8 ms·
The poor are an easy target for governments and private entities, simply because they are easy to abuse and there are so many of them. Unlike the wealthy they
by rdtsc 11y ago
The poor are an easy target for governments and private entities, simply because they are easy to abuse and there are so many of them.
Unlike the wealthy they simply do not have the time, money, resources, ability to unify and fight back as a single block (save some outraged protests and rioting resulting from attack or mistreatment by police, but those one can argue do more harm than good). If they don't have an extra $20/month, chances are they will not have time to sit and write a letter to a senator, or to call a lawyer or organize campaigns.
As the article put it, adding these fees and doing this is really an administrative step, it's just too easy not to do it. If they, say, tried to raise taxes on top tax bracket, that would turn into a long uphill battle probably. There would be local town meetings, letter to legislative representatives, calls to country club networks of friends and so on.
So as a result there are lots of payday loans places, high fees for courts, jail time (unless fee is paid on the spot), for the poor. Even once they go to prison they are turned effectively into slaves, they can't even call home because they nickle and dime there as well.
- everyone 11y agoYou're right, is it a logical outcome. Its inevitable if you let market forces dictate everything. There is a such a strong anti-government 'libertarian' streak to US domestic policy, that is essentially anarchism though. Which quickly defaults to oligarchy / despotism. One of the primary purposes of nations and governments is (or ought to be anyway) to protect the poor and powerless from the excesses of the rich and powerful, to level the playing field somewhat and ensure some modicum of fairness. Those in the US should look to extremely well run countries like Denmark with more socialist governments and strong legislation protecting its citizens. That is how a country ought to be.
- brianlweiner 11y agoIt takes a bit of rhetorical agility to blame "Government officials fining the poor and imprisoning them when they fail to pay" on libertarians.
- yequalsx 11y agoIt does but I think there is some connection to the line of thinking employed by libertarians and those who champion free market principles. At the base of such philosophies, in the United States, is the notion of every man for himself. I've noticed over the years such people ridicule things like "It takes a Village" and other notions of community involvement. We've gotten to a point where a Vice Presidential candidate laughed at the notion of paying taxes as patriotic whilst her son was in the military receiving his training, equipment, and pay from taxes. Taxes are labeled theft by many on the far right. The political climate is such that raising taxes is automatically considered bad and hence municipalities resort to non-taxation means of raising money. When that happens the poor get targeted as they are an easy target. It's expensive being poor in the U.S.
- everyone 11y agoWell a lot of it because the prison system in the US is often privatised and run for profit, as is the parole company in the article. Everyone (including the local government) is incentivised to fleece the poor and there is nothing to protect them. Things that would solve this (based on other countries that dont suffer from these issues) 1. Tax corporations and rich people more. Then the local government wont be reduced to fleecing the poor, also it would make the government stronger relative to large corporations and reduce their clout and lobbying power. 2. Dont let private corporations run prisons for profit. (I dont think I need to explain why) 3. Provide stronger legislation protecting the poor and services such as legal advice to make preying upon them less lucrative.
- matwood 11y ago> 1. Tax corporations and rich people more. Then the local government wont be reduced to fleecing the poor, also it would make the government stronger relative to large corporations and reduce their clout and lobbying power. Government is a lot like any other entity. It will grow as big as it can. Even if you tax corporations and rich people more, the math for government promises still doesn't work out, government will still fleece the poor.
- 11y ago
- happyscrappy 11y agoIf only the US were tiny, homogenous and filled with obedient Europeans.
- everyone 11y agoobedient? The people in the US are the ones being ground under the thumb of big business. People in Denmark are not obedient they are just not being horribly oppressed. And yes, the US is comparable to the EU, being composed of many different states with varying policies. But overall, the US is far more anarchistic (or libertarian if you like) than the EU in its domestic policy.
- happyscrappy 11y agoEuropeans seem to need to believe that Americans are horribly oppressed, but of course that is laughable in the same way as thinking they will be carjacked if they come to the US. Watching too many American movies maybe. Americans pay little attention to Europe while Europeans obsess over America, which sets an odd dynamic because Europe is larger and richer yet somehow ineffectual in comparison.
- everyone 11y agoPersonally, I am just interested in the world. I'm curious, what do you think the US does that is so effectual? I would say that a nation that cares for its citizens and acts responsibly towards its environment is being effectual.
- happyscrappy 11y agoEurope being larger and richer should be the center of the West.
- billiam 11y agoThis exceptionalist view about America is as common as it is laughable. We're not the only way to live, even (or especially) as a wealthy nation. The US is growing more corrupt, and the decline of civic society is being actively driven by a cynical agenda of ultra-wealthy people and the corporations which they control. The result: depending in which state you live, the US is becoming more like Brazil or Mexico (fast) or like Denmark (slowly, but it is happening).
- jnbiche 11y agoI know of very few libertarians who support private prisons. The private prison movement is definitely part of the crony capitalism/fascism trend here that most libertarians hate with a passion. Don't believe me? Check out this discussion on /r/Libertarian, featuring comments from many /r/Libertarian habitues: https://www.reddit.com/r/Libertarian/comments/rn2re/what_do_libertarians_believe_about_private_prisons/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Libertarian/comments/rn2re/what_do_... As a rule of thumb, if a "capitalist" business depends on the largesse of and/or connections/bribes to the government, it's not really engaging in capitalism, at least not the capitalism that the libertarians I know promote. I think many people who disdain libertarianism view it as a more extreme version of free market conservatism. But the two are in fact very different.
