9 ms·
Tesla Model S can now park itself
- raldi 11y agoThis is a pretty misleading headline. s/drive/park/ That said, self-parking ability is still a big deal. Imagine when, say, 35% of the population gets them. You could have super-dense, extra-cheap parking lots for self-parking cars only. They could be packed extraordinarily tight, with no need for human valets. Your car's boxed in all the way in the back? It'll just tell the ones in its way to please get out for a moment. One car breaks down? That's probably rare enough that you can move the ones around it and bring in a tow truck or human driver.
- bitJericho 11y agoOf course it is. It's another TC article.
- sandworm101 11y agoPacked extra dense? They could no doubt shave a few inches here and there, but the basics of parking remain. (1) They would have to have lanes, else every car have to move every time someone wanted out. And these lanes would have to be wide enough that the car with the largest turning radius could still get out reasonably. (2) There would still need to be some standard width for spaces, else a thin car leaving would leave a 3-4' wide space that nobody else could fit into. And a thin car moving into the gap left by a wide car wouldn't be very efficient. (3) Accommodation would still be needed for humans/pedestrians to deal with issues or rescue stuck cars. (4) The new nightmare of the loading area outside stores as autodrive cars line up like cabs at the airport pickup up passengers. At least in a parking lot everyone can load/unload without forcing everyone else to wait. (5) The fire safety rules would still apply. Deep in building codes are provisions for exactly how much of various dangerous things are allowed inside parking lots. A bunch of tightly-packed, battery packed, teslas in a big concrete box is a firefighter's nightmare. Imho far more space could be saved in north america if parking lots had better accommodation for motorcycles. Everyone who rides a bike rather than drive a car effectively saves 3/4 of a parking space if spots are made for them.
- mcbutterbunz 11y agoNot to mention you wouldn't be able to box cars in. You still need to be able to pull the car ou, with or without a driver. This is just a personal valet service which is still exciting.
- op00to 11y agoWhy can't you box cars in? When I park in an attended lot in NYC and Philly, my car is often boxed in because space is so tight. I either tell them when I expect to be back or wait for them to jockey cars around. With self driving cars, it could be straightforward to program them to move around to extricate a boxed in vehicle.
- zachrose 11y agoAnd also win big at Rush Hour: http://www.amazon.com/Think-Fun-5000-ThinkFun-Rush/dp/B00000DMER http://www.amazon.com/Think-Fun-5000-ThinkFun-Rush/dp/B00000...
- CamperBob2 11y ago(1) They would have to have lanes, else every car have to move every time someone wanted out. Which is no longer necessarily a problem.
- sandworm101 11y agoWhy? Are all of these cars going to automagically cooperate in some sort of parking ballet every time the guy at the back wants out?
- colechristensen 11y agoWhy not? Valets do this all the time.
- ceejayoz 11y agoEventually, why not?
- mikeash 11y agoIt wouldn't be that much of a win using the feature as it currently stands. You could park them a bit closer together since you don't have to worry about getting the doors open, but that's it. A decent win, allowing maybe 20-30% denser packing, but not huge.
- blisterpeanuts 11y agoPacking tightly is efficient, but not always desirable. Sometimes you need a little more clearance in the rear for loading or unloading large cargo from the trunk or hatch. It's not going to work in a mall parking lot or a supermarket lot where you want to unload into the trunk from a shopping cart.
- chiaro 11y agoThe ideal would be the car drops you off, parks itself somewhere nearby in a high density area, then returns itself for loading in an open area when you need it.
- dang 11y agoOk we made the title say 'park'.
- chromejs10 11y agoOnly thing about all the self parking stuff is it's a bit too slow. I live in SF, and so far it's been difficult to use self parking in practice. If you take too long you get people pulling up so close to you in the back that you can't reverse, or endless honking. Especially with the Model S auto park since you actually have to pull up a lot farther than a normal person would before you can engage it
- trgn 11y agoI like that idea, but that's basically how they park in many cities around the world already. It's not uncommon for drivers in for example Rome or Brussels to nudge cars with the bumper, to get an almost airtight fit when parallel parking. Underground carparks in Europe are also enormously tight, I don't think robot parking will make it that more packed. The bar is just lower here when it comes to using space efficiently. It's more of a mindset problem than a technological one.
