12 ms·
I'm glad someone is trying it out. Hope they offer insight into what works what doesn't and any caveats. It may also be a bit early, as automation isn't in it
by mc32 11y ago
I'm glad someone is trying it out. Hope they offer insight into what works what doesn't and any caveats. It may also be a bit early, as automation isn't in its stride yet.
Also, this is Finland a small, rich and homogenous country. Whether their model can be adapted to say Indonesia or the US or Japan is to be seen.
The main source of ideas was from Milton and the Nixon administration who with the economy going south looked for alternative means for people to "make" a living.
"...Friedman believed that it should be accompanied by an end to any minimal wage system and any other system of social protection. Friedman also believed it should be as low as possible and financed by a flat income tax"
So it'd be accompanied by a loss of minimum wage floor as well as it should be as low as possible (approx USD 1000/mo after initial trial phase in Finland.)
It's not a comfy lifestyle by any means, but could get people off the streets who otherwise would not have the means.
Given those parameters, with a few exceptions, I don't see this implementation undermining people's will and want to work and at the same time it has great upside in simplicity and affecting their poorest citizens positively.
- logicchains 11y ago>So it'd be accompanied by a loss of minimum wage floor as well as it should be as low as possible (approx USD 1000/mo after initial trial phase in Finland.) To expand on this, removing the minimum wage is meant to make it easier for people to "get their foot in the door". The economic notion is that e.g. if X's labour is not worth more than $5 per hour, and the minimum wage is $10 per hour, then X will have great difficulty finding work (because the ultimate minimum wage isn't $10, it's $0). This means they'll have more trouble obtaining the work experience that would make them more productive. Removing the minimum wage means anyone can work who wants to, and the basic income protects them from the hardships that normally accompany low-wage jobs.
- arcticfox 11y agoThis is actually a really compelling argument that I hadn't heard before. Is there a good, short-ish reference on these arguments that you know of?
- CookieMon 11y agoHere: https://www.reddit.com/r/basicincome/wiki/index https://www.reddit.com/r/basicincome/wiki/index Basic income better aligns everyone's economic incentives, so it solves (in theory) a whole host of the problems we've got. It's great to hear that some form of it is going to be tried.
- notahacker 11y agoIt's a pity that the proponents there have to resort to including mathematical impossibilities on their list.... "A basic income, coupled with a flat tax, is capable of mimicking all aspects of our current progressive (bracketed) taxation scheme, but without brackets." Basic income realigns people's incentives. It might be better than a really badly designed welfare system at removing "welfare traps", but it also can be expected to have a whole host of negative aspects in comparison to other possible configurations of the payment of government subsidies.
- kwhitefoot 11y ago> host of negative aspects Such as?
- polymatter 11y agowhat are the "whole host of negative aspects"? I will accept that there are almost certainly edge cases which I can't predict that will need ironing out. probably due to the administration of updating the list appropriately. but basic income seems very much like the proverbial silver bullet that never exists, so I am curious over its negative aspects. in discussing with friends and family, the worst thing about basic income is it means paying people for doing nothing and that _really_ _really_ angers some people. even worse, it means even millionaires get basic income!
