9 ms·
A lot of what we think we know about WWII is wrong
- orionblastar 11y agoWhat I was taught in public school is that the Germans used slave labor and POWs to work in factories to make their weapons, tanks, planes, rockets, etc and this led to a quality control issue while the USA and Britain had well paid and well fed people who made better quality weapons, tanks, aircraft, etc. The Russians had an advantage because of their AK-47 rifle and a lot of fighting was done at the Russian front as Hitler tried to take over Russia. People forgot that Russia did a lot of fighting as well as had better weapons and stuff as well. The USA has military superiority because we have better technology and better trained people. For example our fighter jets are better designed and our pilots are better trained than their Russian counterparts. Most of the USA's enemies buy fighters and stuff form Russia, but they end up being no match for the USA stuff.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- usaphp 11y agoAk-47 was designed in 1949, I think you are missing something, war was over by that time
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoAfter the war, yes, but design began in 1945 and was completed in 1947, thus the "-47."
- usaphp 11y agoBut it was adopted by Soviet army in 1949 officially, at least that's what Wikipedia says
- dollaaron 11y agoIn AK-47, the 47 comes from the year the design was finished, design work didn't even begin until 1945, so the AK-47 certainly didn't help them win WW2.
- hentrep 11y agoAs others have mentioned, this all occurred before the AK-47 was put into production. I believe the Mosin-Nagant 91/30 was standard issue for Soviets in WW2.
- jamuelsaxon 11y ago>What I was taught in public school Why down vote someone essentially confirming what the main article claims? Are you down voters just too embarrassed by what is being taught in US public schools? I for one am not surprised considering we still hear of fights by school boards to include bologna like "intelligent design" in school books right next to the theory of evolution. Edit: Yes, do respond by down voting this post too. We wouldn't want to shatter your fragile but entirely false views of the world now, would we? "US is the best. US education is the pinnacle of the world! USA! USA! Woop woop!" ... Did I do it right? I can haz imaginary internet points nao? :P
- saryant 11y agoGP is factually incorrect. Defending that is not a recipe for success.
- saint_fiasco 11y agoYou mean he was not in fact taught that in school?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dang 11y ago> But hey, good job trying to twist my intent! I love a good intellectually dishonest conversation! Please don't do this here. It's neither civil nor substantive.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- adventured 11y agoThe US is in fact the pinnacle of education, in several regards. For example it has by far the best university system. No other country comes even remotely close. On any list of the top 50 universities on earth, the US will routinely take the top 40 or 45 slots. If you make a list of the top 20 universities, it's going to be dominated by 19 from the US, with Oxford thrown in for good measure. The US won the math olympiad this year, and is pretty much always near the top. You might want to check out where certain highly praised European countries tend to come in every year by comparison. The US has one of the highest GDP per capita levels, at $56,000 (#5 for 2015, behind only a few tiny nations), to go with one of the highest median incomes - you don't accomplish that without some amazing education output. The US leads in nobel prizes globally. The US leads in general innovation, R&D, and sheer scientific output. Its universities are productive in that regard in ways nobody else comes close to. Its economy is also one of the most productive. The US leads in space, space tech, aerospace, medtech, biotech, pharma, software, Web, Internet, mobile, agriculture, entertainment, defense tech, is one of the leaders in computing hardware, and is also one of the leaders in pretty much every type of energy technology. It's also the world's #2 manufacturer. So yeah, the US does a lot of things really really well. You don't accomplish all of that, and manage to produce such a massive economic engine for over a century, with extremely high output levels per capita, without at least a decent education system to go with it - which is why so few countries can match up to the US economically or scientifically.
- wdewind 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PPSh-41 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PPSh-41 not AK-47
- nether 11y agoAre you drunk?
