12 ms·
Why Torture Doesn't Work: The Neuroscience of Interrogation
- JohnIdol 11y agoJack Bauer would beg to differ.
- 001sky 11y ago"O'Mara takes a moral stand against torture (forced retrieval of information from the memories of the unwilling)" The scope of this is so limited to be a self fulfilling prohpesy...
- TeMPOraL 11y agoIsn't torture supposed to first make you willing, and then have you reveal information without need of force? /s.
- NN88 11y agoI'm pretty sure torture works to some degree, but its unconscionable to legitimize without people taking any liberty to go forward.
- nickff 11y agoMy question to anyone who believes this article to be correct is whether they would have found the same sources and type of evidence credible if it had produced the contrary result. If the answer is no, it shows that you should not expect this article to convince any of your intellectual opponents. For the record, I am not sure whether torture works or is morally justified in the circumstances where it has been applied over the last 20 years, but I find this article entirely unconvincing.
- vacri 11y agoOne other thing to remember in discussions around torture is that the "ticking bomb" situation simply doesn't happen, as reported by professional interrogators. This means that "ticking bomb" is an outlier scenario and the base moral discussions should not start from there.
- pdkl95 11y agoIf by some astonishing bad luck some that type of scenario did happen (highly unlikely, but the probability is not zero), that's what "extenuating circumstances" is for. We already have provisions in law to allow for the very rare and unusual situations where someone is guilty of a criminal act for a good reason. Therefor the people using the mythical "ticking bomb" scenario are asking for something else.
- nickff 11y agoIt has actually happened in at least one case (, at least there was believed to be a 'ticking time bomb').[1] In addition, thought experiments are meant to shed light on the limits (if there are such limits) of certain moral principles, or problems with paradigms, much like reductio ad absurdum is a useful tool for reasoning.[2][3] This is not to say that the torture is justified in the case of a 'ticking time bomb', but it is both a possible situation, and a useful scenario to think about. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2003/04/10/world/kidnapping-has-germans-debating-police-torture.html http://www.nytimes.com/2003/04/10/world/kidnapping-has-germa... [2] http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/torture/#CasStuTerTicBom http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/torture/#CasStuTerTicBom [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reductio_ad_absurdum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reductio_ad_absurdum
- angelbob 11y agoIt is frequent that it's believed to happen. It's possible, but seems unlikely, that it has literally happened, torture has worked and then the US government has somehow not crowed about it. They are looking very hard for scenarios to justify their use of torture, and the results they have revealed (e.g. from waterboarding Al Qaeda members) aren't inspiring, so far. It appears, for instance, that waterboarding people many times (in a few cases, 100+ times) isn't enough to keep them from lying to you.
- rjtobin 11y agoAbout 4 years ago I went to a talk given by the author of the book, the subject was along the same lines as the book: how torture is ineffective because it damages the subject's ability to recall information. Afterwards someone asked a question that a lot of us had been thinking: that in a lot of situations where torture might be used, the information being asked for is very well known to the subject, so unless serious brain damage occurred, the subject wasn't going to forget after torture. Like, "who is your cell leader?" or "where are the guns hidden?". He seemed confused by the question, even after a few other audience members tried to rephrase it. Got the impression he was being intentionally obtuse. I guess it deflated the gist of his work, which more accurately should be something like "torture ineffective when the concealed information is hard to remember". I haven't read the book, but I hope in the meantime he has worked a little to address this question. Seemed like a well meaning guy though, and maybe my memory of the talk has been eroded by the torturous years of grad school in between
- angelbob 11y agoIt's not clear that torture makes it especially likely to prevent lying about information, though. It'd be nice if he studied that instead of making us assume it, though :-P
- dror 11y agoHere's the reason that it doesn't work. Imagine that your village has a 1000 people and someone is torturing you to find out "who is your cell leader." At first you are resisting, and so you name random people in the village. After you've named 50 people or more, you break and name the real person. The torturers though don't know that this is the real person, so they'll keep torturing you, and you'll just go through every name in the village to make the torture stop. How can they separate the real person from the ones you lied about either out of resistance or to make the pain go away? In some cases this could work. They want to find out where you hid the guns, and every time, they go and dig till you break and give them the right place, and then they do find the guns.
