8 ms·
Big Beer’s 5-Point Plan to Crush the Craft Beer Revolution
- lambdapie 11y agoSeems like a good and (EDIT: ethically) legitimate plan for the most part #1. Create your own quasi-craft brands. This seems reasonable. If the taste sucks, the brand won't do well. If it doesn't, using a different brand is legitimate. #2. Snatch up craft brews that’ll sell out. Again, a fair strategy. #3. Defend macro brews, bash craft snobs. I'm not for attacking anyone, but certainly people have been attacking drinkers of macro brews for ages. In the circles I move in, Bud drinkers are openly stereotyped as ignorant and racist. #4. Control distribution. #5. Merge and overwhelm the marketplace. Vertical and horizontal integration for the sake of reducing competition is a bad thing, luckily we have laws to prevent this.
- JackFr 11y agoEvery one knows Duff drinkers are good upstanding Americans, it's Fudd drinkers who are rednecks and hillbillies.
- organsnyder 11y agoRegarding your last point: in my state (Michigan), the laws surrounding distribution are designed to protect incumbents. Though we have managed to produce quite a few world-class breweries. I'm fortunate to have Founders just a short walk away from my office.
- jghn 11y agoIndeed. And this ties to his first point which is that the playing field is far from level so it's not as if those crafty beers are competing on flavor. In many cases that's all one can get, or at least they've set the true craft beers up to fail - e.g. there's a lot of money involved in where on a shelf a particular beer winds up and that affects purchasing. There are many people out there who have heard about the craft beer revolution, don't know any better and will grab the first thing they see. Sure, if they like the product that's AOK. But the effect is that would have been money going to one of the smaller breweries. What do we think will happen once those breweries are extinguished?
- lambdapie 11y agoI agree that controlling the supply chain/shelf space is generally bad (see #4 in my original point, like most economists I'm at best very wary of vertical integration). In spite of my original post, your post has inspired me to buy some true craft beers. Any recommendations? I prefer Lagers, Pilsners and wheat beers. (EDIT: for New York area)
- ghaff 11y agoMost of the best craft brews are fairly local in distribution so it depends on where you live. (I'm more of an IPA and stout drinker anyway so my recommendations on lighter beers aren't going to be all that informed.) I agree that the original piece seems overblown. In my experience, even the "craft brands" of the big brewers cater to pretty mass market tastes and aren't really that interesting.
- jghn 11y agoCompletely missed that there were responses, but in case you all see this ghaff is right that distribution is so spotty for most craft breweries that it's better to find some local folks. Along w/ your last sentence I'd also say that most craft brewers' flagships can be pretty plain jane as well for the same reason.
- wodenokoto 11y agoWhile I'm not a big fan of big-beer and somewhat a fan of micro-brews, I think you are absolutely right. This is not a bad strategy.
- eveningcoffee 11y ago> #1. Create your own quasi-craft brands. I would go as far as call it false advertising. Especially when 10 brands are created that actually contain the same product. Even more, the mere fact that this merger is sought after shows that there is actually need to divide both companies.
- lambdapie 11y ago>I would go as far as call it false advertising. Especially when 10 brands are created that actually contain the same product. I disagree that branding the same product differently is false advertising. As long as the product lives up to the claims made in each case, I don't see what is false. I think you are trying to elevate what you think is important (being made by a small company) to a category that is given special treatment when it comes to advertising. It's like the equivalent of mandatory GMO labeling, but with GMO replaced by being made by a big company. For legitimate reasons to have the same product with different brands, consider programming languages. If Haskell had a fancy web 2.0 website, some people might go there and think "this is probably a stable, production ready language with good documentation". Others might think "this language has probably made too many compromises with the corporate world, and won't be a principled and elegant language". If it was possible to market the language in both ways to both people, wouldn't that be reasonable? Namely, to let the corporate users know that it is production ready, and let the purists know that it is not corporate bloatware? >Even more, the mere fact that this merger is sought after shows that there is actually need to divide both companies. I don't understand this point, can you explain it?