- dang 11y agoWe ban accounts that post like this here, so please don't do it again. Comments need to be civil and substantive, and personal attacks are not allowed. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jonesb6 11y agoI just watched "Back to 1942" which shows a glimpse of WWII from the Chinese perspective. They had to cope with a famine AND a war, and lost ~20 million people during the struggle. To put it into perspective Russia lost around ~28 million [1]. In my opinion it was an excellent film that left me again pondering how much I've really lost in my education by only getting the "Western" version of history. Word of warning, the movie has no happy ending. It's also in Chinese with English subtitles. Available on Netflix. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties
- yeukhon 11y agoBeing a Chinese growing up in America, what you said is true and often I feel the Western civilization didn't appreciate the war in Asia until the Japanese had attacked Pearl Harbor, and even then I feel people see America as the sole savior in the pop culture. America's first battle in Africa was a huge casualty (echoes the stuff in the movie Fury). Of course no one is born out to succeed, but the truth is thousands died on the path to victory. Korean and Chinese had been fighting the Japanese long before Germany declaring war in Europe, way before 1937. For more than a decade, the Chinese had been fighting alone (well with very unpleasant support from the Western civilization like getting weapons at a very expensive rate and siding with the Japanese). Everyone else was still supplying industrial material to Japan, aiding and helping killing millions in Southern-Asia, because the rest of the world wanted to stay neutral. If the Chinese didn't hold back the Japanese, the entire Southern Asia would have fall in the hand of Japan in a few months (what the Japanese generals had promised their emperor). The British and the French armies did not stand a chance in their colonines against the Japanese. Soon May-in, First Lady of Republic China came to the U.S. and begged the U.S. Congress to help China [1]. I quote: "When Japan thrust total war on China in 1937 military experts of every nation did not give China even a ghost of a chance. But when Japan failed to bring China cringing to her knees as she vaunted, the world took solace in this phenomenon by declaring that they had overestimated Japan’s military might." It wasn't until late in the war did the Chinese receive air support (and many kind volunteers from the U.S. Army such as the Flying Tigers group) to help stabilize the war against Japan in China. But millions, were poured into the battlefield, untrained, uneducated, with little armor, fought against a modernized elite army from Japan. Oh not to mention the shitty Commander Stilwell who caused a huge causality of the allies in the Southern-Pacific/Burma...don't get me started there. The British hated him. The Chinese hated him (he seized control of an elite Chinese army division and lost 60% of them - that division stayed and fought the Japanese so hard the Japanese had to surrender). We had lost so many lives in WWII, including tens of thousands of American (some were recruited from U.S. territories that still don't have voting right in the Congress!). We can definitely improve history class by not just always focusing on American's effort. Even the local rebels in Europe helped the Allies to finish missions. Intelligence that the Chinese had provided to the Allies regarding the Japanese had helped Allies in attacking Japanese later in the war. [1]: http://china.usc.edu/soong-mei-ling-%E2%80%9Caddresses-house-respresentatives-and-senate%E2%80%9D-february-18-1943 http://china.usc.edu/soong-mei-ling-%E2%80%9Caddresses-house... -- edit -- For those who can comprehend Mandarin, you can watch https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=30QQtJoJ9Zg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=30QQtJoJ9Zg (and other episodes).
- ikeboy 11y agoThose first few paragraphs give off so many crank vibes.
- nemo 11y agoYeah, this sentence, "Almost every narrative history of the war ever published almost entirely concentrates on the strategic and tactical levels, but gives scant regard to the operational," either suggests the author hasn't read much or is a really poor reader.
- munin 11y agothe history that I got about WWII was that Germany built wunder-weapons that individually were of far superior quality to anything else, but couldn't be built at any kind of scale. their tanks were initially technologically superior, but not much else about their mechanized infantry stuff was. the bismark was probably better than any individual ship in the british navy (when they finally found the wreck they determined that british main gun shells literally bounced off of the armor), but it wasn't better than all of them and the germans could only build one.
- vacri 11y agoThe Germans built just fine at scale - remember that it took the resources of Russia, the British Empire, and half of the US industrial juggernaut to take them down.
- munin 11y ago> America built 74,000 Sherman hulls and engines; Germany built just 1,347 Tigers.
- nemo 11y agoThe Tigers were heavy tanks plagued by manufacturing problems. The Sherman was a medium tank more comparable to the Panzer line - the Germans built around 45,000 of those. The American M6 was comparable to the Tigers, of which few were built and 0 saw battle.
- Pinckney 11y agoPanzer is just the German generic term for tank (or more literally, "armor".) Everything from the tiny, machine-gun armed Panzer I, to the Panzer VI Tiger. The standard, 75mm Sherman was roughly equal to the long-barreled Panzer IV (~6000 built).