- rjtobin 11y agoWhat you've said sounds like a reasonable argument why torture doesn't work in that case. My point wasn't that torture does work (I have no idea about that), just that the research outlined by O'Mara doesn't address situations like this (and so the research isn't enough to prove that "torture is ineffective" as is suggested).
- larrysalibra 11y agoTorture isn't conducted to improve the ability of the victim to recall information but as a negotiating tactic. I'll give you what you want: to stop being tortured, if you tell me what I want to know.
- venomsnake 11y agoThere is a problem with that - even true facts could be deceiving. The only way to verify outside of checking is to continue torturing which defeats the reasons for the person surrendering the information in the first place.
- nickff 11y agoNot necessarily; you could torture someone for something like a key to an encrypted file. This is something difficult to guess, but easy to verify the correctness of. I am not saying that torture is justified in this scenario, but only that it is not true that "to verify outside of checking is to continue torturing which defeats the reasons for the person surrendering the information in the first place".
- venomsnake 11y agoTrueCrypt plausible deniability. Once I have surrendered the key for the outside container, what do you do?
- alendit 11y ago"Hand over the jew gold you jew, i know you have two bags, one real one fake, give me both."
- AlphaGeekZulu 11y agoThe introduction of plausible deniability in encryption is actually the ultimate nightmare from an ethic perspective: The torturer, of course, knows about plausible deniability. And of course, technically, plausible deniability is not limited to two levels (outer and inner volume), but can be performed on an arbitrary number of levels. From the torturer perspective, he has to continue to torture forever, because any passphrase revealed might not be the one for the "true" stash of information. In reality, the torturer does not stop at the first possible instance of revelation, but on the last (which will never be in this case). Plausible deniability actually prevents the torturer from rewarding the victim for the revelation of information by ending his/her pain. Instead, plausible deniability opens the spiral of endless violence.
- bayesianhorse 11y ago"People Are willing to forgo money to talk to others about themselves." A rationale for psychotherapy! (Not that there are no other benefits, of course)
- chroma 11y agoI think torture should be illegal and I think the "enhanced interrogation" techniques used at Guantanamo are abhorrent. But I also think there are real-world scenarios in which torture is not only moral, but where it would be immoral not to torture. This sounds absurd, but consider this real-life case given in The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy[1]: A woman's car is stolen. Unknown to the thief, her child is sleeping in the back seat. The thief discovers the baby and ditches the car. The police soon catch him at a train station. CCTV footage shows him stealing the car. It's over 100ºF out. A police officer describes the incident: > In the police truck on the way to the police station: “Where did you leave the Hyundai?” Denial instead of dissimulation: “It wasn't me.” It was—property stolen from the car was found in his pockets. In the detectives' office: “It's been twenty minutes since you took the car—little tin box like that car—It will heat up like an oven under this sun. Another twenty minutes and the child's dead or brain damaged. Where did you dump the car?” Again: “It wasn't me.” > Appeals to decency, to reason, to self-interest: “It's not too late; tell us where you left the car and you will only be charged with Take-and-Use. That's just a six month extension of your recognizance.” Threats: “If the child dies I will charge you with Manslaughter!” Sneering, defiant and belligerent; he made no secret of his contempt for the police. Part-way through his umpteenth, “It wasn't me”, a questioner clipped him across the ear as if he were a child, an insult calculated to bring the Islander to his feet to fight, there a body-punch elicited a roar of pain, but he fought back until he lapsed into semi-consciousness under a rain of blows. He quite enjoyed handing out a bit of biffo, but now, kneeling on hands and knees in his own urine, in pain he had never known, he finally realised the beating would go on until he told the police where he had abandoned the child and the car. > The police officers' statements in the prosecution brief made no mention of the beating; the location of the stolen vehicle and the infant inside it was portrayed as having been volunteered by the defendant. The defendant's counsel availed himself of this falsehood in his plea in mitigation. When found, the stolen child was dehydrated, too weak to cry; there were ice packs and dehydration in the casualty ward but no long-time prognosis on brain damage. As much as we may wish otherwise, the answers to moral questions aren't always simple. Every time I've related this story, it has convinced my interlocutor that torture can sometimes be moral. Again, that doesn't mean it should be legal or systematized. To make an analogy with less emotional weight: theft and trespassing are illegal, but they're sometimes right. One might trespass to get someone to a hospital more quickly. Or one might steal something so it can be used for some life-saving measure. People accept these rare, one-off situations. So too it should be with torture. 1. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/torture/#CasStuBea http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/torture/#CasStuBea
