10 ms·
Tech Startups Face Fresh Pressure on Valuations
- antiviral 11y agoStock prices are often volatile the first few months after an IPO . Remember Mark Zuckerberg's 'disappointment' in FB's stock price? http://www.forbes.com/sites/tomiogeron/2012/09/11/live-facebooks-mark-zuckerberg-at-techcrunch-disrupt/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/tomiogeron/2012/09/11/live-faceb...
- hluska 11y agoI agree with you. There is a huge difference between being CEO of a private company and CEO of a public company.
- ethanbond 11y agoIs it really a sign of proper valuation and longterm stability to simply survive an IPO? Not every overvalued public offering was such initially. This isn't the case now, nor was it the case during the first bubble.
- boomzilla 11y agoActually the price tracked FB expected revenue very well. For some time after IPO, there was serious doubt on FB mobile ad revenue (as the desktop ad was not growing enough). They somehow grew the mobile add very well and that's when the stock price made the U-turn. Whether the mobile ad is a proven business or not is still the 100B dollar question.
- sjg007 11y agoApp installs which is like yahoo banner ads of dotcom 1.0. Re targeting is effective though.
- steven2012 11y agoActually they're not volatile. They will predictably fall below the IPO price in a majority case after 18 months of their IPO. This holds true back during the dotcom days and even now. It is the minority that build an actual business that grows.
- hluska 11y agoIt strikes me that if the WSJ ran an article with the headline, "Hluska to earn a billion dollars in 2016" both my odds of earning a billion dollars and my realized earnings in 2016 would go up astronomically, regardless of any market or business conditions. In other words, it is hard to quantify the extent to which coverage about how the IPO market is going to stink, and how valuations are going to hit the toilet actually cause IPO markets to suck and valuations to hit the toilet.
- riggins 11y agoI don't know why your comment is being down-voted. George Soros based his entire career on this dynamic and even coined the term 'reflexivity' to describe it. Here's where and why I think the disconnect happens. Most of our possessions in day to day life tend to have a relatively stable value. Your iPhone 6 is worth $600 dollars, oranges are $2/lbs, a t-shirt is $20. Markets for non-capital goods (i.e. goods that are consumed with 1 yr or so) are very efficient most of the time. However, the claim that 'markets are efficient' (and the kinda-corollary that there's some stable intrinsic price) gets applied to all markets all the time. But markets for capital goods are not efficient all the time (by capital goods I mean something where the lifetime is greater than 1 year ... e.g. houses, airplanes, financial investments like stocks & bonds). Because most things in our everyday life have some 'true' value its seems wrong that there are assets that don't have an 'intrinsic' value or whose value is determined by perception. However value is determined by perception. A great example of this is GE. A little history ... up until the early 90's GE used to fund itself almost entirely with short term debt. GE was able to do this because everyone considered GE a AAA credit risk. This 'AAA' expectation from the market actually meant huge additional profits for GE because GE could continually borrow short term debt at short term rates (say 1%) and turn around and lend their customers money at longer term rates (say 5%) picking up spread. In the early 1990's Bill Gross came out and basically said 'this is crazy ... there's no way a company that is financed almost entirely with short term debt is a AAA credit'. Subsequently, GE was forced to term out their debt and this coincided with GE no longer outperforming the market (I haven't followed that closely but I think that GE has slowly been winding down GE Finance). The point here is that expectations (specifically that GE was a AAA credit) had a huge impact on the 'intrinsic' value of the company.
- staunch 11y agoThere are legit tech companies and there are shitty VC-backed hype machines. The former are unconquerable forces of nature and latter should be culled before public investors are harmed.
- insidethewebb 11y agoWere the VC hype machines this big around the 2000 bubble? I was only 10 years old back then, don't know much about the industry before the crash.
- _delirium 11y agoThe late '90s version was much more disorganized and not quite as embedded in institutions (pension funds, governments, etc.) as the current version is. But it was a more "public" bubble in a way, more successful in pulling in money from regular people. There were VCs out there hyping companies, but there wasn't the huge infrastructure of media-savvy venture funds, incubators, startup schools, consultants charging startups money to help get them into an incubator, etc. And they weren't as successful in getting governments and universities on board the startup hype train with all the Innovation Initiatives you see now. But what they did have going for them was a gold-rush feeling that everything was novel: "X but on the internet" was itself almost enough to sell. And the emergence of online brokers (e.g. E-Trade) as part of the same bubble brought an influx of new retail investor money, as your uncle who just heard about the internet started lining up to buy into tech IPOs.
- pkaye 11y agoBack then the bubble was more wide spread in the tech industry. Also startups were eager to go public quickly. High valued stocks would go up 25% on the slightest rumor (ie JSDU was a good example.)
