9 ms·
Atlassian's success reminds what a crappy place Australia is for tech business
- polemic 11y agoHey Australia, why not consider moving to NZ? 1. You can already move / live / work here without any immigration hassle. 2. We have an actual UFB fibre to the home network rolling out now that actually works. 3. Local and central government is pretty keen to support the technology scene - from government grants (refer Callaghan Innovation) to local tech hubs. AND help to connect in SF (http://kiwilandingpad.com/ http://kiwilandingpad.com/) 4. Activity from successful early founders/employees from Xero and others. 5. We build for a global audience -- NZ is just too small to be your only market. 6. Simpler tax system. 7. Better coffee.
- VelNZ 11y agoAs a kiwi living in Australia and quietly working on a bootstrapped startup, I'm keen to hear more about this. Is NZ really a good place for a startup? Is there any government support that doesn't involve giving up equity?
- AlBentley 11y agoWhat about R&D tax rebate?
- hhandoko 11y agoInteresting :) How about VC / Angel / funding scene? Is it pretty vibrant there? PS. The only downside to your offer is the weather, I like my weather 20-30*C :) I've been to Auckland and Wellington before and I struggle with the cold even during summer.
- polemic 11y agoVC / Angel scene is a big issue at the moment, but improving. Capital is tight. That said, if you have a bit of track-record, the 'smallness' of NZ means you can often raise small amounts off the back of reputation. Then you probably want to look overseas for serious money. Or do a Xero and IPO locally - they've shown local 'normal' investors how forgoing profit for growth can work. Also: the wildlife isn't venomous, the trees are not explosive and the sharks don't bite. Met with a friend from Sydney yesterday - she was enjoying the low 20s here after baking in 30+ in Sydney for the last few days. TBH it's a few degrees difference that you acclimatise too - you're not going to need a new wardrobe.
- l33tbro 11y agoBetter coffee? That's a pretty huge claim ...
- suvelx 11y agoIt might have changed in the last 5 years, but I found #5 a point of contention. I found it incredibly hard to find a new job opening when I wanted one, let alone get hired for them. Flew to London and have had jobs thrown at me nearly every day since. I suspect hiring has the same issues. The population is just so small. There's a joke that when you say from New Zealand, somebody will ask "Do you know Karl?". Which quite often, happens to be true.
- polemic 11y agoThis is vs. Australia but it's probably a fair point. It can be a small place (less so in Auckland) and retaining experience is an issue. If you've got exposure to scale outside of New Zealand and good experience, you should be in demand (I mean - let me know eh?)
- pedalpete 11y agoDisclosure, I work for data61, a major recipient of the gov't new innovation strategy. I'm also Canadian and have worked in technology in SF, LA, NYC, Vancouver and Santiago Chile. I have a very different perspective on this. Australia has had more than just one Atlassian. They've also got Campaign Monitor, BigCommerce, Canva, Where 2 (became Google Maps), Envato. Australia is also growing Freelancer (I don't believe it was initially built here), and I'm sure many others. Now, let's look at the comment regarding the newly announced innovation strategy does provide lots (probably too much) money to incubators, but so has every country. The incubator thing is just not successful outside a the few outliers YC, TechStars and maybe 1 or 2 others. However, one of the large components of the plan is tax incentives to early stage investors. There are also bankruptcy law reform. There is also a new Entrepreneur Visa. Now, Silicon Valley will almost always have an advantage to the history and network there. But that doesn't mean that Australia is "a crappy place" for tech business. I find Australia a refreshing change from North America. There is a realistic view on revenue models, less money is 'wasted' on poorly thought out businesses. Australians are bright resourceful people. I think this is a great place to be in tech. It punches above it's weight on the world stage. If you look at regions with major technology successes, what do you end up with? A bunch in the US, a few in China, a few in India, a few in Canada, a few in Germany, a few in the UK. Where would Australia end up on a list of population vs. influence? I think pretty high.
