13 ms·
Apple May Be Using Congo Cobalt Mined by Children, Amnesty Says
- yomism 11y agoThink different? No, exploit the same.
- valleyer 11y agoYou really don't think this is a sin of omission? The abuse is happening multiple suppliers away from the companies in question. And Apple, Microsoft, and Samsung are reportedly implicated. I'm not pessimistic enough to think they are conspiring to keep Congolese children abused. None of this excuses it, and now that is brought to light I expect at the very least that these particular vendors are dropped. But comments like yours seem either intentionally inflammatory or very naive.
- realusername 11y agoIt's just that Apple (unlike Microsoft and Samsung) brands itself as a company with human values so obviously people are paying more attention to this aspect for Apple. But yes, I agree indeed.
- stinos 11y agobrands itself as a company with human values How so? (never got that impression, but I'm also a fervent ad/commercial skipper) Anyway I really doubt any of the electronic devices any of us have is completely clean (wrt this topic). Not sure if such a thing even exist. At least with clothing or so you can get alternatives if you want.
- zimpenfish 11y agoApple do go to (what seems to me, your mileage may vary) reasonable lengths to produce supplier chain responsibility reports and manage such accordingly. Which I guess is the "branding" mentioned above but I'd also guess the intended (snarky) meaning was "empty branding" rather than "branding by doing" which seems to be the case. [edit: minor tweak for clarification]
- yomism 11y agoOf course is intentionally inflammatory, for the sake of discussion at least :) The problem (as mentioned in other comment) is that Apple positions itself as the company that does thing different, the company for the creative people that "cares". And even if I don't hate Apple per se, I like these moments where the wind blows open the courtain, just for a moment, and we can get a peek of the insides of the machinery of our capitalist system. It is the same that happened with the Snowden leaks, we all suspected it but the reality was worse than expected. But hey, I earn my bread developing mobile apps and change phone every year so I'm guilty as charged. But in some twisted way I love to see the way we ignore how things work in the reality when it causes us some disconfort.
- m_st 11y agoOur electronics are composed of so many modular elements that no single company can produce them all entirely. Not even Samsung. It must be very difficult to track down all suppliers on the chain and control and monitor them. All while still making a profit (even for Apple). So I expect the usual behavior here from Apple: Remain silent, listen to accusations first, prepare a good reply and take necessary actions. Quite exemplary in my opinion.
- k-mcgrady 11y agoThere's already been a statement from them, although it doesn't say much more than if they remained silent: > “Underage labour is never tolerated in our supply chain and we are proud to have led the industry in pioneering new safeguards. We are currently evaluating dozens of different materials, including cobalt, in order to identify labour and environmental risks as well as opportunities for Apple to bring about effective, scalable and sustainable change.”
- blockross 11y agoThat mostly sounds like your typical marketing statement to me though, which is of course the best available move in their situation. Sourcing every component for a manufacturing company's supply chain in a responsible way is hard. Especially because tracking these components is made hard by shady providers who know or - for those higher in the chain - suspect that the components they provide are produced/extracted by children and/or exploited workers. But it's basically a "don't ask don't tell" situation where investigating what happens further down the chain can only cost you money or stir up shit, so as long as consumers don't complain there's no business incentive to do that. Obviously Apple is not the only company involved in this, but contrarily to their claim they don't lead the industry at all on this matter. If we had to elect a leader I'd argue it would rather be Intel, see this entry from a week ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10874850 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10874850
- cbeach 11y agoFrom the article: "mobile-phone and laptop makers such as Apple Inc. and Samsung Electronics Co." I'll up vote stories like this when they have the right title. Not one designed for clickbait. Apple goes further than most companies to inspect its supply chain and improve working conditions. So it grates to see Apple singled out for criticism here.
- camillomiller 11y agoYep. At least in this instance it's a safe clickbait. It won't change people's minds and won't affect the stock price, which is awful and tells a lot about what investors really care about. The titles only subtracts some more dignity to the publication and unfortunately to the no-profit organization that's sponsoring its important findings by using Apple as an easy proxy for the industry.
- vmateixeira 11y agoWell.. you wouldn't admit you already knew that your products where manufactured in such conditions, would you? There's a whole market idea and brand image to protect... "Let's just play the blame game and make the guilt vanish somewhere else."
