12 ms·
Being homeless a struggle, even with a $100k job offer
- crimsonalucard 11y agoWhy don't wrongfully convicted people Sue for damages and use the lawsuit to get there records purged? I sure there is a reason why people don't in general I'm just not clear what exactly this reason is. Anyone in the know care to elucidate me?
- jrockway 11y agoSuing the government is not all that easy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity_in_the_Unit...
- johncolanduoni 11y agoIt really isn't. A close associate of mine had a government official back out of a contract he signed (in the government's name) in a way that was so legally clear that it would have resulted in a summary judgement had it been anyone else. His lawyer advised him not to bother unless he could afford to pay the legal fees for a decade long court battle.
- brudgers 11y agoPoor people have trouble paying lawyers. Involuntarily homeless people tend to have more pressing issues than starting an extended legal action. Suing the state over a matter of principal is de facto if not de jure often amounts to little more than a luxury.
- analyst74 11y agoAccording to one of his comments, all the lawyers wanted upfront money to sue the city.
- kriro 11y agoHe probably got an offer along the lines of "your record is cleared if you waive all rights to sue us over this".
- asift 11y agoDepending on where you live, it might be that certain court/legal records can never be expunged. I know a guy who was sober (determined by multiple breathalyzer tests), but arrested for public intoxication. The case was immediately thrown out and the charges dropped, but he lives in a state where arrest records cannot be expunged. It's the only thing that shows up on his criminal record, but he's had job offers fall apart because employers assume he was actually guilty of public intoxication (a charge that usually only comes against people acting belligerent, violent, so drunk they can't walk, etc.) and just lawyered his way out of it. He thought about suing for wrongful arrest, simply to try and bolster his case in employment situations, but his attorney told him that it's nearly impossible to win a wrongful arrest suit and it would cost him 10's of thousands of dollars to even try.
- pkaye 11y agoI wonder if he could start his own consulting company?
- SwellJoe 11y agoIt comes with a lot of the same problems as getting hired by a company as an employee. Meeting with clients when you can't travel easily is a challenge. Living in a homeless shelter puts you on the schedule of the shelter (there are in and out times that are strictly enforced at most of them, if you aren't in by the curfew, you don't sleep in a bed that night), which conflicts with the erratic schedule of an IT contractor. You need a phone that is reliable, and the ability to take calls and emails at any time, which being homeless does not really allow; my friends who are homeless often live by day in coffee shops and libraries and by night in shelters if they're lucky enough to get a bed. Also, though I don't like it, the reality is that black folks in IT are also facing subtle discrimination on a daily basis. Getting hired as a contractor often has none of the same protections that large companies have in place for people of color being hired as employees (government contractors are an exception in that the government has guidelines in place to help insure minorities are well-represented, but selling to the government is a whole other set of skills that he may not have, and may not be able to obtain given his circumstances). Among people of color (and women) that I've discussed it with, they tend to prefer applying for jobs and working jobs in major companies because the HR processes are designed to be less discriminatory. Small firms, even when they intend to not discriminate often make "culture fit" decisions that exclude women and minorities. He's also older. Smaller IT firms are infamous for hiring young and overlooking older candidates. I live in an RV (I did it for four years, traveling full-time, and now I'm back to it after a couple years of stability), and I'm being reminded of all of the ways it makes a "normal life" difficult. And, I'm not dealing with the kind of stuff he is: I have a vehicle and money to travel, I have a phone and reliable Internet, I have a private home where I can have phone/skype conversations with co-workers, etc. Getting out of homelessness is really tough, is what I'm trying to say, and being homeless makes a lot of things that are obvious solutions to problems for you and I much tougher when you don't have the stability and savings and such to fall back on that you or I have.
- djcapelis 11y agoIt's possible, but there's also some annoying bootstrapping costs for starting a company (yes, even a consulting company) that can make it a hard thing to do if you don't have any money or access to credit. I put everything on my credit card to start mine, I doubt he has that luxury.
- zodiac 11y agoWhy is he failing background checks if he's never been non-wrongfully convicted? Genuinely curious to hear from anyone with experience on the employer side of this.
- hueving 11y agoLikely the department of corrections number somehow coming up so it shows that he spent time in prison. Even if it shows he was exonerated, many people will sadly lose interest right then because they get a vibe the applicant is 'in with the wrong people'. The US is terribly cruel to people that have done prison time, regardless of whether or not they were supposed to be there.
- neoeldex 11y agoToo bad it's only almost 1% of the total population.
- sean2 11y agoYes indeed. And that's only the current percent in prison (something like 0.9%) over 3% have been to prison. If you start counting the number of people accused of crimes, but later exonerated, like this guy, it's probably pretty large.
