7 ms·
Indeed. And it is troubling to see only VW being targetted here, and with extremely high potential fines shown in the media. If it turns out that other competi
by kuschku 11y ago
Indeed. And it is troubling to see only VW being targetted here, and with extremely high potential fines shown in the media.
If it turns out that other competitors did the same, VW – and even other German companies, due to the hit the brand "Made in Germany" got from this – might be able to sue the US via ISDS for lost sales in hundreds of billions.
- jacquesm 11y agoThat's not how it works, what will happen instead is that those other manufacturers will also be hit hard by the US regulatory entities.
- kuschku 11y agoThat does not matter. The media focus has been solely on VW, despite others doing the same. This is enough that VW can show to be unfairly targeted, as it’s standard market practice. If VW can show that others did the same, but did not get the same media resonance, then VW can sue for the lost sales based on an estimation of the difference in reputation loss. Hell, even other companies in Germany have reported lost sales due to the "German engineering = pollution" that US media have pushed recently.
- jacquesm 11y ago> The media focus has been solely on VW, despite others doing the same. That's because there is evidence about VW. > This is enough that VW can show to be unfairly targeted, as it’s standard market practice. No, it really is not. > If VW can show that others did the same, but did not get the same media resonance, then VW can sue for the lost sales based on an estimation of the difference in reputation loss. It's an interesting theory about how the law could work but unfortunately somewhat detached from what I know about how the law actually works. VW does not get to claim any 'lost sales' directly attributable to their own conduct, regardless of who reported on it and how frequently even if all their competitors did it too. If VW has evidence that other manufacturers cheat as well they're probably more than welcome to present it. (And if they had such evidence they probably would.) > Hell, even other companies in Germany have reported lost sales due to the "German engineering = pollution" that US media have pushed recently. Yes, and VW is to blame for that. Not the US media.
- kuschku 11y agoThe original report that caused this whole thing presented evidence for 9 companies. 9. VW is not the only one in this whole situation.
- waterlesscloud 11y agoWho specifically do you imagine they could sue?
- takeda 11y agoThe report shown that results from the tests did not match the actual usage. It raised questions that those companies most likely are tampering with tests, but nothing incriminating. It was speculated that possibly that the tests were not reliable. In case of VW, in addition to that report an actual device to fool the tests was discovered.
- jacquesm 11y agoYou should go and read the report.
- panzagl 11y agokuschku's comments only make sense if you assume the US media is a direct arm of the US government.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoMedia in the US is independent and not controlled by the government. The amount of media VW gets over this issue is irrelevant to any damages you may try to conjure up. People may say whatever they like.
- kr4 11y agoMedia Is independent in words but all the mainstream media outlets are controlled by handful of corporates (during 1990s, most of these outlets bought by few corporate houses). These houses have interests related to military-industrial complex. Victory of policies layed out since over 5 decades [0] for dividing and conquering middle east for greater profits can't be let to fail just because Russia decided to save Syria and Germany/France started pondering supporting Russia [1] upon confronting the enormous wave of refugees. 0: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10580490 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10580490 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10718312 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10718312
- jacquesm 11y agoSo we now have links between Syria, refugees, the MIC, Russia, Germany, France and somehow in the middle of that poor VW the victim of being used as the stick to push Germany back into compliance? What do you think they would have used if VW had not conveniently committed fraud?
- kr4 11y agoI just saw a comment by Noam Chompsky, "Americans don't know what's going on. But they don't even know that they don't know." I think "Americans" can be replaced with "people in general" (including Europeans and Asians as well)
- jacquesm 11y agoIt's 'Chomsky' and I can't find a reference for that quote, where did you find that comment?
- facetube 11y ago"Everybody else was breaking the law too" is not a valid excuse for breaking the law.
- kuschku 11y agoObviously, no. But if everybody else isn’t equally punished, or equally investigated, than that is against the constitution, too.
