11 ms·
This company is looking less and less like they're struggling to develop new technology, more and more like a deliberate sham. Given that so much of their supp
by notacoward 11y ago
This company is looking less and less like they're struggling to develop new technology, more and more like a deliberate sham. Given that so much of their support thus far has been due solely to the Cult of Disruption, I can't help but wonder if news like this might make at least a few investors consider a return to good old-fashioned due diligence before placing their bets.
- minimaxir 11y agoWhat's interesting is that venture capitalists are slamming media outlets for reporting on the issue. Here's a rather silly rebuttal to a recent Theranos piece on The Information from Dave Morin: https://twitter.com/williamalden/status/658705178523258880 https://twitter.com/williamalden/status/658705178523258880 "Isn't it time as Millenials that we try to use the Internet to unearth deeper facts and see through these traditional smear campaigns?"
- OopsCriticality 11y agoMorin's rebuttal is all the more laughable in the light that Theranos may be deficient in their quality systems: https://www.theverge.com/2015/10/27/9621026/fda-theranos-lab-quality-inspection-elizabeth-holmes https://www.theverge.com/2015/10/27/9621026/fda-theranos-lab... These aren't trivial problems that can be fixed "at the time of, or within a week of, the inspection", as Theranos claims.
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoIt's also laughable that he thinks the volume of blood drawn for a standard test is what makes him pass out. Nope, that's a purely psychological reaction. If we're talking about donating blood, I'd believe it could be a physical effect, but that's equal to 50 vials in a blood test...
- volaski 11y agoIt's a conflict of interest only if there actually is a conflict of interest. Tell me, what "conflict of interest" does Dave Morin have with Theranos?
- minimaxir 11y agoNot a conflict of interest in the legal sense, but more of a conflict of interest in the ethical sense since venture capitalists have a lot to lose if the allegations have any truth. I edited the parent post for clarity.
- 7Figures2Commas 11y agoIt doesn't look like there's a conflict of interest (Morin, as far as I can tell, is not a Theranos investor), but I think you're overlooking the fact that a lot of prominent tech investors are sitting on investments in companies that have been significantly overvalued, and the cracks in some of these companies are starting to become apparent. There's a decent discussion on this here[1]. Red flags, like reports of late-stage investors marking down the value of some of their unicorn investments, are starting to mount and I think that has to be worrisome for investors who are sitting on large unrealized gains that could easily evaporate. Expect to see a lot more hand-waving on the part of investors as prominent unicorns come apart at the seams. Morin, according to his AngelList profile, is an investor in a number of unicorns, including AirBnB, Dropbox, Evernote and Slack. Two of the mutual funds that invested in Dropbox have reportedly marked down their investments[2] and some media reports suggest Evernote is in trouble[3]. [1] https://pando.com/2015/10/27/techpocalypse-coming/ https://pando.com/2015/10/27/techpocalypse-coming/ [2] https://www.theinformation.com/mutual-funds-mark-down-dropbox-holdings https://www.theinformation.com/mutual-funds-mark-down-dropbo... [3] http://www.businessinsider.com/evernote-is-in-deep-trouble-2015-10 http://www.businessinsider.com/evernote-is-in-deep-trouble-2...
- Crito 11y agoSearch for Theranos (and related terms) in HN history with the search bar at the bottom of the page. A lot of high profile posters making very embarrassing defences of Theranos. Lots of thinly veiled accusations of ageism, sexism, ludditism, etc. I fear few will learn any lasting lessons from this saga.
- kevinskii 11y agoThere were also others who were making pointed and substantive critiques of Theranos on HN many months before any of these stories broke. Edit: Some examples: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8182026 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8182026
- Crito 11y agoThis is true. There were in fact people voicing their suspicion that Theranos was all a crock of shit in the very first discussions on Theranos on HN. Warning signs were there. People were voicing specific technical concerns, as well as less specific concerns over the technical expertise of those involved. For the most part, these critics were brushed off. HN's voting system did not promote their comments; rather it promoted the apologetics.