- jzwinck 11y agoThere are two kinds of background checks. The official kind done by a dedicated team with access and knowledge to retrieve city, state and federal data. And the HR kind, where someone without an investigative background and education spends ten minutes doing web searches and online "stalking" to see if the candidate has any untoward elements in their past. The first kind costs hundreds dollars per candidate. The second can be done for about twenty bucks worth of time. You can guess which approach most companies use. It's easier on most candidates, too, because a real background check requires them to fill out paperwork. An ad hoc one they may never know about...unless they fail.
- 11y ago
- meesterdude 11y agoIs there anything we can do for him? I mean this is just nuts.
- jzwinck 11y agoNow that he's in the NYT he will probably be OK. The question is what to do about other people in similar situations. I once received an application from someone quite famous. But he was famous because of a criminal case against him which was ongoing. We let this scare us off, because as a small company we didn't want the exposure if we did hire him. I'm not sure it was a very moral decision, but does your startup have time to deal with that?
- barsonme 11y ago> Now that he's in the NYT Pedant: the article is in the Seattle Times :-) > he will probably be OK. I sure hope so. I always have mixed feelings when I read articles like this. On one hand, things should usually end up going well for the person (assuming they're legitimate) because of the exposure. But, on the other, it's sad to hear of them being in the situation in the first place.
- sdrothrock 11y agoIn his case, it sounds like the problem isn't homelessness itself, but: 1. A crappy background check system that reports him as an ex-con/drug dealer when he's been exonerated. 2. Companies using those systems and judging him without giving him a chance to speak up.
- nickff 11y agoEven the president is in favor of punishing people who have been suspected of crimes; it seems to be a popular position that people are not really innocent until proven guilty.[1][2] I find this trend deeply troubling, but it does seem at least somewhat popular. #2 is at least partly due to the fact the if the companies allowed him an opportunity to refute the claim, they would be incurring various legal liabilities. The rules meant to protect job candidates often result in them being passed over at the first stage where it is realized they are 'complex' cases. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2015/12/04/can-americans-be-denied-second-amendment-rights-because-the-attorney-general-suspects-theyre-terrorists/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/201... [2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2015/12/06/what-could-possibly-be-the-argument-for-allowing-a-terrorist-suspect-to-buy-a-semiautomatic-weapon/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/201...
- sdrothrock 11y ago> #2 is at least partly due to the fact the if the companies allowed him an opportunity to refute the claim, they would be incurring various legal liabilities. Interesting! I'd thought it was simply done in the name of efficiency.
- kiba 11y agoYou're too old. You have a criminal background. You're too overeducated. We think you'll sue. You're too young. It seemed that companies are loathed to take risk on employee. At the same time, lot of environments contained toxic working conditions, so it's not clear if their choice of employees matter much. But people must find a job to keep themselves afloat or depend on someone having a job. It didn't matter if you're bad at social grace or if you have mental illness or if you're a felon, old or young. Without food, shelter, and peace of mind, I think people would be hard pressed to be economically productive.
- ommunist 11y agoI believe the only clear way for him is to leave the US and land some international job at some place good as Australia or Sing. Yes, the US will loose a good cyber cop. But as you can see here, this is entirely the US systematic problem. Simmons does not deserve to serve lifetime living in the US, struggling for foodstamps.
- cshimmin 11y agoHow is that supposed to work? He can't even afford to leave Seattle.
- ommunist 11y agoCompanies pay relocation to a suitable candidate.
- scurvy 11y agoEspecially those in suitable roles which are really hard to hire for, like security.
- AYBABTME 11y agoThey reimburse, you need the money upfront.
- nkjoep 11y agoTrue. You need the money upfront. It's happening to me, I'm moving to Berlin and needed some money to do it.
- Symbiote 11y agoNot necessarily. I would have thought the company paying directly was preferable, since then they can see invoices, and query costs beforehand. My employer paid to transport my belongings, all I did was get a few quotes. It was useful for them to be involved, since they knew about necessary insurance etc, but an international move was new to me. They also offered to transfer my relocation bonus to me as soon as the contract was signed, but I didn't need the cash so I waited until I'd opened a local bank account in the appropriate currency.
- Dr_tldr 11y agoThis is part of the larger tech hiring culture of "it's better to miss hiring someone good than to hire someone who might be bad." The guy in the story is hit especially hard by this, but HR's paradigm of fear/incompetence/inability to manage people after they're hired is a big piece of it. It's not ever easy for someone classified as an ex-con to get a job, but tech discriminates more than most other professions.
