12 ms·
1984 – When women stopped coding
- grandDesigns 11y agoBecause women are smarter. I notice that graph compares Computer Science ($50K-$150K/year), to Medical School ($150K--$1M), Law School ($120K--$1M), and Physical Sciences (???). Women see the writing on the wall on High School: Med/Law School offer a clear career path to the upper middle class, while CS offers a muddy path at a middle class life. They also see "rich" old Doctors and Lawyers. They have never seen a "rich" old programmer, because they don't exist. Programmers are washed out by 50, while Doctors are in their prime at 50. Data: I am an 80's kid. All the smart girls knew to go to med/law school. All the nerdy guys like me wasted time learning 6502 assembly. We are all doing OK, but the women make 2 to 3 times as much as the men.
- jcadam 11y agoTHIS. I love programming, and spent my childhood hacking away on Apple IIs/Amigas/etc., but if I had my teens/twenties to do over again, I would pursue a career in Medicine (couldn't have stomached a career in Law, methinks) while continuing to program as a 'hobby.' Alas, I followed my "passion." Blech.
- omilu 11y agoGrass is always greener. If you were a medical professional you'd probably be having the exact same thoughts, wishing you had taken up law or computers, anything to escape from all the blood, broken bones and sick and dying people, day in day out, with no end in sight.
- nsxwolf 11y agoHey, at least your passion wasn't glass blowing, right?
- mikkergp 11y ago'Women' and 'men' are fairly large groups by which to organize people. I don't have a source, but I would wager a guess that there were other men who chose medicine and law(particularly since these graphs never grow above 50%) even though you chose a as. And why did women only start to see the writing on the wall after 1984? (Per the graph).
- lotu 11y agoI really question where you are getting your numbers they don't really make sense to me. Second, I will point out that the market for lawyers is completely oversaturated, so if you go to law school unless you went to a top ten law school you may end up working at Starbucks (slight exageration). As far as medicine their is very clear demand but the costs to get their are very high. You have an extra $100K, for 4 years of med school and 3 of residency where you act like a Doctor but get paid shit. You don't start making money until you are 30, while in CS you can be making big buck at 21. Physical Sciences get paid even worse. You cannot make a argument that women are just taking the more optimal career path and leaving men to do what is left over.
- pc86 11y agoI think the argument is that "big bucks" in CS is relative and the ceiling is much higher in medicine specifically (and to a certain extent law but you're 100% correct about the oversaturation). Outside of San Francisco and (maybe) NYC, "big bucks" for a programmer with no managerial responsibilities is probably somewhere in the $120-180k range. In my very low cost of living area, it's in the $100-120k range. You just cannot get a job for more than $9-10k/mo in the area doing development. Team leads/tech leads are similarly priced, and it's not until you're managing multiple teams that you're in the area of $150k. And yes a new doctor will be 5-6 years older and make less than a new programmer. But "big bucks" for a physician is measured in the hundreds of thousands. Anesthesiology tops $430k a year in median salary.[2] It's absolutely a harder, more demanding job, and it starts out much less forgiving. But the ladder extends much, much further and depending on specialty it's hard not to end up solidly upper class regardless of geographic area or cost of living. The 2012 median annual wage for "Computer programmers" is $72k[0] The 2012 median annual wage for a lawyer is $114k, with an arguably much more difficult job market[1], but is incredibly close to the top 10% of computer programmers (which is $118k). The 2012 median annual wage for a physicians is above the maximum reported value of $187,200[2] [0] http://www.bls.gov/ooh/computer-and-information-technology/computer-programmers.htm#tab-5 http://www.bls.gov/ooh/computer-and-information-technology/c... [1] http://www.bls.gov/ooh/legal/lawyers.htm#tab-5 http://www.bls.gov/ooh/legal/lawyers.htm#tab-5 [2] http://www.bls.gov/ooh/healthcare/physicians-and-surgeons.htm#tab-5 http://www.bls.gov/ooh/healthcare/physicians-and-surgeons.ht...
- kelukelugames 11y ago30 years ago, software engineers also had low social status. Only recently did our profession become more respectable.
- Consultant32452 11y agoWhile it may have improved I feel like it's still quite low. Outside of the valley and a few other key cities we're still largely considered anti-social dweebs who can't talk to women, have regressive sexist ideologies, are pedantic assholes, etc.