- eveningcoffee 11y agoFirst point. I give you an example. Say company X is known for product Y and they have competitor Z with product W. Lets imagine that there are group of customers of Z who buy product W only because they oppose to the company X. When now company X creates a product A and tries to make impression that product A is from company B and not from company X, then they are making false claims to reduce the market share of company Z by making group of customers of Z to believe that product A is not from company X and is a fair alternative to the product W. Second point. I am just supporting more actual competition on the market.
- ginko 11y agoWow, you must have drunk a lot of SV kool-aid to be in favor of such business practices.
- tptacek 11y agoWell, that was a mean, superficial, and unproductive response to a thoughtful comment. It's also stupid: "those business practices" will do more to help craft brewers than it will to harm them.
- milge 11y agoGood luck. I've seen so many craft beers popping up around here in the Northeast over the past couple of years. I've met so many people that would never touch a domestic. Personally, I'll have a craft beer, but I'm not a beer snob about it. In Philly, there's been a surge of popup beer gardens over the past few years that usually serve craft beers. I'm not sure about other cities, but I do know craft beers are exploding here. http://www.visitphilly.com/articles/philadelphia/top-10-reasons-philly-loves-pop-up-beer-gardens/ http://www.visitphilly.com/articles/philadelphia/top-10-reas...
- adventured 11y agoThe majors can't stop what's happening, short of a new prohibition to kill all the independents like they did last time.
- vinceguidry 11y agoTheir plan is to buy craft beers as they start getting popular. The idea is not to kill the idea of craft beer, but to use craft breweries as outsourced R&D. They're going to muscle into whatever markets they can. So you might find your beer gardens suddenly getting "sponsored" by Budweiser. The situation reminds me a lot of the current tech climate, where the startup ecosystem serves as outsourced R&D to the big tech companies. Google / Microsoft don't want to kill startups, they want to put them in their place.
- tptacek 11y agoThat's a good thing: it creates exit opportunities for new craft breweries, while also offering serious distribution for good beers that would otherwise be stuck in small geographic regions.
- vinceguidry 11y agoI agree. The scaling of entire industries never looks pretty, but the end result is a better world.
- cpfohl 11y ago
- DIVx0 11y agoA big part of the 'craft beer revolution' for me is supporting local businesses as many of my favorite brews are local to my sate or region. Also since macros have such a choke hold on distribution many of the best local crafts can only be had at taprooms or brew pubs which also plays nicely into 'supporting local' and they're fantastic social centers. I don't think macros could ever really touch those aspects of the scene.
- _delirium 11y agoAt least where I live, I've been noticing the craft-beer scene gravitating a bit more towards "beer bars", bigger places with a lot of beers on tap, anywhere from 20 to 100+ depending on the size of the place. I could imagine the quasi-craft beers from the big companies doing ok in that setting, depending in part on who runs the place and how they label their beer lists. However I think what the big companies are more worried about is mass-market settings, like restaurants, "normal" bars, and six packs in the local liquor store / supermarket. Craft beer has been making some inroads there, vs. being restricted to only people willing to explicitly seek out craft beer. Those account for higher volume, and threaten the big companies' market share, so they'd like to develop some alternatives for those settings to counter it. I think the small-volume local brewer who's only found in one shop doesn'd really threaten them. But they're very worried about the amount of sales national players like Lagunitas, Sierra Nevada, New Belgium, etc. are getting. Plus higher-volume regional companies like Goose Island (Chicago, bought by InBev), St. Arnold (Houston), Sweetwater (Atlanta), Brooklyn (NYC), Green Flash (San Diego), etc.
- clairity 11y agoyes! the fantastic craftsman 1903 prohibition style lager (brewed in pasadena) is for me a signal of a good local bar/pub in LA.