- raldi 11y agoBut in those places, you still need to leave enough room for a driver to open the door and get in or out. That's a lot of wasted space.
- rpearl 11y agoWhy even care about it being your car? How about just a car? At your bidding when you need it and no other time.
- sandworm101 11y agoBecause I got stuff I want to keep in my car. When I go shopping I sometimes hit more than one store and don't want to carry everything from Costco with me into Home Depo. Also dogs.
- jon-wood 11y agoIn that case you'd indicate you need the same car on your return from Home Depot, and have to wait a while for it to show up from the parking lot, whilst people who don't need a specific car just grab the first one in the waiting area outside.
- sandworm101 11y agoAnd no computer has ever failed to properly hold a reserved car. "See, you know how to take the reservation. You just don't know how to hold the reservation. And that's really the most important part." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4T2GmGSNvaM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4T2GmGSNvaM
- obsurveyor 11y ago"When your reservation is over or you are finished with the vehicle, please place this key-like device into steering column where the traditional key would." A manual lockout would be a smart thing here. There's all kinds of solutions to the "computers are dumb" problem.
- aninhumer 11y agoI feel like a simpler solution would just be to store anything left in the boot when the car returns to the depot, and put it back in your next car. There could also be a safe for security and privacy. It's slightly less flexible, but for most cases it's much more efficient. I also think it's slightly less error prone, as there's no user input required, and since the stuff gets removed from the car, it's much less likely that anything will end up being sent to another user. At worst, they forget to put your stuff back automatically, and it's relatively easy for them to send another car, or even send your stuff to your house. Indeed, that might even be a service people are interested in if they're doing a lot of shopping, or they take public transport for part of their journey.
- beefsack 11y agoHigh density automated parking is a solved problem. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automated_parking_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automated_parking_system
- sandworm101 11y agoNot exactly the batmobile / car on command I was hoping for. The 'driver' is still responsible for the car's behavior. My standard for "without you" remains either no person in sight, or the driver in the back seat sleeping off a night at the bar.
- Consultant32452 11y agoIf they're releasing this to the public then the truth of the matter is that the technology is "there" for driverless parking but the regulatory bits are not. "There" in this case meaning the AI is less likely to get into an accident than a human.
- sandworm101 11y agoHave they said that? I don't see anything from tesla saying that these cars are allowed to move without the driver watching. In fact Musk has made more than a few statement denouncing the behavior of tesla owners who have let their cars loose as unsafe.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThe technology is there. The car doesn't require a human watching it while it moves. The government does.
- Consultant32452 11y agoMore specifically, even if the AI gets in only 50% of the accidents a human driver would get into Musk simply cannot recommend relying on it until the regulatory bodies determine he (or Tesla) is not financially responsible for those accidents. We're still a ways off from that.
- BinaryIdiot 11y agoI'm surprised there isn't any news from Tesla about this change. This is pretty cool. Yeah, technically it is driving without you but that's a bit misleading. Still really cool!
- rayiner 11y agoJust had a very low visibility landing into BWI. Feeling thankful for autoland, but also for the unimaginative FAA bureaucrats regulating it...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jon-wood 11y agoIt's entirely possible let your pilot landed manually. All major airports have detailed instructions on how to land there even in the case of zero visibility at ground level. Basically you fly to a specific point at a specific heading, altitude, and speed. Once there you follow the instructions stating you should fly n seconds, then adjust, and repeat until you touch down on the runway.
- lqdc13 11y agoI am actually happy it doesn't drive without the driver. Not that I have a Tesla, but I would never want to own a performance vehicle that drives without me. The whole point is to enjoy the experience. They already took away engine noise and manual transmission. Now might as well just have someone else drive you.
- zouhair 11y agoThen you can go to work and send back the car to your significant other to take the kids to school and then send the car back to you when you need to come back home.
- lqdc13 11y agoI wasn't arguing that it's not practical.
- tim333 11y agoOne of the troubles with 150mph performance vehicles is you spend 90% of your time going slow stuck behind traffic.
- mikeash 11y agoEven if it did, so what? Nobody is forcing you to use these features. Don't like them? Don't activate them.
