10 ms·
New finding: 600M years ago, a single mutation changed everything
- billiam 11y agoObviously important to understand actual modern problems like cancer, but in a broad sense this is just the beginning of coming to a complete picture of the origin of metazoa. This was a single mutation that ends up in all animals, but perhaps other mechanisms were also involved in making the mutation survive and win.
- givan 11y agoinsights into life at that time rely on researchers’ imaginations Where is this 600M years taken from? big claims based on assumptions, I don't like this kind of science, building on too many assumptions and you are going too far from the truth and this is the opposite of what science tries to achieve.
- falsestprophet 11y agoWhere is this 600M years taken from? I didn't read the paper, but probably this technique: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molecular_clock https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molecular_clock
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- zbyte64 11y agor/science/knowledge
- unit91 11y agoIf I understand you correctly, you're saying all knowledge is just a bunch of assumptions. This raises the question, how do you know that statement is true? On that view, you can only reasonably say, "I've assumed it." The belief that all knowledge is based on assumptions is just a rephrasing of the postmodern view that there is no objective truth (is that true?). I don't want to sound like I'm attacking you here, but our beliefs about knowledge and truth are very consequential. If we cannot know anything aside from our assumptions, then all assumptions are equally valid (since we can't know which to discard). This naturally leads to situations where, e.g., racism is assumed to be good by one person, assumed to be bad by another, and there is no way we can determine who's right. In fact, "right" and "wrong" become meaningless because they're only assumptions, as does all language.
- unit91 11y agoNot at all. An assumption is "a thing that is accepted as true or as certain to happen, without proof" [1]. The goal of science is minimize assumptions and maximize knowledge (justified, true belief) [2]. One easy way to do this is to make predictions: "If $THEORY is correct, then under the same conditions, I will observe $OUTCOME. If $OUTCOME does not obtain, I either haven't properly conducted the experiment, or $THEORY is wrong. 1. https://translate.google.com/#auto/en/assumption https://translate.google.com/#auto/en/assumption 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_method EDIT: In response to your rephrasing of "if...then", to "assuming...then", consider that we actually do (or do not) observe $OUTCOME -- we don't assume that we observe it. To use an outrageous (but hopefully clear) example, do we know decapitation is fatal, or do we merely assume it? A long time ago (but in this galaxy) someone had a theory that decapitation was fatal. Experimentation gave us knowledge on this issue. Doubtless, they did not have The Scientific Method in mind, but they used the same process.
- amelius 11y ago> If $THEORY is correct, then under the same conditions, I will observe $OUTCOME Let me rephrase this as: Assuming $THEORY is correct, then under the same conditions, I will observe $OUTCOME A theory is an assumption.
- spdionis 11y agoTheories are not assumptions. They usually include some kind of explanation for $OUTCOME.
- zbyte64 11y agoSince the researcher was reconstructing the evolution of a protein I would say the date was determined using a technique called the molecular clock: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molecular_clock https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molecular_clock That and the rise of multi-cellular life marks the beginning of the Cambrian explosion (542M years ago). That gives 60M years for the mutation to spread and specialize.
- stan_rogers 11y agoThe Cambrian explosion is late in this game; this would be about the emergence of the Ediacaran biota (largely fractal-like body plans, followed by organisms with more specialised structural groups and less-local symmetries) and simpler aggregate colony organisms like sponges, which seemed to come out of nowhere quickly after the Cryogenian. The Cambrian explosion seems to have been mostly about riffing on the bilateral symmetry lick.
- nickbauman 11y agoAKA the "Cambrian Explosion". I wasn't aware this was new. I remember this in HS. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambrian_explosion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambrian_explosion
- JeffreyKaine 11y agoThe Cambrian Explosion has been known for quite some time. This is a theory of HOW the Cambrian Explosion happened. One single mutation. Interesting ideas for sure!
