14 ms·
The sad economics of being famous on the internet
- dayon 11y agoWow. That's one of the most eye-opening articles I've read. I admit to having no idea how difficult it is, at least for some social media stars, to get by on e-fame. The take-aways for me are: 1. If you become famous on social media, understand that it might not make you enough money to survive, paradoxically with more fame leading to possibly less income. 2. If you must make videos, vlogs, blogs, or whatever else online, do something that you want to do for its own sake. Make something that in itself is valuable. Don't make a song because you think it'll make you money or a branded informative video because you think it'll net you an audience and therefore income. Create something great for the sake of the greatness. That way, you can't really lose either way. Because, it seems, either way, you're going to lose.
- malbs 11y agoYou've nailed it right there... "do something that you want to do for its own sake". There are multiple problems solved - you don't come across as fake or forced, the content you're covering seems natural, because you are generally interested in it. The flow of content comes easily because you're actively engaged in the community, so you're almost creating new content accidentally, as a by product of your self-interest. I watch my daughters and their engagement with youtubers, twitchers etc, what seems crazy to me, in terms of what I would watch on you tube, they happily consume - watching people unwrap items they've ordered online, new fads, hours of gaming sessions. I mean really? I'd rather play the games myself! It does lend a lot of weight to the idea that the next generation of celebrities are online based only... The downside is they can't monetize their fame! Or at least, don't know how to yet. I make that whole "next gen celebs online only" comment like it hasn't happened yet, knowing that it is well on the way again from observing my 13/12/11 yr old daughters and their use of youtube/minecraft/instagram (did you notice the lack of Facebook? Yeah...)
- kiba 11y agoI tried to watch youtuber and twitch play games, but mostly I just don't care. Sometime, I get really into it. The vast majority, I just ignore their channel. I suspect it may not all be a generation gap. Some people just find watching other people play games interesting. Others don't.
- malbs 11y agoI can't stand to watch other people play games. I'm with you.
- VLM 11y agoAlso, some games are extremely visual and creative, like minecraft, others are more cinematic / on rails and those games in YT form tend to be excruciatingly boring.
- jerf 11y ago"It depends". I'm fond of Spoiler Warning, which I've been watching for a while, because it's a bunch of 30-somethings (like me) doing interesting game criticism in addition to the other things Let's Plays usually do. They're actually one of the earlier iterations of the idea. I also don't get the appeal of watching someone simply play the game and just generally react, when I could be playing it (or something else) myself. I've only sampled those streams every so often just to check the game itself out (i.e., briefly just sampled about 3 minutes of Angry Joe's Fallout 4 stream, just to see completely unvarnished, real footage). On the topic of 30-somethings, while you may hear a lot more about the youth, I gotta say there's a lot of "30 somethings" in the general "Internet video" space, doing various interesting works. I noticed once I started getting into Patreon that without particularly meaning to be hipster, an awful lot of my entertainment time is spent on grain-fed, organically-raised artisanal Internet video now. It just sorta... happened.
- vlehto 11y agoThere seems to be sex divide coming in future social media. And I can't blame them. Girls need some girl time, boys need some boy time.
- pdkl95 11y ago> Create something great for the sake of the greatness. I strongly recommend ViHart's discussion[1] of Edmund Snow Carpenter's[2] "They Became What The Beheld". It is very easy to focus on the medium, when you should be focusing on the message. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bm-Jjvqu3U4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bm-Jjvqu3U4 [2] Marshall McLuhan may have written the initial version of that book.
- mozumder 11y agoA big problem these people face is their inability to actually sell ad inventory. They have the viewership to get them rich. A million views at $10/CPM for video views is a good $10,000 at a 100% fill rate. If they produce just one of these videos per month, that can get them a nice salary. And they probably do several of these videos per week. These people really need ad salesmen to turn their channels into real businesses. They're not going to have the time to sell ads themselves. There are a lot of issues behind selling ads (just because you have a billion views, doesn't mean you're useful to advertisers), but going to a site like sellercrowd.com should get them some leads on salespeople and techniques.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mozumder 11y agoVideo CPM is far higher than Banner ad CPM. In any case, these people don't have ad salespeople, which is the missing ingredient for profit.
- Donzo 11y agoThis is not true, at least not for AdSense. I've found that display advertising, particularly on desktop, outperforms YouTube ads at about 2.5 to 1.
- seibelj 11y agoAdMob, interstitial (full screen) mobile ads, holy shit. Highest pay rates I have ever seen. The clash of clans style freemium games pay through the roof.