- nightcracker 11y agoIt's not unthinkable that computer-driven cars will be so much safer on the public road that it'll become illegal to have human drivers, as they are much more dangerous. Maybe not in the immediate future, but it'll probably happen at some point.
- mikeash 11y agoCould be, but I see little relationship between adding features like this to a normal, driver-piloted car, and a mysterious future where autonomous cars are the only ones allowed on the road.
- sriram_malhar 11y agoIn a few years, you will tell your smart fridge, "buy a car". The fridge will make the appropriate selection (a Volvo if you drink Organic milk etc.), make the payment from the appropriate account (keep the Swiss account for another day). In about 10 minutes, the car that now belongs to you drives itself to your home, while you go out for a walk.
- jrcii 11y agoYour scenario is reminiscent of Homer Simpson's recent quote: "Siri, tell Amazon to drone me a beer." A drone carrying a beer immediately flies through the window and drops it in his hand.
- mintplant 11y agoI could see "tell X to Y" becoming a central UI pattern for future voice interfaces, where the system's voice agent (Siri, Cortana...) forwards arbitrary command Y to app/service X which is responsible for interpreting Y.
- raverbashing 11y agoNot so exited about this, much more exited by the car driving itself to be serviced if possible (and back) Or just "your car is your own Uber driver"
- intopieces 11y ago>When Autosteer is engaged on a restricted road, Model S’s speed will be limited to the speed limit of the road, plus an additional 5 mph. This means the car is programed to break the law. Does this have liability implications or is 5mph not enough to matter?
- vvanders 11y agoFrom the notes it looks like they're just setting the upper limit on TACC to speed limit +5pmh on residental roads. You can still set TACC to exactly the speed limit without any issues.
- tempestn 11y agoRight, so in other words, the car allows you to break the law - just like any other car - but unlike most, it prevents you from breaking it by much. There is going to be some friction between true self-driving cars and unrealistic speed limits in the near future though.
- sandworm101 11y agoI wouldn't say it prevents you from doing much of anything. The car will still speed however you want it to, just not with the machine in control.
- tempestn 11y agoYes, sorry, I was referring to the operation with automation engaged. As opposed to a standard cruise control, which can be set to any speed you want. Obviously in manual mode it will let you speed.
- mikeash 11y agoIt means the car can be commanded to break the law by the driver. Which is no different from any other car on the road. It's not just spontaneously deciding the exceed the speed limit, it does so when the driver tells it to.
- dschiptsov 11y agoThis is actually very clever. Your car could drive itself in a sandbox before stable technology has been evolved or even legislations on self-driven cars were passed. And of course now you could really show off with that Summon feature before all those losers. This is what we call "clever".
- galago 11y agoThis should be interesting. If I were in a Walmart parking lot facing an empty car and it was trying to take a space, I would probably accelerate at it assuming it would back off, since there's no one who cares. If everyone did this, would it end with some parade of never-parking-Teslas that just drive around the parking lot until their owner gets done shopping? That's not necessarily a bad thing...but it would be a weird new aspect to parking.
- Caprinicus 11y agoNobody seems to have considered the possibility of actually driverless cars. Would not be remotely legal, but interesting to consider them just aimlessly driving city streets or looking for parking that it will never find.
- galago 11y agoOK, say you're in Manhattan. Assuming a private car, instead of paying for a garage, should it be acceptable to just leave an automated car driving around, or instead, driving outward until it finds a public space? Would it result in cheaper garages, or some other crazy problem?
- hayksaakian 11y agowhat if the cost of having my empty car wander the city is cheaper than paying for parking? will parking costs go down? will there be some laws forbidding this behavior?
- sigmar 11y agoThis is a very interesting hypothetical from a public policy standpoint. Perhaps the city would find a need to subsidize parking for the sake of pollution, traffic, and energy consumption concerns. edit: maybe subsidize is the wrong word, but rather that they will incentivize affordable parking and make more available.