- roymurdock 11y agoThe image of the computer scientist/programmer/data scientist is changing pretty rapidly within the younger generation. STEM degrees garner a lot of respect, especially CS degrees, because everyone has suddenly become obsessed with "intelligence" as an indicator of future success and wealth, to the detriment of professionalism and altruism. Programming is now cool and desirable - you can see the shifts everywhere in pop culture. Being a nerd or a geek is a badge of pride for many.
- kelukelugames 11y agoAnd the influx of MBAs and tech-related MBA programs!
- jazzyk 11y agoPerhaps it is cool - but it is still not a popular major to study. Very, very few of my kids' friends in high school picked a STEM major, even fewer CS. Top 10 high school in Massachusetts (which is No. 1 in the US)
- kelukelugames 11y agoI agree. "Silicon Valley" is a step up from "Big Bang Theory", but we don't have a primetime show like "Grey's Anatomy" or "The Good Wife."
- kelukelugames 11y agoWell, I read your comment to my girlfriend and now she is pissed off at me. Sigh.
- dracht 11y ago>Because women are smarter. What kind of reaction do you think you'd get if your assessment had the opposite outcome? I'm all for brutal honesty, but it should be a two-way street.
- delibes 11y agoI'll focus on the professional salaries... "Uncle" Bob Martin gave an interesting talk in London last night about the need for a professional body for software. Doctors have the American Medical Association (or BMA here in the UK). Lawyers have the American Bar Association (I think the Law Society is the UK equivalent). They can regulate their profession, ensuring standards, controlling membership through certification, and raising the value/cost of the members. Perhaps he's right, and we'd benefit from the same in software? http://blog.cleancoder.com/uncle-bob/2015/11/27/OathDiscussion.html http://blog.cleancoder.com/uncle-bob/2015/11/27/OathDiscussi...
- cookiecaper 11y agoThe AMA and the ABA end up performing the function of unions in attempting to guarantee a rough wage floor by artificially constraining supply. One of the ways they do this is by working to ensure that the barriers to entry in the field are artificially high. I believe that licensing and authoritative standards bodies are inevitable in software engineering, but I think it will radically change the face of the programming job market, removing many of its most attractive qualities. It will be a very dark day, and the end of the era of the self-taught programmer, when something like the American Software Engineering Association gets to set the rules.
- kjdal2001 11y agoI saw him give the same talk in Chicago, and the impression that I got was that the body he was advocating for had nothing to do with salaries. The AMA and the Bar might increase salaries by creating scarcity in their professions, but they aren't salary negotiating organizations like a union.
- jazzyk 11y agoWe don't need a union, but a professional body representing us would do wonders. Merely sorting out the H1B visa mess (not necessarily eliminating) would help salaries. My wife is an architect (residential) and her clients cannot tell her to take a shortcut which violates the Building Code. I'd love to be able to say "no" to some stupid, short-sighted requests I get from clients. Without a professional organization behind me - I can't, because I will be deemed "difficult" and lose the business.
- flexie 11y agoLaw is a middle class profession for most lawyers. Very few lawyers make anywhere near $1M per year. I guess that the number of US attorneys consistently making $1M yearly is in the hundreds or low thousands. Median salary for lawyers is $113,530. That's a pay most lawyers don't achieve until they are in their late 30s or 40s. Top 10 percentile is at $187,200. Most lawyers spend 4 years in college and then 3 years in law school to land a $60,000 dollar job in their late 20s. Then they spend another 5-10 years paying off the student loans. Many programmers make that kind of money in their early 20s without any formal education. Also, it's too early to say at what age programmers are "done". There were few developers in the 1970's and 1980's and they are now nearing retirement. Let's wait and see how it goes with the bigger generation of developers that are now in their 20s and 30s. My guess is that many of them will continue until retirement. Source: http://www.bls.gov/ooh/legal/lawyers.htm#tab-5 http://www.bls.gov/ooh/legal/lawyers.htm#tab-5
- pc86 11y agoProgramming also seems like a pretty clear path to management (if that's your goal), which is one of the best upper-middle class professions there is. And once you've proven the ability to manage a team it is much easier to translate that into non-technical management, which opens you up to a plethora of different positions, particularly if you have advanced education (e.g. MBA or similar).
- jazzyk 11y agoA fair number of developers transition to management, but I would not call the path "pretty clear". It is much less clear than for project managers, program managers, etc.
- cookiecaper 11y agoManagement requires an entirely different skillset than programming, and one that many programmers are not well-suited for. Management is not about selecting objectively good tools, and it's not about making hard choices or settling disputes. It's about keeping everyone that works for your employer happy, which is, frankly, 95% about the superficial.