- andrewstuart 11y agoThe key point of the blog post is that any tech company that succeeds in Australia does so purely on its own two feet and that governments are at best mildly supportive of technology and at worst actively hostile. Turnbull destroyed the fibre to the home NBN and I can't see high speed ubiquitous Internet access coming any time soon. Imagine if 95% of Australian home - including ones in the country areas - had super high speed Internet - what that would do for the ability of Australians to live and work away from the cities and how good that would be for regional communities. Turnbull and Abbott tossed that out. I'm cynical about Government support for technology because it usually is very indirect. More often than not any money is funnelled into an "ecosystem of helpers" rather than to the developers. So venture capitalists and incubators get the money which essentially is then substantially dedicated to paying for the salaries and offices of the incubators and venture capitalists rather than going to entrepreneurs. As the blog post points out - there are thousands of developers sitting in their kitchen coding - they do not want a desk and chair as provided by an incubator and - like Atlassian - they do not want to even talk to venture capitalists, let alone waste time and money trying to get funding from them - an extremely unlikely event because the VCs are so risk averse. If I built something that got traction - which is what the VC's want to see - and I really needed VC then I damn sure wouldn't go to Australian VCs for it - that's the path to failure - if you must have money and you have traction, go straight to Silicon Valley first.
- adamseabrook 11y agoThere is always more the government can do but there are two major government assistance programs I was not aware of till I founded a startup here. https://www.austrade.gov.au/Australian/Export/Export-Grants/What-is-EMDG https://www.austrade.gov.au/Australian/Export/Export-Grants/... will reimburse 50% of your sales and marketing costs. So you can go spend $100k on Google Adwords and get $50k back effectively meaning you can outbid all your competitors for the same keywords. https://www.ato.gov.au/Business/Research-and-development-tax-incentive/ https://www.ato.gov.au/Business/Research-and-development-tax... is more well known. What is less well known is that if you make a loss in the year you make the R&D claim they will credit the offset into your bank account vs carrying the offset forward to next year. I am not sure what the equivalent of these two grants is in the US but I know Singapore is even more generous with tax holidays and 500%? of R&D spend grants. Edit - forgot to add there are R&D consultants who will even advance you a percentage of your claim amount in advance to help with cashflow so you don't have to wait 12 months to get the money back.
- throwawayaway 11y agoAm I wrong in thinking there's a fat chance that the US govt. is funneling money to tech startups? I doubt there are grants for this stuff in Silicon Valley. Maybe some sort of trickle down effect from the money that goes into Amazon, intel, MS & IBM. Not sure every home in the US is getting the claimed 10gig internet pipes neither.
- adventured 11y agoYeah you're wrong. The US Government has a $146 billion R&D budget. That kind of spending has directly contributed to the US success in tech. The government - university partnerships have been a massive boon to the US tech industry. They have billions in business grants that you can apply for, covering just about everything you can think of going on in the economy. That includes advanced science and engineering grants, projects at the most cutting edge. Every home is definitely not getting 10gbps pipes, yet. The US deserves a lot of flack for its poor broadband deployment the prior decade. However it is now undergoing an accelerating broadband boom (as in 100mbps+), probably mostly thanks to Google.
- Benjamin_Dobell 11y agoR&D Tax Incentives are pretty much the only thing the Australian Government offers - http://www.business.gov.au/grants-and-assistance/innovation-rd/RD-TaxIncentive/Pages/default.aspx http://www.business.gov.au/grants-and-assistance/innovation-... Massacring the NBN and generally not giving a shit about technology really highlights how out of touch the Australian Government is with the general population. We are among the highest adoption rates for technology (smartphones etc.) worldwide and give a huge amount of money to US companies getting a hold of the latest tech. Our government is ready to completely ream us once more by signing the TPP - despite the fact the US has clauses for things like "fair use" nothing of that nature exists in Australian law. We'll just adopt the shitty parts of US law and none of the (partially) redeeming parts.
- d_t_w 11y agoDidn't you hear? Coal is the future, get digging.
- d_t_w 11y agoFYI non-Australians, I give you (former) PM of Australia, Tony Abbott: July 17, 2015 - "For the foreseeable future coal is the foundation of prosperity" http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/jul/17/for-tony-abbott-its-full-steam-ahead-on-coal-the-foundation-of-prosperity http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/jul/17/for-tony-... That just about sums up the amount of vision in Australian politics.
- TheSpiceIsLife 11y agoTo be fair, he's probably right. Australia has no new hydro planned (we can thank The Wilderness Society for that), and no plans, that I'm aware of, to shutdown any coal fired power stations. So, pending catastrophic climate change, I'm going to guess Tony will turn out to be right. And besides, politicians aren't selected for their 'vision', they're selected for some other set of characteristics, whoever knows what. P.J. O'Rourke has plenty to say on this subject.
- __tmg 11y ago> Australia sucks at technology; rather than help make it suck less, you should > leave your home and ensure that the U.S.A continues not to suck at > technology. Does it make me a cynic if I could only read this as a propaganda piece for The Valley?
