12 ms·
Yet another post for HN to one-up each other decrying the "PC culture" with plenty of "kids these days" rants, while completely avoiding taking the charitable p
by icebraining 11y ago
Yet another post for HN to one-up each other decrying the "PC culture" with plenty of "kids these days" rants, while completely avoiding taking the charitable position and putting ourselves in their shoes.
The amount of hypocrisy that comes with the claims that these students should "learn to cope with uncomfortable ideas" is staggering. Guess what: these students are presenting us with an "uncomfortable idea" and the response has been nothing but knee-jerk.
Well done, everyone.
- Juliate 11y agoThe idea that people's feelings should come first (especially before truth/understanding of reality) is not uncomfortable, but a dangerous, misleading, childish posture. University is for adults, not toddlers.
- coldpie 11y ago> The idea that people's feelings should come first, especially before truth/understanding of reality No one is arguing for this.
- jerf 11y agoYes, they are. As soon as you claim they are, they scurry away claiming that's not what they mean, but as soon as you say "OK then" and move on, they turn right around and it's all about their feelings again. It is very much a part of the modern PC platform that if someone "feels" assaulted, they are, and you must believe them or you are blaming the victim. This is why accusations are as good as conviction in places where PC reigns supreme, because the fact of accusation is itself proof of feeling, and that's it, case closed. Don't fall for this transparent rhetorical ploy. Arguments that only appear transiently to dismiss one point, then disappear into the ether immediately after, are not arguments, just rhetoric. (This is a general point that applies in many places, actually.)
- coldpie 11y agoIn what case is someone doing this at the cost of "truth/understanding of reality"?
- adventured 11y agoIn fact it's being very openly argued all over the place in US culture today. The recent famous video of the Yale professor that was trying to talk rationally to the irrational students around him - it was all about the students claiming they had a right to not be offended, and the notion that their feelings trumped freedom of speech.
- coldpie 11y agoI'm sorry, I don't know what video you're referring to. What rational point was the professor trying to make? That white people dressing in racially-charged costumes should not be shunned?
- Tenhundfeld 11y agoI think this is the video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9IEFD_JVYd0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9IEFD_JVYd0 Along with some NYT coverage on this general topic: http://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2015/11/02/when-a-generation-becomes-less-tolerant-of-free-speech http://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2015/11/02/when-a-gener... This issue of students complaining about trigger warnings and the need for safe spaces certainly seems to be increasingly prevalent, but that could just be due to the media giving it more attention.
- coldpie 11y agoInteresting that according to that NYTimes link, offensive speech is considered protected "free speech," while people objecting to offensive speech does not qualify. I have just as much a right to tell you you're an asshole and not welcome near me as you do to say offensive things to me.
- tdkl 11y ago"Free speech" and "freedom of acting like a little bitch" are two different things though.
- vdaniuk 11y ago>University is for adults, not toddlers. Oh really, so university students are able to consume alcohol, right? edit: noun: adult; - a person who is fully grown or developed. - a person who has reached the age of majority. edit 2: "Longitudinal neuroimaging studies demonstrate that the adolescent brain continues to mature well into the 20s. This has prompted intense interest in linking neuromaturation to maturity of judgment." http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2892678/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2892678/
- vixen99 11y agoSo what? University still remains a place for adults. All sorts of odd laws and regulations pertain to institutions and other organizations notwithstanding.
- vdaniuk 11y agoUniversity remains a place for adults who are not legally recognized as adults but are expected to fully act as adults. So consistent, much logic.
- fixermark 11y agoYou're conflating a binary with a continuum. The dominant American culture is not one with a single consistently-applied rite of passage to adulthood. Over about a decade, people go though multiple transitions (age of majority, voting age, drinking age---heck, a lot of people even recognize the age at which rental car companies stop applying a "You're probably a dangerous driver" surcharge, at 25 years old).
- vdaniuk 11y agoYes, adulthood is a continuum. That's why it's wrong to say that college is for "adults". Some of students are very immature, some have more wisdom than older people. So I am not disagreeing with your point of view.
- vlehto 11y ago>University is for adults, not toddlers. This argument is basically "You belong to social group X. You cannot opt out." Then followed by "because to social group X, you have to behave in Y way. Because that's how X people behave." Depending on the surrounding culture, with that argument you can justify: why men have to wear ties, why young men should be sent to war, why women should wear burkha, etc. Anything conservative goes. I'm not disagreeing with your actual point. I'm just trying to point out that your argument is bad.
- stefantalpalaru 11y ago> taking the charitable position Also known as "wishful thinking". There's no room for charity when reason is called upon. Be as charitable as you want when talking about the weather with your neighbor, but when you're debating something serious you can not look for imaginary excuses for your opponent's mistakes.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- d_theorist 11y agoNobody is proposing that these people should be silenced, or not allowed to express the view. We are just saying that their view is wrong, and childish, and a danger to civilisation.
- SolaceQuantum 11y agoI think it's an exaggeration to say that someone's view is dangerous to civilization.
- d_theorist 11y agoNot one person. It's a prevailing attitude. And the idea that we should renounce freedom of speech in order to prevent hurt feelings - if it ever gains legal force - absolutely is a danger to civilisation.