- vacri 11y agoSherman: 33-ton tank, Tiger: 60-ton tank; Sherman: mainstay of US armor, Tiger: heavy tank. You're comparing apples and oranges. The Sherman's counterpart was the Panzer - which the Germans still only built roughly 15k of - but then again, the Germans also made heavy use of tank destroyers and assault guns - the Stug III by themselves were another 10k worth of hulls. But, again, just because someone has more capacity than you doesn't mean you're not building at scale.
- Asbostos 11y agoAll histories of wars that are still in living memory or close are going to be grossly distorted because people want to hear stories that pander to their own emotions. As a prime example, historians are often legally (and certainly professionally) forbidden from freely studying some aspects of WWII in case the come to conclusions that are still politically sensitive. I'm talking here about the Nazi concentration camps. This is a research no-go-zone where only the officially sanctioned results are allowed to be published and people can go to prison in many European countries for making false or unpopular claims about 80 year old history. Then there's the opposite problem in Japan where the official and popular history paints them as the good guys and hides from their killing 10's of millions of Chinese. Americans fall for this too and feel bad about the nuclear bombing of Japan, despite the enormous good it did to the whole of south-east Asia.
- pekk 11y agoHolocaust denialism does not constitute "research."
- baddox 11y agoDenying any claim, however small, about the Holocaust is not "Holocaust denial" in the sense you're using the term.
- pekk 11y agoNeither is it true that "any claim, however small, about the Holocaust" is "a research no-go-zone where only the officially sanctioned results are allowed to be published and people can go to prison in many European countries for making false or unpopular claims"
- SCAQTony 11y agoIf you look specifically at the Spandeau machine gun mentioned in the article, Is the US using the same damn process with the F-35 Strike Fighter? A plane that is over designed, clunky and extravagantly expensive? From War is Boring: No, the F-35 Can’t Fight at Long Range, Either — Stealth fighter can’t see, shoot or survive. https://medium.com/war-is-boring/no-the-f-35-can-t-fight-at-long-range-either-5508913252dd#.igh2f33ob https://medium.com/war-is-boring/no-the-f-35-can-t-fight-at-...
- UnoriginalGuy 11y agoI don't find the comparison particularly compelling. The MG 42's issues were more logistical. It was designed for an idealised situation (e.g. shooting range). Not as the article describes it "total war" where you have to carry everything you need to the battlefield. That meant issues like weight, complexity (for field repair), and replacements became a real headache. Arguably the real issue could have been bad feedback/communications between lower ranks and engineers/designers (and something we still see today with field equipment failing e.g. see the M16's long history, and how long it took for some of the changes). The F-35 is more "too many chefs in the kitchen." The F-35 likely is over-engineered, but not because of too little feedback like the MG 42, but too much. Every major US military arm tacked on their own little requirements here and there, until the aircraft was so loaded down with toys and gadgets that it could barely fly. For example, the entire airframe is designed around a lift fan that the vast majority will never be fitted with.
- hga 11y agoThe MG 42's issues were more logistical. It was designed for an idealised situation (e.g. shooting range). Not as the article describes it "total war" where you have to carry everything you need to the battlefield. That meant issues like weight, complexity (for field repair), and replacements became a real headache. But the whole idea of the General Purpose Machine Gun (GPMG), which I'll note everybody adapted after WWII, was to make a lightweight "heavy" machine gun. No water cooled barrel, no requirement for a heavy tripod, in the light machine gun use case it was fired from a bipod, and could be put into use quickly. Those extra, quick change barrels were a feature, not a bug, such a German infantry unit was organized around the GPMG, one guy would carry it, others would carry spare barrels and ammo, their job was in part to keep the machine gun running and protected from the enemy. Issues like the high rate of fire were a tactical choice the Germans made, shared by no others to my memory (I believe the theory is that you would seldom have a good target for long, so you had to make the best of it while it existed). E.g. I see in the Wikipedia page that the post-WWII Austrian version has a much heavier bolt to reduce the rate of fire: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MG_42 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MG_42 And the Germans are still using it in the adapted for 7.62 NATO MG 3 variant. Accuracy is also a tradeoff, there are many modes of machine gun fire like plunging where you want a degree of dispersion. That said, yeah, feedback from the front is slow, can take a whole war to result in real changes. These things don't get put to the real test until real war; e.g. aside from the earliest M16s, none of these issues are a patch on the string of problems that initially crippled our Mark 14 torpedo used in WWII: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_14_torpedo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_14_torpedo
- klipt 11y ago> In truth, there were never enough U-boats to more than dent the flow of shipping to Britain. In fact, out of 18,772 sailings in 1940, they sank just 127 ships, that is, 0.7 percent, and 1.4 percent in the entire war. I thought this was partly thanks to Turing et al's breaking of Enigma. The allies had a window into tons of "secret" Nazi communication.