- notacoward 11y agoRandom thought: maybe "gratuitous positivity" is as damaging as "gratuitous negativity" and should be treated the same way. Only seems fair, doesn't it?
- dredmorbius 11y agoThere's an alternative philosophy to consider, stoicism: http://aeon.co/magazine/philosophy/why-stoicism-is-one-of-the-best-mind-hacks-ever/ http://aeon.co/magazine/philosophy/why-stoicism-is-one-of-th...
- jonesb6 11y agoI knew there was a word that described my attitude towards tech journalism.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- notsony 11y agoPerhaps Dave can shine a light on a path forward for Elizabeth, by introducing her to his friends in Indonesia.
- downandout 11y agoMy take on it is that Elizabeth Holmes set out to make this idea a reality, but has been unable to do so. Sadly, all signs point to her trying to buy time via smoke and mirrors. If she has misled investors in the same way she has misled the media, given that she has raised $400 million, she's looking at decades in federal prison. I see this whole thing ending in tragedy, whether that just means the loss of $400 million that could have gone to other startups, a full-scale criminal prosecution, or some other dramatic end. Whatever happens, a happy ending no longer seems to be in the cards.
- tptacek 11y agoProsecution seems fabulously unlikely, given how infrequently founders have gotten in trouble with the law for misleading their investors. Holmes won't be close to the most lurid bad-faith founder claim (if that's how the story indeed ends). This is why we have investor "accreditation".
- downandout 11y agoYou'd be amazed at the seemingly minor misrepresentations that a federal prosecutor can turn into a fraud case. That said, whether or not it gets that far depends entirely on the how the investors feel about it, exactly what they were told, whether they choose to report it as a crime to the FBI, etc.
- sixQuarks 11y agoI wouldn't be too sure about that. Investor fraud isn't the only thing we're talking about here. There are questions about the accuracy of the blood tests themselves.
- jonnathanson 11y agoIndeed. I wouldn't be surprised if prosecutors take a particularly unkind view of the possibility that Holmes has potentially put lives at stake. That said, her board is a veritable who's who of DC powerbrokers. That will definitely be a factor.
- seansmccullough 11y ago$400 million down the drain. Great job VCs. "She's a Stanford dropout with an idea!!!" Is not due diligence.
- trhway 11y agoas history shows one have to be either a Harvard dropout or a Stanford graduate. Not understanding the difference here is like not understanding a difference between finger-prick and venous blood samples :)
- reality_TV 11y agoSeeing this story slightly riles me up. My favorite uncle has a brother who is rich behind wildest dreams. He invested in this supposed unicorn. What did or does she do to get rich people to pull out their wallets and possibly dump their money down the drain? I, on the other hand have so much opportunity knocking at my door (demoing my tech to Google, Samsung, about to go onto an inventor reality tv show and tons more), yet am unable to connect with the same rich people including my uncle's brother. As they say it only takes one wealthy person to invest in you and others will follow. Not sure what other signals that need to happen to show him and or others that based on my history I should be given a similar shot. Been at this for 8 years and these amazing opportunities continue to knock and knock. All opportunities are a huge honor, yet extremely frustrating when you don't have the resources to take advantage of it all!
- CamperBob2 11y agoYou're being modded down for whining, no doubt, but I can see where you're coming from. Every dollar that goes to Theranos (or Enron, or any number of other slickly-packaged plays) is a dollar that doesn't go to someone else's company. Gotta be frustrating to watch that happen over and over when you're personally sure you're a better bet.
- reality_TV 11y agoim not surprised of being downvoted ... i sound like a whiner no doubt. Whining that if your born rich and affluent or have strong ties to such then getting your startup funded is a ton easier. Pardon my whining about how getting funding works for a good majority of start-uppers. Like how many Ivy Leaguers has YC funded? Is it a majority or minority amount?
- olefoo 11y agoExcuse the bafflement. But wouldn't your uncles brother be your father? Unless you meant to use brother-in-law instead of brother in your post? Also it sounds like you have some good tech, but need a partner who is able and experienced in dealing with investors.