- chippy 11y agoTo admit to oneself that the brand and the feelings that the brand makes is wrong actually causes actual psychological harm. It is more logical to defend any attacks. Further, for Apple, most HN/Startup types have the whole suite of Apple products, hardware and software. They have invested tens of thousands of dollars, each, over the years in this brand. To admit to oneself that they made the wrong choice and wasted all that money causes actual bad psychological hurt. Further, for Apple users that have invested thousands of days, each, over the years in using the products and software. To admit to oneself that they made the wrong choice and wasted all time causes actual bad psychological hurt. Far easier, and logical and less harmful it is to defend your substantial investment.
- vmateixeira 11y ago
- VeejayRampay 11y agoPeople already know that their phones are made using materials excavated in awful conditions, then built in awful conditions by minors in Asia and then sold at ludicrous prices around the world. The consensus seems to be (based on my observation) that no one really cares. We can keep on sharing those links to articles that stimulate the outrage for about 10 minutes, might keep social networks fuzzy for a few days, but in the end, it doesn't change anything. Sweatshops still exist, kids are still being exploited. Either people stop buying those goods (and that is NOT happening ever) or start buying green/human-friendly alternatives at 3 times the price for 1/10th of the quality or it will keep on keeping on. It's sad, but it is a reality, as grim as it is.
- derrida 11y agoI don't believe consumer choice is the only agency we have. Can you imagine any others?
- BillyParadise 11y agoAs long as these "exploited children" have no BETTER options, the cycle will continue.
- fucking_tragedy 11y agoChild labor laws in the US put an end to kids losing their childhood, body parts and lives so that they can exploited for a profit. There is no reason such laws cannot be implemented where they currently aren't. We also have the ability to stop US based companies from selling products produced by foreign child labor, but we don't.
- thirdsun 11y ago> There is no reason such laws cannot be implemented where they currently aren't. In countries like Congo there are probably quite a few.
- T-zex 11y agoApple, Samsung, etc. are incredibly wealthy companies, making massive purchase orders. They are capable of impacting entire industries. They must ensure they have clean and ethical supply chains with no excuses. They could also force their competitors to do the same shifting focus away from the patent crap.
- Polarity 11y agodo we really need new devices every year/month?
- BillyParadise 11y agoI keep dropping my phone, so for me, yes.
- vmateixeira 11y agoJust buy a damn 3310!
- froo 11y agoOh man, my Nokia 8910 (the one with the titanium casing) was damn near indestructible. I'd dropped it more times than I can count (once off a 2nd story in a nightclub into a dance floor where it was promptly trampled), backed over it accidentally because it fell out of my pocket as I got into the car and left it in my pocket and washed it 3 times (it stayed on the whole time). The 4th washing was the one that finally killed it.
- r3bl 11y agoWe played football in the classroom with my Sony Ericsson K700i when I was in high school. I still have holes in my wall because I kept throwing it every time some game annoyed me. My charger died, so I disassembled it and put the wires directly on the battery. Finally, I accidentally crossed the wires and the phone died after burning for like 2-3 minutes.
- kbart 11y agoApple, as other companies of such huge size with extremely complex supply chain, don't go too deep to inspect what their contractors do. They turn a blind eye, because it's all down to the matter if you can come up with an excuse and remain clean: "we don't know and physically can't check what all our sub-sub-contractors do, but we will no longer deal with them until they fix it" etc. Unless we have laws that hold all involved parties accountable, such practice will prevail.
- thirdsun 11y agoIn my opinion Apple seems to be going to reasonable lengths to keep its supply chain clean. I think you underestimate the challenge of making sure that suppliers 2, 3 or 4 levels apart from you play by the rules. I work at a small company that uses, among other things, fabrics in their supply chain and even at the second level it's very hard to confirm simple specifications that are much less interesting or scandalous than the topic at hand. I wouldn't want to imagine how difficult it is to do the same thing when it comes to scandals and issues that the supplier of your supplier 3 levels deep actually really, really wants to hide.
- kbart 11y agoI agree that it's a very hard problem and the change of the whole industry is required to fix it. But I believe, with enough resources and will it would be possible. The problem is, that nobody actually cares -- it's all about PR now only. For example, let's take food industry where regulations are enforced on all levels and restaurant, after poisoning their clients, can't simply say: "Sorry, we didn't mean that, we had no idea these mushrooms came from Chernobyl, but rest assured we won't deal with this supplier again".