- flashman 11y ago> These people really need ad salesmen to turn their channels into real businesses. That's what multi-channel networks[1] are all about. MCNs build a roster of marketable talent and (the best ones) work out things like ad sales, product placement, collaborations and appearances in other media. They take a cut and the YouTuber gets to focus on their craft (some MCNs even have shared high-end production facilities). Google has a cozy relationship with many MCNs because of the revenue they can drive and the way they keep content creators in the YouTube ecosystem. This is a best-case scenario - there are of course numerous shadier networks. [1]https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2737059?hl=en https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2737059?hl=en
- Animats 11y agoThat's normal. In 2009, there were five million bands on Myspace. Some of which didn't suck. Maybe five hundred of them broke even. If you've spent any time in LA, you've met actress/model/waitress types. Walk-on parts in a few movies, some commercial work, no real money. Authors have the same problem. A decade ago, there were people who thought blogging was a career. That's so dead. The Huffington Post is now an Aol content farm, with content-farm type rates. Fame leading to riches was an artifact of expensive distribution. That's so over.
- majani 11y agoI wouldn't say fame leading to riches is over. It just follows an extreme long tail curve where less than 10% of the ones who get fame get all the good money, and the other 90% get scraps. Come to think of it, that's just how most businesses are.
- VLM 11y agoCould you model it as a logical fallacy? All super rich people are famous. Trump, Bush family, Walton family, etc. Rich, therefore you're famous. In logical fallacy land, all famous people are therefore rich. And youtube people are psuedo-famous (lets be realistic, 99% to 99.9% of the population don't care about them) therefore they must be rich. Via the miracle of hollywood accounting, I distinctly remember William Shatner (or was it Leonard Nimoy) temporarily living in a van down by the river in the 70s in between trek and later revenue sources. In the hollywood PR era they were all rich even when they were not, in the YT era it can't be covered up anymore.
- vinceguidry 11y agoThe super-rich definitely are not all famous. Plenty of insanely rich executives out there you wouldn't recognize and never make headlines. They may be well-known in their fields, but purposefully keep themselves out of the public eye.
- n72 11y agoThere seems to be the implicit assumption in the post that if one is famous then one should be earning significant money somehow. This is a false assumption. Moreover, perhaps if no one is paying for the content, then it's not worth paying for.
- rotw 11y agoThat's blatantly not true, people on the internet have become massive cheapskates due to the easy availability of everything. Since Napster, piracy has flourished and continues to do so, and most often the most-pirated products correspond strongly to what's most popular in the market.
- fisherjeff 11y agoI think a reasonable, but also apparently false, assumption would be that if you invest significant amounts of time, energy and money into putting out a product consumed by hundreds of thousands of people, you should be able to make at least a living wage.
- FussyZeus 11y agoThe problem with that assumption is that the consumption occurring is probably <10 minutes of killed time for the consumer. What would you pay to lose 10 minutes while waiting for your wife to get out of the changing room or your kid to get out of school or whatever? You wouldn't pay a damn thing for that. Just because a product is widely consumed doesn't make it valuable any more than the time and money put into making it. I can spend thousands to create a 2 by 2 cube of steel and stick it in my front yard, the fact that investment was made doesn't mean its valuable. Edit: Bad typo.
- Swizec 11y agoFame is a marketing channel. The best money comes if it's a marketing channel for a service that you sell. This has always been the case and is why movie stars become producers, why music stars start labels, and why sports stars start promotion companies and clothing lines. In other words: fame is a means to an end, not an end.
- wutbrodo 11y agoI don't mean to sound heartless, but can anyone explain how the economics of these new Internet-enabled distribution channels are "sad"? Don't get me wrong, I've found poverty and lack of economic opportunity to be very sad, for far longer than it's been fashionable to do so, but that's not really what the article's talking about. > Every other week, Tonjes, 29, debates getting another job but wonders how she’d have the time to keep up her three channels on top of a 9-to-5. Maybe keep up two channels? or one? Before the Internet, this story would have been a person stuck in a crappy job who doesn't get to indulge their passion for music _at all_, since they would get _zero_ dollars for it (barring the enormously low chance of getting a major-label record deal, an option which still technically exists). The low barriers to entry for YouTube/Instagram/etc are the other side of the coin for lower income per subscriber than traditional gated channels like getting signed at a record company. TL;DR: Someone being unable to afford their groceries is what's actually sad, but this isn't an article about poverty and lack of a safety net. Low-barrier, low-gatekeeper distribution channels like YT or Instagram _mitigate_ this problem, not create it. Calling the economics of being Internet-famous sad is missing the point by a mile.
- olavk 11y ago> I've found poverty and lack of economic opportunity to be very sad, for far longer than it's been fashionable to do so You are pretty old then, I guess?
- hkmurakami 11y agoConsidering there are quite a few pentagenerians on HN, that wouldn't be so rare.