- klausvanvinkle 11y agoWhether torture is right/wrong good/bad boils down very simply. First, let's assume that torture works (i.e. it gives us the answers we want). If we assume it doesn't work then there's no point in torture or this debate. There will always be people who claim that torture works, so let's just assume it does indeed work excellently and 100% of the time. Second, assume that many innocent people are falsely accused and convicted, because that is true (if you don't believe that, just look at the Innocence Project). Third, if we know that innocent people are sometimes falsely accused and convicted, then it means it could happen to you, your parents, your children. So now the only question you have to answer is: Are you OK with the scenario where you, an innocent and falsely accused individual, are tortured, in the interest of public safety? If you are not OK with that happening to you or your children, then you cannot support torture for anyone else either. If you are OK with that, then you have two tasks: 1) when are you volunteering as a torture subject to prove you aren't just saying that, and 2) you must convince everyone else that they should be OK with that if it happens to them (or 51% of the population in a democracy). You might succeed on 1) (doubtful) but you will fail on 2) if all of those people also have to complete task 1). The conclusion is that it's impossible to torture without introducing a double-standard. Sure, we can do that, but that has the same logic as a law like "I can do anything I want, and you can do nothing, because I'm me and you're not me"?
- SilasX 11y agoI'm not okay with innocent family members being imprisoned. Therefore, no one should be imprisoned ever.
- klausvanvinkle 11y agoGood point, but it's a matter of extremes: Imprisonment can be undone.
- Leszek 11y agoAnd similarly, torture can be stopped. The time and experience of imprisonment cannot be returned.
- littletimmy 11y agoWhy is this a topic of conversation? Even if torture worked it would not be ethical and the people doing it would be immoral.
- sirrocco 11y agoIf your daughter and wife were kidnapped by 2 people and you catch one of them, would you torture him to save them? What if you learned that they are being raped every day? Would you torture him then ? What if you knew they do this every two weeks to another family, would you do it then? What if you caught someone that has a habit of planting bombs in schools, would you do it then ? I don't know if torture works or it doesn't, but it's certainly a topic worth having a conversation over.
- rdtsc 11y agoWhat if the aliens landed? What if lizards are controlling the earth? What if.... > If your daughter and wife were kidnapped by 2 people and you catch one of them Does this happen often to your wife and daughter? Did it happen to anyone you personally know? Or is it a movie plot you are remembering.
- vacri 11y agoHand them over to the police and let them deal with it - they're far better at interrogating people for information, and far better resourced for a rescue operation.
- sirrocco 11y agoI was giving a couple of examples in reply to the "Why is this a topic of conversation?" question. It's not meant to be taken literally as a plan to save someone. I'm just saying that it's worth having a conversation over. PS: what's up with the downvotes in this thread ?
- reddytowns 11y agoIt's often used as a way for a person to shut someone up when they don't have an argument. Seriously, karma should really be called groupthink points.
- rdtsc 11y agoEven if it is working, would that make it ok? What about rape? Should it be criminalized? Is that worth a scientific study from nature? Why is torture in a civilized society not considered like rape. Anyone who suggests, does it, debates about its merrits, should be considered a crazy idiot, ostracized and laughed at. But notice how we as a a society are debating its merits. We have already lost so speak. We lost first when our government engaged in it in large scale. But we lost again when we start excusing and explaining, even if we reach the conclusion "ok, it is not quite working as well".
- raverbashing 11y agoSaying that something is not debatable is exactly the opposite of living in a democracy Excluding hate speech, surely But since you were very fast to call anyone a "crazy idiot" I can see how worried about you are about a "civilised society" instead of your personal opinions
- vacri 11y agoAllowing fringe ideas to dominate discussions so centrally is also exactly the opposite of living in a democracy.
