12 ms·
China passes law requiring tech firms to hand over encryption keys
- godzillabrennus 11y agoFirst, I can't see this actually working out they way they want especially with open source software designed to thrwart detection from governments using amongst other things a form of encryption. Second, I'm betting the US Government has enough sway to get special treatment for American companies.
- pjc50 11y agoUS Government has enough sway to get special treatment for American companies I don't think they do in this case; this is why Google pulled out and Cisco collaborate with the surveillance.
- jfoutz 11y agoAlthough, they do probably have enough sway to get all of China's keys. Perhaps not sway, perhaps just cracking. Nice of China to create a central repo with everything one could want.
- natch 11y agoHow would the US Government even have a leg to stand on here?
- troels 11y agoI'm sure there's a secret court somewhere that can make a decision. Of course we would never know.
- danwakefield 11y agoWell, HOPEFULLY, the western governments pushing for exactly the same thing might think twice now. Any breach in the Chinese system would also be beneficial in highlighting even more flaws in the concept.
- paul_milovanov 11y agoThey won't think twice, but I'm getting the popcorn to see the kind of PR acrobatics they think of around this.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- negus 11y agoPushing? Lol, they've pushed it long time ago https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law
- lazaroclapp 11y agoFrom that page: "there is currently no law regarding key disclosure in the United States" (nor is there in plenty other countries). This an area under very heavy active debate at the legal and political levels and that fact might change in a year. There have also been numerous cases where the lack of such law hasn't prevented agencies for requesting the decrypted data itself, in lieu of the keys. But it's not quite a done thing just yet. So if you oppose key disclosure, there are still plenty of chances to fight it at the political level in many countries.
- fucking_tragedy 11y agoIf anything, the fact that China is doing it is evidence that we need to do it as well to maintain national security.
- simonh 11y agoWhy?
- fucking_tragedy 11y agoIt's the reason given to the public for having given the reins of our communication and technology infrastructure to intelligence and security agencies. There are obvious reasons why the government would want to implement such a program, many of them having little to do with national security. Based on previous propaganda that's been fed to us over the past few years, this is the likely conclusion to be drawn.
- andrewclunn 11y agoSo US companies to be forced to put back doors into products that they sell in China. And the Chinese government DOESN'T think that the US government will also have those keys? It's like they're asking for the US to have full access to their sensitive data.
- paul_milovanov 11y agoIt's all ok as long as they know we know they know we know.
- cmurf 11y agoU.S. has asserted that subpoenas for data controlled by a U.S. company are valid, even if the data is stored exclusively out of the country. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Corporation_v._United_States_of_America https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Corporation_v._Unite... So I seriously doubt the Chinese government thinks the U.S. won't have the ability to get those keys. But these are device encryption keys used to encrypt data at rest on the device. This isn't a demand to escrow the private keys used for data in transit for email and messaging; I don't know how that works in China, i.e. the Great Firewall, if that just depends on blacklist/whitelist sites, or if all devices are required to use a Chinese government certificate for such communications.
- cjbprime 11y agoThe bottom of this article suggests that the requirement to "hand over encryption keys" isn't present in the bill: http://www.theverge.com/2015/12/27/10670346/china-passes-law-to-access-encrypted-communications http://www.theverge.com/2015/12/27/10670346/china-passes-law...
- shaobo 11y agoThe Verge (referencing WSJ) says firms are not required to handover encryption keys. http://www.theverge.com/2015/12/27/10670346/china-passes-law-to-access-encrypted-communications http://www.theverge.com/2015/12/27/10670346/china-passes-law...
- BinaryIdiot 11y agoThanks for that! Mods / admins can we get a more representative title here?
- cmurf 11y agoIt requires the OS/product vendor to enable key escrow though. Apple used to have a mechanism for this. Microsoft has a mechanism for this. And presumably all of them will escrow encryption keys for any products they sell in China. GCHQ wants this too. So if tech companies comply with China's law, why wouldn't they comply with the U.K.'s? And if they comply with the U.K. law, why couldn't there be one in the U.S.?
- blazespin 11y agoDo you have a cite for that? If Apple has to turn on / enable key escrow that's a very huge freaking deal.
- khalilravanna 11y agoI think the point is that Apple no longer has "backdoor" keys for encryption any longer so that they have no keys to give the government when they come knocking. I'm basing this conclusion off a quote from the article: "While the government insists that there will be no requirement for companies to install backdoor", as well as an interview with Tim Cook off 60 Minutes where he stated they won't be going the backdoor route anymore. I believe there are more quotes available from him if you google "apple encryption backdoor".
