8 ms·
Wow, this article looks like it's pushing some agenda hard. They took one quarter that was pretty much the same for NA and Asia and much better for Europe as th
by StavrosK 11y ago
Wow, this article looks like it's pushing some agenda hard. They took one quarter that was pretty much the same for NA and Asia and much better for Europe as the comparable quarter in 2014 and use it to report "fundraising drops"?
Looks to me like someone is trying to actually bring about fundraising drops by using spurious data.
"Q4 2015 pretty much the same as Q4 2014, the sky is falling!"
- blazespin 11y agoInterest rates have finally gone up. Money has become 2x expensive. Everyone was predicting the bottom would fall out of tech when this happened.... and it happened. TBH, the fed should not have gone from 0.25 to 0.5 That was really really dumb. They should have gone from 0.25 to 0.3 or something. My guess if the bleeding keeps up, the Fed will have to do a rate cut. Should help things. Since I got downvoted, let me show the math: For an entity borrowing at fed funds rate, on 100B loan that is 250M to 500M annual payment after the hike. If it were 2.5% to 2.75% on 10B, that would be 250M to 275M. See the difference? Even a 50bp hike would just be 20% higher payments. If you're surviving at the edge of these loans, then doubling your payments could easily wipe you out.
- walterbell 11y agoInterest rates are expected to continue rising in 2016.
- zwischenzug 11y agoIt's interesting that Fed members have downplayed the recent volatility: http://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-usa-fed-dudley-idUKKCN0UT2JE http://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-usa-fed-dudley-idUKKCN0UT2J... '''"The short-term volatility is not something that worries me for monetary policy; it reflects market participants trying to make sense of global developments," Williams told reporters on Friday, adding that he sees no signs of distress or a weak economy in declining asset values, and is unsurprised that stock prices .SPX would decline as the Fed raises rates.''' That's a pretty clear signal that the Fed have knowingly and openly popped a bubble. This is going to be painful.
- Spooky23 11y agoI think there's something to be said for spring cleaning. If your balance sheet is such that the incredibly marginal increase in borrowing costs is anything other than a bump, than you are a dead man walking anyway.
- blazespin 11y agoThe economy structured itself around near ZIRP rates. We were at .25 for a long time which gave whole industries (not just VC) the chance to live on the edge of their financing. This wasn't a marginal increase. It was a very dramatic tightening. Marginal would be going from 2.5% to 2.75% or 3% .. this was doubling. And they did not telegraph anything. If you tracked the CME fed funds probability you'd see that it waffled up until a couple of months beforehand and we were at 0.25 for a very long time. The reason 0.25 used to work as a min step was because a) we were never at such low rates for so long before and b) things didn't have a chance to settle into a particular rate structure so it wasn't really an issue. The difference this time was everyone started building businesses based on 0.25 and had time to do so. Agreed, you shouldn't be doing that. But heck, the economy is pretty messed up so the rules have changed.
- zwischenzug 11y ago"And they did not telegraph anything." - are you kidding? It has to be the most telegraphed interest rate rise in history!
- blazespin 11y agoYes, and then they waffled and said they'd do a rate rise based on the numbers coming in rather than any strict ideology of having to raise the rates. When numbers turned south, the CME probability declined.
- Shog9 11y agoI'm reminded of folks who ignore evacuation orders during a hurricane, latching on to any small lull as evidence that the storms will lift before it's too late. Of course, one tends to hear these stories after it is too late. No doubt plenty of people ignore the warnings and get by just fine, right up until they don't. And then it's someone else's fault.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- marcosdumay 11y agoI don't get why people downvote posts like this. Well, I disagree with your comment on policy, but yes, anybody that was on the edge is pretty toasted right now. The important question is whether VCs were there.
- Silhouette 11y agoOn the other hand, anybody whose financial situation was severely affected by a widely predicted and minimally sized increase in extremely low interest rates was pretty toasted anyway. If you're looking at medium-term financing options -- on the scale of multi-year business loans, mortgage fixed rate periods, and the like -- in most of the Western world, you should probably be considering whether you can afford at least 2.5% interest rate rises over the next few years, not just 0.25%.
- marcosdumay 11y agoThe point is, it's not a minimally sized change. You double the interest rate, you half the amount of money big institutions have available to roll around. I happen to think it was a good decision. But why does everyone insist on calling this change "small"?
- jeffwass 11y agoSo if the rate was zero, and they increased it by 0.01%, your claim would be that it was an infinite rate increase, and big institutions would have zero money to roll around?