- raverbashing 11y agoI agree, but who determines what is a fringe idea? I don't agree with torture, quite the contrary, but the same discussion could have been constructed in the opposite way and the fringe idea could have been that torture doesn't work (which I'm sure happened in a lot of situations)
- rdtsc 11y ago> but the same discussion could have been constructed in the opposite way and the fringe idea could have been that torture doesn't work (which I'm sure happened in a lot of situations) Could be, but not in this case. This is about torture. I would say living in a civilized society, a society where torture is a despicable criminal act (that is why my original comparison with rape) is more important than living in a democracy. Doing stuff in the name of an ideology (democracy) is a also a problem. There were a lot atrocities and murders and other horrible things also committed in the names ideologies. That is, claiming things like "it's ok to engage in these things, because we live in a democracy and that is what we do in democracy". I would rather not live in a democracy but live in a country where torture is not a debatable topic to discuss for sane people.
- pakled_engineer 11y agoAdmitting anything under torture just invites more torture. The IRA "green book" and despatches from the French/Algerian war confirm how worthless torture is for gathering intelligence. Bribery should be tried instead of barbarism.
- kaonashi 11y agoDepends on what you mean by 'work'. It's great for eliciting false confessions, less so for actionable intelligence.
- LordKano 11y agoThe idea that you cede the moral high ground when you use torture seems to have been forgotten. I don't care if it works. I grew up believing that we were "The Good Guys" and under no circumstance is it ever acceptable for the good guys to torture people. What made the Viet Cong so bad? They tortured people. What made the Japanese so bad? They tortured people. What made the Germans so bad? They tortured people. We should never torture anyone.
- lrc 11y agoThis is the whole point of the movie the Great Escape. The allied prisoners know they won't be tortured since they're in a Luftwaffe camp and not a Gestapo one. After the escape, the ones who are recaptured are handed over to the Gestapo and are executed. Even in a 1963 film set in a Nazi POW camp, it was understood that there were rules. Sic transit.
- nickff 11y agoYou are very clearly begging the question here; not everyone agrees that use of torture 'cedes moral high ground', or that torture made the Germans, Japanese, or North Vietnamese 'bad'.[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beg_a_question https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beg_a_question
- jdc 11y agoIt's bad because it increases human suffering, and it's unfair to harm someone who can't fight back.
- TheLogothete 11y agoThat makes me feel all warm and fuzzy, but let's say a terrorist is captured and you have to put a stop to his operation. His cell will kill a hundred or so people in the next month. You don't torture him and the bomb goes off killing 243 people. A year and a half later you capture another and you have to put a stop to his operation. What do you do?
- harryf 11y agoThat torture doesn't work to extract information has been known anecdotally at least since the 2nd world war - read up on Hans Scharf - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanns_Scharff https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanns_Scharff But tortute does work when your goal is oppressing large populations; instilling fear and control. This is the discussion the US ought to be having... what wa the real policy behind torture?
- DennisP 11y agoNot long before 9/11, a friend of mine went through SERE training. He said the main purpose of the torture techniques they used wasn't to gain information, but to make the captive say whatever the captors wished. Then all this torture stuff came up and lo and behold, they used those same techniques from SERE (at least, what's publicly known about them), and the "information" they came up with said there were WMDs in Iraq. (Of course, this wasn't necessarily an unintentional falsehood. It could just be that high command said "get us information on WMDs in Iraq," and special forces soldiers who'd been through SERE used the techniques they knew.)
- notahacker 11y agoWhen and where was torture used to generate theories about WMD in Iraq? afaik it was based on the well established fact that Saddam Hussein had once possessed and used WMDs, cynicism about his stated destruction of them and circumstantial evidence that certain facilities might have still contained them.
- arca_vorago 11y agoI always remeber the line, " How did we know Saddam had wmd? Because we had the receipts!"