- dboreham 11y agoAnd airborne Radar.
- mturmon 11y agoThis seems like a junk article. World War 2, especially the European theater, is one of the best studied historical times in existence. Especially since the Russian archives have come to light. It is really not believable to claim that we have gotten the story that wrong -- with such weak evidence. I don't believe carping about the merits of specific machine guns is substantive, and I think what he said about tanks was incomplete and misleading, although I don't want to spend the time to demonstrate it. The article really went off the rails in dismissing the significance of the Battle of the Atlantic. TFA claims that U boats only sunk 127 ships during 1940, but Wiki claims that 270 ships were sunk during June-October alone. And it is well known that Churchill himself said that winning the battle of the Atlantic was critical to Great Britain's survival. In a later phase in early 1942, after America had entered the war but before it understood the threat, German subs sunk 609 ships at a loss of only 22 u-boats. (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Happy_Time https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Happy_Time) A recent examples of a book that has changed emphases and perceptions about WWII is Timothy Snyder's Bloodlands, on the unique savagery of the Eastern European conflict.
- eru 11y agoI found David Edgerton's "Britain's War Machine) (http://www.amazon.com/Britains-War-Machine-David-Edgerton/dp/0141026103/ref=mt_paperback?_encoding=UTF8&me= http://www.amazon.com/Britains-War-Machine-David-Edgerton/dp...) quit interesting. He highlights that the Germans---far from the technical wizards they are often portrayed as these days---won in the beginning despite inferior material. The British and their allies always had material and technological superiority. (Lots of their gadgets just didn't work very well at the beginning.)
- alejohausner 11y agoThis is pretty much the premise of "Brute Force" by John Ellis (1). It argues that Britain, Russia and especially America won the war by sheer industrial capacity, which vastly exceeded Germany's output. Their logistical advantage was reflected in their tactics. If I remember correctly, in the battle of El Alamein, Montgomery had vastly more equipment than Rommel, and won the battle through massive artillery bombardments and by numerical superiority in tanks. In the invasion of Normandy huge numbers of shells were fired, using carpet bombing which overpowered the Germans in the Falaise gap. Germany's "war of movement", with its aggressive advances, which had been so successful at the start of the war, sputtered to a halt before sheer quantity of materiel against both Russians and Americans. The book also argues that the Allied "brute force" mentality worked against them at times. Patton used a dynamic war of movement against the Germans several times, but was often held back by the plodding methodical approach of his superiors. 1.http://www.amazon.com/Brute-Force-Allied-Strategy-Tactics/dp/0670807737 http://www.amazon.com/Brute-Force-Allied-Strategy-Tactics/dp...
- eru 11y agoBritain's War Machine by David Edgerton argues similarly. (http://www.amazon.com/Britains-War-Machine-David-Edgerton/dp/0141026103/ref=mt_paperback?_encoding=UTF8&me= http://www.amazon.com/Britains-War-Machine-David-Edgerton/dp...)
- pluma 11y agoI think it's an easy misunderstanding: Germany was ruined after WW1. Europe wasn't surprised because Germany was superior. Europe was surprised because Germany was so much more powerful than expected.
- peteretep 11y agoEverything you need to understand about Germany's defeat in two numbers, which can be surprising ones for Brits and Americans: German troops killed, missing or POW on the Eastern front: 2.1m German troops killed, missing or POW everywhere else: 1.2m The Russians beat the Germans in any meaningful sense of the word.
- _delirium 11y agoThis used to be a widespread perception in Western Europe, too, but changed during the cold war. When people in France were asked in May 1945 which country had contributed most to the defeat of the Germans, the answers were: 57% USSR, 20% USA, 12% UK. But asked again in 1994, the numbers had shifted to: 49% USA, 25% USSR, 16% UK. According to: http://www.les-crises.fr/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/sondage-nation-contribue-defaite-nazis.jpg http://www.les-crises.fr/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/sondage-...
