7 ms·
How to Satisfy the World’s Surging Appetite for Meat
- craigjb 11y agoIt seems like the most immediate way to meet low-cost but high volume is through in vitro meat culture [1]. It will likely take awhile to clear the health and GMO-fear hurdles, but it's coming. Especially places where raising livestock in traditional ways drastically harms the environment (mass pig dumps in rivers, or limited land resources in island nations). Decentralizing growth of meat and other food, as mentioned in the article, is probably a good thing too, just like decentralizing internet services or electrical generation. However, I don't completely buy the 'decentralize everything' argument that has become popular lately. While it brings us closer to the libertarian dream, some advantages are lost as well. Also, I'm not convinced the innovations that enable decentralized agricultural or electrical generation don't have the same positive impact on the centralized version of the system. Except, in the centralized system you benefit from economies of scale. We'll probably end up with some kind hybrid system. [1] http://new-harvest.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/post_2012_cultured_meat_from_stem_cells_challenges_and_prospects.pdf http://new-harvest.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/post_2012_...
- copperx 11y agoThe only solution I foresee comes from technologies such as the one you mention, in vitro meat. Billions of families on earth have an entrenched cultural desire for meat. It's much easier for a technological revolution to happen than to change culture.
- logn 11y ago"Some of the company’s prized purebred birds can now add a pound of weight for every 1.2 pounds of feed consumed" That's great news. Also compared to cows, chickens emit much less methane and other greenhouse gases, especially if their manure is handled properly. Not to mention they're working on breeding to improve that. And given it takes only ~ 30 days to raise a chicken, that reduces overall energy consumption running the farm. But I think WSJ understated how healthy a vegan diet is, aside from lacking B-12.
- beagle3 11y agoThere are a lot of myths about B-12. The most persistent one is that it comes from meat. It's actually made by bacteria. Vegetarians and vegans only lack it in modern society because of (a) antibiotic use, harming bacterial population, and (b) "clean" foods, which fails to reintroduce those bacteria, and which lack b12 themselves. Not so surprisingly, the same is true for modern animals including farmed cows and pigs. I can't find a the source now (and apparently neither can wikipedia editors, cause they deleted it), but a very significant percentage of B12 production today (some say upwards of 80%) goes to animals. Some of it for their well-being, but most of it for the people eating them. A contender for the "least-efficient-way-to-supplement-vitamins", I think. Also, many non-vegans and non-vegetarians suffer from B12 deficiency these days.
- takee 11y ago> Also, many non-vegans and non-vegetarians suffer from B12 deficiency these days. As a meat eater with B12 deficiency I agree with this statement.
- firass 11y agoA heritage breed chicken takes 6-weeks to go from hatching to full size. Franken-chickens take around 30 days, but those grow faster than their organs, bones, and muscles can support the speed of the weight gained.
- philfrasty 11y ago„...understated how healthy a vegan diet is...“ One question always crosses my mind when I hear this, maybe someone knows an answer here on HN. It seems easy to tell the negative effects of eating meat (might cause cancer, etc). But are all the effects of not eating animal products at all in the long-term well known? And I don't mean not eating animal products for 1 year or 10 years but for multiple generations. Will people who have not eaten animal products for 1000 years still have a life expectancy similiar to the general population (I guess animal product-eaters)? Will they have more/less diseases, higher/lower IQ, etc.
- 11y ago
- ciconia 11y agoThis is sickening. At the risk of starting a flame war I'll still state my opinion: the only reason for eating meat is taste. The same goes for cheese and other dairy products. The arguments against the meat & dairy industry are well known: chronic disease, depletion and pollution of natural resources, global warming, and above all the moral argument: enslaving sentient beings is wrong. 200 years ago in the US they were breeding human slaves [1]. Today they still breed chicken slaves and cow slaves and pig slaves, selecting for higher fertility and higher production of eggs, milk and meat. Then these animals spend all their lives enslaved, from birth to death, a life of absolute misery. I'm not saying killing animals for food is inherently a wrong act, but enslaving them sure is. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slave_breeding_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slave_breeding_in_the_United_S...
