11 ms·
Ten years later, did Boston's Big Dig deliver?
- martinald 11y agoI think the Big Dig delivered immense benefits to the urban space in Boston. So many US cities are ruined from having urban highways through the core. But on the other hand, really that's just righting the wrong of building them in the first place. On the other hand, imagine what $20bn could have done to the public transit infrastructure in Boston, which is dying out for a Crossrail/RER style project to link the two main commuter rail terminals to allow through trains. I also don't agree with the article about the silver line service to Logan. It's insanely slow (stopping to change over from electric to LNG, traffic in the shared sections and worst of all the buses are just not designed for airports with the luggage and the bunching caused by traffic means some buses are really busy with ones running behind nearly empty. That doesn't happen on proper segregated right of way. BRT is generally a terrible solution, delivering most of the costs of light rail with few of the benefits.
- carbocation 11y agoIn general, I favor the T over driving in Boston because of the reduced variance in travel time. This is not true, however, of the green line above ground or of the Silver Line. The silver line's struggle through traffic (and various airport and non-airport stops on the way to South Station) makes it up to 5x slower to use the T to get to/from the airport compared to just taking an Uber.
- colanderman 11y agoThe secret is to use the Blue Line to get to the airport, not the Silver Line. So long as you're either on the Orange Line or don't have too many bags it's much faster.
- jghn 11y agoDepends on where you live. If you live on the red line (I do) taking the blue line is almost always slower than the silver lie (sic). Remember that there's no red-blue connector, in fact the govt claimed that the silver lie was the red-blue connector because it went to the airport!
- p_eter_p 11y agoThey have made noise about running the blue line to the Charles m.g.h. station, which would solve a number of problems. It would require a stretch of elevated line on Cambridge street right in front of Mass General, so no idea if it will ever happen.
- jghn 11y agoA while back I saw a discussion about them running the current head space past Bowdoin down under Charles/MGH but the problem there was that the required head space would take it under the Charles and that'd end up being pretty costly due to the conditions there.
- Anechoic 11y agoOn the other hand, imagine what $20bn could have done to the public transit infrastructure in Boston, which is dying out for a Crossrail/RER style project to link the two main commuter rail terminals to allow through trains. For what it's worth, the slurry walls constructed for the Big Dig tunnels were built to also accommate the North/South rail link if the state ever decides to fund it. That said the link is such a complex undertaking, I sincerely doubt it will happen in our lifetimes.
- brlewis 11y agoIt would make a big difference. It takes 27 minutes for me to get from North Station to the Fitbit office in the Seaport district whether I walk or take the T (subway). Directly linking North and South Station would be a big advantage. Right now bicycle is the only efficient commute.
- g8oz 11y agoOr hoverboard!
- blisterpeanuts 11y agoThe Silver Line is typical of the public transportation system in Boston: almost good enough, but frustrating in its compromises that passengers have to live with every day. For people west of town, it's a great convenience to park or be dropped at Alewife station, ride the Red Line to South Station, then the Silver Line to the airport. This is versus the old system where you had to change twice. We're thankful for small things. And yes, the lengthy stop to change over from electric to diesel is logical yet seems poorly implemented. Many times I've watched the driver climb out to manually operate the electrodes. Surely it's possible to better automate this process, given that people headed toward the airport are usually in a huge hurry? Maybe eventually they can just make the Silver Line buses completely electrical; batteries propel them above ground, the third rail propels them and recharges them underground, perhaps with hybrid-diesel supplemental power.
- zanny 11y agoGenerally from my observations it just seems that when you have traffic congestion its best to just fix it anywhere its happening, because after any thoughts to environmentalism, when you run out of infrastructure capacity your growth is crippled. A city with good public and private transit will see continuous growth. A city that does not invest in it, maintain it, or fix it will suffocate itself. Thats not to say you should write blank checks or do impossible feats of engineering, but if you want to live somewhere that has a bright future rather than one that remains stagnant, you don't want to see your transit systems fall behind.
- cesarb 11y agoWe're doing something similar here in Rio de Janeiro: the Perimetral (https://pt.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elevado_da_Perimetral https://pt.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elevado_da_Perimetral) was demolished, and will be replaced by a new 3 km tunnel pair (http://www.portomaravilha.com.br/viaexpressa http://www.portomaravilha.com.br/viaexpressa). One major difference would be that the Perimetral was demolished before finishing the tunnel. We'll see how well it works when it's opened this year.