- throwaway7767 11y ago
- lasermike026 11y agoNo one outside of IT should have access to crypto keys for any reason. Dinosaur government institutions need to get with it or go away. Now that I'm done with that this is a critical issue. Mass surveillance is one of the many issues of our time. Time to get to work and time to throw some money at this.
- VLM 11y agoCrypto is too easy. Yes, too easy. Its too easy to make a single master key for a government to demand or someone to steal that unlocks everything. In 1915 when a discovery subpoena goes out for all records relating to dumping dioxanes in a river, the company legitimately unlocks the filing cabinet and hands the files over. They don't get a key to the executive washroom or the telegram private code directory (unless that was in the subpoena) or the complete customer list or really pretty much anything but the paper files relating to dumping dioxanes in the river. In 2015 when a discovery subpoena goes out for all records relating to dumping dioxanes in a river, the company freaks out because if they hand out "the" public key then both the .gov and any .com they're affiliated with and probably individual theives will pown every VPN they ever had and ever will, and all their records of every sort so "oh no we can't hand over keys never to no one". When you look at it from that point of view, the abject failure of IT and IT companies to properly handle encryption is by no means any reason for the judicial legal system to be inconvenienced. In 1915 no judge would have tolerated a response like "Well we can't give you the dioxane pollution paper files and telegrams because then criminals would pown our company because we're incompetent at IT" The other part is sociological. You may hold that phone in your hand, but its not yours, and using it is as dangerous as talking to a police officer or government official or hacker. Its not your phone, never has been, and any illusion to the contrary will result in tears. Ditto a site on the internet. Government protection of privacy assumes the privacy ever existed in the first place, which it doesn't.
- jeff_marshall 11y agoThe existance of "the" key is not an inherent problem in situations like this. Instead, it speaks to poor key management practices by the people responsible for implementing cryptography for an organization. Consider, as an analogy, the (poor) practice of using shared passwords. What do you do when you fire someone who had legitimate access to this password? You have to change everything or risk a compromise of all the systems sharing this password. Hence, the need for tools like sudo that separate authentication (what password / auth key) and access control (what rights). With encryption, it's similarly possible to break one big risk domain into lots of smaller ones using things like separate trust anchors (for authentication) or encryption keys (for access control). For example, If your org gets served a subpeona for your financial records you can give them your tape backups for the relevant time periods plus the necessary decryption key, but withold the decryption key for the backups of your R&D data and the signing key for your VPN.
- Animats 11y ago"This rule accords with the actual work need of fighting terrorism and is basically the same as what other major countries in the world do." "When changes in technology hinder law enforcement’s ability to exercise investigative tools and follow critical leads, we may not be able to identify and stop terrorists who are using social media to recruit, plan, and execute an attack in our country." One of the above is from Li Shouwei, the deputy head of the Chinese parliament's criminal law division. The other is from the US FBI director.
- rsync 11y ago"One of the above is from Li Shouwei, the deputy head of the Chinese parliament's criminal law division. The other is from the US FBI director." ... who have more in common with each other than they do with any of their constituents.
- sergiotapia 11y agothat_is_the_joke.jpeg
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- themartorana 11y agoYeah, but that's not the point. It's that the reasoning is equally appalling, and the outcome is dangerously close to being equally horrific.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tootie 11y agoThe second one is merely an observation of fact.
- AnkhMorporkian 11y agoIn no world should this be surprising. Law enforcement officials have always wanted all power possible to do their jobs. The job of the government is not to give into every demand that law enforcement puts on the table.
- rinze 11y agoWrite laws against the dissidence, but call it terrorism. Then you can argue that you are just trying to get the same level of access everybody else is asking for.
- jumpbackwards 11y agoMany countries require this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law#United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law#United_King... UK is a great example and a good place to not store any valuable data.
- crististm 11y agoIt's time to reconsider our irrational (actually inherited) opposition to "security through obscurity" [ * ]. In times when big brother knows you're using AES and forcibly asks you for the keys, it makes sense to not advertise your encryption scheme at all. Steganography. [ * ] It actually makes more sense to enlarge the search space of an attacker by not providing him the fixed form of a known encryption algorithm/scheme.