- zensavona 11y agoYou're right - it is sickening. And it's increasingly becoming this elephant in the room nobody wants to talk about. I used to be totally in the bandwagon of "those annoying vegans trying to make people feel bad for eating meat". Now I agree - why shouldn't you shame someone for doing something bad? Buying and consuming animal products is bad for everyone involved: bad for the person eating them, the environment and the animals. We would shame corporations for polluting the environment and we would shame a person for abusing their pets in the way factory farming does animals, so why is it ok if they do it by proxy? I read a nutrition book called "The China Study" about 6 months ago and it was the push I needed to seriously give veganism a try. I don't deny it, I love the taste of certain meats and at times I do miss them and I do occasionally still eat fish (sushi is my favourite food). I'm feeling better in every sense. I was surprised to see that my body composition is actually better now, even though my protein intake is markedly lower (I was 95kg and ~14% body fat before and am 87kg and ~10% now, judging BF% with calipers so not exactly precise), my weightlifting strength is up, my cardio endurance is improved, my skin is _hugely_ clearer and I anecdotally seem to have more energy - I definitely feel less lethargic after eating. My biggest concern was loss of muscle mass given lower protein intake, somehow I am looking better and feeling stronger than before. I'm eating around 3-600g of carbs per day (!) which is all coming from whole fruit and veg, which seemed totally ridiculous to me before coming from a close-to-paleo high fat high protein diet. FWIW I'm a 22 y/o male and consume around 3-4000 cals/day and work out 5-6 times per week so YMMV.
- cryodesign 11y agoScience has shown that: - Animals are mostly likely sentient and feel pain and can suffer like we do [1] - Pigs are as smart or smarter than small children [2] - We don't need to enslave and kill animals anymore to survive [3] - Large scale animal farming is harmful to the environment [4] - Working in a slaughterhouse can cause PTSD and has other emotional toll on workers [5] The main reason why we still eat meat is because it's cultural and because we like the taste of it. So considering the above, it's highly illogical to continue this myth of needing animal protein. The future of food is plant-based and we don't have to give up the taste and texture that meat products currently provide. There are alternative products like http://beyondmeat.com http://beyondmeat.com that are superior to meat. If you can opt out of the perverted and insane system that the meat industry is, why wouldn't you? --- [1] http://www.livescience.com/39481-time-to-declare-animal-sentience.html http://www.livescience.com/39481-time-to-declare-animal-sent... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mza1EQ6aLdg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mza1EQ6aLdg [3]http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19562864 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19562864 It is the position of the American Dietetic Association that appropriately planned vegetarian diets, including total vegetarian or vegan diets, are healthful, nutritionally adequate, and may provide health benefits in the prevention and treatment of certain diseases. Well-planned vegetarian diets are appropriate for individuals during all stages of the life cycle, including pregnancy, lactation, infancy, childhood, and adolescence, and for athletes. [4] http://www.ciwf.org.uk/factory-farming/environmental-damage/pollution-in-detail/ http://www.ciwf.org.uk/factory-farming/environmental-damage/... [5] http://advocacy.britannica.com/blog/advocacy/2013/03/creating-killers-human-tolls-of-slaughter/ http://advocacy.britannica.com/blog/advocacy/2013/03/creatin... edit: formatting
- sokoloff 11y agoThe beyond meat products seem ludicrously expensive compared to the products they seek to replace/displace (like 3-6x the cost).
- cryodesign 11y agoQuality meat (grass-fed) is also expensive. Don't compare it with factory farmed (subsidized) meat. The price will come down.
- CuriouslyC 11y agoMeat and other animal products are delicious. Eating them is totally natural. The only issue I have is with cruelty. I would be ok with a rise in prices in exchange for more ethically produced animal products (though I don't think conditions would have to change much for chickens, they're pretty retarded). Historically meat has been a luxury. That being said, if you are a vegan on the internet ranting about animal cruelty and you own basically any mass produced clothing you need to re-examine your priorities.
- cdnsteve 11y agoEating meat is natural? Then why is it our bodies cannot handle digesting raw meat like say, lions? Eating meat is not natural. Humans are not predators.
- odiroot 11y agoHave you heard about tartare steak? It's really popular in Central Europe.
- slyn 11y agoHumans can eat raw meat and do. Tartare, sushi, uncooked shellfish, blue rare, and so on is all raw, though not necessarily common because of disease caused by unsafe handling of the meats and the potential for eating live parasites from when the animal was alive. A secondary reason for cooking meat is that it'll be more nutritious from the heat making the nutrients more accessible for the human body's digestive system. Also, just for the record animals that do eat raw meat can get sick from it and/ or acquire parasites just the same as humans. Most people who have pets (particularly dogs that'll eat anything) for a long time experience this at some point.
- throwaway_gfsd 11y agoOur teeth certainly support it. There's a difference between eating exclusively meat, and eating some meat.
- bsder 11y ago> Eating meat is not natural. Humans are not predators. Um, you are completely off base. Current evidence seems to indicate that, in fact, many of our evolutionary changes from the great apes were all about hunting via endurance. Effectively we evolved to simply chase prey until it collapsed. So, not only is eating meat natural, and not only are we predators. But, we are the implacable Terminator of the animal world.