- notahacker 11y agomost of the whole host of negative impacts depend heavily on the level that it's set and what other benefits are withdrawn, which there's very little agreement over. Low end BI with aggressive removal of other means tested subsidies generally leaves poor people looking for work much poorer; high end BI is leaves most taxpayers much poorer, whilst potentially seeing , much of the increase to people on low incomes swallowed up in increased rent. But more generally: - massive distortion of low-end wages, particularly for unpleasant, useful but not particularly revenue-generating jobs such as cleaning. Further outsourcing of manufacturing work for the same reason might be considered a negative aspect by some (especially people with moderate-to high skills related to that manufacturing) - massive skewing of wage payments away from younger people in many competitive areas of employment, because now that the taxpayer will cover living costs and assuming removal of minimum wages there's absolutely no reason to pay trainees, apprentices (or the likes of runners desperate to make it in television) any non-trivial sum until they've spend a long time "proving their worth". - regional cost-of-living differences and a guaranteed permanent income encourage former job-seekers to relocate to areas where their prospect of getting a job is minimal. This is further exacerbated if better-targeted housing benefit payments and social housing are removed from the equation. - depending on the level of BI entitlement children get they're either likely to become a lucrative income source or unaffordable in many areas, especially for single parents. - a surprising amount of BI revenue will be captured by low-end rents, and other costs that people with more cash to spend at the bottom of the pyramid can't avoid. A surprising amount of BI costs will be funded by the productive - non-citizens are inevitably going to be heavily penalised (otherwise the country becomes an migrant magnet) - many advocates use BI as an excuse to push for middle-class squeezing flattening of the tax system, withdrawal of education and health subsidies etc. - the cost of paying people who would really rather not work almost certainly vastly exceeds the cost of paying wages to people whose job it is to kick people who would really rather not work off benefit programmes. Throw in the fact that people who never had any intention of claiming benefits are now entitled to them. Like every other reform to the tax or benefit system there are a whole host of winners and losers (including people you probably don't want to be winners like "slum landlords" and the indolent, and people you probably don't want to be losers like the owners of the neighbourhood cleaning firm and hardworking immigrants). It's about as far from the proverbial silver bullet as imaginable: it's reforming existing incentives that have (for better or worse) been tested and debated for decades with a blunt instrument.
- derefr 11y agoAlso note that, unlike welfare/EI/disability programs today, a basic income isn't regressive toward those who want to work. You don't suddenly lose your basic income when you take that $2/hr job, so there's no disincentive to taking it.
- paulojreis 11y agoThe disincentive should be perceived by everyone, but it's not. If I accept a lower pay job, I'm doing my part on lowering the pay for that job in the collective bargaining between employer/employee. You might think it's not detrimental for you, but it's detrimental for everyone who competes for that job. And, as your argument is truthful, it will become a spiral: no disincentive in accepting the $2/hr job, then no disincentive in the $1.95/hr job, then ... for n iterations until there's no disincentive in doing it for free, for the experience or the kicks. And, of course, in the end the benefit will go the usual beneficiaries.
- aianus 11y ago> until there's no disincentive in doing it for free, for the experience or the kicks. You say this like it's a bad thing. Study after study show that people perform their best creative work when it's decoupled from extrinsic reward. If basic income covers all of your needs and allows you to do what you enjoy for the sheer pleasure of it, what's wrong with that?
- mcv 11y agoBasic Income should be quite a bit higher then; enough for a fairly comfortable life with no serious financial worries. But then, sure, I'd work for just the fun, the pleasure and the kicks. I probably wouldn't be freelancing for banks, though. Some jobs will always require pay in order to entice people into taking those jobs.
- paulojreis 11y ago> what's wrong with that? What's wrong is a potential increase in income inequality and worst wealth distribution. A corporation or somebody from a upper class will be getting richer from the work being done while the guy(s) doing the work with the basic income will stay at the same level. I don't think we should increase our inequality metrics even further.
- Hytosys 11y ago>Also, this is Finland a small, rich and homogenous country. There are an unknown amount of reasons that would determine the success of a program like basic income, so I'm wondering why the size and homogeneity of a country are always quickly brought up.
- foota 11y agoProbably because they're the most obvious of the factors that could impact such a program.
- lagadu 11y agoI'm sorry, why is that obvious, even in the slightest?
- Hytosys 11y agoOh, shit! How come I always miss the obvious things? What am I doing wrong?
- paulojreis 11y agoI don't know why you're being downvoted. You're questioning economical premises stated as obvious in a tech forum (so, where no special economical knowledge should be assumed). You're doing the right thing - why are they obvious? If he who stated them as obvious can't answer that with solid references, then it's not obvious; it's just an unfounded preconception.