- yomism 11y agoAnd we happily buy their products absorbing their marketing message: "you are a creative and nice person that does good for the world (using our products, that is)". And when faced with the reality that Apple is a money making machine and is only worried about doing a bad thing if it dirties its public image detracting from their marketing message our cognitive dissonance starts screeching. So we, buyers of their products, are good people because they say their products are for good people, right? Look at the thread and find the comments that say "they will remove the contractors, apologize and so they will return to being a good company, they are the best!". Samsung sure is worst in their practices but at least they don't coat their public image with a hippy-happy-creative good natured coat. They are a ruthless asian electronics conglomerate behaving as such.
- golergka 11y agoWhat I don't inderstand about this outrage is, will the Apple declining go buy from this supplier actually change these children lives for the better or not? This child labour happens not because of particular supplier, but because of economic situation in the whole country. If Apple switches from Congo mines to cobalt from more developed places, won't it just make Congo even more pure? Right now, these children work in mines because they need to survive; but if the mines close, doesn't it mean that these children will just loose the means to survive an end up being hungry instead? (Please notice: I'm not making statements, I only ask questions. I don't know enough about this to assume anything.)
- anon1385 11y agoYou're looking at things only in terms of purely economic transactions. The reality is that plenty of kids "working" in dangerous mines are not there because they made some rational choice to accept the risk in exchange for enough money to buy food[1] but because of threats of physical violence. To put it another way they are slaves. [1] why would we even expect children to have the capability to make those kinds of decisions rationally anyway?
- calibraxis 11y agoYes, these children are integrated into a system where we benefit from their child slavery. And our economic theology keeps many of us from seeing the situation simply. ("They're better off as child slaves! They should probably thank us!")
- golergka 11y agoAre you suggesting that "seeing the situation simply" is a good thing?
- calibraxis 11y agoOh yes. Like people here echo Rich Hickey's or Dijkstra's words on Simple Made Easy. (Rather than trap themselves in hairball codebases, gradually unable to move forward.) Like people who reject the complexity of epicycles, that desperate theological attempt to preserve Earth at the center of the solar system. (https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/0e/Cassini_apparent.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/0e/Cassini_...) People will tie themselves in complex masochistic knots, to justify the absurd conclusions of their religious beliefs ("the invisible hand!"). As we see here in this discussion of child fucking slavery.
- lez 11y agoNope. It's me and you who actually give money for gadgets manufactured on far-east, exploiting the hell out of ppl.
- daemonk 11y agoHow far removed from the purchasing chain is someone/organization deemed "morally clean"?
- Khaine 11y agoIt's the same in all industries. Look at airlines. People aren't willing to spend $x to have actual legroom. Everyone only every buys the lowest cost. Or clothing. And modern supply chains are so complex thats its impossible to ensure that 100% of the time policies are complied with. And are the people in these places better off with that job, then without? (i honestly don't know, but surely this is a factor)
- chinathrow 11y ago> And modern supply chains are so complex thats its impossible to ensure that 100% of the time policies are complied with. That might be true but it's still only an excuse at the end of the day.
- Khaine 11y agoTrue, But even if you want to do the right thing the complexity makes it hard to maintain accountability. You audit your supplier, and they have sub suppliers and sub sub suppliers and sub sub sub suppliers. How far down the rabbit hole can you go?
- eitally 11y agoYou're the second person I've seen post this about airlines in the past two days (I believe the first was on Reddit). I have thought about it and don't actually believe it's 100% true. People buy what's cheap at the time they need the ticket. The problem is price variability/gaming by the airlines. You can very easily see >100% variability in the price of the same ticket from one day to the next, and it has nothing to do with objective variables. It's pure price manipulation, just like everything else airlines do (baggage, food, boarding order, upgrades, elite lounges, free drinks, point bonuses).
- Khaine 11y agoI'm not sure what airlines are like in America, but in general (where I am) people only look at price and then complain about it. See http://www.slate.com/articles/business/moneybox/2014/12/cheap_airlines_why_americans_will_suffer_worse_service_on_flights_in_order.html http://www.slate.com/articles/business/moneybox/2014/12/chea...
- Khaine 11y agoIt's the same in all industries. Look at airlines. People aren't willing to spend $x to have actual legroom. Everyone only every buys the lowest cost. Or clothing. And modern supply chains are so complex thats its impossible to ensure that 100% of the time policies are complied with. And are the people in these places better off with that job, then without? (i honestly don't know, but surely this is a factor)
- Shivetya 11y agoInstead of vilifying the corporate interest involved this needs to be resolved by trade restrictions at the national level. Why is it that we only seek to shame the companies who buy goods produced in these countries but never our politicians who don't do anything to get the country involved to improve? Trade sanctions, freezing assets, and more, can get a country's leadership to act appropriately.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoMy pet theory is that we all implicitly know politicians won't do it. I'm yet to see a sanction that was actually about human rights, and not about some political or economical goal. The world leaders seem to care about human rights violations even less than the evil megacorps.