- pouetpouet 11y agoMeanwhile in Utrech, NL: https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2016/01/05/motorway-removed-to-bring-back-original-water/ https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2016/01/05/motorway-remov...
- ascagnel_ 11y agoCar-free shopping districts are an interesting choice, but you still need to make some concessions to mass transit (eg delivery hours for trucks, right-of-way or other lanes for buses or expensive construction of subways, etc), and Europe generally doesn't have the sprawling suburbia of the eastern United States that would require massive ring-roads to handle traffic that isn't feasible to serve via mass transit (although mass transit park-and-ride facilities can help to mitigate that).
- maxerickson 11y agoUtrecht is fairly sprawly: http://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=11/52.1307/5.1605 http://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=11/52.1307/5.1605 My experience of the trains was that it would be very reasonable to live in Hilversum and work in Utrecht.
- Zach_the_Lizard 11y ago>Car-free shopping districts are an interesting choice, but you still need to make some concessions to mass transit (eg delivery hours for trucks, right-of-way or other lanes for buses or expensive construction of subways, etc), Car free shopping districts and streets are common worldwide. Even the US has them. Pennsylvania Avenue in front of the White House is open only to foot traffic and bikes. The only cars in there are emergency vehicles. Charlottesville, Virginia has a pedestrian mall. >Europe generally doesn't have the sprawling suburbia of the eastern United States that would require massive ring-roads to handle traffic that isn't feasible to serve via mass transit The sprawling suburbia of the US comes from poor land use policies that do things like require single family housing. This is true even in cities which are famous for not having zoning, like Houston. Before we engaged in the Great Suburban Experiment the US was one of the world leaders in public transit. LA had one of the largest public transit systems in the entire world. Loosening certain land use controls would slowly repair this problem amongst many others. Lately these laws have attracted a lot of attention in the press, with economists from Paul Krugman on down commenting on land use controls, mostly negatively. Cities are slowly reforming these laws, or attempting to reform these laws, and I suspect that the America of the future will be much more walkable nationally than today's America. Even LA's leadership has realized that the car doesn't scale.
- chrisweekly 11y agoShort answer: yes. I've lived in or around Boston for ~36 of my 41 years. The word "expressway" is no longer farcical, and the hideous rusted green monstrosity that used to cut off the waterfront from the rest of the otherwise very walkable city has been replaced by the aptly-named "greenway" linear park.... it's so much better I can hardly believe it. Yes, public transit needs more and better investment. Yes, the BD suffered from corruption and inefficiency. But, this lifelong Bostonian sees it as a messy, expensive, insufficient but necessary step in bringing this awesome little city into modernity.
- colanderman 11y agoAs a new resident of Boston I have to say the linear park is great. Food trucks + eating in and walking through that park during the summer transforms what would be a soul-crushing concrete jungle into a pleasurable place to unwind during lunch.
- tibbon 11y agoSame here. It was expensive and fraught with issues in making it (including poorly glued ceiling panels when they opened it), but now it seems pretty great. I can get from Somerville to Dorchester or the airport in minutes on 93.
- prplhaz4 11y agoI completely agree. I returned to Boston after 10 years away and was floored by the transformation. I see it as flushing away a huge amount of technical debt that we had incurred over the last 100 years, hopefully setting us up for modernization on many fronts - which is quite a big deal when you consider it's competing to be a top tech hub.
- deveac 11y agoI lived in Boston in the mid nineties for about three years, doing shipping logistics that served the downtown & surrounding areas. I didn't have a frame of reference, and really only ever knew the city in the midst of that debacle, having to design courier routes throughout the area. Needless to say I was intimately familiar with the Big Dig. I had the pleasure of returning to the city in 2015 for a brief bit of work with my current company and was utterly blown away at the transformation of the boulevard, the green spaces, the visual beauty...and just the sense of openness and lightness. I felt like I could breath easier just walking down the street. It's a shame to have had to overpaid so dearly for that, but what an amazing result. It was a great city before, but this just felt next-level.
- lmm 11y agoInteresting that London's Crossrail is being seen as a big spend. Over here the comment is often that in the time it's taken us to build Crossrail, Paris has built 5 RER lines.