- wutbrodo 11y agoHaha, fair enough: I can see how my pithy phrasing of that part of my comment could be interpreted to mean that I saw myself as the only one who cared about poverty and how the world was cruel and nobody else understood </angsty teenager>. What I actually meant by "fashionable" was that, in the couple decades preceding the financial crisis, it was far, far from the mainstream to be concerned about or even acknowledge some of the structural economic issues that had been growing since the 80s or so in the US (for example, dropping social mobility, which is more or less agreed to be a bad thing pretty much across the political spectrum). There were obviously plenty of people who cared in the same period, but that's not really what "fashionable" means. So no, I'm not particularly old, but caring about those issues in particular for a couple of decades gives me something like a 15-year head-start on the epoch we're currently in, when suddenly even the most ignorant and apathetic person in the country can quote factoids from a Robert Reich book or whatever. At any rate, it was a throwaway remark to point out that I'm not just pretending to care about the deeper issues underlying how "sad" Internet economics are because I think it's the "in" thing to do (I know plenty of people who are like this for any social issue that's currently in vogue).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- gedrap 11y agoI understand the sentiment that if you work hard you should get paid a proportional amount of money. But, well, welcome to real life. There are things in life that pays the bills and others that don't, no matter how hard you work at it, therefore, you have to decide how much time and resources you can afford to spend on it. It seems like for these people, they are making a trade off in terms of income and self-realization balance. I feel a bit bad about this slightly cynical comment but, well, that's what I think. It would be absolutely amazing if we all could make a living from what we enjoy. On another note, I might have missed it in the article but I didn't see the author talking about the target audience? Shouldn't it make a huge difference in terms of CPM and therefore revenue? Because I'd imagine that advertisers are willing to pay totally different amounts of money if your average subscriber is in late 20s or 30s, from the USA, UK or Canada and with middle or higher level of income, compared to just a bunch of high schoolers who have little spending power?
- jfoutz 11y agoThat's not really how it works though. First "hard" work isn't really relevant at all. Effective work, that's huge. Second, (but perhaps a variation) quality matters a lot. Since the internet lets everyone talk to everyone (mostly) you get this power law effect. The best take the lion's share of the money. Everyone else struggles. it's a tournament. the very best, or at least most popular, take home millions. Everyone else is bush league and take home pretty much nothing.
- gedrap 11y ago>>> That's not really how it works though. First "hard" work isn't really relevant at all. Effective work, that's huge. Oh absolutely, no doubt about that. It's just that people (outside small circles like HN) don't talk about it and is definitely not romanticized as much as hard work. You work 20-40 hours week, no overtime, and make decent living? Ha you got it easy, shut up now. But look at that struggling poor dude who works 80 hours/wk. Narrative like this, implying that if you are struggling, etc, then you deserve something automatically is quite common in the mainstream. Maybe it's just a cynic inside me but I got this vibe from an article. But probably that's just me. I'd assume because a large share of population can be categorized as 'struggling' and relate to this narrative, making it popular and safe choice.
- hxn 11y agoIt's similar with websites. As a developer, I find it easy to build things people want. My websites get millions of pageviews every month. Yet, I make less then $200 per month from Adsense. No idea how high this could get with better monetization or what the path to betterm monetization would be.
- kybernetyk 11y agoIf those websites have a focus try affiliate marketing to their niche. Adsense is like throwing spaghetti at the wall - some few will stick but most will fall off.
- duckingtest 11y agoCould you link to one (or more) of these websites?
- sireat 11y agoThat seems incredibly low or Adsense has gotten pretty bad in 10 years. Around 2005 I had a very generic ecommerce site on which I threw some Adsense as an experiment. I was getting $200 in Adsense a month from 3,000-3,500 daily views x 30 so ~ 100,000 views a month.
- bridanp 11y agoMillions of page views? Unless you're running a photo sharing site, it seems like this should be more than $200/month. Assuming you know adsense best practices about ad placement, ad sizing, text versus image, have you talked to a consultant about options? I'm not one, just thinking if I had millions of views, that would be the next step.
- hxn 11y agoYes, Millions of pageviews. According to Google Analytics. Adsense only shows about 500k pageviews a month though. Guess the rest uses adblockers. In terms of optimizations, I tried a few placements and settings. Nothing moved the needle much.
- kiba 11y agoSeemed to me a communication mismatch. Youtubers try to act all perfect according to an image because they believe that what the viewers want. So they don't communicate their money trouble. Viewers got this distorted notion that they're rich because of subscribers numbers due to said zero communication. And they acted spoiled when they do one of their sponsored videos.
- chippy 11y agoI don't think they have money trouble at all, they are just saying "being famous sucks if there's no big money to offset the downsides". They want more money so that they don't have to work a normal job, take the subway, do their own shopping. They want the rich and famous lifestyle. Being poor and famous and working hard at it is a drag.