- DennisP 11y agoFrom a quick google, it appears I misremembered somewhat. Torture evidence was used to build the case for war with Iraq, but it was about Iraq's relationship with Al Qaida, not the existence of WMDs. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ibn_al-Shaykh_al-Libi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ibn_al-Shaykh_al-Libi http://www.cnn.com/2009/POLITICS/05/14/iraq.torture/index.html?eref=rss_us http://www.cnn.com/2009/POLITICS/05/14/iraq.torture/index.ht...
- yeukhon 11y agoThe basis of torture is on fear and pain. This works on those who are weak and easy to break. But like other commenters said it is hard to tell lying and truth. Sometimes, the person who finally speaks the truth doesn't even know if the information he/she has is even true.
- saiya-jin 11y agoMy far biggest experience with physical pain was getting big tattoo on the back, 4x4 hour sessions. (got some bones broken, but that's not the same level of pain, and body releases some calming stuff to bloodstream, so really not comparable). Every of those 4 hours, the experience of lying on my stomach, and having a pizza-cutter running through my back here & there. The most sensitive parts are around the spine (understandable) and on the sides of back (not really sure why). The goal is not to twitch or move much, so some sort of mental self-control is necessary. First +-2 hours were cca OK, but after that, even lower amount of pain, presented with high spikes and almost constantly ate away my willpower. After each session, I felt like a small baby, able to navigate back home and perform simple mental tasks, but severely worn off, and mentally weak. I understand this is just a glimpse from a distance to real torture, uncontrolled, when you know you can die from it, or end up disabled in most horrible weays for human being. But it works, to some degree, on some levels. If you want to break somebody, it is one of the ways. The question is, how usable will the individual be after breaking, and your goal (get info, instill fear, or just destroy human being).
- mizchief2 11y agoTorture works just fine if you need readily verifiable information such as the combination to a safe, pin number, etc. Not so much for general information like "give me the names of your comrades"
- kbutler 11y agoMan who says it cannot be done should not interrupt man doing it. (As opposed to man who says it should not be done.) The "should" question boils down to, "How much harm can we morally inflict on some individual(s) in order to benefit others?" Torture is the extreme end of the "harm" spectrum, but when we vote in favor of government benefits or taxes, we vote to harm some in order to benefit others. Individuals and societies differ in how much harm is allowable and in how much benefit justifies a given amount or type of harm.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Torture is the extreme end of the "harm" spectrum, but when we vote in favor of government benefits or taxes Or exclusive monopolies in the form of "property rights", for that matter. A big part of the some moral theories of benefits and taxation is that they should be aligned, so far as possible, to, taken into consideration with property rights, be a mitigator of the harms due to property rights, while reducing the benefits of those who benefit the most from those rights (without making a net harm for any, and leaving the whole system as net gain for everyone, because its not zero sum.)
- saganus 11y agoI think that sometimes there's another factor that gets overseen when discussing torture. The "problem" that I believe is also tried to be addressed with torture is the view that the society that "supports torture" (via their government, even if against the opinion of most people) can't let leniency get in the way of righteous retribution against their enemies. Imagine if someone invents a pill that is literally the "truth serum", and that the subject taking it can't lie for say an hour or so. Would that end torture? If torture's only objective is to get information then it should. But what if torture is really filling another role? one that is not satisfiable by information but by inflicting pain on your enemy? I'm not defending torture by any means, and I do think it should be something that we as humanity should strive to end. But it seems like more often than not you can find people that would not defend torture, "except in cases of extreme need", i.e. when they need retribution. It would be interesting to do some research on what victims of crime and violence, and their families, think about what it would be "fair" to do to their offenders. Maybe it turns out most won't be willing to inflict pain in others, or maybe it turns out most people are vengeful and would like to see their enemies suffer. If the case is the latter, then I think the main problem with torture would be not as a tool to obtain information, but as a tool to inflict retribution. What if a society that is mainly governed by people of the second kind get a hold of the ability to torture? e.g. CIA interrogators, people that sign torture orders, etc? then in their minds it would be justifiable, even if the activity doesn't yield any useful information. If it does, then they get the information AND retribution. If they don't get truthful information then they still get retribution. That's why I think torture is a subject so hard for officials to understand the damage it can cause. As long as they think retribution in this form is OK, then it will be very hard to end this practice.