- Thriptic 11y agoIt's quite a different story now. You're looking at a ~14 year incubation period before you're making those types of numbers as a physician (bachelors, med school, residency, fellowship), plus having to take on significant debt. An overwhelmingly large number of physicians also report a low quality of life and urge others not to enter the profession. I'm not sure how it is for lawyers, but I would imagine there is also a significant up front investment before you start making real money (if you ever do). Contrast this with CS where you can make 6 figures right out of college with significantly less pain during the training process.
- pc86 11y ago> I'm not sure how it is for lawyers, but I would imagine there is also a significant up front investment before you start making real money (if you ever do). Law school alone (ignoring the cost of passing the bar or anything else) is prohibitively expensive for many people. For 2015-16, Yale law school is $78,000/yr[0], Harvard is $85,000[1] (including an optional $2400 health plan), Columbia is $65,588[2], and Stanford is $54,183[3]. So you're looking at $165-255,000 in fees, expenses and tuition over three years. The majority of my friends who are attorneys and have taken the bar also spent several months (up to 6-8 but that does not seem to be the norm) doing nothing but studying for it full time. Everyone took out additional loans to cover expenses, or lived with their parents for free. So it's not uncommon to have $150k in just law school student loans when all is said and done. So the median is still higher for attorneys than for developers, but most attorneys would have student loan obligations in the 1.2-2x median salary range, so often several times more than they're making right out of school. It was bad enough making $45k as a junior developer with $20k in student loans, I can't imagine making $60k as a junior associate in a similar area with $175k in student loans. [0] https://www.law.yale.edu/admissions/cost-financial-aid/cost-attendance https://www.law.yale.edu/admissions/cost-financial-aid/cost-... [1] http://hls.harvard.edu/dept/sfs/financial-aid-policy-overview/student-financial-aid-budget/ http://hls.harvard.edu/dept/sfs/financial-aid-policy-overvie... [2] http://web.law.columbia.edu/admissions/graduate-legal-studies/tuition-fees-and-financial-aid http://web.law.columbia.edu/admissions/graduate-legal-studie... [3] https://law.stanford.edu/apply/tuition-financial-aid/cost-of-attendance/ https://law.stanford.edu/apply/tuition-financial-aid/cost-of...
- ska 11y agoYour analysis is sloppy on several fronts. 1) Medicine and Law are professions, programming is not. You could arguably compare to CS professors, but that's still apples and oranges. 2) It doesn't make any sense to compare (peak, median, whatever) yearly salaries when you have wildly different career paths (e.g. 0 years of school vs. 10+) , debt, etc. What you want is lifetime earnings. 3) Lawyers in general don't make anything like what you think they do. Doctors distribution is also lower than your range suggests. You are right that some of these professions offer, for a smallish number of people, a clear path to a solid upper middle class salary (and few options outside of that).
- cableshaft 11y agoRegardless of the reality (which everything I've seen concurs with what you've said), there are a ton of people making decisions for school that are influenced by media, parents, etc. that keep telling them that the safest career path is doctors and lawyers. That's starting to change nowadays, but only just. I still regularly hear people talk about how cushy and rich all lawyer jobs supposedly are.
- MichaelMoser123 11y agothat is a good explanation, however it does not explain why women did choose programming as a career path before 1984 - were women less clever/was a high salary less important just before 1984 or was programming a more promising career path? I don't know. i heard another explanation - that the home computer brought about a shift in how pop culture did perceive programmers, from now on it was a thing for male geeks. Was that because home computers did not have a particularly friendly user interface at that time ? I don't know. Before that it was like any other white collar office job, after that popular culture became to associate it with you know who. It might be that this image did have some influence on career choices. Again, these are all guesses because nobody can anything definitive on the subject.
- vlehto 11y agoWomen have tendency to value job security higher. Dealing with mainframes is probably kinda secure job. Dealing with personal computers seems very sensitive to economic fluctuations. Maybe women just kept doing what they have always done. And men conquered this new front where employment is less certain. Just like with gold rushes in the past. So the news is no news. http://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2013/ted_20131024.htm http://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2013/ted_20131024.htm
- tryitnow 11y agoCompensation figures really have to be adjusted for hours worked, stress levels, work environment, schooling required (and associated opportunity cost of lost income), etc. On top of that I'd also like to see innate cognitive ability factored in. My guess is that once all the relevant variables are accounted for there's not much difference between the different professions. It will boil down to what one likes to do. Because that's going to be what you stick with and develop excellence in over time. Medicine, law, and programming are all pretty radically different field, so whether or not you enjoy the work is really going to matter. Pick one you like and you'll do fine. Note: The top end in annual comp for doctors and lawyers may be $1M but you really can't compare that to the top end in annual comp for CS because many developers at the top end are compensated in equity - which isn't paid out as income on an annual basis.