- profinger 11y ago50 cent supposedly recently had a similar problem. If you try to act rich people will think you are rich. I am aware that his situation is still confusing as to the actual facts but I am speaking more in an analogy here confirming your sentiment.
- jbb555 11y agoHere is the thing. These people produce something of interest to people at the price of 'free'. If their 'product' was worth anything then they could charge for it, but then of course nobody would pay and they wouldn't be 'famous'. So you can't get rich if you have to give your 'product' away? Not really a big surprise is it?
- InclinedPlane 11y agoExcept for the people who do get rich. Besides which, a lot of times the difference between scraping by and becoming a millionaire can sometimes be a good business manager. Knowing what to do and how best to do it, and keep up with it, can make orders of magnitude difference in monetization. And that's true in any business, in any industry.
- kiba 11y agoIf they don't ask straight out for money, they're not going to get it. If you don't explain the situation to your subscribers, how are they going to be understanding? So you put up this 'persona' on youtube. You said you 'struggled' but now you're not allowed to talk about your problem anymore. So, if you end up doing sponsored videos to make a living and some subscribers decide not to subscribe any longer because you're 'selling out'. Well, I guess they're not really a subscriber like you thought would be.
- pbhjpbhj 11y ago>If their 'product' was worth anything then they could charge for it // I don't think this necessarily follow. I've watched YouTube videos that were as entertaining as TV shows where in the latter's case onscreen & production workers are getting paid. It's not that the content isn't valuable it's that supply is vast and so the price is depressed to roughly "well I'll put up with a couple of add" (near zero). Having worth and being saleable are not directly comparable measures. Air is of effectively infinite worth to humans but you can't usually sell it.
- conradfr 11y agoWhat's wrong with serving table and being "Youtube famous", as long as people recognizing you doesn't disturb the service ? Should a channel with videos of roughly 250k views (with bad directing and average acting) allows its creator to live a rich or middle-class live ? I don't know, maybe but a TV show with these ratings in the US alone would get canceled quickly I guess. I liked the candid honesty but the focus on subscribers numbers or Instragram likes felt delusional or disconnected from real life, (but I didn't know you could live of Instragram sponsored content so I'm clearly not an export in the field). Also I think if you rely on the general public and especially the youths to live you should have a plan B because it's a fickle group, ask any celebrities of reality TV.
- HaloZero 11y agoI think as others have mentioned that people have an expectation that these "Youtube celebrities" are doing well when in reality they aren't. I think the explanations about their attempts to monetize but the problems with monetization are also discussed. I didn't get the impression she was complaining about it as much as the expectation that they are doing incredibly well when they aren't.
- lagadu 11y agoI think it's not as much "people expect her to be doing incredibly well" but more "I expected to be doing incredibly well based on my youtube status". At least that's the vibe I get from her post. It's like that "I have to succeed" line in the article. You have a fairly steady income and spend a lot of time doing something you love; you're already succeeding. You don't want to "succeed", you want to be rich. I'm sorry you feel that being a barista is beneath you, aren't you the special one. edit: to be clear I don't mean you, I mean the person who said that :)
- exar0815 11y agoThing is, how many viewers would those people have, if their content would be, idk, 1€/$/£ per month? Thats the difference to e.g. Twitch personalities or people famous in gaming. Their crowd is a lot less volatile and rapid-shifting than the beauty/lifestyle-crowd. To stay, you have to have knowledge and/or skill in the game you play.(Or boobs, but that stuff is shunned hard by twitch). Maybe, it would be good if yt would provide the artist with something like the "Subscribe" functionality twitch provides, for allowing fans to provide a basic, monthly income.
- ggambetta 11y agoThey all seem to think of their YouTube channel as the content, and the ads as their revenue channel. But how about upselling? They could see YouTube as free marketing, teaser content, for whatever they're actually selling. Depending on what they do, it could be a how-to book, a video tutorial on DVD, 1:1 coaching, etc.
- tunesmith 11y agoClearly they should start talking about money - if more you tubers and musicians and artists and what have you talked about what they are and aren't making, maybe it would start to put more of a dent in the self-entitled feelings that a lot of fans have. The big problem with all of this though is that when artists wise up and stop trying to chase the dollars that aren't there, they stop producing as much creatively, and the fans don't realize what they are missing. More than a few times I've wished that the millions of fans out there would suddenly wake up with a much more evolved sense of taste, willing to reject the art that is a waste of time, and willing to pay for the art that is actually worth their time.
- anon4 11y agoNo, people would just close the tab the moment they started talking about money.
- brownbat 11y agoYeah, if that was the main theme, it'd drop subscribers. But a lot of podcasts will just have a note at the end, "If you want to support me being able to do this full time, donate! Set up a recurring donation and I'll send you [some cheap swag]." Then they can talk about meeting their goal, and how donations keep them free of influence from sponsors, and how it will improve the content if everyone gave just $1. NPR even does that sort of thing. There more and less classy ways to beg for money.