- tluyben2 11y agoWell, HR / recruiters are a bit worse in most (tech?) professions; they seem really lazy when vetting people and just go for the stereotype great employee while discarding everyone else. So the only way back would be to go for a very small company in a smaller town. In the EU he would be hired for sure; I would hire him. I never cared about previous experiences/age/gender/race only about current skills and effort and we did very well by it.
- alakkadshaw 11y agoHe could try working as a freelancer, on websites like Elance/Upwork or something and make some money. Then he could use that money move out of the homeless shelter and then look for a decent job.
- insanebits 11y agoThe problem here is not a shelter but a previous criminal records. +1 for freelancing idea, it might actually work if there are security jobs. But I think security in it's nature is something that needs assurance that person is capable of auditing the system.
- jfoster 11y agoYou're right, though if he's very capable at security stuff, there's probably also other types of freelancing work that he'd be capable of doing.
- halflings 11y agoIt seems like he has more experience in the enterprise world ("Security Compliance"), not sure that's the type of jobs you'd give to a freelancer, or at least not on Elance/Upwork.
- morgante 11y agoOne thing I'm curious about is how he actually ended up homeless. Before the conviction, it seems like he was doing very well (BMW, townhouse). Why did he not have sufficient savings to survive after he got out of prison? (Not trying to blame him for anything, trying to plan for my own life. I strive to maintain sufficient savings so that I would never be homeless even if I never worked again.)
- tdicola 11y agoMaking just shy of $100k in Seattle could be tricky to build up a lot of savings and live in a desired/fancy area with an expensive car. The median home price is well north of $500-600k.
- nostrebored 11y agoPlenty of people live in West Seattle/Kent/Renton/Vashon. You can even live in the CD and still be in commuting distance for affordable rates. There's also no shame in having a roommate. I live in Queen Anne in a 2br house and still have net savings at a comparable salary. Also if you're living in cap hill, slu, Queen Anne, etc., you don't need a car. Everything is in walking distance or busable. You can even go hiking with the buses here! It all just depends on how you live.
- caseysoftware 11y agoI suspect any savings he did have would have gone to his legal defense. It's an all or nothing thing, you wouldn't hold back if you were wrongly accused and had everything to lose (as demonstrated).
- jpindar 11y agoIn the comments, if that is actually him posting under his name, he says "I was in Debt and had JUST started that particular contract ,,an attorney wanted 10.000 up front and I did not have it !! ."
- tehwalrus 11y ago
- jokoon 11y agoArtificial selection at its finest.
- exhomeless 11y agoI was homeless for about a year and a half. The first 6 months were spent sleeping on the streets, and when possible, in a shelter - but realistically, in the area where I was, most shelters were not really a safe place to be, and the few that were filled up early. The remaining time, I crashed at a drug dealers house and helped sell in return. I didn't have much more than the belongings that fit in a mid-sized duffle bag and for a while I mostly survived by cleaning bathrooms at coffee shops before opening hours where the employees didn't really want to do that part of their job - and in return I would get some coffee and a bite to eat. Any money I did get, I saved up. Once I had access to the internet again, and at least a warm place to sleep at night that I considered safe, I started making contacts on IRC. Eventually I had enough money to relocate across country via Greyhound, a couch to crash on when I arrived and prospects for a new beginning. I quickly jumped from $25k to $40k to $60k etc and am currently at $160k with a whole new life and an amazing career ahead of me. It's possible to get out of the situation if what got you there isn't addiction or mental illness - the system does little to help, and without being resourceful it's easy to get stuck in that position for a long time. But it can be done. Granted, I never had the ex-con/drug dealer status haunting me in background checks, but I have been upfront in interviews before and still got the job. Greatest accomplishment in life? Escaping homelessness.
- gabalese 11y agoGreat story indeed, and really inspirational. But that just reaffirms what other commenters already pointed out: the problem is not homelessness per se, but a (unfair) criminal record that doesn't mix really well with a job in security. What I find incredible, though, it's that this record still persists after he has been cleared of the past accusations.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Filligree 11y agoIt persists on the internet. This type of situation is essentially the reasoning behind the EU's "right to be forgotten".
- spyder 11y agoWhy don't they do the background check before the interviews so they don't waste eachother's time and money just to later have a background check fail. Does a background check costs more than an interview and paying for the flights?
- jschwartzi 11y agoIt's probably because the interviewer's time is a sunk cost, whereas the background check would require accounting approval.
- manquer 11y agoNot a for a single candidate, if you however need to do it for all candidates before they are evaluated it will be much costlier :). Doing it after the interview for few candidates is much cheaper. Also it may take weeks to do the full check, you will loose the candidate if you wait for so long to do the assessment .