- geebee 11y agoYou don't even need to go all the way up to medicine. According to US News and Report "Best Jobs"[1][2], median salaries for developers in San Francisco ($114,400), ostensibly ground zero for the "shortage", are only a whisker higher than they are for dental hygienists ($112,970) and are considerably lower than for registered nurses ($127,670). [1] go to US News and World Report "Best Jobs" and drill down by salary and region. Alternatively, you can go to the BLS site - which is what the US News numbers are based on. [2] I'd also like to acknowledge that these numbers "seem" low to me. It's based on BLS data by region, but dev salaries seem higher than this in SF. I've posted this on HN a few times, and I've realized that I need to qualify this with a few statements. I have no problem with nurses earning higher salaries than software developers. It's a difficult and vitally important job and nurses deserve their high salaries and high scores on surveys of professional respect. Yes, programmers have more upside, but check the BLS directly for higher percentile salaries. It isn't until you get to the 90%ile for devs and nurses (in SF) that the devs earn more, and even then, it's only by a whisker. There are also lots of downsides - age related employment issues can get pretty bad for software developers. I do think that nurses have better job stability, experience few age-related employment issues in middle age, and may actually have better job flexibility (they can't wander off and get a cup of coffee whenever they feel like it like most devs can, but many nursing and medical specialties have remarkable options to scale back on work for a period of time, such as having a kid, without severely compromising the long term career path). Another complicating factor - anyone who reads a book on PHP can call him or herself a "software developer" (though BLS stats base this on people who use the title or something similar on a tax return, I believe). Nursing, on the other hand, requires a degree and formal licensure. So it's not quite apples-to-apples. Then again, we separate out physicians from nurses, whereas we include very high salary devs in that number, so again, it's complicated and difficult to make these comparisons. Also, these are numbers for San Francisco - nurses do not out earn developers everywhere. However, the higher concentration of devs in SF/Silicon Valley could skew the numbers as well. I'll stop here, and simply acknowledge that interpreting this data is certainly more complex than simply listing some medians. My real problem is that most analyses of why group X isn't going into profession Y almost never consider the possibility that this may in fact be a highly rational response to market signals. This isn't the only factor, and the social issues NPR mentions are highly relevant. However, we really do need to explore the extent to which a preference for law, medicine, nursing, pharmacy, dentisty, or even dental hygiene over software development may be highly rational.
- HeyLaughingBoy 11y agoAnd to add anecdote to anecdata: the girl who was my senior year lab partner in EE spent a few years as an engineer, decided she'd had enough, and is now a physician in Hawaii. Last time I talked to her, she was quite happy with her choice.
- crusso 11y agoAnd these toys were marketed almost entirely to men and boys. That's a pretty bad correlation-is-not-causation slip there. Marketing efforts, especially in new markets tend to take the path of least resistance. If they were marketing to males, it was most likely because males were showing an early interest in those products and likely to be the quickest way to grow marketshare. My personal experience was that I didn't need anything marketed to me. The K-Mart in my town had a couple of running new computers on an aisle where a friend walked up to them and typed: 10 PRINT "I AM THE GREATEST!" 20 GOTO 10 I was immediately fascinated and wanted one.
- jcadam 11y agoHe forgot the INVERSE:FLASH :) My first program on the new family Apple ][e was a flashing, infinitely-scrolling insult directed at my older sister.
- talmand 11y agoYou mean there isn't some large advertiser-driven conspiracy to hold back girls by only marketing the cool stuff to boys? Marketing actually does the things they do only to make money and not push some regressive social agenda? Clearly you haven't been on the Internet lately.
- scotty79 11y agoI think you underestimate serious drive in children (and older) to be not like the other (gender). You'd be way more reluctant as a young boy to approach computer if everybody knew that computers are what girls play with and all the ads had pink unicorns, stars and sparkle in the background. I vividly remember times when I was 10 or something and even talking to girls was act of treason against you own boy tribe.
- amelius 11y agoAccording to [1], 1984 was the year when Common Lisp and MATLAB were invented. But perhaps a more causative correlation is that in 1983, C++ was born (after being called "C with classes" a few years before). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_programming_languages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_programming_languag...