- mindslight 11y agoThe formal name for the concept is Kerckhoffs's principle. And no, it is not time to reconsider it. It has more to do with defining what the "key" is, and is quite compatible with steganography. If your method is simply "cipher data", it can never have steganographic properties.. If instead it's "two redundant-looking blobs, one random and one AES", then you've got a leg to stand on.
- crististm 11y agoYou are free to stand by your principles. I'm arguing that "security through obscurity" is not equivalent with the "Kerckhoffs's principle" but with adding more obfuscation layers (on which steganography may be one of them) on top of default schemes. People who know better don't advertise their internal network topology. Nor do they show off with their encryption schemes (they might use known schemes but they won't tell you they do it).
- mindslight 11y agoHow those additional layers are defined is quite important as to their effectiveness - do they hold up to scrutiny, or are they merely good enough to trick their designer? Lumping effective crypto along with feel-good ad-hoc schemes into one big category of "obfuscation" is a disservice to analysis. I'll repeat - Kerckhoffs's principle is more about analysis than design. If you insist on eschewing it, what you're actually doing is making it so the "key" of your system includes the design of the system itself. And while it intuitively seems "more key" should make the system more secure, the net effect is the opposite as that poorly-specified "key" merely functions as a difficult-to-analyze crutch. Gödel basically guarantees that anybody can make a cryptosystem so secure they themselves cannot break it. Don't be that guy.
- laotzu 11y agoSo basically any device manufactured in China and sold abroad should be assumed to be rooted by the Chinese government?
- VLM 11y agoAnd any company related to the Chinese government, which is basically all of them. So if you make tractors and use Chinese computers to make tractors, your Chinese competitor who makes tractors can be assumed to have full access to your computer systems, for all practical purposes.
- coldtea 11y ago[citation needed]
- mahranch 11y agoNot OP, but "capitalism" in China isn't like it is in the west. The government literally runs everything, and can demand literally anything they want from companies. If China's government wanted Lenavo to start making blow up dolls, that's exactly what they would do. China's government has absolute authority and total control. People like to compare the U.S government to China's, but these people are fedora wearing neckbeards who almost never leave their parents basement. As someone who has lived in China for a brief stint, expecting any device built, designed and manufactured in China not to have some sort of back door is like expecting the U.S not to spy. At this stage in the game, it's understood and expected. If they're requiring backdoors on technology imported into the country (source: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2015/03/05/obama_criticises_china_tech_rules_backdoor_terrorism/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2015/03/05/obama_criticises_chi... ), why wouldn't they require them on their own technology that they build themselves? It doesn't make sense from a purely logical standpoint. Of course they're not going to come out and admit it, but we're also starting to see evidence of it: Example 1: http://www.zdnet.com/article/former-pentagon-analyst-china-has-backdoors-to-80-of-telecoms/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/former-pentagon-analyst-china-h... Example 2: http://www.geek.com/chips/spy-agencies-shun-lenovo-finding-backdoors-built-into-the-hardware-1563801/ http://www.geek.com/chips/spy-agencies-shun-lenovo-finding-b... Example 3: http://www.computerworld.com/article/2860742/chinese-android-phone-maker-hides-secret-backdoor-on-its-devices.html http://www.computerworld.com/article/2860742/chinese-android... Is it really so hard to believe? Especially when the indirect evidence and logic is so overwhelming? I'm no tin-foil hat wearing conspiracy nut, but come on here... It's China.
- ck2 11y agoI've decided I am going to say "tank man" in every China thread so their censors will kill the page. As horrible as many of things the US has done in the name of its citizens (and on its citizens) one thing you'll never see happen here is internet censorship (instead one-day some US agency will just record every page you've read, or maybe they will have the UK do it for them, so they are technically not spying on their own citizens)
- dragonwriter 11y ago> As horrible as many of things the US has done in the name of its citizens (and on its citizens) one thing you'll never see happen here is internet censorship Internet censorship happens in the US, though its mostly in the form of government pressure on major internet companies to remove access to disfavored content rather than direct government censorship.
- ck2 11y agoHmm, it is disfavored or illegal content originating in the US? Because I've seen US law enforcement takedown US websites that were breaking US laws but I've never heard of law enforcement forcing US isps block foreign content, even if it is breaking US law. I could be wrong though and I'd like to see an example in that case. Maybe the government making youtube or facebook take down terrorist content, that would be censorship I guess if the content is not technically illegal but that's a pretty extreme example.
