5 ms·
> capitalism seems the best method for controlling innate human corruption Capitalism seems better than past failures. But it is surely a local maximum. We hav
by erikpukinskis 11y ago
> capitalism seems the best method for controlling innate human corruption
Capitalism seems better than past failures. But it is surely a local maximum. We have thousands of years of social evolution in front of us. Experiments have hardly been exhaustive, and material conditions seem to be changing faster than ever.
- amelius 11y agoThe best way to control corruption is transparency. Eventually, IT systems will solve large-scale corruption.
- theworstshill 11y agoI agree. Although it will be hard to separate the need for transparency to one's rights to privacy. You can deem that some actions inherently leave you no rights to privacy, but I'm afraid it'll be only a matter of time till everything you do is under the watchful eyes. On the other hand, humans are at the best when they know theyre being watched. Its a difficult tradeoff.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- veb 11y agoThis is not very constructive. I can tell you're being sarcastic, but if you disagree with the parent comment, then perhaps you could enlighten us why?
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agoAll the computers in the world are not going to solve human nature - unfortunately. And transparency can be abused by selective quoting by those with agenda see the UK's MP expenses scandal and who owned the news paper that broke it.
- legulere 11y agoTechnology rarely solves social problems. It often changes society but not only in the good way and how it does is mostly unforeseeable.
- badsock 11y agoIt may happen rarely, but the positive impacts of things like, say, the printing press are too profound to be dismissed that easily
- legulere 11y agoThe printing press was one of the main factors making the reformation possible, which later on led to the thirty year's war. So it's actually a good example of how technology has unintended consequences.
- clock_tower 11y agoRecent historians have been looking at how the printing press was more an instrument of state power than anything else. Remember that printing shops were state-controlled and heavily censored (_The Great Cat Massacre_ has a chapter on print shops in 18th-century Paris); most of their output was royal decrees, propaganda pamphlets, and books friendly to the regime in question. The Reformation began for good reasons -- the Church had been dragging its feet on internal reforms for hundreds of years, and finally implemented these reforms in the Council of Trent, after the Reformation began -- but its spread was normally something that governments did to their people, not something that people chose for themselves. It wasn't an extension of liberty. Henry VIII and Edward VI flooded England with mercenaries, for example; in the Germanies, whether to turn Protestant or not was a decision made by rulers (who were legally entitled to compel their subjects to follow them; some converted to Lutheranism, seized Church property, and then switched back to Catholicism, and persecuted subjects who were slow to make the change each time). First-wave Protestants -- Lutherans and Anglicans -- generally had less religion rather than a different religion; even today, there are conservative branches of the Lutherans and Anglicans who are negotiating with the Catholic Church to return as whole congregations. Calvinism was (if I remember rightly) never imposed from the top down, and typically took power through revolts by the middle class or the lower aristocracy; but Calvinist states tended to be oppressive, warlike, aggressively-middle-class theocracies -- very bad places to be poor or dissident. (_Albion's Seed_ is revealing on this; the modern Islamic Republic of Iran is a less theocratic, less anti-commercial, less oppressive place than 17th-century Puritan Massachusetts was.)
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoI think that's just Commanding Heights on stilts. It may well be that informal systems can be more efficient. The problem with formal systems of accountability is that it ends up serving storytelling rather than being calibrated regulation and control.
- m1sta_ 11y agoCapitalism could work if greed was looked down upon. Billionaires should be taking risks. It should be culturally mandatory to try and save the world. There's also an information problem.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoThe fundamental problem is trying to cast individuals in heroic narratives. The mechanism for status is beside the point. People in Russia had ikons of Stalin. I feel like somehow biasing towards nonfiction is one way to improve this, but that may just be bias speaking. We can't be all that coherent about "greed" anyway - if we do create consumer surplus through business, then this is a good thing. If we enrich ourselves by rent-seeking and cheating, it is a not. Deciding which is which is pretty hard.