- philh 11y ago> I don't know why you're being downvoted. Didn't downvote, but personally, I really dislike sarcasm used in this manner. It's not so much questioning as flat-out contradicting. And it does that in a way which doesn't help to bridge the inferential gap.
- michaelbuddy 11y agobecause if you bring in an influx of color and foreign diversity, you get people who have less in common, less shared values and don't look out for each other. Get a massive influx of brown muslims in your white country, then find out that you no longer cooperate with each other like you did before. It's basically the way in the U.S. that the two party system also uses race and immigration to drive another wedge between citizens. Believe me, you want homogenity. It's better for progress than diversity. Everyone tells the story that diversity somehow is strength. Nope, never has been, it's a story that just feels good but isn't true. The U.S. progresses in spite of diversity and conflict, not because of it.
- legulere 11y ago> homogenous country please stop with this homogenous country bullshit. Finland like any other western country has a significant amount of other ethnicities, more than 10% in the case of Finland. And it's not like people are the same if they are of the same ethnicity. And even if it were especially homogenous, how would that matter?
- vlehto 11y agoAre you a Finn? I am and would definitely call this homogenous coutry. But I know Finns who would never agree on that.
- mrweasel 11y ago>more than 10% in the case of Finland Half of those are Swedish.
- Kiro 11y agoNo, you cannot compare Finland to other western or even Scandinavian countries. It's very different.
- mcv 11y agoI'm pretty left-wing (I consider myself a libertarian socialist), but I agree with Friedman. Once you have a livable basic income, you don't really need a minimum wage and progressive taxation anymore. Those things exist primarily to guarantee livable conditions for the very poorest, but Basic Income would guarantee those livable conditions in a far more simple and effective way. Two important effects of this would be: a) the labour market would become a lot more open and free. At the moment, employers wield all the power because employees need a job. It's not a free market if you can't say no to a deal. With basic income, people can say no if the offer is too bad. But if your alternative is starvation, a terrible job for too little pay is still better than nothing. Minimum wage exists to limit the employers' power to exploit people who have no option to say no. b) It fixes the unemployment trap. For people with unemployment or disability benefits, getting a low-pay part-time job often means they end up with less money (or the same money and more costs) despite them taking the effort to work, because they lose the benefits. This discourages people from working. With Basic Income, you keep that income if you get a job, so you always get ahead by working, even if it's only a little. There's nothing fraudulent anymore about doing little jobs while unemployed. I'd probably prefer both the basic income and the tax to be a bit higher than Friedman would like them to be, but that's part of the standard political-economic give and take. As long as the Basic Income is at least enough for decent food and rent, I'm happy.
- notahacker 11y agoIf you don't have progressive taxation any more, you're either going to be unable to pay for the BI or seriously hurt the middle classes. If the rich pay lower [net] taxes, someone else pays more (assuming you're not on the right hand side of a Laffer curve)
- sago 11y agoI agree, I don't see the logic in removing progressive taxation. Progressive taxation is a recognition that there is a disproportionate benefit in living in an ordered and lawful society for those with high income (and assets, though we seem to have lost the plot on taxation of assets). You depend on the efforts of a lot of people, each of whom has benefitted from the state's education and infrastructure. Your products benefit from the state's legal support, your money from the state's stability, and so on. Progressive taxation is a recognition that those benefits don't scale linearly: those at the highest incomes benefit not only from the linear support of their wealth, but the exponential support of society.
- kwhitefoot 11y agoEveryone in this thread is writing as though this has never been tried before. It has been tried at least five times (three in USA and twice in Canada). The results have been re-analysed in recent years and show that the reduction in peoples willingness to work is very slight. Of course if Finland does it over the whole country then this will be a much larger experiment than the US and Canadian ones. I think that there are good reasons to believe that it will have a very positive effect. It also gives greater bargaining power to the lowest paid so that it should help to prevent the reduction in wages that is becoming a feature of the low end of the employment market.