- erikb 11y agoIt's interesting. There are pro meat eaters and pro animal arguments here, but none of the comments I see states the following opinion: that meat in fact contains a set proteins, fats (and vitamins? not sure) that are hard to find in that combination in other sources. So yes, it is theoretically possible to eat complete and healthy without meat. It's also theoretically possible to put 3 chop sticks on top of each other, put them on your head and walk like that to your super market. That doesn't mean you can do it, by adding some beans and nuts to your diet. It's so complicated that some doctors think they can't do it for a long time to themselves. And it's so individual that no newspaper can tell you exactly how you specifically can compansate. I don't think I know enough about health to have an opinion, but for me it sounds just as likely as meat having no relevance to human health. And although statistics sometimes trick you, I know a lot of very, very thin vegetarians/vegans, but a lot of people with a healthy BMI who strongly advocate eating balanced (including meat, just not as much as most people do), which makes me believe that a small amount of meat may be better for human health than no meat at all.
- 1457389 11y ago>So yes, it is theoretically possible to eat complete and healthy without meat. It's also theoretically possible to put 3 chop sticks on top of each other, put them on your head and walk like that to your super market. That doesn't mean you can do it, by adding some beans and nuts to your diet. It's so complicated that some doctors think they can't do it for a long time to themselves. This is such FUD nonsense; pretty deplorable on this forum. There's nothing theoretical about eating "complete and healthy without meat" - people have been living on vegan and vegetarian diets for centuries without ill effects. People have become bodybuilders, MMA fighters while being vegan too, not that the vast majority of humans need to measure their diets by those of elite athletes. As for "so complicated" here is the American Dietetic Association: >It is the position of the American Dietetic Association that appropriately planned vegetarian diets, including total vegetarian or vegan diets, are healthful, nutritionally adequate, and may provide health benefits in the prevention and treatment of certain diseases. Well-planned vegetarian diets are appropriate for individuals during all stages of the life cycle, including pregnancy, lactation, infancy, childhood, and adolescence, and for athletes. [0]http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19562864 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19562864
- eveningcoffee 11y agoThis article has funny data. By this most of the Europe does not eat any meat which is obviously not true.
- Mz 11y agoEh, I think there are some very valid arguments to be made for eating lower on the food chain. I am not a big fan of moral" arguments per se. Those folks saying they are vegetarian because they think eating animals is somehow cruel or something are basically saying that if they can't hear it scream, its suffering doesn't count. We have scientific proof that plants "scream" (give off a pulse) when attacked and also communicate chemically with their neighbors when infested with insects, etc. So plants do have some kind of awareness of being physically assaulted and they communicate in some manner about this awareness, it is just a form of communication that human ears cannot detect. Saying "if I cannot hear it scream, it is all okey dokey" opens up all kinds of ugly questions (like "Is it okay to be a serial killer if you are deaf?") Anyway, some good arguments to get most of your calories from things lower on the food chain: 1) Ultimately, all calories start as sunlight. Eating lower on the food chain makes our resources go further because the higher up the food chain you go, the more sunlight is concentrated in those few calories. 2) Health. There are several metrics which are negatively impacted by eating higher on the food chain. Toxic chemicals that negatively impact human health tend to concentrate in the fats of animals. Eating vegetarian tends to reduce your exposure to a toxic world. You are also more likely to get serious diseases, like e. coli and certain parasitic infections, from meat than from plants. Most food poisoning comes from meat or dairy, not plants. 3) Cost. Diet for a Small Planet* documented the fact that every country on the planet (at the time it was written) had the ability to produce enough food from traditional, mostly vegetarian, diets to feed all their people. Famine was due to political things, like civil war, and the fact that meat was too costly for poor families who had become accustomed to it and no longer ate the traditional, mostly vegetarian, local diet. I am not a vegetarian. I am someone who eats more vegetarian meals than I did growing up and I have at times been accused of being a vegetarian by my meat-and-potatoes relatives. I also relatively rarely eat beef simply because I am really picky about the quality of my beef. I probably eat less meat on average than the typical American and I am satisfied with the healthfulness of my diet these days. I think a less-meat diet would do most American good. A meatless diet is not really critical and even the author of "Diet for a Small Planet" later relented on her vegetarian stance and repositioned it as "One less hamburger" in a follow-up book, indicating that we stretch the planets resources by reducing our excessive consumption of meat without giving it up entirely.
- rajington 11y agoWe just need robotic farmers that are powered from manure and use real livestock to fight desertification.
- cdcarter 11y agoThe last time the "Meat Question" came around, we thought the solution was Hippos. http://brightergreen.org/2014/01/american-hippopotamus-the-meat-question/ http://brightergreen.org/2014/01/american-hippopotamus-the-m...