5 ms·
There are several shockingly inappropriate things in this article. In particular, the PR person at Amazon is saying that they would have shared employee's pers
by dekhn 11y ago
There are several shockingly inappropriate things in this article. In particular, the PR person at Amazon is saying that they would have shared employee's personal records (including evaluations) as well as other employee's termination conditions (which I consider unrelated to their quotes).
Amazon: what Carney just posted was very inappropriate. I am completely amazed you did this (assuming it was done with approval at the company level). You should be aware that you will start having serious problems hiring and retaining quality employees if you post things like this about your employees.
- hahainternet 11y ago> In particular, the PR person at Amazon is saying that they would have shared employee's personal records (including evaluations) as well as other employee's termination conditions (which I consider unrelated to their quotes). I assume from the article this meant including the consent of the employee in question, given that they were part of the article. It does seem a little odd though.
- baldfat 11y agoDevil's Advocate here: The people named in the article and refuted by Amazon put their personal story a public story. If someone "slanders" a business it can't reply with evidence? Must the company say it is a personal matter that we can't disclose, which reads they are guilty and don't want the truth to come out? End of Devil's Advocate Seems like they were making a statement of if you talk will will fully disclose our information to refute what you said. I think this was hurting Amazon so much that they are willing to payout the "out of court settlement" and "set the record straight."
- roymurdock 11y agoThe details provided in the response are probably being disclosed legally (doubt Amazon PR would screw up that badly), but it shows really poor taste that they would even respond to the NYT piece which was pretty clearly hyperbolic, emotional, and somewhat cherrypicked; even more so that they would adopt the same tactics of naming and shaming ex-employees. The fact that it was also published on medium by the head of PR baffles me - why are they aiming this refutation at the tech crowd that would probably see through this cover-piece pretty easily, instead of getting it into a high-readership, Amazon consumer oriented publication? Poorly planned and executed all around, regardless of legality.
- eclipxe 11y agoThe tech crowd (at least on HN) didn't see through the cover-piece...the comments here were overwhelmingly along the lines of "I knew it! Horrible environment". A lot of confirmation of existing anti-Amazon bias.
- roymurdock 11y agoI'm assuming they published it on medium as a blog post targeting the tech community because they were trying to persuade potential future employees that Amazon is a good place to work. Yet Carney smeared the NYT and ex employees rather than highlighting the positives (I'm sure there are many, but I don't know what they are because he didn't mention them) of working at Amazon. Better yet, Amazon could have just carried on being a good place to work. If your company is doing good, important things its going to take a lot more than a biased NYT piece to really deflate employee sentiment and drive down the quality of your applicants. "Show not tell" is usually a good principle to operate on.
- serge2k 11y agoEven before the times article amazon had a rep as a place that ground through people in a year or two.
- retbull 11y agoThat was my impression and after talking to several friends over there it hasn't exactly gone away. Even people who still work there 5-6 years later give it at best mixed reviews. I don't know how to interpret the mudslinging but I don't think that Amazon is all fun and games.
- caskance 11y agoShow not tell doesn't work. Otherwise there would be no such thing as marketing.
- CaptainZapp 11y ago
- fweespeech 11y ago> If someone "slanders" a business it can't reply with evidence? Must the company say it is a personal matter that we can't disclose, which reads they are guilty and don't want the truth to come out? I'd say the real problem is, honestly, they didn't reply with evidence. If they claimed someone engaged in fraud, and believed they had a case, they'd take them to court and set an example. If they have a software feedback tool with largely positive feedback, they'd show data showing it was an anomaly. Etc. They aren't showing evidence so much as providing anecdotes of their own and if that is the strongest defense they have by a top-level journalist wrangler... Well, honestly, it makes it pretty clear Amazon's position is: A) We can't prove this is bullshit. We know it but we hope you don't. B) If you fuck with us, we'll fuck you right back. That isn't likely to be an effective strategy but they chose it nevertheless.
- chrissnell 11y agoThe same thing happened with an ex-Reddit employee here on HN a few months back. The CEO (?) who responded came off looking far more evil than the guy that was fired. Best to take the high road in situations like these and show to the world how you really are a great company to work for.
- philh 11y agoIf I'm thinking about the same event, I disagree. The CEO didn't come across as evil at all, in my eyes. And I'm not comfortable with a meme that if you're attacked, you shouldn't defend yourself, because defending yourself will make you look bad. That just makes you easier to attack.