- theandrewbailey 11y ago> In an age where the state of the art broadband to the home in the U.S.A. is 10 gigabits, Australia is currently building (it claims) a National Broadband Network at great expense that promises a blistering 12 to 100 megabits per second at the top end I know it mentioned "state of the art", but the vast majority of Americans would be lucky to get 100 megabits without breaking the bank every month. Many (most?) don't even have the option of such speeds.
- evanriley 11y agoYup, I live RIGHT outside of City borders of Durham, NC, where Google Fiber is coming, Frontier is putting up Fiber, and AT&T is putting up fiber. My max available speed? 24mbps DSL for $50 a month. Even though TWC says they are in my area, when they drive to my house they say they can't do anything for me, and I doubt Google, Frontier, or AT&T are going to be able to do anything for me.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- qzervaas 11y agoMany (most) of Australians don't even have the option of 10 mbit. When the new NBN is rolled out, most will have the option for 25 Mbps. This plan is due to be completed by 2020.
- qzervaas 11y agoMy office is "in the city" in Adelaide, a city of 1.25m. Our only reasonably priced option is 12Mbit ADSL2 (which is about 0.8mbps up). We can get 100mbit fibre for $1000/mo, plus cost of installing the fibre. We can get 12/12 DSL for $300/mo. As an app developer, I am often unable to upload anything to iTunes Connect without saturating the link and it timing out. The only feasible option is paying a premium for 4G/LTE speeds on Telstra.
- xxpor 11y agoPart of the issue is that getting transit out of Australia is EXTREMELY expensive. Telstra still has a stranglehold on the country, and the amount of cables out of the country hasn't kept up with demand.
- wahsd 11y agoThe weird thing about these kinds of posts is that it only contributes to places like Australia, in this case, lagging behind other places like the USA. All this is is another one of those whiny posts that sets a mindset that you have to leave Australia and head to the Valley if you want to make it when what the post really should have been about is " We (Australia) really have some work to do. Here is what we need to do and how we push the government to support our industry". It really kind of annoys me that "foreigners" fall to this victim type mentality and then rather than pushing their own local governments to change, they advocate leaving and only exacerbating the problem by draining the local talent and interest group, while piling on to the concentration of people in the tech centers like the Valley. I would love to know what the total damage the USA does to source societies and countries by luring and essentially poaching talent and expertise away. I know that India is really kind of struggling with that issue. On one hand they see it as a source of remittances, but on the on the other hand even in a huge population like India they are really starting to feel the sting of the "brain drain" in the tech sector.
- ajdlinux 11y agoAs an Australian, it saddens me every time I hear of a friend leaving for the States. I can count at least six or seven people off the top of my head who went through my uni's computer science program - a relatively small department, I should add - at the same time as myself, and have since moved to the Bay Area. I can't really blame them, but it'd be nice if some of the brighter ones stayed around.
- voltagex_ 11y agoMoving to Sydney for a job could be almost as expensive as moving to the States. I'm looking in Melbourne but the market down there seems like a mess right now. Couple that with the falling Australian dollar and moving to the US and getting paid in USD doesn't sound so bad.
- ajdlinux 11y agoThe primary motivation for those I know who have moved to the Bay Area isn't the pay (although that certainly is part of it), it's finding more interesting work and being in the SF/SV culture. Personally, I don't like the start-up culture, and I happen to work at a place that does interesting things already, so I'm quite happy staying in Canberra.
- qzervaas 11y agoThis is a propaganda piece from NBNco (the company installing Australia's new broadband network). It basically says Internet that is too fast is bad: http://www.nbnco.com.au/blog/singapores-gigabit-dream-arrives-but-with-a-catch.html http://www.nbnco.com.au/blog/singapores-gigabit-dream-arrive... Or to put it another way: our bad solution is superior because it's slower.
- voltagex_ 11y agoAs an Australian the only reaction I can have to stuff like this is an overwhelming desire to leave the country. We're screwed in the near-to-medium term, and in the long term if we don't improve both our technical capability and the level of political discourse.
- voltagex_ 11y agoAdvising anyone to move countries to go to Silicon Valley (or SFO) seems irresponsible with the out of control property market and all the social issues that come with it. http://sf.curbed.com/archives/2015/10/09/the_median_rent_for_an_sf_twobedroom_hits_5000month.php http://sf.curbed.com/archives/2015/10/09/the_median_rent_for...
- nl 11y agoTelling anyone from Sydney about an "out of control property market" seems... ill-advised.
