5 ms·
We pay the Electronic Frontier Foundation. Consumers, geeks, and the privacy/digital rights inclined. They're doing exactly what donors want them to be doing, i
by Someone1234 11y ago
We pay the Electronic Frontier Foundation. Consumers, geeks, and the privacy/digital rights inclined. They're doing exactly what donors want them to be doing, including this Binge On thing (which is part of a larger Net Neutrality struggle).
I am a T-Mobile customer. And when they first introduced Binge On I was mostly happy (Net Neutrality notwithstanding): seemed like a fair trade, for certain sites you lost video bandwidth but in return received unlimited streaming.
However T-Mobile's implementation is bad and worse still they weren't honest about what Binge On does. It is a completely different arrangement between ONLY limiting sites that signed up, and interfering in third parties who did not, and don't even get me started on limiting video file download rates (i.e. not streaming).
The CEO is just acting like an idiot. Consumer rights groups, like the EFF, are completely entitled to "stir things up" when large national corporations start acting poorly. If you guys didn't want to be called out, perhaps you could have been more honest to begin with?
So as a T-Mobile customer, I am 100% behind EFF on this one. If they started attacking the EFF regularly I'll change networks (e.g. Project Fi), because I value the EFF more than T-Mobile.
PS - Amazon's Smile.Amazon.com supports EFF donations, as an aside.
- joezydeco 11y ago@EFF: "T-Mobile's CEO is dying to know who EFF is. Friends, please tweet at @JohnLegere with the hashtag #WeAreEFF to enlighten him." https://twitter.com/EFF/status/685216654398099456 https://twitter.com/EFF/status/685216654398099456
- epistasis 11y agoI really like the concept of the EFF, and really like most of their work, but when I was reading their blog I quickly started to feel like they go off half-cocked too often. When I first saw summaries of their report my guess was just that there in turning BingeOn on/off on a single account, or that there were temporary configuration problems on T-Mobile's side. Some people like the idea of supporting an out-there extreme to keep the Overton window shifted to an appropriate place. I can see the logic in it, but I value truth first. T-mobile's CEO's schtick is to act like this, and I don't really appreciate that much either, but I do appreciate T-mobile's small movements to make the cell phone market more fluid by getting rid of contracts, and I also still like BingeOn. It gives me more control over my data than Netflix or Amazon or whomever gives me.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI'm torn. I support the EFF with donations, and I'm a 14 year customer of T-Mobile, but I have no problem with what T-Mobile is doing. The EFF has done some great work, but T-Mobile has done far more in bringing sanity back to the US mobile market.
- zanny 11y agoWhen a company does something good does not mean to ignore when they do something bad. And BingeOn is fundamentally bad, because its everything Comcast wanted when they were trying to slow-lane half the Internet, except nobody is in opposition to it because they see as a "benefit" rather than traffic shaping bullshit it actually is. They could have just given everyone unlimited data with deprioritization on their network over fixed data users, but they didn't - they make some heavy consumers of data "free" while leaving others against the tide of data caps, and thus harm the free Internet.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> When a company does something good does not mean to ignore when they do something bad. Agree. > And BingeOn is fundamentally bad, because its everything Comcast And here's your problem. It's not fundamentally bad. T-mobile is not Comcast. T-Mobile has a limited amount of spectrum on each tower, and a limited amount of backhaul to each tower. It can in no way be compared to Comcast, who can pipe Gb/s into your home, and who isn't limited by the laws of physics for delivering bits. They can always drag more fiber. There is only so much RF bandwidth in existence. I have a choice in my mobile provider, I do not in my local internet. If the EFF wants my support back, start lobbying your ass off to get tax breaks and funding for municipal fiber and stop wasting your time on T-Mobile.
- mikeknoop 11y agoThanks for your PS reminder about smile.amazon.com (0.5% of all your purchases go to a nonprofit of your choice). Paired with something like https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/smile-always/jgpmhnmjbhgkhpbgelalfpplebgfjmbf?hl=en https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/smile-always/jgpmh... you can donate to the EFF without even thinking about it.
- ilostmykeys 11y agoThe CEO archetype is that of a a king, maybe even an emperor. It is an ego based role, not an intelligence/experience based role. It's about who you know and who will do your bidding. Underlings do all the thinking and often time in response to dumb decisions by the CEO. That is the archetype. Many CEOs are not archetypal and lean toward being real leaders, but every now and then you will have a CEO who perfectly matches the archetype.
- jasonkostempski 11y agoIsn't T-Mobile one of the Project Fi networks?
- bmelton 11y agoYes it is.
- rsync 11y ago"PS - Amazon's Smile.Amazon.com supports EFF donations, as an aside." God that is so annoying. I was excited to set up EFF as the beneficiary of my "Amazon Smile" - what a great idea! And now I get a stupid pop-up confirmation every time I go on to amazon - even though they know who I am, and who I chose as beneficiary. I have no idea why they make "smile" opt-in every single visit.
- throwaway7767 11y agoMy cynical assumption is that visiting through smile.amazon.com may be used as a pricing indicator, suggesting a tolerance for higher prices. I really hope I'm wrong, but it's the reason I never use it. Online stores use all sorts of weird things as pricing indicators.