- icelancer 11y agoThis is weird, because it is mostly accepted in American History classes - at least from my school and a few other public school kids I asked when I saw this. Everyone I asked at LEAST thought the USSR contributed as much as the USA in terms of winning the war.
- enraged_camel 11y agoMy experience has been the exact opposite. Americans by and large see themselves as the "saviors of Europe" when it comes to World War II. That's where a lot of the deeply rooted hostility towards Europe (especially France) comes from: they shouldn't be giving the USA shit about anything, they should be grateful we saved them from Hitler, etc. etc.
- adventured 11y agoSerious question then: what would Europe look like today if the US had stayed home and not engaged at all in WW2 in Europe or the aftermath? How many more countries would have fallen to the USSR in Europe? Without US supplies, would the UK or the USSR have been able to keep fighting? Would WW2 have dragged out for years longer than it did? And so on. The US spent a huge amount of money to stand off with the USSR in Europe after WW2 (which was in its self-interest). In fact it's still dealing with Russia in Europe to this day, trying to keep them from reclaiming more former Soviet territory, and carrying the majority of the burden in NATO. Most Americans I talk to view their country's contribution in WW2 as the push that tipped the scales in the allies favor once and for all (rather than being the savior of Europe). Or allow me to paraphrase Churchill - he believed the war was won, when the US was convinced to fully join the war effort. Further, what other countries in Europe are we going to claim had a large contribution to defeating Germany? The list is really, really, really short. The UK, Russia and the US carried the radical majority of the effort. It's that simple.
- bootload 11y agoWar is a racket, some lesser acknowledged operation information of WW2: a) IG Faben and Standard Oil and the supply of TEL (Tetraethyl Lead) to Nazi Germany. [0],[1] b) Production of Ford (and GM) engines by German subsidiaries for motorised transport was directly used against the Allies. "Mel Weiss, an American attorney for Iwanowa, argues that American Ford received "indirect" profits from forced labor at its Cologne plant because of the overall increase in the value of German operations during the war. He notes that Ford was eager to demand compensation from the U.S. government after the war for "losses" due to bomb damage to its German plants and therefore should also be responsible for any benefits derived from forced labor. Similar arguments apply to General Motors, which was paid $32 million by the U.S. government for damages sustained to its German plants." This came out from a law suit (class action) by Elsa Iwanowa in 1999 (IWANOWA v. FORD MOTOR CO) for being rendered from Belgium to work in Nazi Germany for a Ford subsidiary in Cologne. [3] It could be argued, more effective control of TEL to the Nazi war machine would have resulted in a halt or severe reduction in Nazi air power. And Ford did sue the US Government post-war for $32M USD for bombing their factories in Germany during WW2. [4] Reference: [0] http://web.mit.edu/thistle/www/v13/3/oil.html http://web.mit.edu/thistle/www/v13/3/oil.html [1] http://soilandhealth.org/wp-content/uploads/0303critic/030311borkin/030311marriage.htm http://soilandhealth.org/wp-content/uploads/0303critic/03031... [2],[4] http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/daily/nov98/nazicars30.htm http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/daily/nov98/na... [3] http://www.leagle.com/decision/199949167FSupp2d424_1453/IWANOWA%20v.%20FORD%20MOTOR%20CO http://www.leagle.com/decision/199949167FSupp2d424_1453/IWAN....
- peteretep 11y agoThere's a very interesting article arguing the simplicity of Russian armaments: http://militera.lib.ru/research/suvorov12/06.html http://militera.lib.ru/research/suvorov12/06.html
- avn2109 11y agoSuvorov is worth reading at length - you can learn a lot about Soviet/Russian strategy, tactics, and military culture from him.
- Synaesthesia 11y agoI think the most important fallacy about WW2 is that nobody entered the war for a noble cause. It was all self-serving. It's often held up as a just war. Now of course I agree Hitler had to be defeated once 1939 came around, but it was also preventable, like most wars. The extent of appeasement was really an eye-opener to me. I'm 1937 the US state department still said Hitler was a "moderate" and should be supported! The background to the Pacific war by Noam Chomsky also tells of an economic war among empires which led directly to the Pacific war. http://www.chomsky.info/articles/196709--.htm http://www.chomsky.info/articles/196709--.htm The indescribable savagery of the war, particularly near the end is hard to imagine. Lastly one of the biggest fallacies concerns Hitler's invasion of the USSR, and speculation as to whether he could have won. The truth is the Germans were incredibly fortunate to do as well as they did! In fact the USSR was a world leader in tank production and tank strategy, before the 1937 purges they had the best and most innovative tank commanders and the most advance tanks. They should have crushed the Germans from the beginning!