- tuxracer 11y agoTake someone who has already demonstrated the know how to make money selling illicit drugs and, as punishment, ban them from legitimate employment for life... That must be super effective! /s
- etivrusky 11y agoTop kek. This article is full of shit. If your skills are worth _anything_ in security then you can make easy money via bug bounties or vulnerability acquisition programs. Most web companies pay thousands of dollars for trivial XSS vulns and you want to tell me that this poor chap can't help himself? Yeah right.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- DawkinsGawd 11y agoYou realize that offensive web application pen testing is only a tiny corner of the whole information security industry, and that most information security professionals don't find bugs. A good portion of InfoSec professionals are not technologists at all. They are behavioral experts, legal experts, policy makers, etc. Judging by his own description of his skill set I would say he doesn't do offensive security at all but rather remediation, policy, and/or maybe forensics.
- nih0 11y ago>Top kek wrong site anon, back to >>>/g/ with you
- win_ini 11y agoI'm always happy when the up voting system works and the most useless, least constructive comments make it to the bottom. As the other commenter said - the universe of offensive pen testing is a small one compared to the IT security playing field.
- imgabe 11y agoAre there charities set up that could help with something like this? I mean it would literally take less than $5k to get this guy set up. A couple suits of decent clothes, a security deposit and first months rent for an apartment, a bus ticket to wherever his job is. That is a bargain for removing a homeless person from the system. Local governments and shelters should be jumping at the chance to do it.
- jschwartzi 11y agoIt's not just that. It sounds like he gets the offer, but it's contingent on his background check clearing. If that's all he needs though, where's the Kickstarter?
- imgabe 11y agoMaybe I was confused. It sounded like some of them were possible but he had no way of getting to the city where the job was. Or maybe he was just saying that even if one did come through he couldn't follow up on it.
- lisper 11y agoI spent two years trying to get a homeless person off the street, and made a movie about it: http://graceofgodmovie.com/ http://graceofgodmovie.com/
- paki123 11y agoThis is so fucking stupid.
- chatwinra 11y agoThis just backs up why I think Finland's recent move[1] to give every citizen a basic salary is the way forward. You'd then give everyone that basic level of security and enable them to progress in life. Yes there are potential flaws with the Finnish scheme (some people on benefits may ultimately lose out, and millionaires getting the same amount as poor people) - but crucially it would probably stop most, if not all, of cases like this, where someone can't escape the pull of homelessness even with opportunity there. 1 - http://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/finland-plans-to-give-every-citizen-a-basic-income-of-800-euros-a-month/ar-AAg3Bn1?ocid=ansmsnnews11 http://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/finland-plans-to-give-ev...
- kuschku 11y agoGermany has something called "Grundsicherung", which is even below unemployment benefits, but can be gotten by anyone, even without having a place of residence. That means if your homelessness is not based on mental issues or being too proud to accept help, you have at least a possibility to get out.
- kraftman 11y ago“I am very pleased to offer you the full-time position of Senior Analyst, Security Compliance,” - so why doesn't he take that job? Or are they offering him the job and then by the time he goes to take it they've googled him and changed their minds?
- kevinchen 11y agoYes, that's entire point of the article.
- kraftman 11y agoIt just seems strange to me that they learn enough about him to offer him a job, and then only after they've done that do they google him and find out his past. Surely you'd do that fairly early on?
- MrApathy 11y agoVery likely the offer is contingent upon the successful completion of a background check. A thorough background check (criminal, education, credit) can cost a few hundred dollars, so firms won't proceed until an offer has been accepted. Even though he was exonerated, his prison stay and other convictions may show up. He can explain, but a firm can rescind an offer for whatever reason they want (outside of protected statuses, which does not include criminal background). For a security position firms may want perfectly clean backgrounds.
- kraftman 11y agoAhh, I was wondering why they would leave it that late, but avoiding extra costs makes sense.
- d_theorist 11y agoIt seems like the conviction is what's preventing him from taking up the job offers, not being homeless.
- brotoss 11y agoWhat is this article actually about? That he's getting $100k offers pending background checks and failing them? Bad title.
- Laaw 11y agoSeems like this story is more about the struggle being black.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- SZJX 11y agoIt's a bit weird though. Why couldn't he just rent a house/borrow money to pay for a temporary residence, then pay off using his paycheck? If his case was indeed already listed as exonerated, then he should be able to at least take some loans. But indeed, whetehr he was truly guilty or not, the stigma put on people via even just one conviction is just horrible. This seems such an ancient and brutal practice in today's world.