- teh_klev 11y agoConstruction of Crossrail only began in 2009 with all services due to be in service by 2019, that's not bad going. Construction of the five RER lines began in the 60's with the last major construction completed in 1999. Sure the concept of "Crossrail" has been kicking about since the 70's but I think comparing the two as you've done is like comparing apples and oranges.
- Johnny555 11y ago10 years and $20B USD for a 40 station rail line spanning over 100km (20km in tunnels) sounds incredibly fast and inexpensive. It took us (San Francisco Bay Area) 10 years and 6.5B US dollars to build a 3.5km bridge... and it still has some serious problems with no solution.
- seibelj 11y agoAbsolutely delivered, one of the reasons Boston is such an amazing city. If you like European style cities, Boston is the only one USA has and it's awesome.
- afterburner 11y agoPhiladelphia and San Francisco have some very European style areas.
- bryanlarsen 11y agoOf course, if you truly want to experience a European city, Quebec City is closer to the majority of the population of the United States than San Francisco is, as well as being much more European.
- afterburner 11y agoI absolutely agree. Quebec City is far and away the most European city in North America.
- maxcan 11y agoPhilly has the Parkway which is a near replica of the Champs Elysees.. What part of SF is "European Style"?
- afterburner 11y agoCrowded 4-6 story buildings in nice styles.
- jrlocke 11y agoAs someone who commutes the full length of the road under the greenway everyday, absolutely. It rarely takes me more than 20 minutes to clear downtown Boston in rush hour traffic, an impossibility without the tunnel. Now if they could just fix the delays and inconsistency on the green line and silver line.
- wcummings 11y agoStill no legally mandated green line extension, so no.
- tibbon 11y agoAs much as in theory the GLX would benefit me (living in Union Sq/Somerville), I'm also kinda like "shrug, the busses work just fine". The Green Line has always been kinda terrible (too slow, too many stops, too crowded), and memories of living in Allston in 2002-2003 make me never want to take it again. Instead, I have options of the 91, CT-2, 86, 87 and 85 busses (yes, all of those within a block of my apartment) that take me to the Red/Orange line pretty swiftly. No "signal problems" or systemic track backups. Yea, busses can break down and they are pretty unreliable in other ways, but no worse than the subways here. Also, the spiking real estate prices around all the "walksheds" near proposed green line stops is really hurting the area and benefiting wealthy landlords. I'd be fine with those landlords needing to chill for a few years.
- cowsandmilk 11y agothere are reasons to think the GLX would be better than the B line or downtown. No traffic signals, more than a block between stops, and no tight turns. Lots of people love the D line, which shares these features.
- jghn 11y agoThe rise of the bus trackers has made union sq area livable. However the GLX would be huge simply from a revitalization angle. I'm ignoring the property value increase, which admittedly is/was something I've been looking forward to
- wcummings 11y agoI use the busses, they work well (especially w/ nextbus/gps/tracking/whatever) but... Somerville is the most densely populated city in New England, the GLX is (was?) expected to carry 45k people per day before 2030. For comparison, Somerville's population is 78,804 (2013) and Cambridge's population is 107,289 (2013). Not really "shrug" to me.
- webXL 11y agoUS House Speaker Thomas P. “Tip” O’Neill, for whom the mainline tunnel is named, cajoled and persuaded Congress to pay 80 percent of the project... Ah yes. Immortalizing those who appropriated other people's money with absolutely no regard for the inevitable cost overruns and mass-transit-crippling debt-- aka "bringing home the bacon". How commendable! No wonder why everyone hates Congress but loves their representative.
- Anechoic 11y agoImmortalizing those who appropriated other people's money Prior to the Big Dig, Massachusetts had funded all of its interstate highways entirely with its own money while still sending it's share of gas tax money to the Feds. The CA/T project wasn't so much appropriating other people's money as much as getting back what it donate to other states to build their highways. mass-transit-crippling debt This is a valid point, but something needed to be done about the elevated artery and tearing it down and replacing it with light rail/commuter rail isn't a practical solution - if nothing else, Maine, New Hampshire and Rhode Island would have been up in arms. If anything, blame the car-focused planning of the 1940s and 1950s for creating the mess in the first place.
- revelation 11y agoThat's the favorite pastime of armchair transportation experts, blame the past for mistakes made today.
- nck4222 11y agoMassachusetts pays more in federal taxes than it receives in federal funding. There are lots of examples of pork barrel spending but this really isn't one of them. This is a project that has and will continue to provided many tangible, measurable benefits to millions of people for decades.