- slazaro 11y agoBut what would these technologies have to do with the decline of women in CS?
- Ygg2 11y agoProbably nothing. More likely marketing computer as boy/nerd toy is what caused a shift.
- rimantas 11y agoI cannot stand this argument, it holds no water. Or rather as much water as the famous FSM graph linking number of pirates to global warming. I was interested in computers since early teens, without even seeing one in person, just reading in magazines. I've got a real opportunity to spend some time with them only in university, and the same applies to my classmates. So no one was given computer as a gift/toy, no one saw any ads for them. Guess who got interested in programming and who did not.
- facepalm 11y agoWhy is that likely?
- Ygg2 11y agoI said more likely, but why is that more likely? Because huge shift in public opinion are from my experience, most likely made by marketing agencies. Also ads like these: http://howtonotsuckatgamedesign.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/fear-of-the-female-geek-xlg_two_bytes_better.jpg http://howtonotsuckatgamedesign.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/...
- golergka 11y agoTranscript or tl;dr available? I assume it has to do with computers becoming a mass-market commodity and marketing strategies involving "traditional" gender roles.
- red_admiral 11y agoYes. Last paragraph of the page, link after Update: -> http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2014/10/21/357629765/when-women-stopped-coding http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2014/10/21/357629765/when-wom...
- facepalm 11y agoThat's what they claim, not sure if they provide any evidence for it.
- purpled_haze 11y agoI have daughters and was not able to get them interested in any computer unless it involves games or social media. But the boys they hang out with are the same way- games only, for the most part. While I played a lot of games on my computer as a youth, I also spent a lot of time trying to program games. Today, I'm a developer. Because of kids' fascination with their phones and tablets, and because programming isn't a "normal" thing on computers, I really don't have high hopes for the future of the development community at all, much less for the future of women in this field. But, getting back to the topic of my daughters, my experience has been that: 1. If given the choice, they would not choose the constructive, mechanical toys I grew up with where they might get into robotics or mechanical engineering (e.g. Thames & Kosmos or Mindstorms) although one enjoyed putting a tin can robot together. 2. They also would not choose the electrical kits to put things together and get into electrical engineering, although I did get a kit and my daughters played with them a few times. It just took too much time and attention to have anything happen, and when it did, it wasn't exciting the way it was for me as a kid- it was boring compared to their phones and tablets. 3. As for development, I was able to show one of my daughters how they could play music by programming in emulator of an old computer, but they had little interest. I was able to get that daughter to work with me to use Scratch to program something for about an hour and she really liked it, but she's not asked about it since. Today's environment is just not the same. As much as parents who are developers try to get their kids into development, I just see it as a losing battle. What the world needs is an operating system (or systems) or even an application or set of applications that almost everyone would want to use that require programming in some form or fashion to accomplish everyday tasks better. But, iOS, Android, OS X, Windows, Linux and most applications that people use and games people play- they don't really work like that so much. You can get by without learning to code as a casual user, and the bar is so high now to create anything that a casual user would actually want to use or play. The closest thing to it really is a spreadsheet application or rules in an email application, and most users barely use those.
- mattlutze 11y agoIn a similar way that some parents will fruitlessly try to coax their children into being the sports starts they want/wanted to be, for some children the "digging about in the computer" bug just won't catch. I hope it won't be too disappointing for you... there's a whole world of experiences to explore with your daughters! I'm on the older edge or in the early middle of the Millennial generation, depending who defines the generation. As such I grew up and grew into technology just as we were getting really immersive operating system UI/UX. I remember fondly the green screen, text-based, 5.25" floppy games we had in elementary school, as well as the immersive film-like experiences today. Chemistry sets were kinda boring, Couldn't have cared less about my Dad's Erector sets, much to his disappointment. I built a few model cars and a F-14 over a span of 6 months, then those lived in a box never to be heard from again. And even in the computer... hacking around in the depths of my parents' computers was never the fun thing. But getting into web development was super cool, because it was raw, new, etc. Even as I look around, the companies I find exciting are more often web software vice native OS. I'm learning to appreciate embedded systems and very low level machine management, but it still doesn't have that spark like hacking about in GeoCities did... What's the raw, new, interesting tech today? I don't wonder if part of it is figuring out what might be the new version of playing with hobby boards or experimenting in system drivers. Even for me, getting a diode wired up to light up as a kid was super boring. But wiring up an iOS app might be super interesting now. Or, maybe your girls would rather be lawyers or vets or oil rig mechanics. I hear that's part of the fun of parenting :)
- cuillevel3 11y agoI don't think it's about absolute numbers, women did not stop coding. It's just more men starting to code, which makes the share of women smaller.