- brad0 11y agoAussie expat in the US here. A studio apartment in SF costs 35k US$ a year to rent. That's almost 50k AUD$ It's at a point where people that aren't earning 6 figure salaries can't live in the city anymore. I know the costs of living in Sydney and Melbourne is high, but SF is next level.
- phantom_oracle 11y agoJust as a side-point to some of the authors (valid) points: Atlassian would have failed in Silicon Valley as well. It is kind of strange where the author mentions how Atlassian bootstrapped its way to an IPO after many years and then tells entrepreneurs to head to "boom or bust" Silicon Valley. The truth is that an Atlassian-style business can be built from just about anywhere. You will need to market appropriately, but if your product is great, it will eventually get to a point where it will market itself quite a bit too.
- capnfabs 11y agoAlso an Australian, working in tech. - There is a lot of good CS talent coming out of Australian universities. Lots goes to the Bay Area, some work at Google, Atlassian, Canva (in Sydney at least). - As others have commented, it seems that there's less useless stuff with unrealistic projections that gets built in Australia. I'm not sure if it's because Australian culture has a strong dose of cynicism (which also probably contributes to some of the remarks in this blog) or because the landscape is indeed bad enough that only the really good startups can survive. - There are some Australian policies that work pretty well in favour of getting individual startups off the ground. Policies that help startups get off the ground include study assistance (~AUD 200 week from government whilst studying, means tested), a similar unemployment support program, and subsidised universities. These only contribute to the success of individuals, however, they're not good for building an ecosystem. - I've heard of a number of Australians travelling SE Asia and trying to get their v1 built from there. The internet is much better and your burn rate is much lower. Plus, the breadth of experience is probably good if you're trying to start something with international longevity.
- Gatsky 11y agoWell this is all true, it could be much better. I think the point is though that relying on Australian Governments to make serious long term commitments to technology infrastructure is going to result in disappointment. The thesis that 'Labour was going to save us, and then the Liberal's ruined everything' is kind of an oversimplification. The NBN was a great idea to be sure, but the Labor government that proposed it proceeded to sabotage itself over the next two terms due to extremely damaging and petty political infighting. In the end Tony Abbott had to just sit quietly while Labour burned itself to the ground, delivering us a conservative prime minister and policies that nobody really wanted. The NBN became a political point. If none of this had happened and Malcolm Turnbull was now in power trying to push the innovation agenda, who knows, maybe he would be proposing something similar to the original NBN. Bad leaders with good ideas are as helpful as good leaders with bad ideas, as it happens. Good leaders with good ideas don't seem to exist in the current climate. And if you're just unpopular it doesn't matter what your ideas are (eg Bill Shorten).
- LCDninja 11y agoIn my experience, back in 1997 it was no different. We won the Australian Internet awards for best software - nobody cared - so we moved to Silicon Valley. Problem fixed!
- noir_lord 11y agoAs someone who went from flaky 3meg at home to rock stable 150meg fiber it makes a huge difference to how you work.
- jondubois 11y agoI think that so far Australia has been a pretty bad place to start a tech company. The startup community is quite small (even in Sydney). And in spite of it being small, it's really hard to raise funding. Almost all of the successful Australian companies you hear about have bootstrapped themselves from nothing and succeeded against astronomical odds. It seems that the few companies that do get funded rarely go anywhere. A big problem with Australian investors is that they're extremely hesitant to invest in projects which are not within their immediate area of expertise - And this is generally limited to simple B2C companies which are basically rip-offs of successful startups in the US. Investors don't care much about potential - They care about numbers. High-tech projects like NoSQL databases, backend-as-a-service platforms, machine learning platforms, etc... These things generally don't get funded in Australia.
- nailer 11y agoLast time I was in Australia (around a decade ago) the country's most well known new entrepreneur was someone who opened a Jamba Juice clone.
- TimJRobinson 11y agoThere is a actually a really nice program for startup founders the Australian government runs called NEIS (https://www.employment.gov.au/self-employment-new-enterprise-incentive-scheme-neis https://www.employment.gov.au/self-employment-new-enterprise...), but very few people know about it. It's basically welfare for those starting their own company. You get paid the normal welfare rates (~$225AU per week in QLD) to start your company. You have to provide a basic business plan and meet up with a mentor once a month to ensure you're actually working on it, but other than that it's a free income stream.
- dhruvsuyam 11y agoGuys. A lot of successful companies are getting created in Australia. Cliniko is one among them. Time and again, it's proven that 'perseverance' is the key.