- ghaff 11y ago>Back then the bubble was more wide spread in the tech industry. In part because each of those overvalued and overfunded startup were buying Sun servers, Cisco switches, EMC storage, etc. Now they're renting some EC2 instances or whatever. As a result, when the bubble deflates at least a bit, the impact is hopefully largely limited to some VC portfolios, premium developer salaries in some geos, and maybe the income flow for some northern California landlords (or those who paid $2M for a fixer-upper in that area). Not especially pleasant for those involved to be sure, but hopefully not a huge deal for everyone else.
- paulpauper 11y agoThe author mentions the worst companies that even I, web 2.0 bull, would never invest in http://greyenlightenment.com/billion-dollar-startup-club-picking-winners-from-the-losers/ http://greyenlightenment.com/billion-dollar-startup-club-pic... He mentions box.net but ignores dropbox. No mention of Air BNB, Uber, Snapchat, Slack. Although these aren't public, there is an investor bias against hardware, but such a bias is warranted given the storied history of once high-flying hardware companies eventually soaking investors due to profit margin compression, competition, or becoming fads or obsoleted, examples being Sony, Atari, Garmin, Nintendo, Sega, Fitbit, Nokia, Motorola, Gopro, Jawbone, Skull Candy, Research in Motion, and many more. Yeah, there is valuation pressure, but for companies that aren't very good. This is evidence investors are becoming smarter and more selective, whereas in the 90's a company like Fitbit would have had a PE ratio of 500 instead of 50, which is what it is right now.
- dmritard96 11y agoits easy to drag hardware through the mud when you only pick losers and ignore the likes of myspace and aol.
- praneshp 11y agoGopro is obsoleted? Just curious why you think so.
- drited 11y agoI have an opinion on this and will take a shot at it, would be interested to see further discussion. In a recent conference call GoPro's CEO commented that most video shot with GoPro cameras are home videos, not action videos. GoPro may have become less relevant because smartphones can now shoot 4k video at 30+ fps. Why spend $400+ for a GoPro when you have a device that is perfectly good for what you will be using it for already? Yes they're doing VR now but as we've seen from the limited uptake of their 3d kits, that won't be big enough to justify GoPro's valuation.
- frik 11y ago
- ChuckMcM 11y agoSummary, given the challenge some companies have had keeping ahead of their last private round when it comes to public markets, large funding sources are pulling back from their irrational exuberance of the last couple of years. That is an entirely expected and reasonable thing for them to do. And it's going to force some IPOs on companies that are not ready for it, and it will cause some companies that used to be "golden" to start dismantling. And that too is entirely expected. And some people, perhaps a quite a few, who thought they were "set for life" and perhaps even thought their kids were set for life, will find that maybe they aren't really yet. That certainly happend to me during the dot com crash and it was a sobering experience. But like the 1,000 sea turtles that crawl out of the sand and into the surf, the 100 that survive may do so for over a hundred years. Sadly there isn't any easy way to figure out which are the survivors until they are the last ones left standing.
- randall 11y agoI love your HN comments. Up votes aren't enough for you.
- meric 11y agoIn fact, the process to precisely figure out the survivors is so difficult, it involves everything ChuckMcM mentioned in his comment. All these things are happening in the market to figure out which will be the survivors, and though a challenging process, the market is figuring it out, for all of us.
- roymurdock 11y agoHow fair is it to compare this round of late-stage devaluations with the dot-com bubble? From what I've read/heard, "irrational exuberance" is an apt description of the scene in the late 90's and early 2000's. But it seems like this latest tech business cycle has taken on a different flavor. Coming off the tails of the financial crisis and great recession rather than an era of relative peace and prosperity in the 90's, this latest round of tech investing has been surrounded by a lot more vitriol and fear than the accounts I've heard of the dot-com bubble, where almost everyone was benefitting from a booming stock market and strong economy, optimistic about the future of the internet, the country, and the world. A prime example that really struck me the other day was PGs article on inequality. [0] In it he expressed that he felt like he was a wild animal being hunted - one of the most successful, famous, and well-respected VCs in the world feels threatened by macroeconomic rumblings? And he's expressing it publicly? Did this ever happen during the dot-com bubble? [1] Perhaps this fear is a good thing, a tempering agent. It seems large, late-round pension funds and institutional investors (who probably manage a great deal of this country's retirement/savings accounts) are being cautious and performing due diligence on these tech investments, rather than simply going along with the crazy valuations and riding the bubble for higher management fees and bonuses. [0] http://www.paulgraham.com/ineq.html http://www.paulgraham.com/ineq.html [1] "I feel rather like a wild animal overhearing a conversation between hunters. But the thing that strikes me most about the conversations I overhear is how confused they are. They don't even seem clear whether they want to kill me or not."
- paulpauper 11y agoThe one for Square is off just 20% from the private round vs. Dec. 31st close. It hasn't really moved that much. Way too soon to assume it's under pressure. Most of the valuations gains were made in the years leading up to the IPO, as companies are going public later and later. That could explain why some of the post-IPO gains seem stunted.
- dawhizkid 11y agoMy guess is that Pinterest will have the most to prove in 2016 among the Unicorns. By far the biggest social network in terms of valuation with the least proven source of revenue.