- arien 11y agoI was thinking along the same lines (personal computers = more boys interested in CS). Then I found this in the comments section of the article: http://i111.photobucket.com/albums/n134/im_thatoneguy/CSDegrees_10-27-14_zps43c754a2.png http://i111.photobucket.com/albums/n134/im_thatoneguy/CSDegr... Interesting that there was a dip of both males and females around 1984. So I'm not so sure of the statement above anymore. However, around the year 2000 there's this peak where males do outnumber females by a great deal (even if the number of females joining also increased). If all these graphs are accurate I'd wonder more about the Y2K rather than 1984...
- vlehto 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_video_game_crash_of_1983 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_video_game_cras...
- Retra 11y agoI feel like that, by 1984, the "this is the sexy future!" vibe that was associated with computers wore off a bit as it became more commercialized and common in people's homes.
- d_theorist 11y agoThis is what I was thinking as well, but they don't give us the data in the article to confirm.
- nmc 11y agoThis is probably true, but equally bad. Why would so much more men than women start to code?
- ishener 11y agoThe actual article is here: http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/10/21/357629765/when-women-stopped-coding http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/10/21/357629765/when-...
- ishener 11y agoI think it's important to also show the graph of absolute numbers of computer science students. Maybe the absolute numbers will show that the number of female students did not decrease, but rather the numner of male students increased dramatically, making the female share drop. Just an angle I would pursue.
- loup-vaillant 11y agoThat would be a worse a measure. Let's imagine that the number of female students did not decrease. Now the question is, why the boys increased much faster than girls? You can't "angle" that inequality away. Besides, I wager that the number of students of any gender increased quite significantly in the last decades. So the fact that one gender stagnated in absolute numbers is less interesting than the fact it decreased in relative terms. Absolute numbers would only be interesting if the total stayed relatively constant.
- lucozade 11y agoI had the same thought so I checked [1]. Really very odd graphs of both male and female students. I haven't seen anything that really explains the peaky total number let alone the ratio profile. Interestingly the higher degrees seem to be pretty stable in ratio terms. Not sure what they may be indicative of though. Very strange. [1] https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d12/tables/dt12_349.asp https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d12/tables/dt12_349.asp
- facepalm 11y agoI don't believe this narrative of "it's because home computers were marketed only to boys". At least, I would like to see some more evidence for it. It seems more likely to me that the story starts sooner, there must have been a reason why computers were marketed to boys. Maybe the first home computers were considered part of the electronics hacking scene (radio shack and what not), and that was already more popular with boys? How many women went to the Homebrew computer club were people were trying to create their own computer before you could just buy them off the shelves (people like Bill Gates, Steve Jobs and Steve Wozniak)? Maybe girls saw home computers and didn't like them. I don't know - but neither do the tellers of the "marketing is at fault" narrative.
- jessaustin 11y agoThe share of women in computer science started falling at roughly the same moment when personal computers started showing up in U.S. homes in significant numbers... And these... were marketed almost entirely to men and boys. Great, another travesty for which we have marketing to thank.
- DeusExMachina 11y agoThe hate towards marketing that is present on HN is almost comical at times. My experience is that, the more you study how marketing works, the more you realize marketing is about what people already want and try to appeal to that. Sure, big companies like Coca Cola have more sophisticated techniques to make their brands appealing, but still, if you look at Coca Cola's marketing, what they sell is "happiness", which is what people want, and they make the association to their beverage. From this point of view, there is no "travesty" to thank marketing for. The reality was that probably personal computers were more appealing to men, so it made more sense to spend marketing resources towards them. Why it was more appealing to them is a good question to ask, and it could be because of many reasons, including culture and society. But marketing probably didn't create that desire, it just used it.
- darkr 11y agoI think you've totally missed the point why people hate marketing. It's not because of a lack of understanding on it's mechanics. > From this point of view, there is no "travesty" to thank marketing for. The reality was that probably personal computers were more appealing to men, so it made more sense to spend marketing resources towards them. Why it was more appealing to them is a good question to ask, and it could be because of many reasons, including culture and society. But marketing probably didn't create that desire, it just used it. Marketing is absolutely about the manufacture of desire. Though above you make the connection between Coca-cola and the harmless association of this beverage to "happiness", this is over-simplifying things somewhat. The psychology of the brand, upon which modern consumer society is dependent, and which marketing ruthlessly exploits, is based around the construction of a self solely through conspicuous acts of consumption rather than through human experiences, relationships with friends and family, or other pursuits traditionally considered to be more laudable. Though arguably it is required in keeping the wheels of capitalism spinning (and by proxy food in our bellies); in reality, marketing is the process of co-opting, subverting, and ultimately extinguishing joy and the human experience.