- mpartel 11y agoCould you link to the analysis you mentioned?
- kwhitefoot 11y agoThis search string canadian basic income experiment statistical analysis repeated on Google got me a lot of hits including these that refer To Dr. Evelyn Forget's analysis in 2009: http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2014/12/23/mincome-in-dauphin-manitoba_n_6335682.html http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2014/12/23/mincome-in-dauphin-m... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MINCOME https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MINCOME
- yummyfajitas 11y agoThe reduction in work effort is 13% - double the effect of the great recession. http://public.econ.duke.edu/~erw/197/forget-cea%20(2).pdf http://public.econ.duke.edu/~erw/197/forget-cea%20(2).pdf It also gives greater bargaining power to the lowest paid so that it should help to prevent the reduction in wages that is becoming a feature of the low end of the employment market. If supply of labor is significantly reduced then prices for labor will rise. Didn't you just claim that won't happen?
- nekopa 11y agoYou keep throwing out this 13% as if it is a bad thing, with no comment on the context mentioned in your link. So I'll add it here for others to view if they don't want to wade through a pdf to find it: 1: The 13% decrease in work effort is per family unit. This is an important distinction, because it led to the following 3 points 2: The primary wage earner in the unit reduced their effort only slightly, but this had a large result due to them making the majority of the cash 3: The secondary wage earner, who was usually the spouse reduced their work effort to stay at home longer after having a baby, and to do more work around the house. 4: The tertiary wage earner, in most cases an adolescent male, had theIr work effort reduced by the fact that it entered the workforce later. This may have been due to them continuing their education. So I think - IMHO - the 13% reduction represent a net benefit for society - dad doesn't have to do so much overtime, mum can spend more time with her baby, and your kids stay in school longer and become qualified for better jobs...
- nordify 11y ago> It's not a comfy lifestyle by any means, but could get people off the streets who otherwise would not have the means. It's not like there is a large problem in Finland with people living on the streets. Rent is subsidized up to 80% if you are unemployed or without income. Unemployment benefits and/or social assistance cover the remaining 20%. If you become homeless, you will be provided with temporary housing. Any homeless problems are usually due to larger underlying personal issues. Some people, such as alcoholics and junkies, will not or cannot adhere to basic living rules and will rather choose to be, or forced to be, depending on how you look at it, homeless. Besides, for a bit of morbid humor, homelessness is a self limiting problem in Finland due to winter.
- pavlov 11y agoWithout income you can get rent support up to 80%, but there is also an absolute upper limit which is much lower than the rent in large towns like Helsinki. So you can't just rent a 1000 € apartment and expect to get 800 € from social security -- the reality is around half of that. Any homeless problems are usually due to larger underlying personal issues. Is that claim supported by any facts?
- nordify 11y agoFrom litterally the first Google result: "Long-term homelessness is a case of prolonged or repeated homelessness , which is often associated with poverty, in addition to severe psycho- social problems such as substance abuse and mental health problems , crime and violence . This group is estimated to comprise about 40-50 percent of all homeless people living alone." http://www.asuntoensin.fi/asunto_ensin/asunnottomuus http://www.asuntoensin.fi/asunto_ensin/asunnottomuus
- retube 11y agoBI is just a huge subsidy for employers. Competition in the labour market will absolutely crush salaries if everyone gets a basic income irrespective of whether employed or not. Now given that income taxes > (or even >>) corporation and dividend taxes even if those reduced wages translate directly into increased corporate profits the net tax take by government will fall, whilst their liability goes up from BI obligations. All BI will do is enrich the business elite and drive further inequality. A semi test case of BI is being inadvertently conducted in the UK with tax credits. Thanks to effectively subsidised wages by the state, wages have remained stagnant or fallen. As wages have fallen more people qualify for tax credits, further subsidizing wages in a negative feedback loop. Net result: the cost to the state has ballooned to 30bn/year from an originally projected 2bn/year with over 50% of working households now in receipt of them, coupled with ever increasing equality gap. Far from harmonising wealth and reducing inequality, basic income will have exactly the opposite effect.