- jacquesm 11y agohello Janne, You keep making these grand claims about the constitution and the law and this whole VW affair that have absolutely no basis in fact. Please stop that it is just throwing up a huge smokescreen and it measurably devalues the discussion. I'm sure that it fits your worldview but fwiw no matter how hard and how often you write this stuff it does not make it true. The constitution has absolutely nothing to do with this, VW was not 'singled out' and you are actively harming your reputation on HN. As a German student I understand that you feel that VW has been treated 'unfair' but they brought this on themselves, BMW was tested as well and passed the test even though they too emitted more NOx than they should have depending on the circumstances, they did not use a 'test defeat device'. From what we have in terms of evidence to date no other company has engaged in such blatant fraud in this respect as VW has. If you have evidence (as in hard evidence, not just hunches) that another manufacturer also employs a cheating device then you could make headlines the world over by sharing that proof and I for one would be very supportive of you. But all these statements that defend VW and even suggest that VW could recover their losses because they've been treated unfairly are not based in fact and make it seem like you are of good intentions but other than that do not appear to have much knowledge of how these things work. So a word to the wise: you have but one reputation, you build it up slowly over the years and you can lose and/or damage that reputation quickly. Please don't let your sense of indignation get the better of you and hurt your interests in the longer term.
- facetube 11y agoHave a citation or reference for that? Because I don't think it's true. Equal protection, adhered to or not, doesn't relieve you of criminal culpability.
- nradov 11y agoThere is no plausible legal theory under which VW or other German brands could successfully sue ISDS.
- kuschku 11y agoEh, yes? If a US company does the same, but does not get the same media exposure, reputation loss, and fees, then it is unfair targeting. VW can then directly sue, because they, as foreign company, were targeted, but another US manufacturer was not.
- nradov 11y agoThat is simply not how it works in the US civil court system. Ask an attorney.
- raesene99 11y agoYou might want to look a bit more into ISDS.. it's an international court which is agreed to in various trade treaties and allows corporations to sue foreign governments where that governments policies negatively affect the corporation. One of the big concerns with TTP/TTIP is that they will expand the use and applicability of ISDS processes and this could impact things like environmental legislation. Part of the concern about the use of ISDS is that the hearings are generally held in secret. In this case I guess if it could be proven that the US government disadvantaged VW by applying fines to them whilst not prosecuting other companies who have done similar things, then if ISDS applies to this trade, it may be possible for VW to sue...
- jacquesm 11y agoOnly in those situations where the US government can be proven to have access to the same level of proof that fraud is being committed compared to the information they had on VW. Chances of success of such an operation: 0. Effect on the PR situation: -10000. Likelihood of engaging in such an action by VW: 0. Anybody except for VW would be in a position to make a move regarding other manufacturers, according to a document linked elsewhere from a German auto magazine there is plenty of reason to suspect that other manufacturers are engaging in similar practices but nobody to date has proof.
- kr4 11y agoThere's a geo-political angle to this targeting. You'd find that the VW emition scandle and fine announcement came just during the time when Germany leaders were starting to get a bit cozy with Russia over sanctions ETC (I remember it was latter half of September, you can check these facts by searching Google.)
- jacquesm 11y agoBollocks, the whole thing was initiated by a European non-profit that contracted the WVU.
- kuschku 11y agoEh, the non-profit thing happened in 2013/2014. The EPA ignored the results for a full year. The VW CEO already resigned in April, several months before the EPA went crazy, due to it.
- jacquesm 11y agoThe reason a year passed is because the report does not indeed contain the sentence 'VW committed fraud', it simply notes some exceptional real-world performance issues for a specific vehicle under test and left it at that. The EPA then had to do a whole pile of work to figure out what exactly was going on and this led to the discovery of the defeat-the-test device.
- kr4 11y agoPlease read my other comments with facts supporting it https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10718312 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10718312 actions of this magnitude are generally guided by multiple and often hidden interests/agenda. Only if we able to perceive the bigger picture by analyzing from different angles.
- jacquesm 11y agoSorry, but that's just a smokescreen (pun not intended, hard to avoid). Yes, VW got hit hard, but there is only one party that could have taken action to avoid this: VW itself. If they cheated that's entirely their choice. If other manufacturers have in fact cheated (and the evidence seems to be mounting that they did but maybe not quite as blatantly) then their turn will surely come.