- superskierpat 11y agoThe main reason I drink craft beers almost exclusively is that I could never drink the more commercial stuff, way too fizzy for me, and there arent many macro black beers (and I've never found a commercial scotch ale) Helping local business and the festival scene is a big plus too. (The festival's are where the major beer vendors really seem out of place, they are loud, abnoxious and they give bigger glasses, thus helping those who are only there to drink get drunk faster) So I guess that make's me a beer snob, but whatever, I'm in Quebec, we won most of the prizes in last year's world beer festival (along with brazil, which is damn good), so I'm in the right place to be a beer snob.
- vinbreau 11y agoYounger me hated beer. I thought it tasted awful but drank it as that was what kids did in the country. I gave up drinking after college because I just couldn't stand the taste of beer, the smell even made me nauseous. Fast forward to my late 30's, moved to Austin and on a whim one night tried a locally brewed stout. It was amazing. I realized I liked beer but just hated the mainstream stuff, what my father calls 'green beer'. So yeah, I guess now I am a beer snob. I look forward to pay day when I can visit the largest store in the area and become overwhelmed with the varieties available to me. I like saisons, farm ales, porters and stouts. Nothing produced by the larger breweries even comes close to a Tank 7.
- superskierpat 11y agoI dont know how it is in other countries, but here in Quebec we basically have a few different kind of macro/micro beers: 1. Big beer like molson, coors or imported stuff 2. Quebec macros like Boreale that are similar to the big stuff in taste but less omnipresent 3. Companies that make beers like micro but have more of a macro scale of distribution: Unibroue, alchimiste, st-ambroise 4. Microbreweries whose beer can be bought in specialised stores, specialised restaurants and (recently!) supermarkets. 5. Local microbreweries with little to no distribution As I grew up I steadily shifted from # 1 to only drinking # 4 and # 5 (with the occasional # 3 or # 2, but only if there is nothing else). So I doubt that we will be seeing our favorite beers go away, the market if just too diversified!
- jonathansizz 11y agoIn my small town in South Carolina, we're just about to get our third new independent brewery in 3 years. The oldest of the three is already talking about moving to larger premises, and both those currently in business are canning their beer with sales already in hundreds of retailers across the region, in addition to selling beer on site. All of them brew at least one light American pilsner to appeal to newcomers and also offer a decent food menu and regular special events. I don't think these kinds of places are going away any time soon. They offer an ambience and clientele that's distinct from a regular restaurant or bar, and I've found myself visiting them more frequently as they continually experiment and improve their beers.
- parennoob 11y agoSome risks to this plan, based on my own (admittedly anecdotal) experience moving in hipster circles. #1. Create your own quasi-craft brands. Definitely the worst. I actually don't mind getting an 8-pack of Coors from time to time for parties but I will not touch Blue Moon or Shock Top now because it always sparks off that awful "You know this is fake craft beer right?" conversation. #2. Snatch up craft brews that’ll sell out. Not bad, especially if you can keep them mostly the same and avoid plastering your name anywhere on the bottle. Runs the same risks as #1 otherwise. #3. Defend macro brews, bash craft snobs. Mostly neutral or high risk. First of all people who are into craft beer don't give a shit about Anheuser-Busch ads during the super bowl. Secondly craft beer has nothing to do with pumpkins. #4. Control distribution. This could actually work in the short term, but has high risk of antitrust action. #5. Merge and overwhelm the marketplace. I don't know enough about the market to say whether this would work – but I suspect they will blow a lot of money on advertising and not attract enough people. --- I would like to suggest #6 to these companies: #6. Draw consumers into your beer Make a documentary about how it is made. Say the stuff that goes into it (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budweiser#The_beer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budweiser#The_beer). A Bud Light can be pretty refreshing during summer. Basically try and do something akin to what PBR did (http://worksdesigngroup.com/pbr-brand-repositioning/ http://worksdesigngroup.com/pbr-brand-repositioning/).
- _delirium 11y agoFor #1, it depends on the audience a lot, I think. I don't think they're even going for the quasi-craft segment in the case of the specific beers you list, but for the summer-on-the-beach crowd (and they're pretty successful in that setting). The intended competitors of Blue Moon aren't craft beers; it's squarely aimed at InBev's Hoegaarden brand, introduced because MillerCoors needed something to compete with InBev in that category.