- AnAfrican 11y agoYou'd punish a whole country for the actions of a rebel warlord that the government is actually fighting ?
- r0muald 11y agoIn case it's not widely known, take this as an opportunity to look at the FairPhone http://www.fairphone.com/ http://www.fairphone.com/ that seeks to address exactly this problem.
- lenlorijn 11y agoFor those who want to know a bit more about FairPhone and specifically how they address cobalt mining. They have a pretty good video and a blogpost about the sourcing of cobalt. Blogpost: https://www.fairphone.com/2013/03/14/a-fair-price-for-cobalt/ https://www.fairphone.com/2013/03/14/a-fair-price-for-cobalt... Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WWVFXesVScA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WWVFXesVScA Full disclosure: I once worked on a part of FairPhone's webshop.
- SyneRyder 11y agoI like this answer, because it starts proposing a solution (and executing on it). Though I'm not entirely clear what the Fairphone solution is, as the blog post & video seem to be at the fact finding stage. I assume it was through deploying extra on-site inspectors, setting up a union & paying more for the cobalt? The other issue is that Fairphone has produced 60,000 phones, but Apple has made 700 Million. Can the Fairphone solution scale 10,000x? How does the co-ordination of inspections & unions change if you increase it by 10,000?
- bigbugbag 11y agoThere's an interesting 2010 documentary "Blood in the Mobile" about the issue of conflict minerals from Congo in mobile phone. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_in_the_Mobile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_in_the_Mobile http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1763194/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1763194/
- twoodfin 11y agoReading the comments here, I'm surprised at how broadly the terrible situation in the Congo is being generalized. This is not one immorally-sourced component among many, it's a massive outlier: A rare element with its richest mineral source in one of the poorest, most chaotic and war-torn nations on the planet. It's correspondingly an incredibly hard problem to solve. At an extreme, Apple probably has the cash to buy its own mines for cobalt but how can they ensure that their suppliers use it exclusively? It's a fungible commodity, after all. If anyone has any ideas that don't revolve around armed 'humanitarian' intervention in the DRC, I'd love to hear them. Also, I'd be interested to hear what problem #2 is if this one could be eliminated. My suspicion is that its degree of horribleness would be a significant drop-off.
- dogma1138 11y agoSigh. Why are people even surprised? This won't change and can't change until we stop yelling "think of the children!" and only demanding for the suppliers to do a better job. Yes some suppliers might be able to do a better job but many cases they also simply can't it's just the nature of doing business with under-developed countries. Similar processes like the Kimberly process that was supposed to stop the trade in conflict diamonds have utterly failed and this is an industry that is built around artificial scarcity which just was dying for an excuse to further limit the production of diamonds to jack up the price. There is very little any supplier can do to actually address this problem, this isn't some large scale mining operation that uses children this is for the most part unofficial mining. Unofficial mining (AKA the official past time of small scale African warlords) is pretty much a bunch of people taking over abandoned mining sites, dump sites for mining waste, sites that were deemed to be uneconomical to develop or just being down stream from the actual mine. While it's true that these sites are often taken over by some gang of former child soldiers and their master (we all liked Beasts of No Nation) more often than not these days unofficial mining is conducted by communities, villages, and individuals who do not hold any one at gun point. These unofficial mining operations do not produce any substantial amount of note (individually, however there could be 1000's of small scale mining operations vs only a handful of large scale official ones which means that anywhere between 10-50% of a given product might be mined unofficially) but they do produce enough to say feed a village (or to buy the wanna be warlord a BMW from the 80's even diamonds are sold for not even cents on the dollar, every 1$ in uncut stones that ends up in the hands of the miner is inflated to 1000 to 10000 by the time it ends up at tiffany's). Those unofficial mining operations are getting mixed with what the big actual mining operation produce and end up in the supply chain, this can happen at so many points that there is no way to enforce any process which will guarantee that the supply is clean of conflict, child labor or any other social decree. Even if you take out the child labor part which while horrid is by far not the worse part that can happen to a child in Africa, the conditions in the official mining operations for registered adult miners are also appalling and so far beyond what most of us could even imagine human beings being able to withstand on a daily basis. So instead of yelling that we should vote with our wallets until those supply chains will be clean we need to realize that they will never be clean as long as you are