- bboreham 11y agoI started Edinburgh University in 1983, and there were about 10% women on the CS course. There were more, I think, on the AI course, but that was in a completely different department.
- apalmer 11y agoDoesnt intuitively make sense to me... adult women stopped being drawn into the computerfield at the same time that male children began getting computers as gifts? wouldnt their be a distinct lag effect of maybe 5-7 years between when the boys got their computers and entered the work force? I think the shift probably had more to do with the perception that computer programming was 'important', a lot of the early view on computer programming was driven by the physical interface... women were viewed as suitable for programming because they were historically suitable for typing and secretary work... i think on some level it was being viewed as a form of dictation that was in a bizarre 'shorthand'...
- chongli 11y agoYour intuition around the 5-7 years lag time would seem to line up pretty damn well with the beginning of the computer revolution in the late 70s. What's the problem, exactly?
- decode 11y agoI agree. Both the TRS-80 (which was specifically mentioned in the audio version of the article) and the Apple II were released in 1977.
- vlehto 11y ago>By 1982, an estimated 621,000 home computers were in American households, at an average sales price of US$530. In a country of 220 million people. If we assume about 4 people could access a single computer, then 1,1% of population had access. So it seems commercials of Apple II and TRS-80 was the thing that compelled women to stay out of the field. Or alternatively getting your hands on dads TRS-80 was incredibly compelling experience to almost every boy out there. Edit: this stuff then https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=05M80HHNB6s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=05M80HHNB6s
- kps 11y ago> If we assume about 4 people could access a single > computer, then 1,1% of population had access. High school students aren't representative of the general population. Schools had computers, so all of them had access.
- TurboHaskal 11y agoBecause they know better than doing unpaid overtime, keeping up to date in an ever changing industry driven by popularity contests and having to work for free on some open source project because somebody thought that what you do in your free time is somehow more relevant CV wise than what you actually do for a living. I wouldn't worry much anyway. We won't be seeing many of those articles once the bubble bursts.
- analog31 11y ago1984 was also when manufacturing jobs went into decline. In my locale a lot of displaced auto workers went into programming. (edit: Off-by-one-century error)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- aggieben 11y agoCan someone post the TL;DR (uh....TL;DL?) from the podcast here? Looks like a decent discussion going on, but can't tell that anyone actually listened :-) I'll cop to the fact that I'm just not going to spend the time, though I'm interested in the conclusion(s).
- nmc 11y agoThe post was updated with a link to this transcript/summary: http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/10/21/357629765/when-women-stopped-coding http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/10/21/357629765/when-...
- anjanb 11y agoA lot of indian women are taking to coding/programming career. Currently, the estimate of number of women programmers in india is about 1,00,000. They are expected to grow to 2,00,00 in less than 10 years.
- kyllo 11y agoI think it's becoming a fairly popular career for women in China as well.
- scbrg 11y agoNot to be nitpicky, but you probably want to review how you typed those numbers. The second is smaller than the first, and the commas are not grouping the zeroes in groups of three. I suppose you mean either 10^5 or 10^6, but I'm not sure which.
- gauthr 11y agoThey're using the Indian numbering system -- see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_numbering_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_numbering_system
- talmand 11y agoThat's really interesting, thanks for the link. But it still doesn't make sense, because if you remove the commas from 1,00,000 and 2,00,00 you end up with 100000 versus 20000. Based on the examples in your link I'm assuming that the last figure should be 2,00,000. In the examples all the high number always end with three zeros.
- scbrg 11y agoWow, I did not know about this. Thank you for the link. As sibling poster points out though, there still ought to be an error in the numbers as written, as the second is smaller than the first, but the context of the text implies that it should be larger.
- rasz_pl 11y ago
- BerislavLopac 11y agoI would like to see a parallel breakdown of professors by gender, for the same fields in the same time frame.
- coldtea 11y ago>But a lot of computing pioneers, the ones who programmed the first digital computers, were women. And for decades, the number of women in computer science was growing. But in 1984, something changed. The number of women in computer science flattened, and then plunged. Those statistics kind of refute those lamenting male culture etc for the lack of more women in computer science. One would imagine the 1969-1984 that the graph shows, the "male culture", bro attitudes, etc were far more imposing that they are in the milenial, PC environments of today. We're talking about the seventies to early eighties, after all! And yet, there were more women back then than they are now. (Always suspected the usual explanations weren't the reason. It's not like medicine, law school, finance, etc have much better male cultures than computer science).
