8 ms·
Biggest mystery in mathematics in limbo after cryptic meeting
- mipapage 11y agoI remember at university how, when attending the few multi-disciplinary meetings or get-togethers, I would marvel that these people - on the same campus! - didn't get together more often in order to share and stimulate growth or share strategies, which inevitably occurred during these meetings. I wonder why a handful of qualified mathematicians couldn't get together and go to Japan to sort this proof out...
- hgibbs 11y agoThere is literally only a handful of mathematicians that are qualified and they have gone to Oxford to sort it out - bar mochizuki.
- mipapage 11y agoYes, part of what I was trying to say is why not get that handful of folks together and go to Japan, to the source. Logistics? Ego? Funding? Perhaps a trip is in the cards...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- OJFord 11y agoThis was just one workshop that happened to be at Oxford. Probably it occurred the other way around to you imagine - "let's host a workshop here [at Oxford], what shall be the topic?" Article says there is another one planned in Japan that will no doubt be attended by a (proper, less those put off!) subset of those at Oxford.
- jessriedel 11y agoMoney and time. I'm sure you could straight-up pay some of the qualified mathematicians to figure it out, but you'd need to make it worth their while. Offer to buy out their salary for a couple of years, plus hire them a few postdocs and grad students to further their own projects, and I'm sure a few would be happy to help. But it would cost the better part of $1M for each guy.
- mturmon 11y agoThere was an earlier workshop in Japan. From wiki: "A workshop on IUT was held at RIMS [Japan] in March 2015 and in Beijing in July 2015. A CMI workshop on IUT theory of Mochizuki was held in December 2015 in Oxford, IUT-Oxford (2015). A workshop on IUT will be held in July 2016 at RIMS."
- zbyszek 11y agoHaving worked in a university mathematics department I noticed that the pure mathematicians tended to keep themselves to themselves, for instance not attending talks by visiting mathematicians unless it was of direct relevance to their research. In contrast, we theoretical physicists would listen to any visiting speaker just for fun - even on occasion experimental particle physicists, applied mathematicians or computing specialists. Perhaps pure maths is just more deeply specialised and leaves no possibility of such dilettanteism.
- Al-Khwarizmi 11y agoI think it's probably because it's very difficult to understand a pure math talk if you didn't already have significant understanding of the subject before the talk. I don't work on pure mathematics, but I work in a field of computer science where there is both theoretical and empirical/applied research, and I do, and enjoy doing, both. However, when it comes to attending talks, I do go to a lot of talks on empirical subjects just for fun, but I hardly ever go to a highly theoretical talk for fun. I only do that if the talk is highly related to the specific work I do; if you see me in a theoretical talk otherwise, it's probably just for social compromise. The reason is that I can perfectly understand the gist of an empirical paper in 20 or 30 minutes, where there is no way I will understand a piece of theoretical research by listening to a talk if I haven't gone through the paper carefully before (and if you have done that, there is often no point in going to the talk anyway). Honestly I think the talk format doesn't lend itself too well to highly theoretical work. I have learned a lot about empirical research and obtained many useful ideas from talks, but in the theoretical field, the useful ideas and insights I got from talks are few and far between, and I would probably have obtained them more efficiently from reading papers anyway...
- serge2k 11y ago> True to form, Mochizuki himself did not attend, although he did answer participants’ questions through Skype Why not present his papers through skype? If the problem is just a dislike of travelling. It could also help with any issues related to public speaking or that type of thing.
- JonnieCache 11y agoHere's a detailed report on the situation from one Brian Conrad, who attended the meeting: http://mathbabe.org/2015/12/15/notes-on-the-oxford-iut-workshop-by-brian-conrad/ http://mathbabe.org/2015/12/15/notes-on-the-oxford-iut-works...
- logicallee 11y agoI don't understand how something, that anyone understands, can be this cryptic. Someone some time ago mentioned that all of Einstein's major papers on special and general relativitiy can be covered in a semester or two. Isn't the hard part discovering this stuff? How can anyone discover mathematical proofs but it is so impossible to communicate them that nobody in the world can follow your train of thought? I mean people are really, really good at communicating. It's kind of what we do. I don't understand how anyone can publish proofs that don't succumb easily to understanding by experts who concentrate on them for a long time, perhaps with tiny hints by the author. It's not as though we're looking at fragments written in a long-lost language we have no access to, from a culture nobody has access to, on unknown subjects, and with the authors dead hundreds of years ago! The author is right there. The subject isn't even art (like poetry criticism or something), it's fully rigorous. Understanding someone's proof (for devoted experts) should be easy, right? What gives?