- SolaceQuantum 11y ago>the idea that we should renounce freedom of speech in order to prevent hurt feelings Who is saying this?
- rokhayakebe 11y agoIf you are in college, you are no longer a kid. From 1 Corinthians 13: When I was a child, I talked like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child. When I became a man, I put the ways of childhood behind me.
- givinguflac 11y agoAre you suggesting people should not learn to cope with uncomfortable ideas? This is a pretty ridiculous comment you're making here. Freedom of speech and expression has, is, and always will be more important than one's personal comfort. That said, these people are just as free to voice these small minded, selfish complaints as I am to ignore them.
- coldpie 11y ago> Are you suggesting people should not learn to cope with uncomfortable ideas? No one is arguing for this.
- DanBC 11y agoWhile I tend to agree with you there are a bunch of things that are not being taught because students have said their feelings are important. Suicide dropped from sociology lessons: http://www.theguardian.com/education/2015/jun/15/suicide-dropped-sociology-exam-a-level http://www.theguardian.com/education/2015/jun/15/suicide-dro... (A-level students are 16 to 18 years old) I agree that teaching suicide to children is going to be difficult, and that most of the reason is about actual harm, not feelings - the increased risk of death or harm to the students from the Wurther Effect or stigmatising views. But all of that can be worked around. You provide a mix of comprehensive support of different types to students; you promote a culture of inclusion an sharing in that room. Suicide is really important. It's the leading cause of death of men aged between 15 and 49 in the UK. Rates are increasing. NHS cuts mean it's harder to get good quality support. Appropriately talking about suicide probably doesn't raise risk, and may well lower risk. So, it's a shame that this topic got cut from the syllabus. There are other examples in this thread of law students not learning about rape law because it's too distressing to hear. That shows a misunderstanding of what PTSD survivors want when they talk about trigger warnings. The point is not "I should be able to live my life and avoid every mention of this thing that causes me significant distress", but "I am currently vulnerable, but getting support, and I need a little bit of warning not so I can avoid the subject, but so that I can make sure I have the little bit of extra support I need to keep me safe". However: the people on the other side are mostly fucking hateful cunts who scream "What about my freedom of speech?" while seeking to silence the people they're screaming at.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jerf 11y agoI appreciate the attempt to perform judo on this debate, but "the uncomfortable idea that it is my obligation to make sure they are comfortable" is not amenable to that treatment. They're still trying to assert that all discomfort needs to be localized in not-them, and that it's everybody else's job to carry the discomfort the world has so they are protected from it. If this were naturally a world where all ideas were comfortable except for the influence of a few bad apples, it might not be a problem, but since the world does contain uncomfortable facts, opinions, and people in abundance, they're basically demanding that everybody else shoulder the burdens.
- lagadu 11y ago> completely avoiding taking the charitable position and putting ourselves in their shoes No. I, or the world will not be taking a "charitable position". As any other human being living in society I'm often confronted with things that I'm not comfortable with. Would you like to know what I do about them? I step away because it's none of my business judging other people's beliefs and the integrity of my feelings is not their responsibility. So, to reiterate: no, sir. I will not yield something that I do not ask for myself. I will also not be shamed into whatever you're trying to shame us for and I laugh at the notion that you believe you would be successful in that attempt.
- vonklaus 11y agoI can't tell/understand this PC meme. I have heard older generations talk about minorities in a way I wouldn't. It was a different time, women there are people (very old) alive born before women could vote. Maybe it is societal conditioning, but I think that is wrong and look back on older generations and think they must also have known. I can not say the same thing for much of these PC causes. I find it iritating and bad for society, much like I am sure racists in the south found the gradual acceptance of interracial dating and increased equity irritating. I find many of the causes championed, or at least incedents in the news, to be a mockery of a free society but I can't help wonder if I am the same as Jim Crow. I suspect he felt quite vindicated as well.
- tveita 11y agoPeople absolutely sincerely believed that not giving women the right to vote was for the best both for society and the women themselves. There wasn't some malicious conspiracy involving a majority of the voting population. Women were thought to be naturally uninterested in politics, and to not have the head for it anyway. Dabbling in politics was seen as an unwomanly thing ladies should be spared from. Not unlike how people today think that the scarcity of women in tech is due to them naturally having less interest in it. It's easy to ascribe the status quo to the natural order of things. Of writing of that era I like "Are Women People?"[1] It's written from a suffragettes point of view, but it includes some cherry-picked quotes from anti-suffragists, such as: "The grant of suffrage to women is repugnant to instincts that strike their roots deep in the order of nature. It runs counter to human reason, it flouts the teachings of experience and the admonitions of common sense."—N.Y. Times, Feb. 7, 1915." That was the kind of thing you could write in a newspaper of the time and have people agree with you. That should tell us something about how blind we can be to contemporary societal problems, and how silly we will look in hindsight. [1] http://www.gutenberg.org/files/11689/11689-h/11689-h.htm http://www.gutenberg.org/files/11689/11689-h/11689-h.htm
- JoshuaJB 11y ago> with plenty of "kids these days" rants I'm a student at a top 4 year university, and I find the lack of student backbone nauseating. The current trends in university culture go entirely counter to the reasons that we have higher education. Instead of encouraging expression, our culture deafens it with its constant concern towards avoiding offence.