- whyIndeed 11y agoI think I get what you mean, but your wording is just slightly off. The Fallacy: That anybody was a noble actor. Your wording makes it sound like there's a wrong-headed perception that war is not noble, and that the correction to the fallacy is to find ALL participants VERY noble, valiant and in high regard. Then, your next sentences: It was all self-serving. It's often held up as a just war. These clarify what you meant to say, and contradict the preceeding statements. The words "fallacy" and "nobody" inadvertently constitute a double negative.
- frozenport 11y agoNonsense, why did France, UK enter the war? How about Poland?
- Synaesthesia 11y agoWell France tried to avoid confrontation and the U.K. was trying to hold on to its empire and contain the German threat, but also had many business interstate in Germany. The allies thought they could diplomatically outmaneuver Hitler. France and the U.K. then caved to Hitler's demands repeatedly and essentially sold Czechoslovakia and Poland down the river to Hitler at Munich 1938, and during the "phoney war". France was then surprised by the swiftness of the German attack but capitulated very quickly. Her armies were still mostly intact when France fell. It must also be remembered that the extent of collaboration in France under occupation was very great and the French resistance was always very small.
- Animats 11y agoThese are old, well-known issues. WWII machine gun designs reflected WWI trench warfare experience - fixed gun positions, fire in the general direction of the enemy. WWII didn't go that way, mostly because everybody had tanks, and could now operate against machine guns. The most effective tank of the war was the USSR's T-34. More T-34s were produced than any other tank, including Shermans. The T-34 had a good gun, a decent Diesel engine, and an adequate transmission. The Sherman was a lighter tank, and early Shermans had a rather weak gun and some strange powerplants. (One version had five V-8 car engines arranged in a circle around one crankshaft. Chrysler had a good plant for making V-8 car engines, but the specialized machinery could not make a bigger engine.) The Sherman's big strength was simply that it was a good driving machine, and tens of thousands of them were driven from the French coast all the way to Berlin. Patton's "War as I knew it" talks about this, in the chapter "Touring France with an army". Many of the heavier German tanks would wear out on a long road trip; within Germany, tanks were often moved by rail. Basic truth: the tank that makes it to the battlefield beats the tank that doesn't. (The overly complex Tiger tank transmission thing is real, but confusing. Tanks steer with the transmission. The Tiger tank had a steering wheel, which controlled the relative speed of the two tracks. The Sherman had two foot clutches which disengaged the left or right track, and turning was more of a lurch than a smooth turn. The Sherman could not turn in place. There was a Tiger variant with an electric drive, like a Diesel-electric locomotive, but that was harder to keep working than the hydraulic/gear system. Modern tanks steer like the Tiger, but now the technology works.) The article author's info about the U-boat was is totally bogus. There was a big worry that Germany would be able to starve out the UK. Liberty ships, convoys, "jeep" carriers, periscope-spotting radar, and Ultra intercepts reduced the effectiveness of U-boats. The US Merchant Marine puts the number of ships lost to U-boats between 2,742 and 2,919.[1] The figures for 1940 are from 470 to 520, compared to the author's 127. [1] http://www.usmm.org/battleatlantic.html http://www.usmm.org/battleatlantic.html
- boring_pedant 11y agoYes, it is. Captain America is a fictional character, the US didn't 'win' the war, and yes, all 'winners' engaged in war crimes that were just as heinous and cruel as the losers.
- Synaesthesia 11y agoI agree with you, except that the USA very much did win the war. The problem with winning wars is that the victor gets the learns that military power violence is a solution to problems.
- AC__ 11y agoAfter being downvoted for a completely innocuous comment on this thread it is apparent that people only want to hear 'textbook' history, so I won't bother adding anything other than to say politics runs roughshod over history all day long. If humans survive another 70 years, I wonder how the history of the War OF Terror's 'coalition of the willing' will be written(whitewashed is probably a more suitable term), tyrants and criminals or liberators?