- vermontdevil 11y agoThere's a reason why we have a United States. We all chip in our money and spread it around to help fund various kinds of infrastructure projects that would be too burdensome for one state to handle. I mean Alaska is in a harsh environment. Why should I fund their infrastructure projects? But I gladly do so knowing the rewards are greater - having a strong and prosperous union. That's the point. Of course there's always the issues of cost overruns, corruption, etc.
- acomjean 11y agoThe big dig helps, but as someone who worked 20 minutes north on the same highway, the traffic just seems to have shifted north. The biggest win is the second tunnel to the airport and the extra space. Boston/Mass has a history of failing and/or giving up on infrastructure (2020 olympics/ North South Rail link, Cape wind, Hollywood East Studios) and taking their time on others (finally new garden, convention center). So while its impressive the big dig got built, this city needs public transit so bad and even the small expansion of the green line (old trolleys) into somerville has been so delayed and mismanaged (no bid contracts!) its in danger of being canceled. I think part of the problem is regional transportation expansions here can be canceled by very local authorities (see red line expansion into arlington) I think givernments need to realize people are its natural resource and making them want to stay is important. Commuting here is not great. MS/Facebook/Napster all started in Massachusetts, but went west to become viable.
- Johnny555 11y agoThis is a classic case of induced demand - build bigger/better roads and more people will use them. The money would be better spent on improving transit and walkability/bikability of the city (to encourage people to live closer to work) A freeway lane carries around 2400 passengers/hour, a light rail line can carry around 20,000 passengers/hour. Heavy or commuter rail can carry around 40,000 passengers/hour.
- markbnj 11y agoThe picture at mid-point on the page, of one worker digging and 11 people watching, probably offers as pointed a commentary as anything else in the piece.
- cryoshon 11y agoYeah, I dunno if it was worth all the billions, but the Greenway is really beautiful and ties the entire city core together with a beautiful grassland. They even had some Burning-Man mini gathering on the Greenway this summer, and that definitely couldn't have happened if the entire city was still dominated by a highway. The tunnelways are pretty good-- even though they seem to have breakages pretty frequently, they improve the traffic to Logan a lot.
- rsync 11y agoWill San Francisco ever get a big dig ? Genuinely curious if it is ever proposed for the 101 corridor that goes through the city. For those who don't know, the 101 "freeway", which is the main artery north/south through the city, turns into a neighborhood street for several miles (and for several other miles (van ness) goes through a busy city center). If you are north of the golden gate bridge and you need to go to SFO, you will drive through single family, residential neighborhoods, stopping at stop signs and traffic lights. That's the route. But there's no other route, so the only solution would be a tunnel, as far as I can tell. Is this ever proposed ? Does anyone else want this ? Basically Presidio to SFSU, I think ...
- davidu 11y agoThe most appropriate solution for SF is to build a vehicle and rail tunnel just under the bottom of the bay that goes from Candlestick to the on-ramp of the GGB. It sounds crazy, but much easier than digging through the city (and going above ground is a non-starter). BART did this at reasonable cost (less than $2b in today's dollars) from SF to OAK in just four years with the Transbay tube. So it's very doable and would solve massive traffic issues in SF.
- prplhaz4 11y agoThe difference would be that the trans-bay tube sat on the floor of the bay, this would need to be under the floor (at least when it crosses the tube). Probably still the most cost-effective solution...
- rsync 11y agoAhh, yes - that would be a good idea. Well, really anything would be better than stopped at a stoplight in front of some dudes yard on 19th ave....
- artsrc 11y agobuilding a lane of high speed urban transport is really expensive. And a rail lane has 50 times the passenger capacity of a private motor vehicle lane. So if the problem is linking people to sfo, rail is much cheaper. You need to get the link to rail at both ends right. Maybe you need baggage check and parking available in Marin county where you get on the train.
- paki123 11y agoTo those who don't want to use facebook or sign up,(for chrome) just go into inspect mode, and just start deleting divs.
- TheMagicHorsey 11y agoIt delivered in the sense that Boston looted MA and the USA to pay for an infrastructure project that was WAY out of proportion of their population. For a point of comparison in the Bay Area ... imagine Sunnyvale took 24 Billion dollars of California and US money to build a giant municipal park.