- corysama 11y agoAlso, I'm starting to see semi-big labels come out with fairly decent original crafty beers such as Sierra Nevada's Narwhal and New Belgium's La Folie. These are definitely not repackaged ShockTop and they are doing a fair job of competing with smaller brews for tap space at beer snob bars.
- conceit 11y ago5 points you didn't know were planned to crush ...
- tptacek 11y agoThis is past silly. It makes absolutely no sense for "big beer" to try to "crush" craft beer. First, it's not possible: it's too easy to start new breweries, and too easy to get local distribution to bars and the kinds of stores that already do a good job of stocking craft beer. The capital costs to start a new craft brewery are small. There are tens of new brewery starts in major metros every year (we're flooded with them in Chicago). So AB InBev takes out Goose Island. Who cares? For every Goose Island, there's a dozen Half Acres. Second, it doesn't make economic sense. Macrobrews and tiny local craft brews are not substitutable products. Macrobrews are defined not by quality but by availability: they're produced in enough quantity and their logistics are managed competently enough to be reliably available in the places where people who buy macrobrews shop. The same is absolutely not the case for craft beer; even the best-run largest-scale craft breweries are often on allocation systems with retailers. By the way, AB InBev's customers generally aren't trying to maximize IBUs, don't give a shit which hop varietals got used, and would probably assume a brett beer had somehow gone bad. Again: not substitutable products. Meanwhile: on the off chance that a Three Floyds or Bruery "graduates" to real nationwide distribution, in 6-pack/case format, Big Beer will simply buy them. They can, in effect, use craft breweries as laboratory for product development: the products that succeed in the market get acquired, and AB InBev supplies its logistics and distribution to milk profits from the acquisition. It's a very old, very effective business model (see, for instance, Cisco). Finally: I call BS on the idea that Big Beer somehow ruins acquired craft breweries. Goose Island is if anything doing a more consistent and competent job now than they were prior to the acquisition.
- jlittel 11y agoIt makes perfect economic economic sense. Craft beer is growing[1], and beer companies want to keep that piece of the pie. They're producing their own craft beer, buying smaller brewers, and disparaging the competition. [1] 8% in 2013 to 11% in 2014 http://www.bizjournals.com/albany/news/2015/03/18/craft-beer-market-share-up-across-nation.html http://www.bizjournals.com/albany/news/2015/03/18/craft-beer...
- tptacek 11y ago"Craft" isn't a kind of beer, so there isn't 11% of the market to go after. About the closest you'd come to that is super-hoppy IPAs. If the narrative I'm supposed to be worried about is that AB InBev blankets the market with a good super-hoppy IPA, I guess I'm fine with that.
- whistlerbrk 11y agoDoes anyone seriously consider Blue Moon to be craft beer? Past silly is right.
- intopieces 11y agoWhy wouldn't they? It has all the hallmarks of one. Most people don't research their beer origins.
- ingenieros 11y ago"AB InBev and SABMiller spend a total of $500 billion annually on sports sponsorships" That can't possibly be right! I read in an earlier article that their revenue last year was "only" 26 billion or so.
- PhantomGremlin 11y agoI questioned that same thing. The claim is made in the linked "Marketplace report". Perhaps they meant to say $500 million? If so, what's three orders of magnitude difference between friends? Just a rounding error? Why are business reporters so utterly innumerate? The most disappointing thing to me is that Time magazine goes back to 1923. Henry Luce would have never stood for such gross mis-reporting. But I guess there's no money any more to pay competent people.
- wmil 11y agoThe article is missing the most obvious way. Lobby for tighter health and safety inspections and documentation. Compliance costs usually scale in a way that's favorable for large manufacturers.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ernmando 11y agoOn the point of craft breweries selling out -- that will lead to more craft breweries popping up. Having big exits makes it easier for new breweries to get investors. Having Google, Facebook, and others buying tech startups doesn't kill the startup ecosystem, it's the fuel.
- dogma1138 11y agoAren't the majority of "craft beer" brands are actually owned by the big breweries these days?