- steinsgate 11y agoOne common objection to the theory of evolution claims that the theory is self contradictory. It says that it is impossible for complex features such as wings, eyes etc to evolve because they will require a series of mutations that do not individually confer any evolutionary advantage. Since they do not have any evolutionary advantage, they cannot spread in the population. Therefore the chance of these mutations appearing in series is almost as small as these mutations appearing simultaneously. The chance of these mutations appearing simultaneously is, of course, astronomically small. The usual counterargument says that just one mutation is usually enough to create a functional prototype of a complex feature/organ (MVP, if you please). A series of mutations is not required. This study provides yet another example backing this counterargument. One single mutation can change an unicellular entity and make it behave like a multi cellular organism. Intuitively, one would think this would take many mutations. However, intuition is wrong in this case, and in many others.
- aggie 11y agoEven as someone fully accepting of evolutionary theory, this diagram felt like a revelation: http://i58.servimg.com/u/f58/17/30/76/23/evolut10.jpg http://i58.servimg.com/u/f58/17/30/76/23/evolut10.jpg
- fiatjaf 11y agoI don't understand what is the good from passing from 1 to 2 or 2 to 3.
- tamana 11y agoMore light collection and higher resolution of details
- InclinedPlane 11y agoFrom 1 to 2 you get directionality. 2 to 3 improves directionality a great deal (it's basically a continuum from depression to pinhole eye).
- 11y ago
- once-in-a-while 11y agoWhat? 600M years? Really? Are you folks aware that 1000 years is already a very long time? Any number bigger than, say 100.000 years is just the same as infinity, regarding to time. This "infinity" problem simply requires too much faith, and will never have real evidence. Not very good attributes for a credible theory. Maybe it's about time to get a better one, with less time involved? This way the faith required would be at a real human reachable level.
- x3n0ph3n3 11y ago> Any number bigger than, say 100.000 years is just the same as infinity, regarding to time. Tell that to a geologist or an astrophysicist and you'll be laughed out of the room. There's plenty of evidence of timescales in the millions and billions of years.
- once-in-a-while 11y agoExactly the opposite is true: theres is overwhelming evidence that the Universe (and our solar system) can't be older than just thousands of years. Often in history majority was wrong. And history is repeating itself, repeatedly.
- ta0967 11y agooverwhelming evidence that the Universe (and our solar system) can't be older than just thousands of years i'm very curious about your sources.
- ceejayoz 11y ago> Are you folks aware that 1000 years is already a very long time? Geologically? Not at all. It's 0.000022% of the age of the Earth.
- once-in-a-while 11y agoIf you take, let's say, 10 thousand years, and try to explain every single detail of our planet, in all branches of science involved, you get the whole picture completely painted, without contradictions. Big numbers are just imagination, there's nothing you can prove about it. The so-called "measured" numbers of the age of different fossils etc. found are actually selected numbers of years: they pick the ones they agree with their theory, and discard all the others (that is, the majority). Very scientific, indeed :/
- dnautics 11y agothe article over generalizes the find to be basically bereft of real information. "Instead of working as enzymes (proteins that facilitate reactions inside the cell) the proteins were now what’s known as an interaction domain. They could communicate with and bind to other proteins, a useful skill for cells that have decided to trade the rugged individualist life for the collaboration of a group" Enzymes switch between being enzymes and interaction domians across all taxa everywhere in the tree of life, so this is not the "money shot". Moreover, unicellular life do plenty of intracellular, collaborative communication (e.g. quorum sensing). Reading the paper, the specific switch enabled the orientation of cell division to be communicated from one cell to another. This is interesting because this communication is not over an anisotropic chemical gradient, but encodes directional and spatial information.
- ajross 11y agoThis is the closest that article gets to an "explanation": > A single mutation that repurposed a certain type of protein. Instead of working as enzymes (proteins that facilitate reactions inside the cell) the proteins were now what’s known as an interaction domain. They could communicate with and bind to other proteins, a useful skill for cells that have decided to trade the rugged individualist life for the collaboration of a group. Which is total gibberish. Yet unsurprisingly the abstract to the actual paper (helpfully linked in the wapo article: http://elifesciences.org/content/5/e10147 http://elifesciences.org/content/5/e10147) is gibberish to me for different reasons. Is anyone expert enough to attempt a "for technical dummies" reading?