- marcosdumay 11y agoIf the rate was zero the, incredibly small attrition banks suffer while creating money would completely determine how much money is in circulation. If not for it, yes, the amount of money would go to infinity, and would get down infinitely much by any positive rate. My point is, this attrition turned up to be incredibly small, and still irrelevant at the US later interest levels.
- aNoob7000 11y agoI think the Federal Reserve telegraphed the rate hike enough. They've been talking about raising rates for over a year now. If you're finances are so shaky that a quarter point rise is going to cause you financial stress then that's your problem. Maybe some of these companies need to start making money and before they are valued at a billion dollars.
- roymurdock 11y ago1. Not all money has become 2x more expensive. Extremely short term loans have become marginally more expensive for the borrower. Mid and long term interest rates remain largely unchanged, on downward trajectory. 2. You changed the amount of principal in your example. A company that goes under due to an expected 0.25% bump in short term interest rates was in extremely poor financial health to begin with. 2. I was under the impression that VC firms typically raise money from a pool of investors and they take a cut of the % return to those investors. How likely is it that VCs are financing a substantial (if any) portion of their investments through short term loans subject to the short term interest rate? 3. The minimum possible FFR adjustment is 25bp (historical, not a hard rule but a custom) 4. Fed does not adjust monetary policy to suit specific sectors of the economy 5. Fed has committed to getting to 2.0% core inflation by 2018 [1] and would not have risked credibility loss by raising rates if it did not intend to continue to hike (and hike fast) [1] http://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/fomcprojtabl20151216.htm http://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/fomcprojtabl201...
- branchless 11y ago0.05%. Good grief, if you can't run your project on a 25bps increase then sorry your idea might have to go under. As others noted it wouldn't double your payments as tech doesn't have access to overnight rates with zero spread.
- cmurf 11y agoThis is just absurd. You're looking at just one part of the economy and whining about 25 basis points? It's just... annoying. Get out of the kitchen if you can't handle a match stick. The last time the housing market was this hot, the federal funds rate was 5.25% or 10x what it currently costs for banks to borrow. Rents from L.A. San Francisco, Denver, Chicago, New York, are climbing at double digit rates year over year. The overwhelming majority aren't getting the kinds of salaries and wage increases to afford such increases. The Fed had only been saying rates need to go up for 2 years before they actually did it, but did the market price this in? Not entirely, a good chunk of the market was in denial about the inevitable.
- MathsOX 11y ago>That was really really dumb. They should have gone from 0.25 to 0.3 or something. That's not how interest rate setting works at all. Plus, the Fed is still using a banded window that encapsulates your five basis point rise. What company is borrowing at Fed Funds rates? If - theoretically, because we have to be quite theoretical to operate under your assumptions - a company was that exposed to interest rates and had zero hedge against interest rate vol they would not have the credit to hope to get funding anywhere near Fed Funds rates. If you're surviving at the edge of loans (i.e - you're in a potential distressed scenario) you'll have bonds trading at a significant discount. This is exactly what began to happen during the early part of 2015, when Fed Fund futures had little chance of the Fed moving priced in.
- JonFish85 11y agoThat's the trick of it though: it doesn't take long for the bottom to fall out. Sure, it'd be great if everyone could be patient and wait 4-6 quarters, to take a broader picture and react accordingly. Unfortunately, startups are built on the idea of extremely fast growth, which means that quick changes that affect several companies could very well be the harbinger or something bad. All it takes is a couple of bad months, and the dominoes could really start to fall. So yes, patience is surely a virtue. But it's probably worthwhile to be vigilant because it doesn't take long to fall hard from the peak.
- woah 11y agoWell, really, these startups should be able to show this quick growth without constant infusions of cash. I thought that the point of all the money was to keep ahead of the competitors who are also raising a lot, not as a baseline of operations.
- api 11y agoThat's the trap many have gotten into. They raised to keep up with the Joneses, but if you raise it now you have to spend it. Now your baseline is higher and if your growth is not utterly insane or if you can't monetize it quickly enough and have to raise again, you are now potentially toast. It's infinitely easier to raise spending than cut it. The latter involves morale crushing things like layoffs and telegraphs an outward appearance of failure that drives off customers and future hires. Startups that have avoided this trap or who have a model that converts into revenue more easily than "get users and pray" might be fine, but I think a lot of unicorns and want to be unicorns with bricks strapped to the accelerator are about to be turned into glue. But unicorn glue is great. It's sparkly and can bond any surface. :) Edit: of course the wildcard here is the question of how economically incestuous the startup world is this time. That's what made the landing so hard in 2001. We know there are some startups that mostly serve startups, but nobody knows the percentages.