- rdtsc 11y ago> As a rule of thumb, if a "capitalist" business depends on the largesse of and/or connections/bribes to the government, it's not really engaging in capitalism, at least not the capitalism that the libertarians I know promote. That is why I don't think Libertarianism is viable. It is just as a nice fantasy ideology, much like Communism is. It looks good on paper, if you remove lots complications -- such as how the real world works. They keep talking how they believe Libertarianism would be great if just government stayed away. Communism is just like that, it is perfect, if everyone just worked consciously, without cutting corners and so on. In the real world, the shortest and quickest way to make a profit and rise to the top is regulatory capture and lobbying. For a mere couple of million it is possibly to buy state and federal legislators. It is just stupidly profitable to promise executive position to those in regulatory agencies after they quit. How many revolving doors there are between FCC and Verizon, or FDA and drug companies and so on...
- ManFromUranus 11y ago>>One of the primary purposes of nations and governments is (or ought to be anyway) to protect the poor and powerless from the excesses of the rich and powerful That is not the primary purpose of government at all, nor should it be I would argue. Government primary purpose is to be the enforcer of laws and rules ( as well as the entity responsible for the maintenance of the existing code of law).
- zbyte64 11y agoShouldn't the laws and rules allow for fair opportunities for all? If the laws overwhelmingly favour the rich and the government is primarily concerned with maintaining those laws then you have a tyrannical, unjust government. I suggest the following amendment to your statement: Government primary purpose is to be the enforcer of laws and rules in the pursuit of fairness. You need to look no further then America's bail system to see that our justice system favours the rich.
- tsotha 11y ago>There is a such a strong anti-government 'libertarian' streak to US domestic policy, that is essentially anarchism though. This is patent nonsense. "Anti-government" libertarian types (who aren't actually anti-government, by the way) have no interest in throwing masses of people in jail. Only 10% of the prison population is housed in a private prison - if the libertarians were in charge they'd all go broke. No, the problem is the big government people who want to incarcerate everyone who spits on the sidewalk - the very antithesis of a libertarian.
- TearsInTheRain 11y agoThat's interesting. I wonder if it is within the realm of an organization like the ACLU to take on some of these problems for the poor
- rayiner 11y agoThe ACLU has been fighting similar problems in Georgia. They have won settlements for some of those affected, and have been a significant factor in getting reforms passed in the Georgia legislature addressing these issues.
- shas3 11y agoI'd add the amorphously defined 'weak' to the things that make people targets. News media, for example, has long been exploiting the basic human weakness of having an appetite for sensational news even if it contradicts facts. The absence, in people, of various types of self-control drives profit in entire industries: collection agencies, banks and credit, dietary plans, fitness centers (people not cancelling memberships), pretty much every marginally useful subscription-driven product or service, alcoholic beverages, pubs, etc. One of the downsides of capitalism is that it is often considered perfectly acceptable to capitalize on these basic human defects. What makes the whole thing worse is that, many people don't have a choice over self-control. Research, in behavioral economics, for example, has established that some flaws are so basic to human behavior that they are hard to overcome. Obviously, the democratic state, being a highly regulated not-for-profit (for the large part) entity answerable to the people, has no business exploiting people's weaknesses!
- squidfood 11y agoTell that to the state lotteries...
- facetube 11y agoThe lottery should be illegal, full stop. It's a tax trap that launders already-taxed money from the poor in to high-marginal-rate taxable income for the government, using a method of fraud (read: gambling) that's illegal for most individuals to engage in or set up on their own.
- kuschku 11y agoOr the profits of it should be legally required to be only spent on helping the poor.
- sbov 11y agoIt's not that simple though. If e.g. the state spends $10 million on the poor with the lottery illegal, then the lottery is made legal and $5 million from it is earmarked for the poor, what's to stop the state from lowering the previous $10 million to $5 million, which would mean the poor are getting no more money than before the lottery was made legal?
- guelo 11y ago> but those one can argue do more harm than good Off the top of my head, we've had a record number of police misconduct prosecutions this year. The FCC weighed in against gouging prisoners for phone calls. This fight against debtor's prison issue is gaining traction. #BlackLivesMatter and the riots that kicked it off have been extremely succesful so far.
- Kalium 11y agoI don't know about you, but the riots have very much turned me off to activism lately. There were riots single-digit blocks away from my Oakland apartment where people smashed up businesses that were innocent of any wrongdoing. Anything those people want and advocate now makes me think "Fuck you, more $$$ for da popo". I don't care what they want, what they think, or what their grievances are.
- HarryHirsch 11y agoAnd that's your piece of first-hand experience why rampant inequality afflicts even the wealthy.
- mindslight 11y agoIt's not so much inequality as injustice. Belief in the system is what keeps the violent mob at bay. When that's destroyed, it's clear they're going to run into trouble sooner or later. So they might as well get something for it. The injustice of the broken court system is more widespread than the hashtags would lead you to believe. You just get more benefit of the doubt if you look like the judge/persecutor, and it's easier to avoid serious harm if you have better-paid representation.
- Kalium 11y agoSomehow, I think this is not the response they were hoping for. Right now my main question is not if I can placate rioters by giving them what they want.
- 11y ago
- utefan001 11y agoThis is so sad. This has got to stop. (repost from below) bsimpson 2 hours ago Here's the John Oliver version of the same story: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0UjpmT5noto https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0UjpmT5noto