- gjm11 11y agoI'll have a go. Disclaimer: I'm not a biologist; corrections welcome. Consider a growing multicellular organism. It grows by a process of cell division. Each division turns one cell into two adjacent cells. The structure it ends up with will depend on the orientation of those dividing cells (you'll tend to get growth "along the axis of division", so to speak). A wide variety of multicellular organisms have a mechanism that orients cells according to features on the outside of neighbouring cells. (It "mediates spindle orientation in diverse animal taxa by linking microtubule motor proteins to a marker protein on the cell cortex localized by external cues", as the abstract puts it. The "mitotic spindle" is a structure involved in cell division, also called mitosis. It's mostly made out of long thin things called microtubules, and its job is to separate the chromosomes for the two new cells, which it does using "motor proteins". The cell cortex is the inner surface of the boundary of the cell.) One part of this process is the way in which a protein involved in the mitotic spindle attaches itself to that thing on the cell cortex. The relevant bit of that protein is called the "guanylate kinase protein interaction domain" or GK_PID for short. A protein interaction domain is a bit of protein that interacts with other things; multiple different proteins can contain instances of the same interaction domain, just as multiple different programs can contain (say) the same code for computing SHA-256 checksums. The paper reports evidence that a single mutation enabled the GK_PID to attach itself to the marker on the cell cortex. ("The complex was assembled through a series of molecular exploitation events, one of which – the evolution of GK_PID’s capacity to bind the cortical marker protein – can be recapitulated by reintroducing a single historical substitution into the reconstructed ancestral GK_PID." So. This doesn't say that multicellularity was enabled by a single mutation. It says that one small but important part of a process that's necessary for complex multicellular organisms was enabled by a single mutation. Still pretty cool, but the journalistic science->hype conversion machine is clearly operating as usual here.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dkural 11y agoThe scientific article makes a far from convincing case for the purported importance of this mutation. The journal its published in (eLife) is not exactly known for high-quality comparative genomics / molecular evolution work either. The Washington Post article is misleading at best. Hyperbole.
- x3n0ph3n3 11y agoI find the number of young-earth creationists in disguise here very surprising.
- tokenadult 11y agoAs another comment noted, some of the participants in this thread about the interesting article kindly submitted here appear to be unaware of the factual basis for evolutionary theory. For anyone who wonders how we know that the earth is much more than 600 million years old, or how we know that current living things descended from a common ancestor, more or less remote depending on how closely related the current living things are, see 29+ Evidences for Macroevolution: The Scientific Case for Common Descent,[1] which is a very informative and interesting website with a lot of information about biological facts and geological facts that have been discovered since you and I graduated from high school. [1] http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/comdesc/ http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/comdesc/
- raz32dust 11y agoHow does it impact the probability of extraterrestrial life? I mean, after 4 billion years of relative peace, Earth still had only single-celled organisms. And it would have stayed that way, if not for this particular mutation. So it is not just how many planets can support life. First, it will need to continuously keep supporting life for billions of years before any form of intelligent life can emerge. THEN it has to wait till such a pathbreaking mutation occurs, which might take a random amount of time. I am starting to gravitate towards the lower bound of what the Drake equation estimates to be the number of planets with intelligent life. (= we are probably alone in the universe)
- gus_massa 11y agoDon't worry too much about the possibility of multicellular life in other planets [0]. This press article is totally overhyped. Read this comment of bmer about the original research article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10884255 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10884255 [0] [Or to be more precise, IIRC the transition from bacteria to eucariota is more difficult. I'd worry about that step instead.]
- dschiptsov 11y agoIs there another way than a mutation, propagation to an offspring(s), survival and successful reproduction of these, then over-reproducing others due to this adaptation (or by a pure chance) etc?
- osoba 11y agoI thought multicellularity on Earth evolved independently around 50 times? So it does kind of make sense that it would be the result of something as simple as a single SNP that changes a function of a protein from whatever to binding to proteins of external organisms. Perhaps more complex mechanisms (multiple mutations) wouldn't have the likelyhood of occuring so many times
- avaku 11y ago"In the wild world of pre-complex life, this development was orders of magnitude better than Twitter for getting organisms organized." Ha ;)