- ashmud 11y agoI find it interesting the transition towards physical sciences and away from computer science in the late 1980s. At that time, my mother, who was educated and worked in chemistry, started working at home as a programmer. It was a very good job that allowed her to work remotely most of the time and set her own schedule.
- panglott 11y ago1984 was the year that CS majors began to drop off. You're not talking about girls that were begging their parents for a C64. You're talking about girls that were born circa 1962-1966 and after. Many early programmers in the 1960s and 1970s were women because it was seen as the equivalent of secretarial work, a sector of the office labor that women were confined to due to overt sexism. The profession was then masculinized in overtly sexist ways. If women fled CS, they were fleeing an overtly sexist niche (which both locked them into submissive, secretarial roles as well as undervalued their technical accomplishments). http://gender.stanford.edu/news/2011/researcher-reveals-how-%E2%80%9Ccomputer-geeks%E2%80%9D-replaced-%E2%80%9Ccomputergirls%E2%80%9D http://gender.stanford.edu/news/2011/researcher-reveals-how-...
- cicero 11y agoI've read elsewhere how in the earliest days of computers, men designed the hardware and relegated the programming to women because it was seen as clerical work, albeit advanced clerical work. Because of this, women, such as Grace Hopper, became well established in the field. The advent of the Apple II and TRS-80 exposed kids (including myself) to computers, and with these machines, programming was the most accessible aspect. You could try to modify the hardware, but then you risked ruining the most expensive piece of equipment in the home. However, you experiment all you wanted with the BASIC prompt, and that's how I learned to program. There is something different about girls and boys such that this kind of tinkering with gadgets appeals much more to boys than girls. I remember excitedly showing our new Apple II to my cousin who is 6 years older than me, and who had recently finished her CS degree and was working in "data processing." I expected her to have the same gee-whiz reaction I had, but she was not impressed. To her, the Apple II was a silly and expensive toy. I think that in a way, when myself and other male "Micro Kids" entered the university and professional CS world, we changed the dynamic from a more professional to a more hacker-like culture. Not only did our numbers heavily tilt the gender distribution, but I think we also made the culture less attractive to women. My cousin, now in her late 50s, is still in IT as a higher-level manager in a large oil and gas firm. Right now, she appears to be spending a lot of time dealing with the logistics of some major office relocations. It is probably the kind of work that many on HN would consider boring, but I am sure it is essential to the smooth operation of a large modern corporation. When I hear her talk about her work, she comes across as being more responsible and practical than her younger male peers, and I don't doubt that's the case.
- deveac 11y ago>There is something different about girls and boys such that this kind of tinkering with gadgets appeals much more to boys than girls. There is something different about what our culture teaches and signals to girls and boys from the moment they are born such that this kind of tinkering with gadgets appeals much more to boys than girls.
- stuxnet79 11y agoSame thing if you want to be a programmer and happen to not be indian, white or chinese.
- scotty79 11y agoIsn't that about the same time when greed driven people started doing such crappy games that adults (women included) stopped playing them altogether? After the market nearly died they had to move games from electronics to child toys but they had then pick either boys toys or girls toys and they went with boys. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i08CVkBxvBM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i08CVkBxvBM https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_video_game_crash_of_1983 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_video_game_cras... It seems that there is only one way for normal people to enter programming and it's through games.
- hasenj 11y agoMaybe it's actually the time that men became more interested in software. The first programmers were mostly females because men in STEM were probably more interested in physics and hardware. This is entirely a hunch on my part, but even the term "soft-ware" sounds almost derogatory. Imagine if math was called a soft science? Why, it's all imaginary! I think the term "soft science" is some derogatory towards fields like social sciences.
- tzs 11y ago> But in 1984, something changed. The number of women in computer science flattened, and then plunged. So did the number of men. Bachelor's degrees in CS peaked in the US with 27k men, 15k women in 1985-86. Then they dropped by 1993-94 to 17.5k men, 7k women, and then started going back up. By 2002-04, they both had reached new peaks of 44.5k men, 15.5k women. There's something going on here that is more complicated than what is captured in that sex ratio graph. Data from here: http://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d12/tables/dt12_349.asp http://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d12/tables/dt12_349.asp