- debaserab2 11y agoI believe you're referring to this: https://np.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/2iea97/i_am_a_former_reddit_employee_ama/cl1ygat?context=3 https://np.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/2iea97/i_am_a_former_r... I dunno, I think if you go out and try to call out your former employer on a public forum (that they own), they have the right to lay out their side of the story at least. It would have been more evil for them to remove the comment entirely - which is exactly what many companies would have in this situation.
- jsprogrammer 11y ago>If someone "slanders" a business it can't reply with evidence? What evidence did the business present here? All that has been made are claims. I have not seen any internal investigation or performance report. >Seems like they were making a statement of if you talk [we?] will fully disclose our information to refute what you said. They don't seem to be making that statement. The information Amazon has was not fully disclosed, but selectively sampled and leaked. If Amazon was serious about full disclosure, they would release all the records they are using as evidence.
- pm24601 11y agoWhat evidence? Amazon, like most employer, can fire at-will. And Amazon has the money and lawyers to fight long and hard ( unlike most ex-employees ). This is a pure ad hominem attack that has nothing to do with the question at hand: how good or bad is amazon as a place to work? What would the response be if Jay had casually outted someone as transgender or gay? "Back when Mr. O. was a woman before the sex change operation, ...." or "When Mr. O. came out as gay, ..." Neither statement has anything to do with the issue of how Amazon is as a work place. But Jay's decision to reveal unsubstantiated accusations in a public forum designed to sabotage an ex-employee's future earning potential says a lot.
- pbreit 11y agoAlso inexcusable that Carney's bio is not the first sentence in the post. Would it not work for Amazon to come out with more of a "Look, it's a difficult business and our folks work incredibly hard. Sometimes it might get a little out of hand. We want to make sure all of our employees are healthy and treated with respect while fulfilling Amazon's mission of delighting customers around the world. We are constantly looking at our practices and the work environment at Amazon and will continue making improvements as we see fit. We don't think the environment portrayed by the Times article is accurate but it has prompted us to work even harder to make Amazon the best place to work."
- rdancer 11y agoIt's badly composed, not inexcusable.
- roymurdock 11y agoHad to chuckle when I read this sentence - Even with breaking news, journalistic standards would encourage working hard to uncover any bias in a key source. - then scrolled down to see Jay Carney's bio: "Senior Vice President for Global Corporate Affairs at Amazon. Previously, he served as White House Press Secretary and spent 20 years as a reporter for TIME."
- srtjstjsj 11y agoWhat a weird career trajectory. Smells like revolving door corruption to give Amazon privileged access to government.
- rdancer 11y agoFollowing your reasoning, if an employee's story is used to prop up a hit piece in the national paper of record (the irony!), providing important context serves the readers, the public, and current & prospective employees. But I get it, you don't like them. But it blinds you to the obvious, and makes your argument weak.
- fweespeech 11y ago> There are several shockingly inappropriate things in this article. In particular, the PR person at Amazon is saying that they would have shared employee's personal records (including evaluations) as well as other employee's termination conditions (which I consider unrelated to their quotes). Yep. Additionally, its pretty clear Carney was hired as a political PR wrangler for the sole purpose of cleaning up messes like this and this is the best he can do. If it was someone inexperienced, I'd assume this was just an error in judgement. However, with Carney's experience, is pretty clear this is the best spin that could be put to paper ... and that really says something. Their only option is to attack the character of the people involved in the articles about Amazon. They have no data, no evidence of any kind beyond "These are bad people". For a data driven company, it shows they either failed to collect related data and/or that data shows the article was accurate despite the poor choice of sources. > (By the way, the tool that the Times suggests is institutional encouragement to anonymously stab people in the back is rarely used and, when it is, most feedback is positive. Also, it’s not anonymous. The reporters knew that and dropped some qualifying language deep in the story after painting a picture that was far more entertaining than accurate.) Yeah, I'll believe if you if you were able to quantify it. The fact you didn't even try to provide data for this claim causes me call bullshit. > We decided to participate by sharing much of what Ms. Kantor asked for, yet the article she specifically said they were not writing became the article that we all read. And, despite our months-long participation, we were given no opportunity to see, respond to, or help fact-check the “stack of negative anecdotes” that they ultimately used. Then provide data, rather than anecdotes of your own that show you in an even more negative light among the privacy minded?