- tyre 11y ago
- Animats 11y agoIt's about time. Volkswagen had that in 2008.[1] Audi in 2012. Chevrolet in 2014.[2] [1] http://www.gizmag.com/volkswagen-demonstrates-fully-automatic-reverse-parking-system/9217/ http://www.gizmag.com/volkswagen-demonstrates-fully-automati... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3zh_5QGA1zw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3zh_5QGA1zw
- sandworm101 11y agoBMW 2015 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UDQxcvYzAog https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UDQxcvYzAog Honda 2013 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6MjmRDIVxws https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6MjmRDIVxws Nissan 2014 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bQZ-UDY3lpQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bQZ-UDY3lpQ Audi 2013 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vt20UnkmkLI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vt20UnkmkLI Lexus 2009 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ldLpPehy1k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ldLpPehy1k (TopGear)
- sjburt 11y agoIt's a bit difficult to tell from the videos, but it seems like the only one of those that was a production vehicle was the Nissan, and there was quite a bit of manual intervention (shifting into forward and reverse). To be fair, I don't really understand the point of the Tesla feature either... can it do anything but pull the car from right outside a garage to inside the garage and vice versa?
- sandworm101 11y agoThey have rolled out some of the autopark features. I think all the sold cars required the driver in the seat. The versions that I have tested myself have all been horrible. They were so slow, or required unnatural maneuvers to scan the space. One dealer told me the feature was only for "People who cannot look over their shoulder, you know ... old people." None of them would un-park the car. I still needed the basic parallel parking skills to get out of the spot.
- 11y ago
- neximo4 11y agoAren't there a number of cars that can already do this? I recall watching an episode of Top Gear where the car parked itself while the driver was not in it. I only wondered what happens when it can't find parking?
- pearjuice 11y agoThe door will automatically open and a soothing, motherly voice will tell you to please get back in the car and find an appropriate spot to park.
- kevan 11y agoThe pull into garage feature seems targeted towards people who have tiny carports like you see everywhere in SF.
- ck2 11y agoI'm curious what happens when there are two dozens of these in an active parking lot (or near each other on a highway) and they get false sensor echos. Then one day there will be half a dozen brands with slightly different sensors messing with each other via accidental interference and echos. Public has no idea how this stuff works and starts putting a little too much faith into it can lead to some horrible accidents.
- Udo 11y agoWhen I took a test drive of the Model S recently, one thing that struck me about the autopilot was that it's not (in my opinion) sufficiently clear what mode the car is operating in at the moment. Semiautomatic mode should be a glaringly obvious UI change, but instead it's just an icon. It reminds me of certain fatal plane crashes that led to improvements in cockpit layout and operation. Are we about to make the same mistakes with cars?
- dkbrk 11y agoIn particular, I think Aeroflot Flight 593 [0] is representative of this sort of problem. Autopilot control of the ailerons was accidentally disabled without clear feedback of the change in mode, this led to overcorrection by the autopilot using other control mechanisms as it attempted to restore the aircraft's heading and within a minute the plane entered an uncontrolled dive and crashed. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aeroflot_Flight_593 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aeroflot_Flight_593
- akira2501 11y agoThis is an old video, but I love watching these airline pilot saftey presentations. This video in particular covers a lot of these automation issues. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pN41LvuSz10 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pN41LvuSz10
- bsaul 11y agoYour comment made me realize it would be a great idea to provide external signs as well, showing to people outside that the car is operating in autonomous mode. It could be lights for examples, a bit like when the car is going to move backward, only less powerful and with a different color. This should also be standardized in a way across manufacturers.
- cromulent 11y agoAbsolutely. I would suggest that cars have two other standardised lights in addition to turn signals: a) Brake light on the front of the car So that when you turn across traffic on a yellow light you can see that the oncoming car is braking. b) Thank-you light on the back of a car. Maybe blue. We can already express displeasure, but wouldn't it be nice to express pleasure with other road users.
- jakobegger 11y agoI expected a bit more from the much hyped Auto-Park feature. It seems that all that the new "Summon" feature does is move up to 13m forward or backward in a straight line. I can imagine that there are some cases where this is useful, but in general you'll still need to do that annoying 3-point turn yourself...
- mikeash 11y agoIt does steer a bit to avoid obstacles. If you have it go forward into a garage, for example, it will center itself within as it goes. The options for automatic parking while you're in the car are broader. It can parallel park or reverse into a perpendicular space for you in that situation.