dealing with a region such as the Congo. Instead of making another pointless process which will just going to be circumvented at all levels while jacking up the price for the end consumer (which every one in the supply chain, especially as it gets closer to the source will just pocket the difference). Companies should put the money that consumers would end up paying into programs that might actually work and not into the endless pit of bribes that any certification process would turn out to be when facing the unmovable object which is reality. Apple can switch a supplier and it will, but it won't find a clean one as no such supplier exists even if they'll find the most expensive one with the best intentions. Because the local population which runs these operations will always have the upper hand and as long as the conditions exist that make it more likely for children to end up digging up rare earths for your smartphone or diamonds for your tennis bracelet this won't change. I hope the day would come where a company like Apple could be brave enough to come out and say look we can't buy Cobalt which wasn't mined by kids, but we made a calculation that if we could it would be 17% more expensive so we are jacking our own prices by 17% and transferring the difference to X Y and Z in hopes that in 20 years we could buy Cobalt which was not only not mined by children but also mined by miners with life expectancy which is longer than our yearly product cycle. But as long as people would keep on yelling boycott this and boycott that it will never happen and the only thing Apple can do is to continue to play the pass the hot potato game with it's suppliers (which will continue to restructure and change names to be put back into that list) and maybe have Tim Cook do an apologetic we are the world cover...
- acd 11y agoPhones must be a 100% recyclable so that we can reuse their materials or earth will become a giant wastedump.
- at-fates-hands 11y agoThe most ironic thing here is that the current CEO of Apple is the guy who was so focused on the bottom line at Apple while Jobs was the running company, he forced many of the suppliers to guarantee certain production goals at insanely low labor rates to maximize profits. If you want someone to demonize, you don't have to look very far.
- jacquesm 11y agoThere isn't a complex consumer good that does not have at least one part of it that somehow was produced in circumstances that are abhorrent. This is something that is a societal - and even a global - issue, not one limited to specific brands, though there are brands that are more directly involved in these horrors.
- ianstormtaylor 11y agoWhy is the title here only "Apple", when the article's title is "Tech Giants" and it mentions Apple, Samsung and Microsoft?
- twoodfin 11y agoAs you can see from the URL, the original title was the more click-baity one that ended up on HN.
- jjtheblunt 11y agoSensationalism and attention seeking is why. And the subjunctive mode indicated by "may" usually evaluates to "is not" in new articles. There's some "law" associated with that sensationalism news article observation, but I don't know its name offhand.
- mattdw 11y agoBetteridge's Law of Headlines states (roughly) that "headlines in the form of a question can usually be answered with 'no'". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...
- jjtheblunt 11y agoThanks!
- mahranch 11y agoKeep in mind it's "usually", not "always". Some people take that law to mean "always", especially here on hackernews.
- ratsmack 11y agoI have seen many articles change their titles after they are initially published. Maybe it is from companies or readers pushing back when they feel the headline is unfair.
- ilostmykeys 11y agoApple is evil to the core (pun pun pun)
- wahsd 11y agoUgh! These damn SJW types are so f-ing annoying. Sure, I get it, kids are mining cobalt in destitute, far flung places. What are we thinking, they should all be sitting at home in their McMansion and jacking off to internet porn and insulting people's mothers on XBox Live all day like other spoiled ass rotten crotch-fruit.
- dang 11y agoComments like this aren't allowed here, regardless of the view you're expressing or criticizing. Please post civilly and substantively or not at all. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html
- randyrand 11y agoDevils advocate: Schooling is expensive and not every country can afford it. Before schooling, children used to work year round as soon as they were able. In fact big families were primarily for the labor. Isn't this better than families being poor and dying from starvation? This is part of the growing pains of being a developing country.
- davidgerard 11y agoMisleading title. Actual title is "Tech Giants Accused by Amnesty of Using Cobalt Dug by Children", and companies named are Apple, Samsung, Microsoft and SDI, because they buy from one dodgy Chinese cobalt company.
- trhway 11y agoworldwide enforced minimal labor and environmental standards is the only way to go. And like with war crimes and crimes against humanity such standards should be enforceable by any nation anywhere in the world.
- ommunist 11y agoAnd we all consist of sizeable chunk of carbon released from industrial age pollution, when slavery was an ordinary thing. So - how should I pay Amnesty International, or Greenpeace for acknowledging that my internal chemistry uses immoral carbon atoms?