- serge2k 11y ago> For a data driven company, it shows they either failed to collect related data and/or that data shows the article was accurate despite the poor choice of sources. They do an annual survey of SDEs, and they do release that data internally (aggregated/anonymously). SO they do have data. The problem is if they release data taht says "Oh well X% of our engineers are happy with the company" Then when happens when someone says why not (X+Y)? It's data without comparisons to give better context.
- empath75 11y agoThey're going to have a hard time retaining and hiring quality employees if there's an unanswered NY Times article out there about how awful it is to work there. It's sort of a damned if they do, damned if they don't situation. But I think if you're fired for fraud I don't think you have a reasonable expectation that your employment details will remain private if you publicly slag the company that fired you for theft.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoThe genie is already out of the bottle. No matter what Amazon says (or what PR person they hire to whitewash the situation), I would still never work from them after what was revealed (not only from the NYT article, but from other anecdotes I've seen online).
- chrissnell 11y agoI disagree. Carney took the low road with this response and by posting confidential employee information, Amazon is stooping to the level of the accusers. I find it very troubling that a public company would willingly wage a smear campaign against ex-employees on a blog. I don't doubt that many of these employees had an axe to grind--and frankly, I could smell that when I read the NYT article--but any damage to Amazon was just compounded with Carney's post.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jsprogrammer 11y agoAnd they won't have a hard time retaining and hiring quality employees if all employees know that if you ever speak about your time at Amazon, some SVP for XXX might start selectively leaking portions of your personnel records? >But I think if you're fired for fraud Sure, but this is only a claim that Amazon/Carney have made. They have presented zero evidence for the claim. Also, Amazon/Carney released information about other employees that they have not claimed committed fraud (nor have they claimed any wrongdoing by those individuals).
- iiiggglll 11y agoIt's also weird that this is on Medium and not Amazon's own website. If this is an official company response to the article in question, shouldn't appear more that way?
- kordless 11y agoThe last inappropriate bit reads like ad hominem inception: > The next time you see a sensationalistic quote in the Times like “nearly every person I worked with, I saw cry at their desk”, you might wonder whether there’s a crucial piece of context or backstory missing — like admission of fraud — and whether the Times somehow decided it just wasn’t important to check. Mr Carney is basically saying when you read an interesting article in the NYT, you should assume that they are withholding information. Ironically, this is exactly what the press accused him of doing not so long ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nKcDUi1-lbA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nKcDUi1-lbA You know what Jay? I'll do my own trust and fear evaluations, thank you very much. I don't need some mega corporation telling me what to think.
- zaroth 11y agoRegarding sharing employee evaluations, two things; if you go on the record with press discussing your evaluation and says it says one thing, but it actually says another, I think the company is entitled to respond. Anyway, it's not clear to me if the employee isn't on Amazon's side here (angry at being misquoted) so how do we know this wouldn't have been after getting permission from the employees in question? Obviously there's a long quote from Dina Vaccari contradicting the reporting. As to sharing the reason an employee resigned from the the company, I don't think an employee's conduct while at a company is confidential, and if they are a strongly biased source, then the NYT needs to know that, and then adjust their reporting accordingly.
- zo1 11y agoIt may have been inappropriate to "share" some of the evaluations, even though they were so very vague and non-descript. But, it's also possible that the employee voided any contract between themselves and Amazon by speaking to a third party (NYT) about the inner workings of Amazon.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dekhn 11y agoYes, I think it was inappropriate of Amazon, but I absolutely believe they consulted their lawyers before making this post. It's the signal they're sending to future employees that matters here.
- pm24601 11y agoAmazon just did real harm to Mr Olsen's employability. To be so casual about this is typical Amazon. Also this is classic ad hominem attack. If the message is true attack the messenger. Jay wouldn't need to attack Mr. Olson personally if the message was wrong. Why does Jay lead with an attack on Mr. Olson? Could it be that that is the best he can do?
- zo1 11y ago
- thekevan 11y agoSo you are saying that if an employee tells the public something about an employer that is false, the employer still can't respond to the public with something about the employee that is true?
- Spooky23 11y agoEmployee reviews or reasons behind a termination for cause are not legally protected information. They are work product, owned by Amazon, subject to the contract with Amazon.