- silverbax88 11y agoSo, if you are producing for fans who will never pay you for your work, is it worth it? We're not talking about purely artistic endeavors here, and the people who can do their form of 'art' without worrying about money are few and far between. Robert Crumb was paid for his work. Beethoven was paid for his work. Van Gogh wasn't paid for his work and it helped drive him to suicide. So, is it better to have 10,000 fans who will pay you for your work, or 3,000,000 who won't pay you anything, ever?
- cousin_it 11y agoHere's how you do it right: http://www.accursedfarms.com/rosss-fun-filled-beg-a-thon/ http://www.accursedfarms.com/rosss-fun-filled-beg-a-thon/ Ross got quite a lot of donations after that.
- brownbat 11y agoThis sounds like the economics of all entertainment industries. It's a lottery system. The visible success stories are atypical.
- jacquesm 11y agoFame for fame's sake is not going to get you food on the table unless you're very lucky (and even then it will always be hollow). Fame + some marketable skill will. It's the same thing with websites that are attracting lots of eyeballs but don't have a way to monetize them. Those things are called 'hobbies'.
- kriro 11y ago"""Van Gogh didn’t have to shill for Audible.com to pissed-off fans of his art.""" Pretty sure many artist of that day had to paint wives/daughters of rich folks that they'd rather not have painted to get by. And most artists that sell for millions today were pretty poor unless they had a random rich person and were their "pet artist". I'll sound pretty heartless but the post sounds entitled. There is no grantee of riches just because you're "famous". Actually turning that fame into money is a skill and not something that happens automatically. If you think it's unfair and you deserve more because you have so many fans...charge them directly and not through indirect means like adds, branding or product placement and see how many stick around. """The most Allison and I have made combined on one deal is $6,000, and 30 percent of that went to our multichannel network""" And despite that they started a company to make it a full time gig? I also don't buy the implied sentiment that telling the truth about being more or less busto despite all the followers is seen as whining. Sure by some but you don't want those as followers. Transparency is usually valued very much in communities.
- dhimes 11y agoPretty sure many artist of that day had to paint wives/daughters of rich folks that they'd rather not have painted to get by. And most artists that sell for millions today were pretty poor unless they had a random rich person and were their "pet artist". Probably why people picture Jesus as a European white guy.
- yen223 11y ago"I also don't buy the implied sentiment that telling the truth about being more or less busto despite all the followers is seen as whining. Sure by some but you don't want those as followers. Transparency is usually valued very much in communities." Rather ironic, considering the rest of the comment.
- kriro 11y agoAgreed, I should make it clear that I do appreciate that the post itself was made. I don't think it's whining. I just think the view of "many followers" = "should at least make ends meet" is a bit optimistic. But then again I have the same view that I criticize when it comes to OpenSSL not getting enough money (how can this possibly be it's so valuable for so many people) so maybe I just don't get youtubing for a living. It's the same argument...mmmm...food for thought :)
- jackgavigan 11y agoAndy Warhol never suggested that our 15 minutes of fame would be accompanied by fortune.
- xcavier 11y agoThis issue isn't new. It was very prevalent in Web 1.0 world. At the time, I opined something rather harsh: If your business model relies on free [read: freemium] services, you have a hobby, not a business. It remains true today.
- inaudible 11y agoThis is the creative economy in a nutshell, it's just not highly lucrative except for a small number of edge cases, for the rest it's peanuts. The danger embedded in this exception is that it's the generally mediated norm for the creative 'genius', the artist living the high life receiving reward for their exceptional talent. Skill + followers = reward. People in the top spots have earned their place. Anyone who has participated in a creative profession long enough will have seen many brilliantly talented people fail, and critiques will follow as to why they missed out (obsessive personality, no marketability, poor communication, not in touch with reality, poor career trajectory, no exposure, etc). Creative people are pinned against each other, so these critiques flow from fellow producers too, and sadly when one person calls it a day, others will see opportunity left in their wake and attempt to fill the gap only to deal with similar patterns. Mostly failure is just part of the biz and no real indicator of talent. Many will reach for the 'lottery' metaphor to justify creative economy, which I think at it's heart is true. Creative capital is amassed by a tiny minority in a global pool, and the 'pop' market intends to keep it this way - it's much easier to manage and account for a tiny list of select 'important' people, rally behind them and create an economy that benefits all parties (distributors and artists) than to embrace the entirety of creative output. But again there are exceptions. And these are the ones maintaining 'creative integrity', who then become every other artists benchmark for succeeding against the odds. They help fertilize the pool, keep enthusiasm up and make people have faith that good work can succeed. Again another lottery, and these rare successes often become heavily fortified by the same industry, itself championing the outsider and benefiting from the perceived 'integrity'. However, when you decide to give up on the supply chain completely and present yourself to an audience honestly things can actually come good. There are audiences that have given up on the supply chain too, and are sympathetic to artists presenting themselves with all their frailties. Once a connection is made, these people become real subscribers and will pay to keep this connection flowing and will even help advertise the artists they love (think t-shirts). There are many great examples of artists who have decided to control their supply chain, get intimate with an audience, and nurture the connection as directly as possible. They still work with mass culture but only as an interface to build audience. How hard is it for these Vloggers to do the same, kick the supply-chain (freeloading hits) and direct their core audience to their own supply. Surely it's as simple as adding to their 'please like / subscribe to our channel' spiel with a 'and to see our other content visit our website direct'. Maybe something will disrupt the 'pop' industry and create equity, but when mass piracy doesn't change much and pay services still only give majority revenue to top billers, it seems that 'pop' is more agile than most give lip service to.