- api 11y agoIt's not a stretch. We live in a serial bubble economy where central banks inflate and pop speculative bubbles to give the illusion of recovery. This has been going on for a long time: dot.com, housing, oil, ... They do this because it's easier than tackling deeper issues like wage stagnation and demand collapse that are preventing a true robust resurgence of growth across the entire economy as existed from the 50s until the late 90s and the 2000 crash. That would take things like fair trade reform to limit wage arbitrage and possibly a rebirth of unionization or something similar. It would radically change the economy and would probably involve even more short term pain since the whole Normal has organized around cheap labor, cheap manufactured goods, cheap credit as a substitute for wages, and high asset prices. All that would invert. As far as the mainstream economy goes, 2000 was the end of the postwar run. Leave any of the coastal bubble fueled rich cities and visit the American interior and you'll see the long term decay... or Google the stats on heroin and meth addiction. These bubbles barely touch the heartland, which is in a depression that began in 2000.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>They do this because it's easier than tackling deeper issues like wage stagnation and demand collapse that are preventing a true robust resurgence of growth across the entire economy as existed from the 50s until the late 90s and the 2000 crash. That would take things like fair trade reform to limit wage arbitrage and possibly a rebirth of unionization or something similar. It would radically change the economy and would probably involve even more short term pain since the whole Normal has organized around cheap labor, cheap manufactured goods, cheap credit as a substitute for wages, and high asset prices. All that would invert. I don't think the central banks are doing this on-purpose. They're doing it because the people with control over fiscal policy have decided to spend all their time worshiping the Austerity Gods. (Belts for the belt-tightening god! Cuts for the cut throne!)
- api 11y agoYou're getting downmodded, but you're right. That's one problem. The other is unfair international trade rules that allow oppressive foreign regimes to compete against workers in liberal democracies with slave labor and no environmental laws. There is no way domestic industries can compete with that. It always costs more when you have to actually pay people and comply with OSHA regulations and when you can't spew unscrubbed coal ash into the air by the megaton.
- myth_buster 11y agoI think Europe will see a surge in investing while US dries up as one is beginning QE while the other is closing it out.
- _yosefk 11y agoBy "investing", you mean front-running the central bank, right?
- oldmanjay 11y agoUSA today is not exactly a news source of note. I'm not saying there is no bubble, but I wouldn't personally put a lot of stock in their take on anything.
- lloyd-christmas 11y agoHere's a longer dataset from PriceWaterhouseCooper's VC funding data: https://www.pwcmoneytree.com/HistoricTrends/CustomQueryHistoricTrend https://www.pwcmoneytree.com/HistoricTrends/CustomQueryHisto... My interpretation: 1999-2001 was, obviously, a completely different beast. While there was a bit more investment in 2015 than 2014, it was variable by quarter over the last 2 years and just looks volatile rather than bubble-y. What I focused on, and believe is the most important thing to notice, is that the number of deals hasn't really changed. Any spike can be attributed to larger investments per company/round. The reason I see this as more important is that the reach of any "bubble" to the downstream dependents of VC cash (data analytics startup land) likely wouldn't extend as far as the end-of-the-world crowd likes to suggest. Outlook: I think this year will be more telling than the last as to whether or not funding in 2014-15 was just volatile or if we're actually making a move towards 2002/2009 troughs. I struggle to believe it will trending upward from here. I'd like to think the VC world is slightly more cautious (which is likely why we've seen the recent volatility).
- noobermin 11y agoI am not a business man, but I am a developing scientist who's trained his graph reading bullshit detector. "Flat" is relative to the scale of the graph, and when you have a maximum on the graph (the 2001 bubble) that dominates, and changes that are not on the scale of the peak look like they are "flat". To fix this, change the time period from after 2002 to remove the offending peak. Then, you see pretty much a rise from the 2009 recession onward with wiggles in the number of deals. Of course, the only issue is as a non-business man, I don't know if 300 deals per quarter over ~7 years is a significant increase or not. Also, I don't know what is considered "normal" as I assume the minimum at 2009 is probably below the norm, so for all I know, we could be hovering just above 0. Still, there is definitely an upward trend there at least for the aggregate category (if that is what we are discussing). EDIT: 2016-2009 = 7, I can't count