- mmarx 11y agoThe papers on Inter-universal Teichmueller theory span over 500 pages alone, and they build on material developed earlier that needs to be understood too. Those papers were published a little over 3 years ago, so claiming that they can't be understood “by experts who concentrate on them for a long time” might be a bit premature.
- logicallee 11y agobut the article doesn't make it sound like it's not "fully understood." the article makes it sound like not even the summary is known - for example, what parts of the other papers are used, what isn't. As though the experts didn't even known what parts of theories were being referred to. very bizarre.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoThe summary is known. Have you read the abstracts?
- aamar 11y agoNot mentioned: Kedlaya was Mochizuki's student and then later his teaching assistant back in '92-'94 (for a tough course[1]). Mochizuki hasn't had that many students; Kedlaya might be one of a few to have an advantage in understanding his approach. The bad news is that the new participants seem to have made no progress on the IUT papers themselves. But the good news is that some substantial progress was made on the background material, and that there are some folks still interested in continuing. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Math_55 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Math_55
- guard-of-terra 11y agoI guess we can now ask a lot of simple questions in math for whose there can be answer, but the solution itself is untenably long to be produced or understood by mere mortal, not a computer or computer-like individual. Same way as we can't really reason about inner workings of machine learning model that yields useful results. Talk about transhumanism.
- bhaak 11y agoJust because his proof is long, convoluted, and cryptic doesn't mean that there won't be a simpler proof down the road. Maybe some of the tools just haven't been developed yet. Look for example at how the Greeks and Romans struggled with mathematical problems many of which are today easily solvable in high school because we have advanced techniques and a positional notation for numbers. As far as I understand it, a lot of the problem stems from the fact that Mochizuki is quite a hermit. And that's a problem if you want others to understand what you have done for years. This workshop was crucial that it showed several people that trying to understand the proof could be a worthwhile task.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoWhat if there won't be? What if, for many of questions, the only proof is as decipherable as MD5 of question?
- bhaak 11y agoThat's probably highly improbable. Look at how many different proofs the are for the pythagorean theorem: http://www.cut-the-knot.org/pythagoras/ http://www.cut-the-knot.org/pythagoras/ I'm not mathematician but I guess if there is really only one possible proof for a given question (Gödel might have proven that this is impossible but I don't know for sure), then the question isn't actually an interesting one. Because this would mean that the question touches only very few topics. But the abc conjecture is interesting because it has lots of links with deep questions in number theory.
- 11y ago
- ryporter 11y agoI view some of these math researchers like startup founders who are absolutely brilliant technically, but who lack almost all ability to interact with customers, investors, etc. As a solo founder, they will fail. However, if they attract a co-founder who complements their skills, they can be wildly successful. It sounds like Mochizuki would have benefited greatly from such a co-author, in order to truly prove his result to the community.
- enewc 11y agoMath is objective. The proof is either correct or not. Human interaction doesn't matter, except for perhaps marketing the importance of the results. In this case, the history of the problem itself has done the marketing, so any valid solution would be a wild success regardless of how socially eccentric the researcher is. Another recent example of such a mathematician is Grigori Perelman.
- moron4hire 11y agoMathematics, being a human endeavor, is fundamentally about human interaction. There's no point to doing math if there is no communicating it to other people.
- eveningcoffee 11y agoThere's no point to doing math if there is no communicating it to other people. I would not agree with that. One can do math for personal pleasure.
- webkike 11y agoYou can argue that everything can be reduced to human interaction, but mathematics is certainly not about human interaction in any meaningful sense
- moron4hire 11y agoIt's the only pure way to describe existence. That isn't meaningful? Mathematics is a language, first and foremost. To argue otherwise is to fundamentally misunderstand its goals, methods, and form. You can draw all the squiggly lines on paper that you want, but it won't mean anything until someone else interpets it. You cannot prove logic that only exists in your own head, because you cannot prove yourself rational. Your very existence does not even make sense without other people perceiving you.
- lelf 11y agoIf you don't follow how it came mathematicians have so much trouble with some papers: This is part I — http://www.kurims.kyoto-u.ac.jp/~motizuki/Inter-universal%20Teichmuller%20Theory%20I.pdf http://www.kurims.kyoto-u.ac.jp/~motizuki/Inter-universal%20...
- IshKebab 11y agoJesus. This surely requires a computational proof.