- Dylan16807 11y agoThey've taken domain names, does that count as blocking?
- dragonwriter 11y agoWhen it is done because of content, and particularly to suppress content (as opposed to the domain owners rights to particular content), there is a pretty good argument that it is a form of censorship.
- mc32 11y agoIt'll be interesting to see what Apple do in this case, their having said that they would not build backdoors for their products --but it's difficult to see them turn away from one of their largest markets. I'm guessing they will make concessions for the sake of market, whreas Google, so far, has resisted that temptation.
- blazespin 11y agoWill Apple have to start escrowing the root key for devices they sell in China?
- ams6110 11y agoIt will be interesting to see whether they value their principles more than sales in the Chinese marketplace.
- robryk 11y agoSo how does it apply to e.g. keys to backups of Apple devices if the device was bought out of China and then used in China?
- timguoqk 11y agoA friend of mine has a startup in China. He told me a year ago that the law already required his company to talk with government officials every month. They also needed to create a backdoor API according to a well-written specification for the government to access all the information in the database.
- TheSpiceIsLife 11y agowell-written specification That may very well be the defining difference between the Chinese and Western-governments.
- astrostl 11y ago"The United States is a nation of laws: badly written and randomly enforced." - Frank Zappa
- enraged_camel 11y agoI think "selectively enforced" is a better way to put it.
- slowmovintarget 11y agoNo, Frank Zappa had it best. Your words may be more accurate but his words are better.
- jijji 11y agohahah good luck with that
- xjia 11y agoAccording to the original text, tech firms are only required to provide necessary technical support in decryption, not simply handing over the keys. http://news.xinhuanet.com/politics/2015-12/27/c_128571798.htm http://news.xinhuanet.com/politics/2015-12/27/c_128571798.ht...
- netcan 11y agoI wonder if at some point in the future this will seem like a reasonable request for IS to make?
- krick 11y agoI think in the most "civilized" countries for the long time already it's that we (as whole communities) agree to the law (and the authority) either because we don't know about it or we believe that we personally (as individuals) will never have to actually follow it. I wonder if we're far beyond the point when we could actually stop following the law if it becomes bad enough and it's already virtually 1984 but we just didn't really notice. Or if there's still some hope out there, somewhere.
- DKnol 11y agoI'm terribly interested in what kind of environment "if it becomes bad enough" specifically refers to, in your comment.
- slowmovintarget 11y agoMy wife, a current citizen of China, has a uniform response to these kinds of stories. "Well what do they expect!? If you do business in China, of course that's what you get. If they don't like it they can get out." Her point being that no one should be surprised when an authoritarian government exerts its authority. Also, water is wet.
- jmckib 11y agoNo offense, but it sounds like she's trying to justify authoritarianism by shifting the blame to its victims for not "getting out".
- crdb 11y agoI read it somewhat differently. From my limited interaction with Chinese citizen as a resident of Singapore, many think more pragmatically. "We do what it takes to get a billion people to first world middle class standard of living. Yes, there's a bit of collateral damage but you guys' industrial revolution was not all roses, read some Dickens. We can have the luxury of rights when we're there. You're telling me to eat cake since we ran out of bread." In other words the majority of Chinese citizen (that I know - YMMV, selection bias, etc.) think that the government is doing an alright job considering its constraints, and don't feel particularly oppressed - the authoritarianism is population-sanctioned. Just like the new French anti-terrorism measures.
- paul_milovanov 11y agocrdb: are you my separated-at-birth twin? I've been looking for you all my life. These are my thoughts exactly, down to my favorite Dickensian analogy. Everybody's favorite pastime, pointing fingers on China on everything from "freedoms" to the environment, is really more of a reflection on the commentators' astonishing lack of historical perspective. There's no shortage of fifty-year-olds around China today (say, about a population of Sweden's worth) that will tell you how they were plucked out of the university and sent to work the fields for years during the Cultural Revolution, and point out the exact level -- somewhere between knee- and waist-deep in shit -- that the country was at prior to Deng Xiaoping. I'm sure anybody that witnessed the change from then to now would have a richer and more nuanced opinion on China's government.
- azevedomarti 11y agoChina: We passed the law. Everyone on earth knows we are controlling the internet. U.S.: We support freedom but due to national security, we can control the internet without passing the law. By the way, please help us to hunt Edward Joseph Snowden. He violates our definition of freedom and transparency. Thank you!