translate?hl=en&sl=fr&u=https: //fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bandit_de_grand_chemin&prev=search "Under the old regime the offense was punished with the torture of the wheel"
- bigbugbag 11y agoIsn't that a known fact that US police train their k-9 to false alert to get probable cause for a search ? There's this video by Ex narcotic police officer Barry Cooper that features a segment on k9 false alerts: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j-mU77Pie44&t=23m30s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j-mU77Pie44&t=23m30s
- ceejayoz 11y agoIt's very possible many of these cops have no clue they've subtly trained the dog to alert. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clever_Hans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clever_Hans
- karmakaze 11y ago> He believes the dog may have inadvertently been cued to hit on their car. How do they explain how the dog was 'inadvertently trained'?
- brbsix 11y agoFirst they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Socialist. Then they came for the Trade Unionists, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Trade Unionist. Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me. Sort of difficult to empathize with a federal police officer ever-so slightly maligned by the application of a terribly unjust national drug policy. Too little, too late.