- rwmj 11y ago> Thanks to effectively subsidised wages by the state, wages have remained stagnant or fallen. What's the evidence for this?
- ams6110 11y agoIt makes perfect sense. Each person has an income need, X. If they get B basic income, employer only needs to pay X - B whereas without basic income he needs to pay X.
- lhopki01 11y agoThat's a poor implementation of basic income. If each person has a need X then B should be set at X. That way if they work for someone everything on top isn't for need but want. Gives them the ability to choose more.
- saiya-jin 11y agoAgreed, look at it this way - most people don't earn minimum, but more. They will still work to keep their standards (paying rents, mortgages, cars, kids, lifestyle they are used to etc.). Employers are not dumb, they will reflect this immediately. A healthy society should always motivate people to WORK and produce products/services, that's what keeps society running. If main goal of BI is to remove that motivation, I fail to see it as a step in right direction.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- laotzu 11y ago>It may also be a bit early, as automation isn't in its stride yet. I'm curious as to how you would judge whether or not automation is efficient enough to do this? Buckminster Fuller, former president of the Mensa society, argued that we passed that invisible line back in the 1970's: >In technology's "invisible" world, inventors continually increase the quantity and quality of performed work per each volume or pound of material, erg of energy, and unit of worker and "overhead" time invested in each given increment of attained functional performance. This complex process we call progressive ephemeralization. In 1970, the sum total of increases in overall technological know-how and their comprehensive integration took humanity across the epochal but invisible threshold into a state of technically realizable and economically feasible universal success for all humanity -Buckminster Fuller, Grunch of Giants, 1982
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- saiya-jin 11y agoInteresting to read another YC article from top page - http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/nov/12/beattyville-kentucky-and-americas-poorest-towns http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/nov/12/beattyville-k... Some opinions there describe welfare as evil thing, removing any motivation for people to even try to get a better life. maybe not applicable for Finland, but interesting nevertheless as coming for 1st-world country (although they describe themselves as 3rd-world one). Let's not forget that for every hard-working individual there is X slackers looking how to get as much out of system with as little effort as possible, by any means necessary. I fail to see how BI would motivate those people to get better, and contribute to our society. Hopefully in this case, road to hell isn't paved with good intentions as usually...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- JulianMorrison 11y agoPeople doing regular work have to do physical labour, cognitive labour, emotional labour. People getting welfare or charity generally still have to, at minimum, do emotional labour, looking suitably pitiful before the handout and then suitably grateful after. And often physical and cognitive labour as well, filling in forms, schlepping to mandatory signing-on, etc. This is why welfare is demotivating. People reasonably feel they have already done the work, they as feel drained as if they were in a job. They know that if they don't do the things, the welfare vanishes. Whether it's a job or welfare, everyone in our current system is scrabbling. And so everyone is stuck in a scarcity mindset. Basic income is different. There is no scrabbling needed, not even emotional work, it just arrives. And so I expect that will flip people from a scarcity mindset to a leisure mindset. They won't be slacking, because slacking is a way of scrabbling. They'll want to do something, although without the need for a day job any more, that might be more towards the creative side. Some will "retire" on BI and write their novel or go back to university. Others will want to work to make more than the BI. Expect a period of labour shortage, manufacturing turning to robots in reaction, a surge of cultural product such as has never been seen, and mass education with a broadening of the scope of people's interest into "blue sky" non employable fields.
- theklub 11y agoIt would straight up fund criminals in the US. Kinda like welfare currently does. (mostly drug dealers)
- scott_karana 11y ago> Also, this is Finland a small, rich and homogenous country. Whether their model can be adapted [Japan] is to be seen. Isn't Japan also a homogenous, small, rich country? Seems like an excellent place to try this, to me. The only explanation I can think of is that you meant "small" as in their population, not geography.