- kelvin0 11y agoIt's very simple: Lots of people want to be famous and want to heard/seen/recognized. It used to be that only a very select few would get into Show Business, Radio, Movies and make quite a bit of money (still today). Fast forward fifty years, the barrier to entry in the space was lowered: anyone can post videos that cost next to nothing to make. That makes for more competition in that 'wanna be famous' space, and guess what? Surprisingly not everyone is making truck loads of money...
- cousin_it 11y agoYou have 100K "fans" and no money? That's crazy. Why not beg for donations? Be upfront about your financial situation, figure out how much you need per month (without side jobs), and announce that you've set up a donation ticker. If you don't make enough in any given month, apologize to fans and tell them that creating free content isn't sustainable for you.
- pmlnr 11y agoThis would probably be the best and only working approach for creators these days. ( Sidenote: flattr.com was supposed to be addressing this but from the consumer side. )
- sp332 11y agoYeah, that's what I couldn't get. If they're not paying you, those 100,000 people aren't customers, they're just strangers. They do absolutely nothing for you.
- Briel 11y agoHonestly, at this point online influencers with midsize followings should treat their creative content and the fanbase they've been able to build up as a portfolio of their skills to get their foot in the door of more lucrative opportunities. I'm not quite sure why they're working minimum wage jobs to make ends meet when they could for example be using their online experience consulting for businesses who would love to devise impactful, authentic ways to connect with the demographics of their fanbase. I think a lot of these middle tier influencers would benefit from training on how to present their skills/experiences to businesses who are willing to pay. (Not viewers.) I just read a story about how this girl Esmee Denters (she used to be signed with Justin Timberlake, then the label dropped her) was working part time at a yogurt shop. She could easily make much more for example coaching aspiring singers on to navigate the music industry, etc. Basically, maybe your viewers won't pay for your content but you can use your content for the proof of expertise to start an auxiliary business that makes money.
- jkaunisv1 11y agoYou're right, they really could benefit from such training. I don't think these people know that it's a thing that businesses will pay them to consult, let alone which businesses those are or how to contact them. I certainly don't know who I would reach out to, or how, if I had 100k instagram fans and wanted to do some consulting. How does one acquire this knowledge?
- rgejman 11y agoHow is this different than the traditional arts and entertainment fields? Most singers, song writers, painters, sculptors, writers, etc also struggle their whole life to make a living. Just because your art is digital and you can reach hundreds of thousands of people at the click of a button doesn't mean that you will become rich overnight. Sure we need new revenue models for content on the Internet--but my prediction is that they will lead to a lot fewer people watching content (much less paying for it). Not to mention that if your fan base is comprised of 13 year olds who need to ask their parents for a credit card every time, you can't make much money off of them.
- sp332 11y agoFamous ones though? It doesn't take 100,000 fans for a musician to make a living.
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago100k subscribers isn't 100k fans. A fan, in the past, would be someone who shelled out $15 for your album and goes to your shows. A "fan" in this context is some guy who stopped by your youtube video, hit skip on your ad, clicked subscribe, watched a little and left and maybe checks out your next video or two. The monetization per fan here is pretty stark. You would get a few bucks in pocket from the first example and next to nothing from the second. Selling 500,000 records is decent cash. Getting 500,000 views of a jokey video that caters to kids or the easily distracted isn't.
- sp332 11y agoI guess the article waffles between subscribers and views, because subscribers are worth a lot more when you're negotiating product placement money. So I guess the analogous question is: Say 100,000 people are interested enough to notice every time you put a song out. Is it plausible that collectively they decline pay you enough to make a living?
