5 ms·
Of course it was, as were things like the explosions afterward. However, management always gets in the way--either up front, because there is profit pressure,
by bsder 11y ago
Of course it was, as were things like the explosions afterward.
However, management always gets in the way--either up front, because there is profit pressure, or on the backend, because there is profit and/or political pressure. This paper covers the up front failures.
However, backend failures, like spraying water on the core (NOT one of the established procedures because calm engineers knew that the reactor could dissociate the hydrogen and oxygen) rather than letting the core melt into the bottom of the containment area which was designed to deactivate and contain the core, were also rampant.
This was just like Three Mile Island. If people had sat on their hands, done nothing, and let the engineered last-chance safety systems do their job, things would have turned out better.
Reactors should not be for-profit. Rickover showed us all how to do it right, but we lack the stomach.
Here is his quote about real reactors: "On the other hand, a practical reactor plant can be distinguished by the following characteristics: (1) It is being built now. (2) It is behind schedule. (3) It is requiring an immense amount of development on apparently trivial items. Corrosion, in particular, is a problem. (4) It is very expensive. (5) It takes a long time to build because of the engineering development problems. (6) It is large. (7) It is heavy. (8) It is complicated."
- jakeogh 11y ago"sat on their hands, done nothing" That's how it should be, but in this case not doing anything was not an option. The passive (gravity fed) cooling system on the first reactor to melt had it's valve's almost closed when they lost power. Seems like a bad design to even have valves on it but I'm not a Nuclear Engineer. And people at Daini were able to prevent meltdowns by hand-laying miles of high current cable. Reasonable documentary: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0H9wDRHZHP0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0H9wDRHZHP0
- ori_b 11y ago> The passive (gravity fed) cooling system on the first reactor to melt had it's valve's almost closed when they lost power. Seems like a bad design to even have valves on it but I'm not a Nuclear Engineer. It wasn't a great design. But that's what happens when you take reactors that were built before Chernobyl, were optimized for producing material suitable for nuclear bombs instead of safety, and then run them long past their designed lifespan. More or less, these reactors should have been retired long ago, and replaced with more modern designs.
- spronkey 11y agoBut they weren't because money. So people die.
- guscost 11y agoThis is repeating points from other replies, but it has to be said again that much of the passive-safe design in a BWR/PWR has to do with the fact that it will melt down (rather than go prompt-critical and explode) even when every cooling system fails, since the coolant itself is what allows the reaction to continue.
- DonHopkins 11y ago>"sat on their hands, done nothing" Sounds like Bush's response to Katrina. "Brownie, you're doing a heck of a job." Was Cheney the big dog they hired to bark at Bush in case he attempted to touch any of the buttons?
- jfoutz 11y agoThat almost sounds like a human interaction problem. Maybe a codebook with keys, that gives you access to a room with a big lever, that doesn't really do much other than kick in the emergency last chance safety systems a little early is the right way to go. edit And they should really hollywood it up. all the lights in the building dim, the siren from alien blaring, maybe a fog machine in the room with the lever.
- monochromatic 11y ago> Reactors should not be for-profit. Maybe. The motivations are different for a government project, but I'm not convinced that they're better.
- nickff 11y agoYes, this point is the basis for 'public choice' theory.[1] The levees in New Orleans were government built and maintained; should we not take the failures there into account before we rush to judge the private sector for Fukushima?[2] The other problem with blaming private actors for problems at Fukushima is that (as far as I can tell) they followed all the standards and regulations as required by the regulators responsible for public safety, which seems to indicate that if anyone was at fault, it was the government regulators. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_choice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_choice [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005_levee_failures_in_Greater_New_Orleans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005_levee_failures_in_Greater...
- RockyMcNuts 11y ago> if anyone was at fault, it was the government regulators. that seems to imply that the power plant's owners responsibility was not to ensure safe operation, but merely to follow the government regulations. to my ear, the tone of the argument is that there is a 'rush to judge' private actors who cannot be judged or blamed. surely, it's possible that oversight was inadequate on the part of both management and regulators?
- nitrogen 11y agoThere are other organizational types beside government and for-profit, and even those two aren't mutually exclusive.
- dredmorbius 11y agoThe point that it's organisational and management issues which so frequently seem to be behind major disasters -- four of the larger nuclear accidents (Fukushima, the earlier Japanese criticality incident at Tokaimura, Chernobyl, Three Mile Island), as well as numerous other large-scale industrial accidents, of which energy systems play a large role: the BP Gulf Oil spill, Exxon Valdez, Banqiao Dam (China, 1975), recent South Carolina flooding and dam bursts, the Union Carbide Bhopal, India, disaster. You cannot engineer out human nature. This isn't a root cause for which there are technical solutions. I hugely recommend Charles Perrow's Normal Accidents and The Next Catastrophe. As well as other writings. Note that Rickover also wished we'd never gone to the nuclear option. He defended his choice for lack of options, but would have preferred to see all plants mothballed. "Paper Reactors", which you quote in part, is excellent.
- eropple 11y agoI have to second Perrow's Normal Accidents. I read it first in college and I've kept my copy sitting on my desk ever since as a reminder. (I joke-not-joke that, if I ever run a startup, every employee gets a copy on their first day.)