- malandrew 11y agoPinterest can at least insert itself between you and products you might buy to earn referral dollars. My understanding is that for certain markets it has a lot of eyeballs like wedding planning. Personally, I think Snapchat has the most to prove.
- boomzilla 11y agoI think the novelty for Pinterest will wear off. There is only so much gratification in viewing beautiful pictures put together. I don't see any other value Pinterest is providing. Snapchat, on the other hand, at least provides a communication channel for a very active demographics. Yes, it has to compete with a lot of big guys in the space, but the utility is there in the product.
- mahyarm 11y agoI see the value of Pinterest being something like houzz. You recognize products being sold inside pictures and then sell ads related it to it. It's like visual google advertising. You get the advantage of people looking for the thing that they want to look at.
- Estragon 11y agosnapchat's unique appeal seems to be snakeoil, though. There has to be someone out there making a snapchat archive tool for nasty people.
- egillie 11y agoI think of Pinterest as replacing magazines à la 'Better Homes', and magazines didn't seem to suffer the novelty problem.
- 11y ago
- nstj 11y agoThere's a great podcast with Sam Altman discussing these "valuations" a couple of weeks back[0]. He describes how the valuations everyone talks about in the press often come from preferred stock financing rounds (ie: classes of stock which come with a caveat limiting both their upside and downside). As a result, the numbers betray what many people think to be the company's "valuation" come IPO time (Square, which possessed a 'ratchet' was an example of this apparently). As a result he said it's possible to largely disregard many of the stated "valuations" in the press for these $1bn+ companies as their financing rounds have been closer to debt than equity. One key upshot of this also was that people holding common stock (employees who have exercised options, e.g.) may be caught with their pants down as they made choices based on a stated valuation which differed from that of their shares. [0]: The Jay & Farhad Show: The Tech Industry: Tech Bubble or Tech Bust? https://overcast.fm/+DcD5EhUGs https://overcast.fm/+DcD5EhUGs
- steven2012 11y ago2016 is the year when Silicon Valley feels the wrath of Buffett's "when the tide goes out" old saying, and probably most haven't been wearing swimming trunks in a long time. The stupidity, of course, is the media and the rest of the Valley using VCs' own valuation as some sort of data, instead of the self-interested BS that it is. VCs are the greater-fool theory in action, and the greatest fool are the retail investors. Look at Groupon that somehow IPOed, and the only ones that lost money were the mutual funds and retail suckers that bought in. VCs are considered great if they are right 1 out of 10 times. The only reason why they don't go belly up is because they stack the deck in their favor through liquidation preferences, onerous funding terms, etc. So why on earth would we believe them when they say companies like Lyft are worth 5B or Snapchat is worth 20B? When the Revaluation of 2016 hits, it will be harsh and immediate. VCs act like a flock of birds and it's binary. Either they are in feeding frenzy mode, or they are cowards on the sidelines. When a couple of VCs start getting cold feet, they all get cold feet, and when that happens, unicorns start dying. Companies like Dropbox that have a real business model but whose maximum prospect of profits have been critically injured by Box's IPO, will probably get destroyed by either horrible funding terms or a Square-like IPO. Lyft will probably be dead by the end of 2016, and people will be wondering how they burned through 1.5B in funding. My bet is that 2/3 of the unicorns are acquihired for terrible terms, dead or on life-support by the end of 2016. If only I could short them, I would, but since I'm living in the Valley, I'm probably going to be negatively affected by this unfortunately.
- hitekker 11y ago> My bet is that 2/3 of the unicorns are acquihired for terrible terms, dead or on life-support by the end of 2016. If only I could short them, I would, but since I'm living in the Valley, I'm probably going to be negatively affected by this unfortunately. I make this same prediction, and the consequences will affect me as well.
- jedberg 11y ago> If only I could short them, I would, but since I'm living in the Valley, I'm probably going to be negatively affected by this unfortunately. Hey it's not all bad. The last time this happened, traffic on 101 got really great for a few years and you could get a reservation at any restaurant you wanted to (assuming you could afford it).
- Animats 11y agoBox. Uh oh. Maybe they shouldn't be building that second big building in downtown Redwood City. Could be worse. [1] That impressive building complex on the San Francisco bay was built to be the new headquarters of Excite@Home, which went bust in the first dot-com crash. Those buildings were empty for most of a decade. [1] https://goo.gl/maps/DbJevhk55wA2 https://goo.gl/maps/DbJevhk55wA2
- nickpsecurity 11y agoExcite. Oh darn, I guess I had finally forgotten they existed until you said that. Curious, did you ever use metasearch solutions like Turbosearch that showed top results from all those crappy engines?
- Animats 11y agoNo, I'm just aware of them because those buildings are near me. There's a public jogging trail around that big complex.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoYour answer is still unreal to me given I expected them to be ancient history by now.
- Animats 11y agoExcite@Home is long gone. The buildings remain.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoOh OK. That makes a lot more sense to me. :)