- braythwayt 11y agoI consider myself fortunate that I like my day job more than I like writing words. Otherwise I would feel much of the same depression. When I go to conferences or tech meetups, people tell me how much this essay or that book changed their life, and it's wonderful, but the revenues from everything put together wouldn't have paid for a van or a spot by the river for the eleven years that I've been writing. Being internet-obscure is a wonderful and rewarding hobby, if you can afford a hobby. But for me, the rewards are in the writing and in the feeling that I'm contributing a little bit to helping people enjoy programming. Which is a lot like other hobbies, where part of the social thing is helping other people enter the hobby and enjoy it.
- pmlnr 11y agoIt took me a while to realize what the problem is. For a long time, we've seen sponsored content as a bad, evil thing, that is driven by greed and capitalism. ( See corresponding Wayne's World moment https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KjB6r-HDDI0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KjB6r-HDDI0 ) This still stands for many situations but it seems like there are people out there only accepting and promoting things they: - believe in - have no issues with ( neither moral, nor technical ) - or even actually use them. All these cases are, in my opinion, valid cases for accepting money and is pretty far from evil. Image a world where all the commercials are done by people actually believing in the product - and not the money behind it.
- manigandham 11y agoI'm not sure you described any real problem. More like the creators have no clue on how to run a business. No different than many starving artists who have no monetization talent or abilities.
- WhitneyLand 11y agoThere are some parallels with entrepreneurs: - Seems more glamorous from the outside that it usually is. - Most people never make a lot of money. - Having a significant user base (just like Instagram followers) does not guarantee success. - Going to get a "real job" feels like selling out.
- crikli 11y agoThe creator is servant to the distributor. Doesn't matter whether you're talking about the creation of Scotch whisky, computer code, or video content.
- jerf 11y agoI see Patreon got a single dismissive handwave, but, err, why? I mean, yes, I saw their putative reason, but it makes no sense to me. Why don't they sign up for it, tell their fans the truth they just told Fusion.net, and let the chips fall where they may? Worst case scenario is that it doesn't work. Heck, lose half your fans, .5% of the remainder pays you a couple bucks a month... that probably would count as a huge win. I have actually watched a couple of my Patreon recipients go from bending their art in various ways for money (nasty ads on the site, etc.) to just making the art. The piper must always be paid, but a wide, amorphous crowd of Patreon supporters individually paying in just a couple of bucks a month, all of whom have sampled your free wares and pretty much know exactly what they're getting is probably just about the best boss you could imagine. (Modulo perhaps having to deal with the occasional person who may stomp off loudly taking their money with them, but I haven't seen that yet, and that's where the "width" comes in; if one person stomps away with their 2$/month, well... whoop-de-do. and all of my patreon supportees that are keeping up their end of the deal are seeing slow-but-steady patron growth. Slow-but-steady growing subscription revenue starts to add up!)
- pmlnr 11y agoI'd highly suggest Flattr instead, though that needs a little more push unfortunately, but unlike Patreon, Flattr can support any source of creation ( including even blogs ).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jerf 11y agoHow successful has Flattr been, compared to Patreon? There's at least dozens and possibly hundreds of people making an at-least-middle-class amount of money on the platform. (Hard to tell. I'd love to see some statistics myself.) Is Flattr that successful? I don't encounter it very often but perhaps I just don't move in the right circles. It's hard for me to recommend something that doesn't seem to work over something that does, when we're talking cold hard cash and whether or not you get to make a living. (Edit later: Ah, dangoor links to graphtreon, which has the data I was looking for. Using $50K/year in Patreon income as the cutoff for "middle class", trying to account for Patreon fees and the extra details of covering health care, it looks like we've got ~100 people or groups making at least one "middle-class lifestyle" amount of money on Patreon alone, quite a few more "starving artists" if they were only on Patreon, and a long list of people making good monthly supplement money to what must be another income.)
- dangoor 11y agoI think CGP Grey is an interesting counterpoint. I think he said that his YouTube channel is something like #700 in terms of subscribers, so he's not up at the top of the food chain. And yet, he gets paid $13.5k per video: http://graphtreon.com/top-patreon-creators http://graphtreon.com/top-patreon-creators with "only" 5100 patrons. He's also on two successful podcasts that doubtless net him a few thousand more per month. He's also gone out of his way to make sure that he's not visibly famous (he doesn't appear in his videos), which is an interesting contrast with the people in this article. If I had to guess the biggest difference between CGP Grey and the people discussed in this article, I would guess that CGP Grey had a plan and optimized for things that can actually make a living for him. He talks a bit about this on the Cortex podcast.
- vinceguidry 11y agoTo make money directly from your audience, your audience has to have money. The one parallel I saw in all of the article's examples is that they're all catering to young kids. I bet someone could make a tidy fortune coming up with a monetization strategy for these artists. My guess is that targeting parents would do the trick.