- ilitirit 11y agoIt is essentially a communications problem. Brian Conrad summed it up: For every subject I have ever understood in mathematics, there are instructive basic examples and concise arguments to illustrate what is the point to generally educated mathematicians. There is no reason that IUT should be any different, especially for the audience that was present at Oxford. Let me illustrate this with a short story. During one of the tea breaks I was chatting with a postdoc who works in analysis, and I mentioned sheaf theory as an example of a notion which may initially look like pointless abstract nonsense but actually allows for very efficient consideration of useful ideas which are rather cumbersome (or impossible) to contemplate in more concrete terms. Since that postdoc knew nothing about what can be done with sheaf theory, I told him about the use of sheaf cohomology to systematize and analyze the deRham theorem and topological obstructions to construction problems in complex analysis; within 20 minutes he understood the point and wanted to learn more. Nobody expects to grasp the main points of IUT within 20 minutes, but if someone says they understand a theory and does not provide instructive visibly relevant examples and concise arguments that clearly illustrate what is the point then they are not trying hard enough. Many are willing to work hard to understand what must be very deep and powerful ideas, but they need a clearer sense of the landscape before beginning their journey. http://mathbabe.org/2015/12/15/notes-on-the-oxford-iut-workshop-by-brian-conrad/ http://mathbabe.org/2015/12/15/notes-on-the-oxford-iut-works...
- paulmd 11y ago>hyperbolic orbicurve >global realified Frobenioid picture You just made that up. --Maths Professors
- moosinho 11y agoLet's map some ideas: Mochizuki -> Prophet | abc conjecture -> "god" conjecture | 500-page proof -> "holy book" And there we go, a brand new religion. The whole situation is like something out of Monty Python.
- ilitirit 11y agoHere's a comic that makes light of the situation: http://www.sandraandwoo.com/comics/2014-11-24-0636-hodge-theater.png http://www.sandraandwoo.com/comics/2014-11-24-0636-hodge-the... From: http://www.sandraandwoo.com/2014/11/24/0636-hodge-theater/ http://www.sandraandwoo.com/2014/11/24/0636-hodge-theater/
- williamjennings 11y agoI just learned about Math 55 and would trade plenty to teach that course. The problem here is that Mochizuki uses too many German Nazi references. Those people had no academic integrity whatsoever; and their works are exclusively stolen, through war crimes and the Holocaust. After you do the right thing, and translate Mochizuki's nomenclature into French and Slavic; the proof is no longer valid, and the problem is negligible. For the record, Oswald Teichmüller is a fraudulent Nazi war criminal who robbed Felix Hausdorff during the Holocaust. The undeniable fact that Oswald Teichmüller is solely published in a journal of racial propaganda makes Mochizuki's choice of terminology questionable at the very least. The fact that I am being suppressed for this demonstrates unambiguously that Mochizuki's proof is nothing more than media hype and puffery.
- late2part 11y agoI dont understand what you mean. Can you clarify?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- williamjennings 11y agoOswald Teichmüller stole technical documents from Felix Hausdorff and then published the written material in a Nazi pseudoscience journal, alongside racial propaganda. It is therefore incorrect to cite Oswald Teichmüller, because his words are criminal plagiarism presented in an abhorrent context.
- MatekCopatek 11y agoI can agree with this being extremely problematic in a political sense - it's horribly wrong to rip someone off, even more so by robbing them during wartime. Quoting such stolen material is a kind of passive support and should not be tolerated. BUT - how does that affect it from a purely scientific perspective? Is the quoted stolen material also incorrect? Because it would be equally bad, IMHO, to ignore an important and correct scientific finding just because it was produced in an unacceptable way. If I exaggerate a bit, it's similar to someone experimenting on babies to discover a cure for AIDS - sure, they're a terrible person and should not receive praise/compensation for their discovery, their actions should be condemned. But should we also throw away the discovered cure?
- timwaagh 11y agothe reason they fail to understand the proof seems the same everybody else fails at math. funny even the greatest mathematicians can have this problem.
- espeed 11y ago"A consensus emerged that the highlight of the workshop was a lecture on 9 December by Kiran Kedlaya, an arithmetic geometer from the University of California, San Diego. He zeroed in on a result from a 2008 paper by Mochizuki5 that linked the statement of the abc conjecture to another branch of maths called topology. The link was immediately recognised as a crucial step in Mochizuki’s grand strategy. "
- myth_buster 11y agoOn a related note, Shinichi Mochizuki has been speculated to be Satoshi Nakamoto. http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2013/05/19/ted-nelson-says-that-bitcons-satoshi-nakamoto-is-shinichi-mochizuki/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2013/05/19/ted-nelso...
- PaulWillis 11y agoI'm not a mathematician at all but does anyone know if this may have implications in the field of cryptography, because it involves prime numbers? Also, the word "cryptic" in the title. ;)