- Retric 11y agoYou cannot engineer out human nature. You can do a lot to minimize the effects of human nature or even utilize it. You just need to build systems for humans not some abstract ideal. Case in point, the giant Menu inside a fast food restaurant has a lot of counter intuitive properties designed to alter people’s behavior. It's not pretty, but it works. Note, we are talking about the masses of humanity not just those you select or train etc. Now, doing the same for complex systems is hard. But, clearly there are ways to improve.
- dredmorbius 11y agoYou can engineer to influence human nature. But often the task is, as you highlight, to take existing tendencies and influence them. Fast food, and consumer marketplaces generally, are highly engineered to prompt desired behaviors. Those generally aren't, though, very high reliability error-correcting behaviors. Some other examples that come to mind: 1. Public spaces designed to be "riot proof". Generally this works by avoiding single large assembly points, putting entrances and exits such that there's no through transit of a space or building, and otherwise dispersing the energy of crowds. 2. Las Vegas. The manipulation is so grossly apparent to me that the entire place disgusts me. Windowless interiors, no clocks, bright lights and flashing displays, loud music. And, most iconically: moving walkways to take you into casinos, but having to depart under your own power. 3. Much of air safety practices. While it's not possible to design out pilot (or other human) error, you can become highly aware of what leads to accidents. The commercial air travel industry is a fascinating study in risk reduction, starting with the goal of incident studies, which is to ascertain cause, not assign blame. Perrow goes into this in depth in his books.
- Someone1234 11y ago> However, backend failures, like spraying water on the core (NOT one of the established procedures because calm engineers knew that the reactor could dissociate the hydrogen and oxygen) I cannot find any other information on this claim and I just read the main Wikipedia article, this article, and the Wikipedia timeline. Didn't the hydrogen explosions start before they started spraying the reactor/building with fire trucks anyway (March 12th Vs March 17th respectively)? According to the timeline it did. So while hydrogen explosions definitely occurred due to an overheating core, it is specifically laying blame at the use of emergency water to try and cool the core that I am asking about. It does not seem accurate.
- bsder 11y agoIt seems I stand corrected. It looks like the hydrogen was a result of the dissociation of the zircalloy.
- guscost 11y agoAccording to a chart in this press release[0], fresh water was being pumped through Unit 1 for ~10 hours prior to the first explosion, during which time none of the "active fuel" was submerged. I'm not a professional but it seems like a lot of that water would have evaporated and could have been oxidizing the cladding the whole time, if it was hot enough. I wouldn't discount the rest of your theory too quickly. [0]http://www.tepco.co.jp/en/press/corp-com/release/betu11_e/images/110515e10.pdf http://www.tepco.co.jp/en/press/corp-com/release/betu11_e/im...
- paulmd 11y agoNot that Zircalloy won't dissociate, but you're correct, don't discount the water either. At one point during the Windscale fire they tried to pump down liquid CO2, but the reactor face was so hot it was ripping the O2 off the molecule. They next tried to pump down water - there was a very real risk that it would rip the water apart as well, feeding the fire and potentially forming a hydrogen bubble and exploding. However they were able to deliver it in greater quantity than the CO2, and succeeded in cooling the fire.
- api 11y ago(9) solar+wind+storage is orders of magnitude simpler, can be incrementally financed, and is nearly on parity in many markets. The middle point -- ability to be incrementally financed -- cannot be overstated.
- pdkl95 11y agoWhere, exactly, are we storing power in the TWh-scale? The terrible availability[1] of wind and solar is going to require a heroic amount of storage, which isn't going to be "simple". It will probably have serious environmental impact as well. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor#Real_world_capacity_factors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor#Real_world_cap...
- scriptman 11y agoWasn't the organisation that built Chernobyl a state owned company and in many ways equivalent to a not for profit? Government owned or not for profit doesn't necessarily mean better. In many cases it's worse.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoIf we flip the question around - what is it about the profit motive that makes it better? If workers can design and construct a better nuclear power plant why couldn't they do that - within the same budget constraints, etc. - unless there's some third party getting paid just for being rich. Is greed really the most important thing to add to a human endeavour to make it successful?
- scriptman 11y agoConsidering that markets when combined with stable institutions, property rights and the rule of law, have done more to reduce poverty, increase lifespans and health than any else in history, I think the onus of proof is on the other side. If you consider migration a type of voting mechanism, then countries that feature markets tend to attract more votes. I'm not sure what it is about the profit motive that makes it better, but empirically it seems to result in more successful outcomes for everyone in the countries where it is available when compared with countries where it isn't available. If workers can construct a better nuclear power plant without anyone making a profit - they are welcome to try. If they did a good job, I would congratulate them. But when it comes to alternate economic systems, there seems to be a lot of talk and little action on the ground where the work gets done. Talk doesn't feed people or keep the lights on. I think you are misjudging those people that have made large profits as being purely greedy. From what I've seen, they are driven, hardworking and focused on achieving their vision. For most, profits are just the means to the end they imagine. Do you really imagine the world would be better off if Elon Musk's profits were confiscated and given to some government bureaucrat? Would a workers collective take a risk on inventing new technologies? History suggests not. The funny thing is that most of the benefits from the hard work of entrepreneurs flows to everyone else, not the entrepreneurs themselves, through more plentiful food, health and technology.