- carsongross 11y agoThe way art used to work, back when it was actually good, was that artists found rich patrons to sponsor their work. This seems like a good system to me.
- sp332 11y agoThat gives the patron way too much control over your output.
- carsongross 11y agoYes, it does: http://www.italianrenaissance.org/wp-content/uploads/Michelangelo-David-e1429028121909.jpg http://www.italianrenaissance.org/wp-content/uploads/Michela...
- tehwebguy 11y agoSeems like everyone here is getting hung up on the author rather than discussing the specifics of being famous AND poor. That's got to be very strange feeling, one that Aaron Swartz most likely felt.
- dade_ 11y agoIs it that strange? I don't have a clue who these people are. 70,000 followers on the Internet is not that notable, especially since no one knows if a follower is a person, a robot or a corporate SM account. Where is the story of the people with millions of followers that can't make money? Also, being famous isn't going to make you money unless there is business smarts involved. Working as a waitress, well she probably needs to do some networking. I remember meeting Dave Moffat, once famous, still has fans, working as a waiter. Really super nice guy, not smart, very unaware of business, and no clue how to monetize. If I had a million followers, what I would do...
- kruhft 11y agoIf only there was a way to cash in our imaginary internet points.
- Yhippa 11y agoreddit karma to BTC. reddit basically pays you for being a good actor on their sight and not trolling. This benefits reddit since people will want to come to the site to read the insightful comments.
- sledge 11y agoNot seeing where economics has a play in this. Other than people allocation their resources for unnecessary alternative uses.
- awl130 11y agobefore we shed a tear for these erstwhile celebrities let's indeed take a look at the economics. in statistical terms their curse (and I will argue, their blessing) is kurtosis. earnings by entertainers (such as in pro sport, film, TV, music) are not normally distributed but heavily skewed towards the left. the few at the top vastly overperform the rest. thus you have pewdiepie earning millions and the vast majority losing money. the same happens in film, for example: the lucky few thousand A-listers earn millions while the millions of other actors bus tables. there are several reasons for this kurtosis: mostly having to do with vertical differentiation---the characteristic in which one product is clearly preferred over another. at the cinema, for example, each movie is priced identically and yet one is clearly preferred than the other. this leads to a few films becoming runaway successes and the rest barely breaking even. there is a positive feedback loop that magnifies the effect over time. you see this quite clearly in the youtube ecosystem as well. youtube videos are "priced" identically; and so obviously there is a clear preference for one over the other, as there is a clear preference of a performer over another. risky careers are sexy. these performers may bemoan their situation but in fact it is precisely this kurtosis that gives them their fame. after all the opposite of a kurtocracy is a mediocracy[1], in which rather than the extraordinary dominating, the ordinary dominates. another fantastic label for such industries is "humdrum" industries[2]. nursing, teaching, bookkeeping, dentistry, engineering, accounting, retail are all mediocracies in which employees do not face extremes of success and failure. some of these fields are clearly available to youtubers should they find their current path untenable. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_De_Vany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_De_Vany [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_E._Caves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_E._Caves
- matchagaucho 11y agoPewdiepie's post-production skills are off the charts; coupled with content that people genuinely want to consume. Internet increases the quantity of content, but quality of content drives compensation.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoAn interesting read. One of the things publicists are good at doing is converting 'star power' into dollars. I wonder if there are any agents out there recruiting these folks.
- manigandham 11y agoI found this mostly amusing. When did fame automatically equal income (nevermind riches)? This is a business. Doing anything for free and expecting to magically get paid = bad business. This article highlights the silliness of it all by quoting things like subscriber and follower numbers as if that means anything. So what if you have 1M subscribers? The internet has democratized and made content distribution much easier, faster and cheaper. It hasn't somehow changed the economics behind selling content itself. This is basic pricing research - do your consumers care enough to actually pay for what you have? If so, then how are you going to capture and convert that? Ads? Subscriptions? Donations? Figure it out and put the plan in place. There will always be some people to whom it's not worth it - just because they're vocal about it doesn't mean you need to go into depression. And you don't need to be homeless to continue your "art" either. Neither option is healthy and it's what sets apart those who can actually succeed at this. Perhaps the funniest line in this whole article is this: > Aspiring vloggers may want to think about getting business degrees, because that’s what being famous online is: It’s protecting your assets, budgeting, figuring out production costs, and rationing out money to employees—whether that’s yourself or a camera crew. Yea right... except that a business degree would at least teach the basics of having an actual business model.
- couldntresist 11y agoI couldn't resist to point to a "related" comic: http://orig09.deviantart.net/aa8f/f/2015/350/c/9/__en___what_a_wonderful_world____by_couldntresist-d9kbfdw.png http://orig09.deviantart.net/aa8f/f/2015/350/c/9/__en___what...